ipl-logo

Truth Revealed In John Stuart Mill's On Liberty

1286 Words6 Pages

In 1951, Solomon Asche conducted a simple experiment in order to measure the tendency for a person to let their surrounding peers affect his or her answers to the uncomplicated question of the length of lines. While the correct answers to the questions were quite obvious, if the test subject was among a group of people who gave incorrect answers, that test subject was much more likely to give the same wrong answer, despite knowing the truth. Only rarely did a person deviate from the majority answer. Consequently, only when that person accepted their role as a pariah was the truth revealed. This experiment is a prime example of one of the main components of liberty in John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty. While Asche’s experiment poses questions based upon (supposedly) irrefutable mathematical facts, its surprising results reveal that a majority opinion is not necessarily the truth, and that “if opponents of all-important truths do not exist,” then society will never be able to progress (Mill 36). This means that no matter an individual’s …show more content…

Mill considers this situation also very concerning, referring to it as “the tyranny of the majority” (4). Even without a formal law or government in place, the citizens of a society tend to regulate themselves to a certain extent. However, this extent, more often than not, turns into a autocratic opinion that shames the minority that has a different perspective. Society must take into consideration these defective forms of decision making while determining the legal status of polygamy. To arrive at a fair decision, the citizens and their governing body would have to work in conjunction. In a sense, this means electing laws through majority rules, but while still maintaining minority rights. This essentially comes down to respecting the rights of all citizens, no matter the person’s view on polygamy. This idea is described through Mill’s harm

Show More
Related

  • Lincoln First Inaugural Address Analysis

    657 Words  | 3 Pages

    A majority, held in restraint by constitutional checks and limitations, and always changing easily with deliberate changes of popular opinions and sentiments, is the only true sovereign of a free people. Whoever rejects it, does, of necessity, fly to anarchy or to despotism” (Basler,

    Read More

  • The Sons Of Liberty: Radical Changes During The American Revolution

    1934 Words  | 8 Pages

    The American Revolution was the world-changing birth of a nation that was founded on the strong belief of natural rights and freedom through independence. These beliefs, however, were not what the initial supporters of what would become the revolution intended. Instead, these people, known as the gentry, had initially sought to preserve their authority to rule, a right they believed they already had. Although, after employing the middle sort to help them and slowly giving them more power, new radical ideas had emerged. Suddenly, the gentry’s wish of restoring their authoritative power changed into a nationwide fight for natural rights and independence.

    Read More

  • Compare Harrison Bergeron And The Lottery By Shirley Jackson

    860 Words  | 4 Pages

    Individuals are the building blocks of society, but they can’t dictate the way society flows. In the short stories “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson and “Harrison Bergeron,” by Kurt Vonnegut, and the theories of enlightenment philosophers, individuals can not change society. Tessie Hutchinson from “The Lottery,” tried to persuade her village that the tradition was wrong, but she faced death. While, Harrison from “Harrison Bergeron,” tried to overthrow society's ideas, through atrocious actions. The philosophers believed that the governors of society should be responsive and secure rights for the people.

    Read More

  • Majority Rule Tocqueville Analysis

    1660 Words  | 7 Pages

    Does Majority Rule threaten Liberty? Brian Shuffler University of the Pacific American Political Thought – 134 Professor Becker Does Majority Rule threaten Liberty? Our Constitution was designed to check majority rule and to stymie the ascendency of primacy in our society. According to the Declaration of Independence, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness” . This proclamation is the bedrock and principle that our democracy was founded on.

    Read More

  • Canadian Polygamy

    894 Words  | 4 Pages

    In conclusion, there should be a complete ban on polygamous relationships in Canada despite its intended religious values as it can cause harm to children, women, society, and the institution of a monogamous

    Read More

  • Polygamy In Canada

    1320 Words  | 6 Pages

    While these are the opinions of lawyers, who have an obvious interest in the outcome of the case, simple mathematics and probabilities reinforce their claims as feasible. In contrast, some argue that society would be better served by legalizing polygamy. A recent research paper, funded by the Justice Department and Status of Women Canada, argues that this practice should not be singled out for criminal punishment. Instead, laws that address the problems that women and children face in polygamous relationships, such as support and inheritance rights, would be more beneficial.

    Read More

  • Cragon And Nielson

    837 Words  | 4 Pages

    Wood (2011) gives detail on polygamist Kody Brown and his families reality TV show Sister Wives. Wood focuses on the legal fallout after airing Sister Wives. The article also shows how the Browns argue against the U.S. Supreme Court, which ruled that polygamy is an “offense to society.” Wood (2011) gives his opinion by saying polygamists are free to live however they want and that society will never be able to prove them wrong due to freedom of religion in the United States. Wood (2011) states that polygamy is tolerated in multiple countries that have heavy restrictions and if those countries allow it then surely the U.S. will allow it as well.

    Read More

  • George Reynolds Vs Polygamy Case

    976 Words  | 4 Pages

    The government cannot make laws regarding religion, but can reach actions when the principles are a violation of “social duties or subversive of good order.” Seeing as polygamy has always been treated as a crime against humanity and marriage is considered the most important factor of social life, one can see as to why this case was such an important encounter with the

    Read More

  • Summary Of Liberty And Knowledge By John Adams

    1203 Words  | 5 Pages

    The main point of this article that John Adams is trying to let the reader understand is that everyone should have equal rights under the law of the Declaration of Independence. Adams is saying that whoever holds the power has the freedom, and he wants the people not in power fight to get the same power that those in charge have. In “Liberty and Knowledge”, Adams writes “Let the bar proclaim the laws, the rights, the generous plan of power delivered down from remote antiquity-inform the world of the might struggles and numberless sacrifices made by our ancestors in defense of freedom.” This quote is saying that the rights that people hold in the United States was given to them was not just handed to them. Their ancestors fought for those equal

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On The Civil Rights Movement

    1184 Words  | 5 Pages

    Each belief obtained in this world is mirrored by its opposite allowing those to decide which reflection they choose to abide to. In America, one’s perspective defined what each person stood for. During the Civil Rights Movement, controversy stood at the base of the country as many chose “a side” to be on as an argument of what was deemed constitutional and unconstitutional continued. However, although many may have had their separate beliefs, the common ground consisted of the principles of democracy written in the Constitution. Although, it was a less popular belief highlighted during the Civil rights movement, the whites too faced issues with the loss of their principles of democracy as the federal government continuously abused their power.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Stormy Mind Of John Stuart Mill

    1104 Words  | 5 Pages

    I chose to review the fifth chapter of “New Ideas From Dead Economists” titled The Stormy Mind of John Stuart Mill. John Stuart Mill was born in 1806 in London to two strict parents who began to educate their son at a very young age. Mill’s father was James Mill, a famous historian and economist, who began to teach his son Greek at the age of three. The book reports that “by eight, the boy had read Plato, Xenophon, and Diogenes” and by twelve “Mill exhausted well-stocked libraries, reading Aristotle and Aristophanes and mastering calculus and geometry” (Buchholz 93). The vast amount of knowledge that Mill gained at a young age no doubt assisted him in becoming such a well-recognized philosopher and economist.

    Read More

  • Summary Of John Stuart Mill's Consideration On Representative Government

    1128 Words  | 5 Pages

    If people have no place to voice their will or take part in deciding their own destiny, the community might grow disinterested and passive in their relationship with their government. Mill believes this is problematic for society because history, as he sees it, has shown that more democratic societies have more ‘energetic, and ‘developed’ societies as well as more ‘go ahead characters’ not seen in more totalitarian societies. Yet, this criticism might fail to cover a deeper problem of disinterest; it might lead to a level of moral deficiency as well. Mill fears that a loss of ability and activity, leads to a society losing its sense of communal responsibility and social justice. In their aloofness, people might be less inclined to believe that they have any responsibility to society since society has ceased to have any rights or purpose under absolute authority.

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis Of John Stuart Mill's 'Utilitarianism'

    1564 Words  | 7 Pages

    John Stuart Mill, at the very beginning of chapter 2 entitled “what is utilitarianism”. starts off by explaining to the readers what utility is, Utility is defined as pleasure itself, and the absence of pain. This leads us to another name for utility which is the greatest happiness principle. Mill claims that “actions are right in proportions as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness.” “By Happiness is intended pleasure and the absence of pain, by happiness, pain and the privation of pleasure”.

    Read More

  • Vegetarianism Exposed In John Stuart Mill's On Liberty

    516 Words  | 3 Pages

    John Stuart Mill was an English philosopher and an influential political theorist. In his great work, On Liberty, demonstrated the harm principle. Along with the harm principle, there is a great question among the text. The question is, why should heresy be permitted? As a Christian, seeking the truth is hard due to many heresies that are in the world.

    Read More

  • John Stuart Mill's View On Freedom: A Definition Of Freedom

    1119 Words  | 5 Pages

    Being Free 1st draft Freedom is word used in a lot of contexts, but the official meaning of the word is “the power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants” (Freedom). Meaning that you have the right to do something, with the focus being on you as an individual. This means no one can tell you what to do, like for example a state. This is an important aspect and part of political theory. Liberty is also used and viewed as the same category of theory, and has the definition “The state of being free within society from oppressive restrictions imposed by authority on one’s behavior or political views” (Liberty).

    Read More

More about Truth Revealed In John Stuart Mill's On Liberty

Open Document