ipl-logo

United States Military Academy's Honor Code

1983 Words8 Pages

1. Introduction
The United States Military Academy is an institution that prides itself on its leadership development. An important aspect of developing second lieutenants is developing “leaders of character who internalize the ideals of Duty, Honor, Country and the Army Ethics” (Gold Book 4). This character and moral development starts with the Cadet Honor Code. The United States Military Academy’s Honor Code states “A cadet will not lie, cheat, steal or tolerate those who do.” In this paper, I will argue that Kant’s moral theory supports the first three tenets of the Honor Code when strictly interpreted. However, when applying Kant’s theory to the Honor Code as we practice, Kant cannot morally justify social tact. Additionally, I will show …show more content…

Honor Code and Kant’s Moral Theory
It is important to define the two variations of the Honor Code before analyzing it through a Kantian lens- “strictly written” and “as practiced”. Strictly written is a literal interpretation of the Honor Code, while as practiced allows for the exception of social tact. This means that a person is allowed to lie in circumstances that “are designed to spare the feeling of others” (USCC PAM 1-8). Examples of social tact include complementing a meal you do not like and telling someone their dress looks nice even when it does not.
Before we can analyze the Honor Code, we must understands Kant’s moral theory. Kantianism can be broken down into two main categorical imperatives, the formula of universal law and the formula of end in itself. Kant’s categorical imperatives provide a way for us to analyze the morality of different maxims (motives for actions). The formula of universal law states that, “I out never to act except in such a way that I can also will that maximum should become a universal law” (Kant I 99). More colloquially, Kant is saying that you must be able to imagine and live in a world where this maxim is universalized. Kant’s second categorical imperative, the formula of end in itself, states that you should never treat others (including yourself) as a mere means, but always as ends in themselves. It is important to differentiate mere means and means. Mere means is when an individual uses someone as a tool for their own goals without …show more content…

Application of Kant’s Moral Theory: Lying, Cheating, and Stealing
Now that we have defined Kant’s moral theory, and understand that if a maxim passes one of the categorical imperatives, it passes both of them, we can apply Kant’s theory to the four parts of the honor code. In this section, I will briefly apply Kant’s theory to lying, cheating, and stealing because they are the easiest to digest. I will spend the majority of the paper focusing on the toleration clause of the Honor Code since it is the most difficult to apply and it is the most problematic to Kant’s moral theory.
Kant would argue that lying in any circumstance is immoral. Thus, Kant would approve of the strictly written Honor Code over the as practiced Honor Code. Initially social tact may pass the formula of universal law, however, under strict logical scrutiny it fails. An individual might be able to conceptualize and live in a universe where social tact was practiced. However, it is hard to objectively establish in what situations it is right to spare someone’s feelings and in what situations it is right to tell the truth. Additionally, it is hard to draw the line when social tact is sparing someone’s feeling or hurting him or her in the end. For example, if Sally’s mom does not know her meatloaf is terrible, how will she improve her cooking? If Joey does not fit into his shirt and you do not tell him the truth, how is he going to deal with the bullying he gets in public? In terms of the formula of ends

Show More
Related

  • The Rescue Defence Of Capital Punishment By Steve Aspenson

    744 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ross came up with a list of seven basic prima facie duties as they apply to individuals. These duties included a duty to (1) reparation, (2) fidelity, (3) gratitude, (4) justice, (5) beneficence, (6) self-improvement, and (7) nonmaleficence. Tom Regan’s Rights Theory stems around the idea that every person has four basic, semi-universal rights: (1) the right not to be harmed, (2) the right to aid when their rights have been violated, (3) the right to self-defense, and (4) the liberty right. In this paper I will also discuss Tom Regan’s worse off principle.

    Read More

  • Theme Of Honor In Henry IV

    1245 Words  | 5 Pages

    Honor in today’s society holds close to the same meaning as it did when Shakespeare wrote the play in the sixteenth century, and it is a closer definition to Hotspur’s than Falstaff’s by

    Read More

  • Examples Of Violating Social Norms

    1060 Words  | 5 Pages

    In spite of the fact that normal social norms depended on elaborate codes and standards for behavior, present day frameworks for conduct are all the more firmly attached to judgment skills behaviors that exhibit a level of sympathy. It is an essential social norm that we ought to knock the entryway of any apartment or house before getting into it. This kind of social norm is imperative because this

    Read More

  • Flammang The Taste Of Civilization Analysis

    1807 Words  | 8 Pages

    “Be kindly affectioned one to another with brotherly love; in honor preferring one another” (Romans 12:10). Long ago, there was a time when courtesy emerged. During that time, civilization valued standards, morals, etiquette, and politeness. Certain regulations existed for speech, which ensured no one was confused or unnecessarily offended. There were also numerous laws regarding behavior, which made sure everyone’s needs were cared for and no one was harmed, insulted, or excluded.

    Read More

  • How Has Honor Changed Over Time

    1055 Words  | 5 Pages

    In an article written by a journalist for New York The Sun, Shalin Punn about James Bowman and his book Honor: A History, he states about honor in the past “In its most primitive sense, what Mr. Bowman labels "reflexive honor," it was that instinctive desire "not to lose face." If someone hit me, I would hit him back, and in doing so I would have been defending my honor” (Bowman). First this shows honor has changed over time because people define honor in a less primitive way now. As well as this definition has been built on and changed as time went on. In light of honor changing, over the years the definition of honor may have been skewed to fit the time, in modern culture honor can be defined as a man’s integrity.

    Read More

  • Immanuel Kant: The Only Good Without Limitation And The Good Will

    789 Words  | 4 Pages

    However, the good will may depend on outside factors to bring about good in a person. Thus, I argue if Kant’s theory were true, it would be very difficult to be a good person as utilitarianism do not allow for acts that go beyond duty. Kant’s argument suggests that good will is the only thing good without qualification. First, Kant begins to distinguish between things that are good without qualification and things that are good only under certain qualified conditions.

    Read More

  • What Is Kant's Categorical Imperative

    789 Words  | 4 Pages

    Kant sets out to elucidate what the categorical imperative contains. We ought to bear in mind that the categorical imperative is not a concept that can be established by an appeal to experience, since experience cannot furnish us with what ought to be, but rather what is. The categorical imperative, Kant explains, is not analytic, but rather it is a practical synthetic principle a priori, and establishing how synthetic a priori propositions are possible is always a daunting undertaking. With this difficulty, Kant resolves to postpone the resolution of the unconditional imperative for the latter part of his work (420). Kant argues that hypothetical imperatives – imperatives based on desire or inclination – are conditional, since they are dependent

    Read More

  • Ethics In Criminal Justice: Kantian Ethics And Principles

    394 Words  | 2 Pages

    Elnora Williams AC1707819 Ethics in Criminal Justice J06. V.3.1 Assignment 6_08 KANTAIN ETHICS AND PRINCIPLES Kant described his system of ethics in his 1785 book, "Groundings for the Metaphysics of Morals. " Kant's categorical imperative differs from hypothetical imperative activities are taken to attain an end that an individual wants for himself. Kant felt that ethics could not be determined from a hypothetical imperative because it is too subjective.

    Read More

  • Kant's Emptiness Charge Analysis

    3638 Words  | 15 Pages

    Since the golden rule does not actually specify what we should do, this vagueness of the golden rule points to the reciprocity of considering people. For example, it would also not make sense for me to criticize someone else for, say, breaking the speed limit if I then went and broke it myself, for Kant, it is a sure sign of its subjectivism, it does not indicate the essence or the content of morality, therefore its inadequacy as a foundation of moral philosophy. In this thesis, I will explicate CI2 expresses Kant’s genuinely universal moral system requires that I do not break speed limit, not because of the psychological concerning or consequences, but I treat others as humanity or ends, not merely means. (See my further discussion in

    Read More

  • What Is Mill's Ethical Theory

    1524 Words  | 7 Pages

    Kant: Obviously I don’t expect individuals to follow these ethical rules to a tee. In fact, it is very difficult for us humans to follow these. However, in an ideal world, we’d only act such that we’d hope others act towards us, and this theory would produce moral laws that we can use all the time. Lynch:

    Read More

  • Decorum In The Military

    1772 Words  | 8 Pages

    In doing so, Sherman draws on Cicero 's notion of decorum being indexed to our roles or personae (noting that this notion usefully allows us to separate the deferential respect due to rank and based on one 's professional role, from the dignitary respect due to all and based on our shared, and most fundamental, role as rational agents), and Seneca 's account of how decorum and emotional demeanor can help "weave the fabric of community. " The decorum insisted upon by the military, focusing on stolid determination, respect and obedience, and camaraderie and friendship between soldiers, can cement the bonds within military units (bonds shown in many studies to be essential to combat effectiveness); the approach to decorum taken by enlightened commanders can be enriched by familiarity with Stoic treatments of the subject. It is in this chapter that we find the most direct and unmixed recommendation of Stoic views; the remaining chapters deal largely with emotion in Stoic theory and in the life of the warrior, and while Sherman certainly finds much of value in the former, she repeatedly softens or even controverts key Stoic claims, often leaning in the direction of

    Read More

  • Kant's Categorical Imperative

    305 Words  | 2 Pages

    The categorical imperative of Kant may be applied to modern day morality but not entirely. The imperative put forth by Kant follows the fundamentals of absolutes, which in many cases are true. However, when standing alone the categorical imperative does not cover all aspects of the spectrum and therefore would not be applicable in form alone. The primary reason for which Kant’s imperative fails would be or can be directly caused by variant situations. For example, what if there were to be a situation that on either hand the action would be deemed immoral, which would be chosen?

    Read More

  • What Are The Negative Effects Of Phishing

    1490 Words  | 6 Pages

    Kantianism is the critical important of good will of desire to do the right thing. Kant's ethics state that human beings must follow a categorical imperative, which is an absolute moral standard that does not vary based on individual circumstances. Kant stated that a behavior is only ethical when it would remain beneficial if performed universally by everyone. In this study, Categorical Imperative (2nd Formulation) is suitable in this study which act so that you treat both yourself and other people as ends in themselves and never only as a means to an

    Read More

  • Kantian Ethics And Moral Reasoning

    1674 Words  | 7 Pages

    While going to school, there were always groups of people who were more popular or were involved in many things which allowed to feel superior to other peers who were not as involved or were not popular. Kantian ethics is emerged

    Read More

  • Non Formal Impartiality Analysis

    1444 Words  | 6 Pages

    For non-formal notion of impartiality, humans may well hold to the supreme moral value which motivates us to regard others as ends in themselves not merely means. We do not steal the grain because such action would demean our humanity, we help others because never treat others merely means but ends, C2 is not merely a negative assertion, as the narrow formalists charge. The supreme value espoused in C2, is, then, not too formal to guide our action; it possesses concreteness or substantive matter that informs an impartial approach to

    Read More

More about United States Military Academy's Honor Code

Open Document