ipl-logo

Who Is Anne Hutchinson's Argument Against Religion

415 Words2 Pages

John Winthrop wrote in his journal that Anne Hutchinson claimed she received direct and divine revelations from God. Hutchinson taught and preached the doctrine of the Inner Light as she kept “two public lectures every week in her house” (117). Hutchinson believed she was in direct communication with God and did not need to obey the Church’s law. However, the Puritans came to consider that Hutchinson’s belief was against the word of the Bible and God as it demonstrated a Satanic and evil religious viewpoint. The Puritans “banished (Hutchinson) out of (their) jurisdictions as being a woman not fit for (their) society” (33) and judged her to be guilty of speaking untruthfully.
The Puritans believed that Hutchinson’s “untruthful” claim was satanic and against God because it went against the words and morals of the Bible. Winthrop asserts to Hutchinson …show more content…

The text Winthrop incorporates seems to support that in the Puritan’s belief, the Church goes above the law and everything concerning legal rights is carried out by the Church. Winthrop states that “the church, with one consent, cast (Hutchinson) out” (118). This text helps support why the Puritans believed that Hutchinson’s claim was against God and satanic. Because Hutchinson followed and preached the doctrine of the Inner light, which did not heed the law of the Church, the Puritans believed she was committing crime against the Church as well. The Puritans believed any religious beliefs that did not heed to the Church’s law is ultimately satanic and against God. After Hutchinson’s banishment from their society, the Puritans rejoiced “it was a happy day to the churches of Christ here, and to many poor souls, who had been seduced by (Hutchinson)” (119). This statement by the Puritans helps indicate that any wrong doing against the Church was considered

Show More
Related

  • How Did Religion Affect The Puritans In The 1600s

    354 Words  | 2 Pages

    Religion was very important to the Puritans in the 1600s. John Winthrop a member of the Puritans gentry, wrote to his wife the ‘I am verily persuaded God will bring some heavy affliction upon this land.” A year later he went and lead a group of a group of puritans to New England. By the 1630s another twenty thousand Puritans would come to America. When John became governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, he told immigrants that will have to guide people toward this holy ideal or they were not welcomed.

    Read More

  • Differences Between New England And Chesapeake

    591 Words  | 3 Pages

    Religion was an essential part of everyday life and it provided individuals with a purpose in life. John Winthrop’s goal was to expand the Protestant community (Puritans) and his main focus was to have a better relationship with God. Winthrop especially desired for all the settlers of New England

    Read More

  • What Is Anne Hutchinson's Role In Religion Before The Great Awakening

    301 Words  | 2 Pages

    Religion before the Great Awakening was strictly based on class and social status. Most people in the colonies sat in different seats, and they were divided into sections. It was not until the Great Awakening that these different social groups of people started to mix. Women, for example were treated harsh in the Puritan churches. They were considered as subordinates of men, and they did not have any roles in churches.

    Read More

  • Anne Hutchinson's Struggle Against The Puritan Rule In Massachusetts

    349 Words  | 2 Pages

    About 124 years ago today, an important woman arrived at our colony, her name was Anne Hutchinson. She was one of our founders and a significant figure, not only known in this colony. Anne had a different interpretation of the Bible, this was against the Puritan rule in Massachusetts, and that’s why she was exiled to Rhode Island. While she lived in Massachusetts, Anne was recognized for holding church meetings in her own home. This was because of the way she interpreted the Bible.

    Read More

  • Who Is Ann Hutchinson In A Model Of Christian Charity

    830 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ann Hutchinson was a woman who was banished from Boston in 1638 by John Winthrop, due to her being unfit for the society. Hutchinson was deemed unfit by Winthrop because she believed the minister, John Wilson, was preaching against the Puritan belief of predestine or covenant of grace. Ann thought Wilson preached more off the ideology of the covenant of works; meaning if a person worked hard enough to be good and do charitable things, such person would earn a place in heaven. Puritans believed that God chooses people to be a part of his “elect” (people who would go to heaven regardless of their sins) and this spot in heaven could not be earned. Since Ann Hutchinson accused Wilson of preaching against Puritan views, she was soon banished for

    Read More

  • Anne Hutchinson Research Paper

    225 Words  | 1 Pages

    The heresy of Anne Hutchinson of Massachusetts expounded in 1634. Anne Hutchinson was forty-five and a mother of fifteen children. later following the Puritan leader John Cotton to the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1634. She brought attention to Cotton’s theology through her way with words. This attracted people to meetings at her home, on Mondays to talk about Cotton’s Sunday sermon.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Anne Bradstreet And Jonathan Edwards And The Puritans

    1079 Words  | 5 Pages

    Puritans are a people with a very strong belief in both God and the power of God. When people see power, they interpret it in different ways. Some know of power through anger and impulse, while others see power through the goodness the powerful one shows. Although Anne Bradstreet and Jonathan Edwards are both puritan poets, their writings convey mainly different, though sometimes similar, views on God because they have different perceptions of His will and the use of His power. Anne Bradstreet listens to and accepts anything that God wishes, and that is shown through her poem Upon the Burning of my House.

    Read More

  • Winthrop's Argumentative Essay

    133 Words  | 1 Pages

    (Q) How could the leaders of the Puritans look at this case and think that their religion or their lifestyle is healthy for the people? Winthrop 's ideology is basically telling the people that no matter what good deeds you do it 'll never be good enough for God. On the other hand this guilt is basically what built America. Why else would the Puritans be working so hard to make a functional city (besides the Queen 's authority and the promise of freedom of religion) they thought that they were the "chosen ones" by God and that the city upon a hill was the promise land.

    Read More

  • The Trial Of Anne Hutchinson: Heretical Teacher Or Guardian Of Religious Liberty

    823 Words  | 4 Pages

    When I began researching Hutchinson and found out what she stood for, I questioned and couldn't quite understand why what she believed in was persecuted by the Puritans. The article called “Anne Hutchinson - significance, beliefs, banishment - history” stated, “Hutchinson, like Cotton, stressed salvation by God’s grace alone (the Covenant of Grace), and she disavowed the Puritan belief that good works were a sign of God’s grace,” (2009). This quote encapsulates what Hutchinson believed and I feel the same as her. I originally thought the Puritan Doctrine was just like a regular Christian religion, but a little more strict. I never knew that this doctrine didn’t agree with having a personal relationship with God on your own terms.

    Read More

  • Puritan Ideas And John Winthrop's Impact On American Culture

    1394 Words  | 6 Pages

    The ideas constructed by the Puritans were not simply a principal starting point for American culture because they were the first in the country, but because they offered distinct ways of thinking that are still deep-seated in our culture today. Although many of the ideas of Puritans have evolved or vanished over time, it is important to give credit to the Puritan writers and thinkers such as John Winthrop and John Cotton who offered ideas that were new at the time and that stayed with the American consciousness—culturally, socially, and politically. “John Winthrop's legacy can be seen primarily in the fields of government, commerce, and religion. It was religion that would most impact John's life; his religion would ultimately impact the

    Read More

  • Religious Rhetoric

    1221 Words  | 5 Pages

    In John Winthrop’s speech about the city upon a hill, he makes an appeal towards the unity of the group by mentioning that they needed to, “Entertain each other in brotherly affection,” in order to walk humbly with God (Winthrop, 1630, pp.1). By doing so, Winthrop told the other Puritans aboard the Arbella, they would keep the, “Unity of the spirit in the bond of peace,” and God would walk with them, showering them with blessings and wisdom (Winthrop, 1630, pp.1). While this community was built upon the idea of peace, brotherhood, and helping each other in the name of God, the Salem Witch trials were almost the opposite. Coming from the mouth of Deodat Lawson, he told the people of Salem to come to arms, to be, “faithful unto death in spiritual warfare,” and spare none to rid themselves of the satanic fury afflicting them (LeBeau, 1998, p.89). In mentioning that people should follow their faith until death, the tone is vengeful and full of blood lust, even though it is assumed that the original purpose of the sermon, at the time, was to restore faith in the magistrate who had condemned five women to be executed on spectral evidence, which Cotton Mather abhorred as legal evidence (Mather, 1971; LeBeau, 1998).

    Read More

  • Summary Of Anne Hutchinson's American Jezebel

    1036 Words  | 5 Pages

    In her book, American Jezebel: The Uncommon Life of Anne Hutchinson, the Woman Who Defied the Puritans, Eve LaPlante explores parts of the life of Anne Hutchinson. Her intent is to tell the story of Anne Hutchinson’s life and clear her name as a woman who was accused of being a heretic in colonial America. LaPlante walks the reader through the trial Anne Hutchinson had with the leaders of her colony and gives background information throughout the book to share the story of Hutchinson’s life. LaPlante starts the story of Anne Hutchinson’s life at the beginning of her well-known trial. She tells of the occurrences in the room and compares Hutchinson’s trial to her father’s trial, which was similar in their accusation and punishment.

    Read More

  • Comparing Sinners In The Hands Of An Angry God And Upon The Burning Of Our House

    1000 Words  | 4 Pages

    Jonathan Edwards’s sermon “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” and Anne Bradstreet’s “Upon the Burning of Our House” seem at first glance quite similar to one another regarding context, however, after taking a closer look, it becomes apparent that there are some substantial differences. These differences cannot be understood without the knowledge of cultural context concerning the Puritan belief system and their lifestyle. “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” was written with the sole purpose of scaring and intimidating the people that purtinans believed to be sinners. Edwards’s work contributed to a movement called “The Great Awakening”. It’s objective was to make the so-called ‘sinners’ aware of their wrongdoings and compel them to repent.

    Read More

  • The Crucible Reverend Hale Quotes

    986 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Fall of Reverend Hale People’s views are constantly changing. They can be so confident in the beginning and afterward, they can be uncertain about their beliefs. This is exactly what happened in the Salem Witch Trials with Reverend Hale. Between February 1692 and May 1693, people were accused and brought to court on allegations of witchcraft. Puritans were a harsh branch of the Church who believed that they are God’s chosen ones.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Devices In John Winthrop Speech

    393 Words  | 2 Pages

    Puritans are Europeans who escaped religious persecution from the Church of England. The Puritans age likely varies from children to adults. However, it’s apparent that Winthrop is appealing more towards Puritan males to create their ideal utopia. Winthrop evokes God to entice the colonist to fruitfully colonize the land. He uses nationalism, religion, and imagery to entice the colonist into creating a bountiful colony.

    Read More

More about Who Is Anne Hutchinson's Argument Against Religion

Open Document