What Is The Difference Between Corey Brough Pros And Cons
Human Right Contraventions:
Australia v Brough
Teianee-Kai Breznikar
0061072288
University of Southern Queensland
Running Head: HUMAN RIGHT CONTRAVENTIONS 2
HUMAN RIGHT CONTRAVENTIONS 5
Word Count:
Human Right Contraventions:
Australia v Brough
The Australian government closely participated in the negotiation of the human rights treaties, these were signed and ratified explicitly recognising the rights of everyone. However, contraventions occur and generally involve one or more members of particular groups in society such as the indigenous, people with disabilities, youth and prisoners. A publicly recognized example is the case of Corey Brough. Brough is an juvenile indigenous Australian with a mild intellectual disability. He possesses a partial and limiting communication ability and has been diagnosed with Attention Deficit Disorder. The case entailed solitary confinement for 25 days within an adult facility; subject to isolation, exposed for excessive periods to artificial lighting, left without appropriate clothing or blankets and administered antipsychotic medication without appropriate medical valuation.
UN Source Documents and the Breach
During March 2003,
…show more content…
However, the HRC had rejected the claims that the administration of anti-psychotic medication to the minor without his consent had breached of Article 7, noting that the medication was prescribed following medical advice with the intention to control the self-destructive behaviour being experienced within the facility. It was concluded that he was therefore entitled to compensation for the ordeal under the convenient and Australia had a responsibility to ensure it did not happen to anyone else (Selected Decisions of the Human Rights Committee Under The Optional Protocol,
Prerogative Power In Australia
790 Words | 4 Pages‘The Tampa Decision: Examining the Australian Government’s prerogative power to detain and expel unlawful non-citizens in 2001’ The executive power of the Commonwealth has largely been neglected, both by the High Court and by commentators, receiving scant attention in comparison with the Commonwealth 's legislative and judicial powers. However, it was just fourteen years ago, in 2001, when a Norwegian cargo vessel MV Tampa being denied entry into Australia after rescuing 438 asylum seekers sparked one of the most controversial yet illuminating civil cases in Australian legal history. The result was a civil suit (Ruddock vs Vadarlis 2001) in which the Federal Government successfully appealed the initial ruling to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia, where it was found that the government does indeed possess a prerogative power to prevent the entry of non-citizens into
Washington V. Harper Case Summary
1116 Words | 5 PagesThe Right to Refuse Psychiatric Treatment Title and Citation: Washington v. Harper, 494 U.S. 210 (1990), Type of Action: Due Process Clause allowing the state to force antipsychotic medication to a serious mentally ill inmate. Facts of the Case: The respondent Walter Harper has been an inmate in the State of Washington Penal System since 1976. While not on antipsychotic medication, he has a tendency to become violent. On two occasions, he was transferred to the Special Offender Center (SOC). The SOC is and institution for convicted offenders who display severe psychiatric behaviors.
Asylum Seekers Persuasive Speech
492 Words | 2 PagesImagine if you were born into a country filled with poverty, fear, anxiety, despair and sorrow. The pain and suffering you would go through every day was so violent that you and your family had given up on all measures of hope. Every day you would fear persecution and you couldn’t even feel safe in the comfort of your own home. But what if there was a sliver of hope of escaping this drama occurring in your homeland by leaving by boat. All this drama gone in a flash, wouldn’t you want to try?
The Importance Of The NGRI Defense
861 Words | 4 PagesMany jurors and civilians can not accept that an individual was being let go because they were mentally ill, and not being held responsible for the action they had done. Most people believe that the NGRI verdict is better than the guilty verdict, when really that’s not the case. There are many myths that the public holds about the NGRI defense which can be a serious issue in search for help with ones’ health. Because of this, it is important that the public is educated and non-bias when it comes to deciding a
NMC Code Of Care: A Case Study
112 Words | 1 PagesCovert use of medication can be seen as dishonest as the NMC code (2015) states respect the level to which people receiving care want to be involved in decisions about their own health, wellbeing and care; the code of practice also states act with honesty and integrity at all times, treating people fairly. In contrast however, Beauchamp and Childress (2009) highlights non disclosure, limited discolour, deception or lying may be considered when veracity and the principle of autonomy is thought to conflict with other ethical obligation. Jean was given the opportunity to understand and evaluate what was being asked and was provided with all relevant information to support their decision making process.
Racism And Discrimination In The Criminal Justice System
1958 Words | 8 PagesLawmakers and criminal justice personnel are meant to be guarded against discriminatory laws, policies and practices and to guarantee equal and effective protection of the law to everyone. However, the sad reality is that discrimination does exist in our criminal justice system. This paper emphasises to show how certain groups in society such as the aboriginals or indigenous people have been discriminated against in some form or another by the police or by the criminal justice system itself. Racism and discrimination for Aboriginal people is a very real existence.
Asylum Seekers
1692 Words | 7 PagesIn Australia the current policy on asylum seekers and refugees, outlined in the Migration Act 1958 requires “people who are not Australian citizens and do not hold a valid visa to be detained” (Australian Government 2013, p.1). Newman, et al. (2010) illustrates that most asylum seekers in immigration detention centres endure horrific conditions of overcrowding, abuse of human rights and a lack of access to healthcare. The articles above support Newman’s et al. (2010) findings and further highlight the harmful physical and psychological effects of mandatory detention on children and their families.
Research Paper On Asylum Seekers
218 Words | 1 PagesOne of the issue that Australia is facing is asylum seekers traveling by boat and leaving their countries since their home countries due to war and terror to seek for a better life. Unfortunately that according to Australian Human rights commission that the Australian policy in 1992 that all non-citizen, including children, who seek entrance to Australia without legal visa are detained and most detainee are in detention centre. The biggest concern that asylum seekers are place in immigration centre which include children. There is 215 children in closed immigration dentition facilities and 642 children in community detention in Australia.
Essay On Asylum Seekers
499 Words | 2 PagesThis analysis looks at refugees and the social justice issue of Australia’s discriminatory treatment of refugees traveling to Australia seeking asylum. Australia’s current treatment of Asylum seekers includes taking them from an already extremely stressful environment and detaining them in remote detention facilities where they have limited interaction with family and friends. In some instances, this includes children and young people. The University western Sydney (2016)
Australia Persuasive Speech On Asylum Seekers
739 Words | 3 PagesIn Australia, refugees and asylum seekers are treated like the enemy in a war: the target of a highly resourced, military-led “deterrence” strategy complete with arbitrary detainment, detention camps, guards to terrorise them, forced deportations and the violent suppression of those who protest. Australia is failing to meet the standards required when regarding the treatment of asylum seekers. It is fact that asylum seekers make up less than 3% of Australia’s annual immigration yet the idea is being distorted to that of which they will overpopulate a country that prides itself on being a multicultural society. I want to shed light on the misconception that asylum seekers are not ‘legal’ when in actual fact it is a human right to seek freedom.
Amnesty International's Report 'By Hook Or By Crook'
502 Words | 3 PagesAmnesty international, a human rights organization, has released a report entitled "By hook or by crook". Documented between 2013 and 2015, the report finds the Australian government to be bribing crew members to disembark the passengers away from Australia. The report entails personal accounts from asylum-seekers, crew members, and the Indonesian police. The abuse evinced in the report show Australian officials intercepting a boat, boarded by asylum-seekers, and the transaction of $32,000 and maps for the destination to be directed to Indonesia. Amnesty International was able to interview the six crew members who were arrested for people smuggling, and learned that they had been directly told to land on Rote Island.
The Four Main Ethical Theory Of Beauchamp And Childress
1167 Words | 5 PagesRelevant legal and ethical considerations, focusing on the 4 main ethical principles and how each of these apply to this case using research evidence. Focusing on the ethical theory of Beauchamp and Childress, it is considered one of the most fundamental elements for beginning a discussion in the Not for resuscitation (NFR) debate. (Fornari, 2015). The four main ethical principles, autonomy, non-maleficence, beneficence and justice hold the grounding block for issues of this nature. End of life care is an imperative characteristic of acute stroke nursing, as stroke mortality rates remain high, regardless of enhancements in the health care industry.
Social Justice Refugee
1120 Words | 5 PagesThe concept of social justice encompasses finding the optimum balance between our combined responsibilities as a society, our responsibilities as individuals to contribute to a just society (University of New South Wales, 2011) and ensuring fairness, freedom and equality regardless of race, religion and ethical background. The social justice issue of Refugee’s suffers from a deprived extent of human dignity, human rights and social justice. The definition of a "refugee" is revealed in the 1951 United Nations Convention Relating which defines a refugee as an individual who: "owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the
Mandatory Child Detention Affects Common Good
135 Words | 1 PagesCommon good is a social aspect that describes issues of interest, benefit or concern to all, (Andre and Velasquez, 2014). The issue of child detention affects the common good. The common good here is freedom and the protection of human rights for all the children. Child detection serves as a breach of the freedoms of child protection and human rights of the detained children. The mandatory child detention system practiced in Australia is a form of child abuse.
Adoption Pros And Cons
1833 Words | 8 PagesArticle 12 of the United nations Convention on the Rights of the Child in regards to Adoption. Professor Ursula Kilkelly & Dr. Conor O’Mahony 12/01/2015 111705261 Table of Contents Abstract The right of children to be heard in adoption proceedings was generated from the provisions as laid out in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child [hereinafter UNCRC] in particular Article 12 .
More about What Is The Difference Between Corey Brough Pros And Cons
Prerogative Power In Australia
790 Words | 4 PagesWashington V. Harper Case Summary
1116 Words | 5 PagesAsylum Seekers Persuasive Speech
492 Words | 2 PagesThe Importance Of The NGRI Defense
861 Words | 4 PagesNMC Code Of Care: A Case Study
112 Words | 1 PagesRacism And Discrimination In The Criminal Justice System
1958 Words | 8 PagesAsylum Seekers
1692 Words | 7 PagesResearch Paper On Asylum Seekers
218 Words | 1 PagesEssay On Asylum Seekers
499 Words | 2 PagesAustralia Persuasive Speech On Asylum Seekers
739 Words | 3 PagesAmnesty International's Report 'By Hook Or By Crook'
502 Words | 3 PagesThe Four Main Ethical Theory Of Beauchamp And Childress
1167 Words | 5 PagesSocial Justice Refugee
1120 Words | 5 PagesMandatory Child Detention Affects Common Good
135 Words | 1 PagesAdoption Pros And Cons
1833 Words | 8 Pages