In the book, The Great Deluge: Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans, and the Mississippi Gulf Coast author Douglas Brinkley takes you on a journey through the political corruption and under calculation of the magnitude of Hurricane Katrina’s effects.
He starts off the essay with his own personal account of the damage that Hurricane Katrina left. From there he moves into stories of other people from Louisiana and their evacuation stories. These stories ranged from animal shelters from multiple days prior, to stories about people who were just planning to wait it out. Then he moves into the main points of the book and how repeatedly the Mayor and Governor fail the people of New Orleans and surrounding areas by not taking the warnings and repeated
…show more content…
There is nothing that could encompass the overall feeling of Hurricane Katrina other than a picture of the broken levees and flooded houses. You could read all of the descriptions in the world about the Hurricane and the flooding and the deaths and the loss of homes, but none of it could perfectly show you how horrific the event truly was as one 2x3 inch image. It was not just flooding that was pictured that made a lasting impact on the audience's views of the devastation, but the people walking through their childhood neighborhoods that had been completely demolished into just piles of rubble. Something else that was striking in the pictures was the amount of people who had died. As the pictures showed people died in vastly different ways. There were examples from drowning in the church, to heart failures, to police violence, to infections in the Superdome. This book really makes you think about how differently the situation would have been handled if the hurricane had landed somewhere else.
Brinkley also clearly states his argument and backs it up with countless facts from a multitude of sources. By doing this Brinkley boosts his argument to make him seem more trustworthy because not only does he just use arguments that support his claim, but he also finds counterarguments and confronts them with facts and statistics to prove their
…show more content…
One of its strengths was for sure the pictures, but also the first hand stories of many people who actually survived the storm thus not just putting the argument from the author's point of view, but from several people's points of view. One of the main weaknesses was repetition of the same concept. It is understandable if you want the audience to grasp a certain part of the story so you repeat it once or twice, but three times or more consecutively the idea just becomes overused and no longer interesting. Another weakness was presenting what seemed to be a truly biased opinion on certain matters. For example his views on Nagin were quite negative and he did not present very much information that supported a possible counterargument on other things that might portray the mayor in more of a positive light. Brinkley definitely achieved his purpose for this book and it was quite an eye opening thing to read
Among these sources will be books, academic journals, oral history, and newspaper articles from the late 1980s and early 1990s. Additionally, newspaper articles documenting the remembrance of the storm at anniversaries of the event will be useful in providing insight into what happened. For example, the New York Times has its’ articles from the 1980s and 1990s available for access through its website. In addition, the Greenville public library has copies of newspapers from all over the nation that have been digitized and stored online that will have information on the events of Hurricane Hugo. The oral history will take the form of interviews with residents of Charleston, South Carolina who were eyewitnesses to Hurricane
In the book A.D New Orleans After The Deluge, By Josh Neufeld is about Hurricane Katrina and how it affected the people of New Orleans. This book was about real people that escaped and lived through the storm. Most people lost everything including their houses, all personal belongings, and jobs. As I was reading the book was shocked that in the beginning most of the characters were not worried about the storm they just wanted to wait it out. No one was expecting such a big storm and thought it would turn east like they normally did.
In the Wake of Hurricane Katrina Dave Eggers in his non-fiction book Zeitoun tells the story of Hurricane Katrina from the eyes of a Syrian-American family, the Zeitoun, who were living in New Orleans during the storm. Zeitoun, who is a father of four and a contractor, devoted his life for his hard work by serving the community of New Orleans. Zeitoun showed tremendous bravery during the Hurricane Katrina. He rescued many lives, including abandoned dogs at the time of the hurricane. The government response to the storm was very slow at that time and there was a lack of preparedness at all levels.
An Unredeemed Captive was written by John Demos and is about the Williams family and the trails they were put through. In the preface of the book John’s first sentence was “Most of all, I wanted to write a story.” He had taken an interest in Indian captivity and how they treated their captives. It took him awhile to choose what he wanted to write about and eventually settled for the Williams family. He writes about how the Williams family got abducted and eventually all were released except Eunice, who would come to embrace Catholicism, marry a Mohawk Indian, and eventually come to forget her heritage and even her first language-English.
Additionally, scientists had been warning New Orleans and the government that climate change would lead to increased storm activity and that the city’s defenses weren’t strong enough for such a storm. However, these warnings were ignored by the government and no preventative measures were taken which has influenced the effects of the storm. The reason for the poor response of the government and their negligence of the warnings is arguable. However, it is positive that the reason for this is that the majority of the people affected were the poor, and mostly colored, citizen of New Orleans. The city is racially and economically segregated and these citizen lived in the lower parts of the city, which go down to 11 feet below sea level.
“A time like this could change a man”, Abdulrahman Zeitoun thinks as he paddles the streets of New Orleans, first-handedly witnessing the devastating effects of Hurricane Katrina (138). This quote from the novel relates to an important assertion Dave Eggers makes. This assertion is that times of trouble can change a person, and can bring out his or her inner demons. This assertion is shown throughout the ending of the novel, where Eggers describes the effects of Zeitoun’s false imprisonment on Kathy’s mental state, through Kathy and Zeitoun’s relationship in the years following the storm and through Zeitoun’s trouble with the law in the years subsequent to the storm.
Hurricane Matthew began to form itself from a tropical wave off the coast of Africa in late September. It has been calculated that 26 citizens have died as a result of Hurricane Matthew’s flooding. Robert Ray, the author of the CNN News article, ‘‘Hurricane Matthew: Days of disaster unfold under a cloudless sky,’’ wrote this to inform his audience of the monstrous damage that the hurricane has done from Florida to North Carolina, after it hit Haiti and other Caribbean countries. His audience is the family and love ones of the citizens that experienced the hurricane hit and those that are concerned of the terror the people went through and want to find more information in how to help. Ray’s use of appeal to pathos helps him effectively be able
“The Atchafalaya” is an article by John McPhee, concerning the flow of the Mississippi River into the Atchafalaya region. McPhee interviews several people who have jobs related to the river and the maintenance of the Atchafalaya’s water flow. The location of the Mississippi River is crucial because if it moves, it could potentially destroy all of New Orleans and Baton Rouge, and, subsequently, their status as major shipping channels. Reading this article, I gained more insight on the importance of the river for the state of Louisiana and New Orleans. A quote in the article summarizes the reoccurring theme of society versus Mother Nature: “Man against nature.
Superstorm Sandy Superstorm Sandy devastated almost all of the eastern seaboard and parts of Cuba. The hurricane started as a normal tropical storm over the warm waters near the equator (Pacific and Atlantic oceans). Then began to spin counterclockwise and form into a hurricane. The hurricane was given a category one rating on October 23, 2012.Even though the hurricane did not touch the Dominican Republic it still dumped twenty inches of rain in Hispaniola. Over fifty people died from flooding and mudslides.
The “Johnstown Flood” was a chaotic result for a small middle class family, natural disasters happen so much in one’s lifetime and can be emotionally crippling. This natural disaster caused many families and homes to come crashing down, all the townspeople shed tears that day as they watched their homes and loved ones float away with the water. The parents, wives, and husbands all looked in horror as they watched their family die in front of them. David McCullough’s story “Johnstown Flood” deals with a disaster that has major impact on the characters in the story. As we begin this story we look into the lives of the Quinn family, A small middle class family in the late 19th century.
In the book The Grapes of Wrath, it portrays many of the experiences being lived in the Great Depression and the Dust bowl. But, it also portrays some of the many lives being lived in the modern age today. The book makes a powerful draw to many of the readers due to the fact that America was once in this position; that almost every family was in this position during the Great Depression. Even today in the modern age, most of readers have been through the struggles of trying to survive or what their family members had to do for a better life. The book gives a lot of connection and shows deep meaning that people understand the most.
Originally airing on HBO in a two part special, the documentary's eyebrow-raising premise placed on emphasis on the socio-political controversy surrounding the US government's poor management of a natural disaster. Various testimonies from interviewees revealed a historically oppressed city that left almost two thousand people dead, thousands more displaced from their beloved homes, and billions of dollars in damages. Lee's directorial masterpiece captured stories of potential corruption within New Orleans, and the pain of multiple families torn apart by death and disaster. Years later Lee followed up with a second series about the after effects and reconstruction of the storied metropolis titled "If God Is Willing And Da Creek Don't Rise." Tidbits of information, like the government's secret initiative to completely demolish government assisted-living housing projects.
When The Levees Broke Rhetorical Analysis Essay On August 29th, 2005, Hurricane Katrina made landfall on the coasts of southeastern Louisiana. Shortly after, New Orleans’ flood protection system failed, causing floodwalls and levees to topple and break. Covering major points in the film, as they broke, the lives, spirits, and thoughts of many Americans were also broken as well. In a documentary released on August 16, 2006, director Spike Lee utilizes rhetorical strategies to produce a profound vision into the city and it’s citizen’s internal devastation, grievance, and recovery of spirit, and our nation’s failure to assist; when the levees broke. The numerous incorporations of the emotional appeal strengthen Spike’s opinion in a unique way.
After reading The Perfect Storm, by Sebastian Junger, I have concluded that the book kept my attention throughout, but I believe it could have improved. The storyline is scattered among many different stories, all centered around the meteorological nightmare of October of 1991. The setting, time, and place quickly change from story to story as most end in human lives being slain by the storm. I believe the movie is structured better, as it is centered around only one story, the story of a Gloucester, Massachusetts fishing crew on the Andrea Gail. I do not think the author had the experience of these men, whom he wrote about to remember and respect.
Sandel, Michael J. (2009). Justice: What’s the right thing to do? New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. Introduction & Background Information In the book, Justice: