ipl-logo

What Are The Three Dimensions Of Bottled Life

938 Words4 Pages

Power can be divided into three different dimensions, according to Lukes (1974: 11-25). This essay will discuss the three dimensions and give examples of them by using the documentary ‘Bottled Life’ by Urs Schnell, in which the company’s business with water is investigated. First, there is the one-dimensional view of power, which is used to analyse behaviour and hereby, strictly the observable making of decisions. Actors who are successful at attempts of making decisions that will have an impact on other groups are seen as powerful or influential, terms which are used interchangeably. These decisions are made about an observable conflict involving the interests of the actors involved, which are visible and shown as the actors’ preferences …show more content…

This dimension has a critique on the second, accusing it of being too qualified, thus still too close to behaviourism (Lukes 1974: 21). It also turns down the idea that there must be conflict in consequence of the exercise of power. It is possible for an actor to exercise power over another actor or individual by manipulating their desires and subjective interests. This means that power, as seen in this third dimension, can also be used to prevent conflict from happening. This results in latent conflict, where the subjective interests of the affected conflict with their real interests, even though they might not realise it (idem: 23-25). This dimension adds to the nondecision concept as well, by explaining that it is possible for there to be a nondecision, even if the people do not feel deprived. In this case, the nondecision exists by manipulating the (subjective) interests of the people and that way, keeping issues off the agenda (idem: 24). The documentary shows a clear example of the third dimension in one of the towns in Maine. The company of Nestlé has bought land there to be able to acquire as much water as they want for their business. To prevent the citizens of the town from complaining, they have been ‘a good neighbour’, donating money to education, helping finance playgrounds and most importantly, creating jobs in this town, where the economy was crumbling before they got there. (Bottled Life 2012). By doing this they are shaping the subjective interests of the citizens, even though it might not be in their real interest to welcome the company, due to ecological reasons for

Show More
Related

  • Occupational Therapy Code Of Ethics Essay

    579 Words  | 3 Pages

    One way OT’s and OTA’s can use to solve dilemmas is to lis the Pros and Cons of the action, assign a quality value to each action (0-10), then base your decision on the action with the highest value. Another way dilemmas can be solved is to ask the following questions: who are the players in the dilemma? What other facts or information are needed? What actions may be taken? What are the possible consequences of each action?

    Read More

  • Richard Neustadt Presidential Power Analysis

    515 Words  | 3 Pages

    Undoubtedly, The President is the furthermost known person in a country due to the position he occupies and many times his actual power has been questioned. Two distinct perspectives arose to describe the president’s power as persuasion and unilateral power. First, the persuasive perspective from Richard Neustadt illustrates presidents’ power as persuasive. It highlights what Neustadt believes that is a misconception among the general public who believe that the president is a supreme authority that governs the country, as he prefers from his oval office.

    Read More

  • Power In The Hunger Games

    266 Words  | 2 Pages

    Power is best understood as pursuing freely chosen ends, towards which our actions are oriented and are then commanding the necessary means towards the pursuit of those ends. Power, therefore, is an enabling capacity. The more power one has, the wider is their range of choices that they may realistically pursue (Bauman & May 2001). Bauman & May notes, “To have power, among other things, means to be able to decide what is not important and what should not matter or concern” (120). This definition of power by Zygmunt Bauman and Tim May was chosen because it best relates to the circumstances in The Hunger Games, in which President Coriolanus Snow possesses power over the Capitol and other districts.

    Read More

  • Comparing Power In Macbeth And The Hunger Games

    776 Words  | 4 Pages

    But first what is Power? When researching Power words such as authority, control, direct, command and influence all appear. These words all support the following statement “Power is the ability to influence and control the behaviour of others.” The problem with power is that it often leads to those in power abusing it. As Lord Acton famously quoted “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.”

    Read More

  • Marketing Case Study: FIJI Natural Artesian Water

    1166 Words  | 5 Pages

    It has become difficult though profitable for a business in finding out the balance consumer social sensibility and effective marketing message. The product reputation can have an impact through social issues awareness as well. In the similar way, FIJI water remained quiet on social issues that were indirectly related. It has freedom to market its product showing only its positive aspects ignoring all its negative impacts on the surroundings environment. This could become the most effective way unless the people become aware and conscious about its

    Read More

  • What Is Lukes Device Of Critiquing Traditional Conceptions Of Social Power?

    235 Words  | 1 Pages

    Lukes contrasts the ways power operates in government settings versus how it operates in a larger societal context. His device of critiquing traditional conceptions of power is by arguing that there is not one but 3 dimensions to social power. The first dimension restricts power to decisions taken by a class of political actors such as politician, civil servants and lobbyists. Its assumed that power is distributed evenly across various political parties and interest groups. In this scenario, the actors decide the outcome of an issue where there is an observable conflict of interests.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Bottled Water

    715 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bottled water is harmful to the environment due to the plastic holder that contains the water, is made from chemicals that could make anyone or anything sick. The plastic also takes a very long time to decompose in the earth and you can not burn the plastic without the chemicals in the plastic reacting to the heat, causing a harmful gas that could be fatal if it is breathed in by humans and animals alike. As mentioned in paragraph five in the article “BUNDANOON JOURNAL: Ban on Bottled Water, Apparently a First, Puts a Small Town on a Big Stage.”

    Read More

  • Power And Influence In The Crucible

    1011 Words  | 5 Pages

    Power and influence in society have a huge impact on the way things happen and affects perception. A prime example is the power that presidents and prime ministers have. Given this power they can effectively influence and persuade others. Power and influence is often associated with gender, conflict and roles and relationships. The importance of the power and influence can be thoroughly examined using texts that demonstrate ideas presented as truths.

    Read More

  • The 48 Laws Of Power: A Profound Exploration Of Human Nature

    640 Words  | 3 Pages

    Title: "The 48 Laws of Power: A Profound Exploration of Human Nature" Introduction: "The 48 Laws of Power," authored by Robert Greene, is a captivating and influential book that delves into the intricate dynamics of power and manipulation across various domains of life. Through meticulous analysis of historical events, biographies, and psychological principles, Greene presents 48 laws that provide guidance on acquiring, preserving, and utilizing power. This essay will provide a comprehensive analysis of the book, including its evocative title, skillful characterization, engrossing plot, prominent themes, and the deft employment of two literary devices: irony and symbolism. Characterization: "The 48 Laws of Power" possesses a distinct persona,

    Read More

  • Imperialism In Macbeth

    679 Words  | 3 Pages

    Most people question, “ How does the quest of power cause people to act? ”. Over the years the question has been proved to cause people to act differently. Not just in history but in many movies, plays, books, and even in current events today. The quest of power drives people to do things out of their character.

    Read More

  • Explain How Multifunctional Use Over Time

    137 Words  | 1 Pages

    Multifunctional use in time: This is the multiple use of space in the 4th dimension. Spaces, such as buildings or public spaces could provide various functions in different moments. It is a form of multifunctional use in time. However, multifunctional use in time is believed to have limited feasibility for regular urban functions.

    Read More

  • Three Faces Of Power Theory

    919 Words  | 4 Pages

    It is how the powerful manipulate the powerless in order to fulfil the needs of those with power. What one may have here is a latent conflict, which consists in a contradiction between the interests of those exercising power and the real interests of those they exclude. These latter may not express or even be conscious of their interests, but ... the identification of those interests ultimately always rests on empirically supportable and refutable hypotheses (Lukes 2005).

    Read More

  • Othello Power Analysis

    1029 Words  | 5 Pages

    Power is often the root at which conflicts begin. As those on the bottom attempt to gain power and those at the top of the power dynamic attempt to consistently degrade those below them to prevent them from gaining influence. In William Shakespeare’s Othello, the surprise, seemingly societally transcendent, ability for Othello to gain power and Othello to be able to marry Desdemona, is immediately followed by those in power trying to relieve Othello of his role in society, leading Othello to even attempt to exert his own power. The powerful men of Othello attempt to destroy and subjugate the lives of others to prevent them from advancing and maintaining power.

    Read More

  • Definition Essay Reality

    740 Words  | 3 Pages

    While there are areas around you that cannot be manipulated, you are either interacting with these zones indirectly or they are so far from you that they do not hold a great deal of importance (Berger & Luckmann, 1966, p. 36). The parts of reality that will directly impact your life are the things that hold the most importance, however, there are several interests that may not impact your life at all and are simply for personal enjoyment. Many people hold interests in subjects such as personal fitness, technology, or cuisine; these subjects may not be intricately involved in their everyday reality but they are considered the simple pleasures in life. There are some forms of reality that are not shared with others, such as dreams and these would be considered a private reality.

    Read More

  • Strategic Rationality Of Game Theory

    880 Words  | 4 Pages

    Game Theory and the Prisoners’ Dilemma Strategic Rationality In this chapter, Daniel Little indicates that under circumstances of uncertainty and risks, decision-makers attempt to maximize utility through collecting information of the utility and analyzing the probability of each feasible choice. Finally the maximum expected payoff of outcomes is given to the decision-maker since all other decision makers also made the rational decisions. Also strategic rationality is embodied on interactive social behavior that these individual decision-makers make choices regard to predictions about the other decision-makers’ next move in performance, the choices that other agents made lead to the level of outcomes that individual decision-maker would receive. Generally speaking, individual choices are made from strategic interaction and under circumstances of uncertainty.

    Read More

More about What Are The Three Dimensions Of Bottled Life

Open Document