Friar Laurence is to blame for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet The deaths of Romeo and Juliet are the most well known tragedies in literary history; but could their deaths have been prevented by the actions of Friar Laurence? In William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, many characters contributed to the death of Romeo and Juliet, but Friar Laurence is truly the one to blame. He married Romeo and Juliet against their parents wishes, tried to unite them with a faulty plan and in general, did not behave like the adult he is. If not for him, Romeo and Juliet may have had a happy ending to their love story. The Friar’s first mistake was marrying Romeo and Juliet. To begin with, the Friar did not really care about the marriage. After being pressured …show more content…
Firstly, The Friar’s plan is created due to his rashness. Juliet comes to the Friar for help as her parents are forcing her to marry Paris. The Friar responds to her by saying, “ When you’re in bed, take this vial, mix its/ contents with liquor, and drink. Then a cold, sleep-/inducing drug will run through your veins, and your/ pulse will stop…”(4.1.95-8). Instead of reasoning with this nervous girl, the Friar rashly gives her a potion. A much smarter way to deal with the issue would be to sit down with the parents and explained that Juliet had already been married. She may have been punished by her parents but she would be reunited to Romeo none the less. Furthermore, the Friar failed on his part to get Romeo the message. He gives it to Friar John but he cannot deliver it as he says “ Suspecting that we both were in a house/Where the infectious pestilence did reign,/Seal'd up the doors and would not let us forth,/ So that my speed to Mantua there was stayed,” (5.2.9-12). Clearly, the Friar did not inform Friar John of the importance of the letter. If he had told him lives were at stake, Friar John would have stopped at nothing to deliver the message. Lastly, the Friar failed to communicate to Romeo in the manner they had agreed upon. Before Romeo leaves, the Friar tells him, “Sojourn in Mantua. I’ll find …show more content…
First off, Friar Laurence should have been more responsible and told the prince about Romeo and Juliet’s marriage . Besides the Friar’s confession in 5.3, the Friar never tells Prince Escalus of Romeo and Juliet's secret marriage. The Prince would have accepted the marriage as it is in the confines of the law (Canon 219). With Prince Escalus’s support, their would be no reason for Romeo and Juliet to keep their relationship a secret and they would be accepted by Verona. However, Friar decided to keep it undisclosed. Secondly, Even after seeing the consequences of Romeo and Juliet’s marriage in Tybalt’s death, he continues to keep it a secret and doesn’t stop the lovers. After he and the Nurse chastise Romeo for his cowardness, the Friar says to Romeo, “Go, get thee to thy love, as was decreed./Ascend her chamber…”(3.3.146-153). Despite Romeo’s murder of Tybalt, Friar Laurence continues to aid him. Had he been an adult, he would have stopped caballing with Romeo and urged the Prince to pardon him. To conclude, The Friar in his cowardice allowed Juliet to die. Upon finding her and Romeo and Paris’s corpse he says, “ I dare no longer stay,” further proving his cowardly nature (5.3.171). The Friar is afraid that he will be caught in the tomb,as is forbidden, so he quickly runs out of the tomb and leaves Juliet alone. As an adult, he should have been more brave and help Juliet get out of their. Instead, he ran like a
If Friar Laurence thought more about being a responsible man that worked towards the common good, he would have made the smarter decision to disagree with the marriage and tell the parents of Romeo and Juliet about their secret love and perhaps try to solve their everlasting feud in the process Secondly, Friar Laurence displayed another imprudent action when he decided to leave Juliet alone in the tomb. Despite Friar Laurence knowing about how mentally unstable Juliet was he still decided to leave. He did this because he cared more about his safety rather than Juliet’s. As a result, this gave Juliet the perfect opportunity to commit suicide. If Friar Laurence were to make a smarter choice and act like a responsible parental figure, he could have stayed with Juliet, and possibly prevent her from committing
He does not think of all the consequences and problems that can come from a secret marriage. Friar is usually very wise and thinks things through, but when it comes to Romeo and Juliet’s marriage, he does not think things through clearly. Not only did Friar allow these two children to get married, he let Juliet play dead to get out of marrying Paris. He knew it was wrong to allow this adolescent to fake a death and “ruin” her parents life. Now, Friar John has no blame in this, but if it is so urgent that Friar Lawrence gets the note to Romeo, he should have given it to someone who he knew would not get distracted.
Friar Laurence decided to marry Romeo and Juliet without planning for all possibilities. Friar never planned for all possibilities in both occasions, which had caused all the problems and the death of Romeo and Juliet. When Friar Laurence set up the plan with Juliet he tells her, "Hold; get you gone, be strong and prosperous in this resolve: I'll send a friar with speed To Mantua, with my letters to thy lord. IV i, 37-40" Friar gives Juliet confidence to Juliet before she decides to drink the potion. Friar Laurence did lots for Romeo and Juliet but also caused them harm.
If he gave him the letter sooner, Romeo would have known Juliet was only sleeping and not dead. Friar did not make sure the letter was delivered to Romeo. John told him that it wasn’t sent. There conversation went like this, “I could not send it - here it is again - nor get a messenger to bring thee, So fearful were they of infection… But I will write again to Mantua, And keep her at my cell till Romeo come-”(5.
The person that is to be blamed for Romeo and Juliet’s tragic death is Friar Laurence, because these three reasons. He told Juliet to fake her death, he married them when they just met, and Friar Laurence couldn’t send Romeo the letter telling him Juliet wasn’t dead. The first reason why Friar Laurence is to be blamed for Romeo and Juliet’s tragic death is because he told Juliet to fake her death. The evidence is stated in document c in the note, it states that “Juliet asks Friar Laurence to help her avoid marrying Paris, referred to here as this county.
The marriage couldn’t have happened without Friar Laurence. Also readers might think that Friar was selfish by just wanting to end the family conflict by marrying them. You may ask why? Because Friar wouldn’t be directly involved and he wouldn’t see the consequences that Romeo and Juliet would see. Also for his far fetched plan to get them back together.
While Friar Lawrence initially gave the potion to Juliet in order to help her, he did not think of what problems he could create outside of just Juliet's life. As shown in the quote her mother takes her “death” very hard and threatens to take her own life. While devising the plan Juliet the Friar states, “Hold, then. Go home;be merry; give consent/ To marry Paris. Wednesday is tomorrow./ Tomorrow night look that thou lie alone;/ Let not the nurse lie with thee in thy chamber.”
Friar Lawrence asked this to John. Friar John could not deliver that letter because of an infection, the Black Plague. I don’t know why Lawrence didn’t just deliver the letter himself and not put his responsibilities on somebody else. He was just trying to help, but resulted in the death of Romeo, Juliet, and Paris. If Romeo would have got the letter, then he would have never gone and bought that poison and killed himself in the Capulet’s tomb.
There are several people that could be blamed for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet however, Friar Lawrence is the one who is truly to blame for Romeo and Juliet's deaths. He is most to blame out of all people for many obvious reasons. Friar Lawrence is most responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because he was the one who married the two lovers even though they weren't suppose to be married, gave Juliet this deadly potion,and he feels so guilty at the end which means he knows he's to blame. Friar Laurence was the wise adviser to Romeo and Juliet. He kept their secret and helped them be together.
As they arrange a marriage behind everyone’s back, everything seems to be testing them; including a fight that broke out and ended in Tybalt’s murder and Romeo being banished from his hometown, Verona. Juliet could not go without being with her love, Romeo, and quickly had to find a way to be with him before her other marriage that her father arranged for her took place. As the friar arranges a plan for the two star-crossed lovers to reunite, things don’t work out the way they’re supposed to and end in the deaths of both characters. In Shakespeare’s, “Romeo and Juliet” Friar Laurence is to blame for Romeo and Juliet’s deaths because he is devious and has a poor planning ability.
Romeo and Juliet: Friar Laurence is to Blame In Romeo and Juliet, Friar Laurence plays a major role in the deaths of the pair. The Friar is a member of the Order of St. Francis, a group of wise and generous priests, Romeo and Juliet trusted Friar Laurence and his insight, turning to him for advice, and solutions. However, Friar Laurence’s rash decision in marrying Romeo and Juliet, his reckless plan for rescuing Juliet from an arranged marriage with Paris, and his fear of committing sin all added to the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. He was there throughout Romeo’s and Juliet 's lives; he married them, came up with a plan to keep them together, and was a friend throughout their tragedies. Friar Laurence, through his lack of good
From my first thoughts, Friar Laurence is looked upon as a respectable, and trustworthy man. We, as the readers, know that he does not have these qualities. In William Shakespeare's The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, Friar Laurence is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. Friar Laurence is to blame because he pushed Romeo and Juliet to get married, he was unable to get the letter to Romeo on time, and he gave Juliet a potion that put her to sleep for 42 hours. Doing that tricked everyone into thinking she was dead.
Young Juliet beseeches Friar Laurence to help the two lovers reconcile, begging him to reunite her with Romeo and, once again, the Friar hastily agrees to help and immediately curates a plan that goes as follows; Juliet will take a potion that makes her appear deceased and upon receiving a message from the Friar informing him about the plan, Romeo will meet Juliet at the cemetery as she wakes up, where the lovers will reunite and run away from Verona together. However, Friar Laurence creates this plan so hastily that he fails to see the risks and potential dangers. It is up to young Juliet to question his plan, saying, “What if this mixture do not work at all? Shall I be married then to-morrow morning?” (4.3.21-22).
Romeo and Juliet is a story of hasty decisions. The young couple must quickly decide to get married, how to act after Romeo is exiled, and whether or not to take their own lives. Many of these decisions are made under the guidance of the children’s mentors, Friar Laurence and the Nurse. Throughout this tragedy, Friar Laurence and the Nurse are the only adults that Romeo and Juliet seem to feel that they can trust and are in turn some of the main people that influence the outcome of the play. The Nurse and Friar Laurence play very similar roles, both in the play and the lives of the children, but the ways in which they advise and influence the children include more differences.
But he was not even capable of doing that! In act 5 scene 2 Friar John says “My speed to Mantua there stayed” (5.2, 12). This quote is stating is that Friar Lawrence entrusted the letter in someone who not capable of completing the task. This results in Romeo being ill informed and killing himself because he thinks Juliet is dead. As a repercussion of Romeo’s suicide, Juliet kills herself in vain of her lost lover.