In Ernest Hemingway’s short story “Soldier’s Home” depicts the common and tragic affect of war on soldiers. The protagonist in the story, Harold Krebs, face what many other soldiers have experienced after being at war many soldiers perhaps have come home from war physically, but mentally they are elsewhere. This is the concept in this story that Hemingway has presented. Krebs comes back home after wartime to a seemingly solid home in which he no longer feels comfortable. Krebs returns home very late after World war I and discovers that he has missed his deserved warm welcome back at his own home town. Returning from the war to an empty, desolate train station, Hemingway makes it very clear that his arrival is uncelebrated. This idea is …show more content…
Before the war, there was a time when he was not different than any other boy in his town. This idea is made apparent by the picture of Krebs with his buddies at the Methodist College to which he once attended. Hemingway explains for the reader the details of this picture: “There is a picture which shows him among his fraternity brothers, all of them wearing exactly the same height and style collar” (Hemingway 152). Before the war, Krebs was working toward his future by going to college and hopefully become a contributor to society one day, once he went to war his future goals and plans drastically changed. Throughout the story, Krebs is depicted as a war-hardened and dedicated soldier. Hemingway never indicates to the reader the extent of his actions in the war, so the details of the war are left up to the individual to piece together. For one reason or another, when being asked about the war, Hemingway narrates that Krebs often lies. The significance is how he does not like to lie since lying makes him feel horrible about himself, but he continues to do so. Krebs hates to lie about the war, however, he does it because he feels obligated: “As he lies to meet expectations of society, his own self esteem drains away, leaving him blank and barren” (Brouder 67). He feels he is forgotten as the town moves on from the war. The other soldiers have also moved on with their lives, but Krebs cannot break himself from the grasp of
This reminds me in paragraphs four and five the lies Krebs makes is a person who is fallen or injured they are not important those people are overlooking them. This reminds me of the relationship of Krebs and his sister when they have fights together. Also, this love is reminded between him and his sister when at the kitchen table eating breakfast and finally that conversation turned into a fight(16). Finally Krebs goes to his sisters indoor baseball game to watch as he was
More than 5,000 families in the United States, have sedulous relative fighting for our country’s freedom. Many of those families have not the slightest idea of what war is like, and all of its physical and mental effects. The author uses descriptive words to take the reader on a mental voyage. The soldier keeps a conversationalist tone and uses rhetorical strategies such as imagery and rhetorical questions to show how miserable he is living. The e-mail begins with the solider mentally describing your living area; he describes it like a million dust particles that are glued to you.
If we come back late from the Soldiers’ Home we have to show passes” (Remarque,1985,1929,p.187).Although the soldiers were not under the same exact confinements as the prisoners some of their restrictions flowed over into the lives of soldiers. The soldiers were confined and watched under the guards along with the soldiers unknowingly. The separation from their families is something both men had to deal with unwillingly due to the circumstances they were placed in. In war, men are separated from their family for months at a time.
The presence of a missing comrade express the horrors that soldiers face because of the extensive effort and time that the search entails. As the young men continuously search for their missing comrade, Kiowa, muck covers their bodies, which hinders their ability to identify one another. The muck and filth “seem to erase identities, transforming the men into identical copies of a single soldier” as all of the men become unrecognizable under uniform (O’Brien). With the use of symbolism, O’Brien develops a state in which the soldiers lose their sense of appearance from the filth that covers them. Kiowa, the soldier that had fallen, “was angled deeply into the muck, upside down” after a piece of shrapnel struck him (O’Brien).
Unfortunately, World War I took a drastic turn towards Harold Krebs mentality. Returning to a town that has no care in the truth makes Harold Krebs disgusted making his leave easier to make. Constantly having to lie and repress his new self to the world was nauseous enough for Krebs. The psychological theory shows that Harold Krebs became a stranger to himself, society, and family; therefore, his detachment of society will help him discover himself.
In Ernest Hemingway’s “Soldier’s Home,” Harold Krebs is a returning soldier from World War I that receives no praise. Hemingway uses conflict and setting to develop Krebs as a depressed character who wants to avoid lying about feelings. Hemingway uses the setting of “Soldier’s Home” to influence the character of Krebs. The story takes place post-World War I, “He enlisted in the Marines and did not return to the United States until… 1919”
Krebs feels loved by his family. “ He was still a hero to his two young sisters. His mother would have given him breakfast in bed if he had wanted it.” Even though Krebs isn’t welcomed into his town with open arms, and his stories aren't wanted, he was still loved and considered a hero by his family. Everyone in his family looks up to him and wants to hear his war
Krebs resentment for God continued to grow as a result of being forced to keep quiet about the
Hemingway begins Krebs’ story in a Methodist college in Kansas when the war starts off in 1917. When the war ends Krebs chose to stay in Germany for the next six months and when he comes back he realizes that the town moved on about the war and didn’t get the welcome he thought he deserved. This leads to the theme of not being able to find an outlet for pain. He wanted people to listen to his stories so they would be able to see the pain of what he went through throughout the war and the heroic actions he accomplished while fighting
The True Weight of War “The Things They Carried,” by Tim O’Brien, brings to light the psychological impact of what soldiers go through during times of war. We learn that the effects of traumatic events weigh heavier on the minds of men than all of the provisions and equipment they shouldered. Wartime truly tests the human body and and mind, to the point where some men return home completely destroyed. Some soldiers have been driven to the point of mentally altering reality in order to survive day to day. An indefinite number of men became numb to the deaths of their comrades, and yet secretly desired to die and bring a conclusion to their misery.
The narrator puts the reader in the environment and the society of Kreb to enforce the theme of the story. This allows the reader to interpret the struggle that Kreb is going through after returning from
Krebs received the coldest welcome out of all the soldiers in town, thereby receiving little to no thanks for his service. He didn’t seem to be all too concerned with that aspect, but as a soldier we can gather that he felt used by his own town and neglected. This place he calls home is more like a cell that only he and his other soldiers endure as they try to resume their lives in regular society; and this hits Krebs hard. His ambition was lost in the war, and the tasks of everyday life seem trivial now.
Jamie Hobbs Ms. Birkhead 20th Century Literature A233 29 September 2015 Comparison/Contrast of The Harold Krebs and the Narrator In the early 20th century no one had any great understanding of a psychological illness and the outcome was the suffering of many ill patients. "Soldiers Home" takes place right after the war in 1919 and shows how the war can effect a man 's perception on life immensely. "
Hemingway uses the story to painfully highlight the internal conflict that leaves an individual veteran like Krebs questioning his peculiar heroic status after fighting in the war. The protagonist of the short story, Krebs, is drafted by the state into the U.S. Army fighting in Rhineland having been uprooted from his home. The character traits of Krebs can be defined as rebellious, detached, and stressful. The creation of the character Krebs has been the epitome in the realization of the devastating
Krebs thought girls were “not worth the trouble.” (85) Although he may not have had the motivation to pick up the girls, he “liked looking at them.” (85) This is in no way the girls’ fault, however it shows how the war affected Krebs’ drive to do tasks that involve socialization. Perhaps if the townspeople were more open to listen to Krebs’ story then he would be more comfortable with girls. His mother is an example of how he interacts with women.