ipl-logo

What Was Fdr's Court Package Plan

1143 Words5 Pages

FDR's Court-Packing Plan On February 5th of 1937, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt surprised the public when he announced the controversial Judicial Procedures Reform Bill of 1937 (more commonly known as the Court-Packing Plan). This plan was constructed in response to the criticism his New Deal programs were facing during his first term as president. He presented a bill that was aimed at expanding the membership of the judges in the Supreme Court. Franklin D. Roosevelt introduced the proposal after garnering majority votes in the 1936 elections. The motive behind his move of expanding the Supreme Court was to make the court more efficient. President Roosevelt argued that he wanted to bring diversity to the courts and also bring new ideologies …show more content…

He wanted to expand the court so that it could accommodate up to 15 members (Proctor 1147). The move made his critics charge against the bill, and they argued that the president wanted to pack the court so that he could neutralise the hostilities of the Supreme Court Judges against his new dealings. The critics believed that he tried to stop the judicial arm of the government from checking the actions of the executive arm of the government. Through this event, the constitutional principle of checks and balances protects the three arms of government was used appropriately. The judicial arm of government believed that the legislation that were being pushed by the executive were not good for the country and they struck them off. The legislative arm also played a role in checking both the judicial branch and the executive branch. Although he presented a different thought, the critics believed that since the courts had been striking down his New Deal bills, he aimed to introduce more judges so that they could help …show more content…

Through the New Deal legislation, the president had aimed at ensuring that he leads the country out of the economic regression that was being experienced at the time. The New Deal legislation also saw the executive arm of the government grow both in power and in size. This is because the executive branch controlled most of the sectors that shape the economy of the country. For instance, President Roosevelt was in charge of the rural electrification program, and he was also in charge of the federal labour laws, the Social Security creation and other programs and projects that helped farmers and people in business to grow their enterprises (Jackson, Donald & Riddlesperger 165). Through this, the president Roosevelt was able to manage the economy of the country. The president through the FDR's Court-Packing Plan had to ensure that he had the judicial arm in check and also balance its powers so that some of these legislations could be implemented (Lovell n.p). The executive arm of the government was checking and balancing the powers of the judiciary at this point in this event. The judiciary and the legislature also tried to ensure that the executive arm does not increase its powers and authority to the extent that it can control the other arms of

Show More
Related

  • How Did Fdr Build The Power Of The Executive Branch

    645 Words  | 3 Pages

    FDR was able to (very covertly) bring the executive office's power up by lowering the power of the judicial office. He achieved this by passing a bill called the Judicial Procedures Reform Bill in 1937. This bill (better known as the 'court-packing plan') was a legislative initiative that was proposed by FDR to add more justices to the American Supreme Court. FDR's purpose in attempting to pass this bill was to obtain favorable rulings in regards to the New Deal legislation, that the court had originally ruled unconstitutional. FDR pursued the New Deal legislation in an attempt to provide relief, recovery, and reform to the nation during the Great Depression.

    Read More

  • Was Franklin Roosevelt's Court Packing Scheme Evidence Of This?

    473 Words  | 2 Pages

    Thus, as the public grew angry at the Supreme Court’s decisions, Roosevelt struck, proposing the Judicial Reforms Bill of 1937, now known as the Court Packing Scheme. He wanted to add more justices to the Supreme Court to shift the court towards his favor, so the court would allow his bills. Intending to gain public support, Roosevelt introduced this idea to the public through his 9th fireside chat, But this backfired.

    Read More

  • President Franklin Roosevelt's Court Packing Scheme

    435 Words  | 2 Pages

    Was president Franklin Roosevelt’s Court Packing scheme a plan that consisted of a wish to help end America’s Great Depression or was it a hunger for dictatorial power? Franklin Roosevelt based his election campaign on a New Deal, a series of programs he claimed would help end the Great Depression. While Roosevelt won the election, many of his New Deal bills would not win the approval of the United States Supreme Court. Franklin Roosevelt believed the problem lied not in his bills but in the Supreme Court. He believed the four Conservatives Justices would convince Justice Owen Roberts, who was somewhat neutral, to vote against Roosevelt’s bills.

    Read More

  • Summary Of A Brilliant Solution

    1319 Words  | 6 Pages

    They had to find the perfect balance for the executive branch. They could not give them too much power or else there would be an opportunity for tyranny and the possibility of another monarchy, but on the other hand, the branch had to possess enough power to do something and make a change. The problem faced with the articles of confederation was a lack of power and this cannot be fixed with more lack of power. Pinckney said, “How far do you intend to go in reducing the power of the states?” (Page 69).

    Read More

  • New Deal DBQ

    949 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the 1930’s a group of government programs and policies were established under President Franklin D. Roosevelt, they were created with the intention to help the American people during The Great Depression. The Great Depression was a time were many banks failed, many businesses and factories went bankrupt, and millions of Americans are out of work, homeless, and hungry. Most New Deal programs gave American citizens economic relief, chances for employment and helped for the general good. The New Deal’s intention was to help Americans during these troubling times filled with economic uncertainty, and in that aspect, it was a success. After the New Deal was implemented, unemployment rates were gradually lowered.

    Read More

  • Theodore Roosevelt Dbq

    545 Words  | 3 Pages

    It is hard to believe Theodore Roosevelt was never supposed to become the President due to all of his significant contributions to the office and to the United States. Roosevelt agreed to be the Vice President of McKinley knowing that, assuming the role would end his political career. However, following the assassination of William McKinley, Roosevelt was brought back into politics where he became the President. Roosevelt was different from other presidents in that he saw the office as a legislative leader, brought many reforms that benefit modern America today, and handled challenges in a quick manner.

    Read More

  • Federalism Vs Tyranny

    943 Words  | 4 Pages

    [the three branches] should not be so far separated as to have no constitutional control over each other.” (James Madison, Federalist Paper #51, 1788). This quote by James Madison shows that the Constitution basically separates powers of each branch, and gives each the right to stop the other if they feel that something isn’t fair or equal without creating a ruler or making one branch the strongest. With the concept of checks and balances, the founding fathers were able to stop soft tyranny, and keep government in a balanced and equal

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq Essay

    564 Words  | 3 Pages

    The wealth during the 1920s left Americans unprepared for the economic depression they would face in the 1930s. The Great Depression occurred because of overproduction by farmers and factories, consumption of goods decreased, uneven distribution of wealth, and overexpansion of credit. Hoover was president when the depression first began, and he maintained the government’s laissez-faire attitude in the economy. However, after the election of FDR in 1932, his many alphabet soup programs in his first one hundred days in office addressed the nation’s need for change.

    Read More

  • How Did Federalist 51 Impact Today's Government

    543 Words  | 3 Pages

    These checks and balances ensure a separation of powers and prevents Madison’s fear of corruption due to too much

    Read More

  • How Did Theodore Roosevelt Affect The Economy

    1215 Words  | 5 Pages

    Franklin Roosevelt was a very influential and important president in American history who had an immense impact on the American economy and social policy during the 1930’s and 40’s and throughout the future of America, he also shared some ideas with the author John Steinbeck. He idolized Theodore Roosevelt, and took great inspiration from him. He has served as president for longer than any other president in history, serving for three terms instead of the usual two that is generally accepted as the maximum amount of time that a president can serve. He drove America out of the great depression and through the second world war.

    Read More

  • Comparison Between Presidents Hoover And Franklin Roosevelt

    713 Words  | 3 Pages

    The transition between presidents Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt marked the transformation from a weak, to a strong form of government, which became directly involved in the lives of the people. This was primarily caused by the difference in the executive leaders ideologies, where Hoover was more focused on individual responsibility and capitalism, Roosevelt was more concerned with immediate action based on government intervention. Overall, the New Deal sacrificed the amount of personal responsibility that the people had with their own economic security. The power of the federal government was strengthened, but the long-lasting effects based on the social and economic policies was beneficial for the United States. Herbert Hoover began

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq Analysis

    1944 Words  | 8 Pages

    Beginning with President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s inauguration in 1933, the New Deal was passed in the context of reformism and rationalism as the United States proceeded through the Great Depression. The American people looked to the President to instill reform policies to help direct the country out of an economic depression, and thus often sought to abandon the society that existed before the Great Depression. Roosevelt instituted New Deal policies to attempt to combat this period of economic decline, many of which were successful and appealed to the American people’s desires. President Roosevelt’s New Deal is often criticized for being excessively socialistic in nature, thus causing dramatic changes in the fundamental structure of the United

    Read More

  • Why The Judicial Branch Is The Most Powerful

    478 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court at the time was Chief Justice John Marshall, and he declared that this whole process of delivering commissions for judges, the Judiciary Act, was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court declared this act illegal, because it gave the Supreme Court a power that they were forbidden to have. This is when the first law was declared unconstitutional and judicial review came into

    Read More

  • Franklin Delano Roosevelt Ethical Issues

    947 Words  | 4 Pages

    At the start of his presidency, the biggest threat to America was the Great Depression. Within his first 100 days, Roosevelt introduced his first set of New deals. They were a large amount of various acts, that called for radical action. Some of the most notable accomplishments of Roosevelt's new deal included the AAA, the Social Security Act, and the Emergency Banking Act. The Agricultural Adjustment Act allowed the government a firmer position in American agricultural.

    Read More

  • New Deal Turning Point

    1830 Words  | 8 Pages

    Relief for the unemployed, Recovery of the economy and Reform so there was not another Great Depression. FDR aimed to help the economy recover and to do this, created the New Deal. His far-reaching vision was to put American’s back to work and fix the economic collapse. It created jobs, establishing public work programs and encouraged

    Read More

More about What Was Fdr's Court Package Plan

Open Document