Western And East Asian Literature Essay
IX: Comparing Western and East Asian Literature
IX(a): Similarities
Arguably, there are very few similarities between Western and East Asian portrayals of dystopian-utopian societies. However, there is no doubt that the only quality that joins the two very different schools of thought together would be how they are all human beings. Based off the analyses on A Wrinkle in Time, The Hunger Games, Psycho-Pass and No.6, I will now be exploring the similarities that Western and East Asian literature both share.
Part (a) of Section IX aims to answer the following question(s) pertaining to portrayal:
What are the similarities between Western and East Asian portrayals of dystopian-utopian societies?
Love for independence. Western and East Asian literary masterpieces alike embrace their independence fiercely and is a theme often brought up throughout the texts. Breaking free from an overbearing power figure is a constant in these texts. This can attributed to the fact that literature in East Asia and Europe are considered postcolonial works, owing to how they were once colonized before
…show more content…
When it comes to the most basic questions of what it means to be a human being, there is no division in the Western and Eastern sides of the world. Both share a fundamental purpose of philosophy to find meaning in one’s life and purpose to one’s path. According to the analysed texts, the common human innate trait of “curiosity” and “otherness” is exploited. For example, in A Wrinkle in Time, the concept of “otherness” is frequently explored through the introduction of actual aliens and life forms outside of Earth; in The Hunger Games, “otherness” is conveyed through the Districts and how little is known about other districts besides the fact that they exist; in Psycho-Pass Akane is curious about how the Sybil System works; in No.6, Shion, who has never set foot outside Kronos, has his curiosity piqued when he finally learns about the slumps outside the
Fahrenheit 451 Comparison Essay
872 Words | 4 PagesA dystopian society is dehumanizing, unpleasant, and completely unlike modern American society. Or is it? There are many similarities and differences between dystopian societies and modern American society. Three examples are in the book Fahrenheit 451, the film “2081”/”Harrison Bergeron”, and the novel The Selection. These similarities and differences can be represented in first responders, handicaps, and jobs.
Examples Of Outsiders In Jane Eyre
988 Words | 4 PagesGrowing up as a Buddhist Chinese Malaysian in an increasingly Islamic Malay-centric Malaysia, I oftentimes feel like an outsider. Consequently, I was drawn to the outsiders and the social Other in literature during my undergraduate years in NCCU. The presence of the Other and the outsider can be traced from ancient Greek dramas to modern literature, from Medea to the Underground Man.
Year 11 World History Essay
742 Words | 3 Pages1. Constantine was a former soldier that was given the title of Cesare of the West (in the Roman Tetrarchy created by Diocletian), and was assigned to the furthest reach of the empire which was the English city of York. 2. Constantine issues the Edict of Milan which declared official tolerance for Christianity. He also demanded the Christians to change their day of worship from the Hebrew Sabbath to the Roman day of the Sun.
World History Dbq Essay
1316 Words | 6 PagesDuring the Age of Exploration Europeans hoped to subside the power of Islam and diminish its threat to the security of Europe by expanding and controlling global markets by reducing their market trade, although it was believed the Muslim world had entered a period of decline and turmoil with the collapse of the Abbasid Caliphate during the Era of the Mongols, on the contrary in the shadows of the Age of Exploration between the late Fifteenth and early Sixteenth century in the Middle East and South Asian subcontinent the rise of three great Muslim Empires, the Ottomans, the Safavids and the Mughals was occurring, the Ottoman empire being one of the strongest. (William J. Duiker and Jackson J. Spielvogel, World History, vol. 1,446). These
Similarities Between Anthem And Fahrenheit 451
825 Words | 4 PagesFree thinking is outlawed in these worlds where everyone belongs to a complacent society. By doing this, the main characters often struggle with not wanting to stand out rather than doing what they expect for themselves. In both of these texts, the protagonists face conflicts not only in the world but also in themselves.
1984 And 1984 Comparative Essay
508 Words | 3 PagesDystopian texts espouse a variety of didactic messages that depend significantly upon both the context and zeitgeist of the time in which they were created. Differences can be found when comparing the techniques and perspectives the authors have chosen to represent their contextual concerns to audiences. Together both Fritz Lang’s silent black and white film ‘Metropolis’ 1927 and George Orwell’s novel ‘Nineteen Eighty-Four’ (*referred to as 1984) 1948, confront and provoke audiences to consider the impact that (abusive power + unquestionable control= insert question statement) can have not only on the characters in these two texts, but also on the cultural and political lives of the reader and viewer. By subjugating & dehumanising the lower classes, dictators are
S. Buck's The Good Earth And The Possibility Of Anti-Orientalism
1841 Words | 8 PagesThe novel’s fictional version of China is sometimes an unfairly bleak portrayal of the country, and its most shocking scenes cohere with false Orientalist narratives of Western imperialism and Asian inferiority. However, for an American author, Buck writes with unique authority; few Westerners in her era could match her breadth of knowledge about China, and even fewer could match her dedication to the advancement of cultural empathy with China. Despite the inescapable influences of dominant Orientalist narratives, Buck was able to craft a socially truthful, yet relatable text for Western audiences. Looking back at the outsize impact of The Good Earth, it becomes clear that it defies conventional definitions of Orientalism. Rather than assigning the ‘Orientalist’ label as a veiled accusation of racism and ignorance, scholars should instead recognize that—with the appropriate author intentionality and real-world impact—certain Orientalist works could be culturally acceptable, if not valuable
Social Values In Master Yun's Peace Under Heaven
1523 Words | 7 PagesThe author of “Peace under Heaven” demonstrates how a family of capitalists with falsified idea of social values goes to decline during the Japanese colonial period through depicting the personalities of four generations of Yun’s family. The author uses the satiric literary technic to describe the main protagonist, Master Yun, the typical capitalist living in the Japanese dominated Korean society. Master Yun only concerns his own self interests and discards the real threaten toward his own race and the whole Korean society from Japanese empire. He mistakenly thinks the Japanese dominated society is a peaceful world, which entirely contradicts the pure desire of Korean race. The son of Master Yun, Ch’angsik is a character only chasing
An Analysis Of Min-Zhan Lu's From Silence To Words
1001 Words | 5 PagesIt came to dominate my understanding of the discussion on the social and historical scene and to restrict my ability to participate in that discussion.(444) If we go back and use the reference again of the electronic tool we can see the struggle of being at home and communicating with her family and having an influence of capitalistic viewpoints and living the life of a capitalist, then immediately having to communicate in a different language at school and being surrounded by socialistic views and living the life of a socialist. Her thoughts were constantly flip-flopping and this became very frustrating for her. If we bring all these struggles into one main purpose, Min-Zhan Lu’s mother falls into silence two months before her death and Min-Zhan Lu attempts to “fill up that silence with words that I have since come to by reflecting on my earlier experience as a student in China.(437) The struggles that she faced growing up in China as a student and her past experiences have really helped her overcome life obstacles and develop her as a better reader and writer.
Mongols Dbq Essay
583 Words | 3 PagesIt’s the 13th century and a small tribe from central Asia and they are on the rise of conquering many land vast and far. This is the Mongol that is on the rise to conquer land by traveling through Asia, the Middle east, and Eastern Asia. There territory reached from Poland to Korea and Vietnam to Syria. The Mongols was a fearsome tribe that was very barbaric. They were a tribe lead by a man named Genghis Khan a very powerful man.
The Happiest Refugee
797 Words | 4 PagesThis report was commissioned by The Asian Education Foundation, to analyse the growing number of Asian texts being produced. This report will asses Family life, Resilience and the issue of Racism. Asian tests have had a large increase from the publishing of Anh Do’s autobiography, The Happiest Refugee. 2.0 Representations of growing up Asian in Australia 2.1 Family Life In the autobiography ‘The Happiest Refugee’, Do has a high regard for his family, that he illustrates throughout the memoir.
Confucius Lives Next Door Summary
602 Words | 3 PagesBook Review #1: “Confucius lives Next Door” When T. R. Reid became chief of The Washington Post's Tokyo bureau, he and his family moved to Japan for an extended stay. Moving from the wide-open spaces of Coloroda to the noise, rush and crush of Tokyo. As Reid and his family were opting for total immersion in Japanese culture, they decided to live in a Tokyo neighborhood and send their children to public schools within Toyko. The book “Confucius Lives Next Door” is T.R Reid's account of their experience as an American family living in a country with the population of roughly 28,000,000 people. The book is also an analysis of East Asia's postwar economic miracle and what Reid sees as it’s even more important "social miracle," the creation of ordered, civil societies marked by "the safest streets, the strongest families, and the best schools in the world," where lost wallets are returned to their owners with cash intact, baggage can be left unattended in the busiest train station, and no one locks their cars or bicycles.
Gene Luen Yang's Boxers Chapter Summary
600 Words | 3 PagesGene Luen Yang offers a humanistic perspective on western imperialism in China during the late nineteenth century to early twentieth century in his graphic novel Boxers, a tragic narrative about Chinese grassroots resistance against foreign occupation in which an armed revolution ultimately fails. The novel focuses on religious identity, and cultural connections in the face of invasion. Boxers highlights the negative effects of imperialism through clashes between different religions, ideologies and power structures. Therefore, the criticism of western imperialism presented in Boxers could support a world systems theory approach to international relations because it shows to exploitation through westernization and the squandering of cultural
Similarities Between 1984 And The Hunger Games
847 Words | 4 PagesDespite the large gap in time between their publishing, they share many obvious similarities in their interpretation of futuristic dystopian societies. However, the subtle similarities of the use of children and hope to control population is
Neocolonialism In Jessica Hagedorn's Dogeaters '
981 Words | 4 PagesJessica Hagedorn’s Dogeaters exposes lives of numerous characters living in the postcolonial Philippines. Hagedorn vividly paints the picture of a society freed from the foreign oppressor that still clings to the imported values and struggles to recreate itself. The postcolonial confusion and a sense of a lost national identity have allowed for a newly formed nationalism to spread. Yet, the influence of the former U.S rule lingers as society remains infatuated with Hollywood movies, soda drinks, and shopping. The Hagedorn's novel displays “the pressures that neocolonialism places on gender, as well as the pressures the gender places on neocolonialism” (Chang, 637).
More about Western And East Asian Literature Essay
Fahrenheit 451 Comparison Essay
872 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of Outsiders In Jane Eyre
988 Words | 4 PagesYear 11 World History Essay
742 Words | 3 PagesWorld History Dbq Essay
1316 Words | 6 PagesSimilarities Between Anthem And Fahrenheit 451
825 Words | 4 Pages1984 And 1984 Comparative Essay
508 Words | 3 PagesS. Buck's The Good Earth And The Possibility Of Anti-Orientalism
1841 Words | 8 PagesSocial Values In Master Yun's Peace Under Heaven
1523 Words | 7 PagesAn Analysis Of Min-Zhan Lu's From Silence To Words
1001 Words | 5 PagesMongols Dbq Essay
583 Words | 3 PagesThe Happiest Refugee
797 Words | 4 PagesConfucius Lives Next Door Summary
602 Words | 3 PagesGene Luen Yang's Boxers Chapter Summary
600 Words | 3 PagesSimilarities Between 1984 And The Hunger Games
847 Words | 4 PagesNeocolonialism In Jessica Hagedorn's Dogeaters '
981 Words | 4 Pages