John D. Rockefeller, Andrew Carnegie, and Cornelious Vanderbilt are some of the names of the most influential businessmen or titans of industry. Their impact and achievements have shaped what the American economy is today. Their business strategies, inventions, and innovations have had a positive and negative impact on the world. While it is important to recognize their accomplishments and success, it is also crucial to have it be known of their negative impact on society. These men should be taught equally; including their positive and negative impacts on society. Andrew Carnegie has been one of the most impactful contributions to the steel industry in history. Carnegie strived and thrived for the economic scaling of steel which led his company, …show more content…
The most notable unethical practice that Carnegie continuously participated in was the poor treatment of his employees. The extremely poor working conditions within his factory were not taken kindly by the workers. Carnegie has made it clear to his workers that he is anti-union which raised concerns for his employees. His workers demanded better pay, hours, and working conditions which weren’t being met. Protests began to rise and Carnegie needed to dissolve them as soon as possible. Carnegie's handling of the Homestead protest was a disaster. Carnegie's plan was to hire Pinkerton agents to dissolve the protest group and break them up, but this would result in the deaths of several employees. People are now questioning whether Carnegie cares for his workers even with clear evidence of unethical practices. Carnegie’s work also contributed to the monopolistic business practices which would cause problems within the industry. “This first man gets the oyster and the second man gets the shell” is a quote by Andrew Carnegie and what he means by it is that being the first to do something and the person who stays on top will get the rewards. With this type of mindset, Carnegie believed that he always needed to be on top of the chain which could be an explanation to his monopoly. By having a monopoly on a resource that is needed everywhere, Carnegie was able to …show more content…
Rockefeller is another major business power holder of his time. Rockefeller is most known for his absolute power within the oil industry. Rockefeller’s company, Standard Oil Company, has made great strides in the oil industry. Rockefeller’s innovative ideas and pursuit of domination pushed his oil company into such a powerful position he created a horizontal monopoly. With a company, this large, Rockefeller has provided countless jobs and opportunities for his employees. Rockefeller is also responsible for providing infrastructure beyond the Standard Oil Company by making storage facilities, newspapers, general stores, and even railroads. During this time, railroads were becoming increasingly important because of their quicker transportation of people and equipment. Rockefeller didn’t stop even after business; with his old age, he wanted to continue to help others by using his largely accumulated wealth. He donated around $540 million to many charities including medical research, scientific investigations, and vaccine research. According to Philanthropy Roundtable, Rockefeller is one of the most accomplished philanthropists in history. Rockefeller wanted his deeds to live on even after his death. “Next to doing the right thing, the most important thing is to let people know you are doing the right thing” said Rockefeller, and it means that Rockefeller knew that he was trying to do the right thing and wanted people to know that is was, which could lead to a deeper
Andrew Carnegie once said, “No man can become rich without himself enriching others” (Crazy Billionaires Speak: Motivational Quotes by Billionaires on Success, Business and Life 9). Many people associate Andrew Carnegie with his contributions to the economic world during his lifetime and future generations. However, he was also an inspiration to all, because he proved that a person living in tough times could ultimately strive and attain his/her utmost success. Additionally, Carnegie is the embodiment of the American Dream, because he is known as one of the greatest industrialists of his time who grew economically from rags to riches. He strived to achieve world peace and inspired others to follow his footsteps.
The boom of industrialization in the United States lead to several changes throughout the nation that forever affected both the economy, as well as workers within it. One such worker was named Andrew Carnegie, who as a boy began in a very poor family, but then throughout his life worked hard to advance up to one of the highest positions in the steel manufacturing industry. This made his presence widely known throughout the American economy, and furthermore later brought up the argument: was Andrew Carnegie a hero? Throughout his life, though primarily during his career, Andrew Carnegie made several debatable choices concerning his work. These choices further clouded the argument as to whether he was a hero or not.
Andrew Carnegie, a Scottish American leader was best known for his steel and production and philanthropy also know as to some as a robber baron and to other as a “captain industry,” Carnegie founded the Carnegie Steel in the Progressive Era. His company led to him learning about the lives of the workers and to see how life really worked for them. He began his essay “Wealth” by describing the problems of generosity by the rich men of the upper class. Carnegie wanted the wealthy men to comprehend how to be philanthropy and reconstruct their surplus means in a responsible and thoughtful manner.
In his view, hoarding wealth and failing to use it for the greater good was shameful. Carnegie, following his philosophy, donated millions of dollars to fund libraries, cultural institutions and education all around the world. By building and funding such institutions, Carnegie left behind a semblance of his positive contributions as a Captain of industry by setting an example for others in his position. Take detailed notes from the reading about why Carnegie was a Robber Baron (bullets are fine).
Andrew Carnegie's views on wealth is almost the same as how billionaires think and use their money today . Carnegie's thought that people with money they would be able to help the poor by building libraries and other type of building that would help the middle class to get an education. He taught by helping the middle class rise from poverty and give them an education they would be able to do great things in life. Based on what I have read in both article Andrew Carnegie's views were considered ethical because he wanted what was best for the poor and he wanted to help the coal miners and give everyone an education.
Maybe it is because of the way that he plans on addressing the strategies on how to stay successful and what problems some may encounter. “The Gospel of Wealth are Carnegie’s ideas on how the government should deal with the new wealth of the world. He became known as the second richest man in the world and he strongly felt as if men in his stature should spend their money responsibility and wisely. Such as, giving to the poor and helping them when needed”.
Carnegie’s True Intentions Andrew Carnegie was an immigrant from Scotland that used the Bessemer’s process to change the steel industry and became one of the richest entrepreneurs during his time. He was crucial during this time because he helped build the steel industry. Steel was stronger and could be used to build taller structures such as skyscrapers. Carnegie’s success was a result of his hard work and dedication. He became an inspiration for others because his romantic story showed that hard work will eventually pay off.
Carnegie could have offered more to his employers who risked their lives each day to provide him with a successful
Throughout his lifetime he aided in launching the area of biomedical research, and funding scientific investigations. For example according to the website Philanthropy Roundtable he states “The best philanthropy is constantly in search of the finalities—a search for a cause, an attempt to cure evils at their source.” This is depicting that Rockefeller knew the challenges of intelligently donating large sums of money to human welfare, this established a sequence of institutions that are significant in the history of American Philanthropy,science,medicine, and the general public health. This helps portray my argument on how he is indeed a captain of industry. Due to Rockefeller’s donations the research resulted in vaccines for diseases such as meningitis and the yellow fever.
Rockefeller, aside from being the richest person ever recorded, also happened to be one of the most controversial figures of history. He began his journey to wealth during the civil war by starting an oil refining company, the profits of which he saved, except for what he gave to the union. Eventually, he established the firm Rockefeller, Andrews, and Parker; which owned two oil refineries in Cleveland. This firm was the predecessor to Standard Oil, which would soon become his empire. Once Rockefeller opened Standard Oil and began to rise in the ranks of the competitive industry, the means by which his business grew became clear and were met with strong criticism.
Carnegie was involved in a highly competitive business. Does this excuse him (and others) for their treatment of workers? As told Carnegie grew up poor and then was forced to work unbearable hours and six days a week for little pay. “In 1849, at the age of 14, Ohio Telegraph Company hired Andrew as a telegraph messenger for $2.50 per week. With roaring ambition and an unbelievable work ethic propelling him, Carnegie taught himself the language of the telegraph and within a year became the operator.
John Jr. kept the organizations and schools up and also, created an organization for the United States Service. This, organization help with soldiers coming back from World War II. John used the foundations that his dad started to, donate three hundred million dollars to help the men and women fighting for our country. John D. Rockefeller Sr. was devoted to wildness and seeing the beautiful scenery. John Jr. then donate for conservation plans, the donations went from Yosemite National Park in Maine to Acadia National Park in California.
Carnegie was considered a Robber Baron for many reasons. For example, he gained huge profits because of his workers low wages. In the excerpt, “Who was Andrew Carnegie,” the author said, “his steel workers were often pushed to long hours and low wages.” Workers worked in harsh conditions and received no benefits causing them to live in poverty with scarce food, clothing, and shelter. Workers were tired of the low wages and decided to go on strike.
Andrew Carnegie amassed his fortune by utilizing vertical integration and employing cheap labor, at the expense of the common man. This tactic proved effective when competing with other companies. However, as a result, workers were manipulated and used as pawns in a game with a predetermined winner. Working as blue collar laborers, the employees had no chance to improve their socioeconomic status and their way of life, completely contradicting Carnegie’s own theory that wealth would be rewarded to those who worked hard and proved themselves capable and competent of handling it.
His employees couldn’t even express distress without getting incarcerate. This amplify their discontent even further with Carnegie. Laborers did not agree with Carnegie and publicly disagree with