Why Andrew Carnegie Is Not A Hero Essay

Andrew Carnegie was one of the wealthy men in America and was very charitable, he impacted the United States with his steel to transform cities. During these economic and social problems generated by industrialization, he responded by providing money to fund charities. Institutions, school, pensions,

Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man. He donated lots of money to people and places and charities that needed it the most . This would be one reason why someone would think he is heroic. Many people would not really see this heroic because he was a wealthy man he had a lot more money than what he donated. Yes he did donate a good portion of his money but people

Finally, Andrew Carnegie was selfish. In Document I, it shows that while iron & steel workers work longer than machine shop workers, machine shop workers received more than iron & steel workers. Andrew Carnegie’s daily wage was about $92,000, meaning he could’ve paid his workers more but refuse to. Furthermore, in Document D, during 1875 & 1876, Andrew Carnegie was profiting $10 for one ton of steel rails and ripping people’s money off when he could’ve just profited by $3 per ton of steel rails like he did in

At last, Andrew Carnegie was a hero to America because he had one of the most influential philanthropy of all philanthropists. “Because he can administer it for the community far better than it could or would have done itself.”(Document E) Carnegie helped society change in a way that they will understand that not all rich people are ignorant with their money. He also made them believe that they can achieve more than they think they can. His story developed people to change the way society was looked at. Carnegie dint only change people but he changed America. That is someone I can call a

    Andrew Carnegie was not a true hero. Many may say, going from rags to riches makes Carnegie a hero. Going from rags to riches makes someone a role model to others, to show how life can be improved through any situation. Andrew took money from good people, he only gave to other wealthy associations, and contributed mainly to his own company. A hero performs acts to help the community, discreetly or anonymously; Andrew Carnegie did

For many reasons Andrew Carnegie was not a hero but a robber baron. In his personal life, business approach, and philanthropy he was not heroic. He would either just hide the bad things that he would do or just not do anything heroic. He basically a standard robber baron for the time. The only reason that some people think he was a hero was because he would trick the public or every once in awhile do something good. Andrew Carnegie was a man that cared more about money then other people. This is just one of the many reasons that makes Andrew Carnegie not a

Mr. George Pullman was considered one of the worst robber barons of the 19th century. He manipulated his workers to do everything for him and strived for success.

Andrew Carnegie was a “robber baron” as shown in the way he acted towards the people who helped him reach the top and the terrible working environment that he subjected his workers to. He did various things in an attempt at overshadowing the awful things he did and positively alter his public image. His mentor, Thomas Scott, taught him the skills he would use to become the undisputed king of steel. Costs were the most important aspect of any business and reducing those required cutting wages, demanding 13 hour days and utilizing spies as a way to thwart possible strikes. Many years after Carnegie had gone out on his own, Scott met with him thinking that the years they spent together and all he had taught him would unquestionably result in help in his time of trouble.

During the late 19th century, there was a growth in industrialization. This brought new opportunities for the poor and the rich. For example, Carnegie helped build the steel industry in Pittsburgh Pennsylvania, which made him one of the richest man in the world. As Carnegie gained more wealth, he questioned who money should be given to. Carnegie was both a Robber Baron and a Captain of Industry.

Andrew Carnegie was a money hungry man. Having a share in government affairs and underpaying his employees. All just help him get ahead of the other competition. He worked his way to the top then had lower people do the work for him. The rag to riches story is an inspiring story, but once you make it to the riches; why let others

The late nineteenth century was a pivotal moment in American history. During this time, the Industrial Revolution transformed the nation, railroads had dissipated all throughout the country, and economic classes began to form, separating the wealthy from the poor. One of the wealthiest men of this generation was Andrew Carnegie, a Scottish immigrant who fled to America to make millions off the railroad, oil and even steel businesses. Carnegie is considered one of the richest men in history, and even with all that wealth he decided to give back to the community. As a matter of fact, Carnegie donated most of his funds to charities, universities and libraries in his last few years. He believed that if the wealthy don't give back some of their profits to the community, they are living a dishonorable life, and although I didn't necessarily agree with this radical viewpoint at first, I now am a firm believer in Carnegie's argument about wealth.

He is a fanatical about costs in that when he asked his friend Frank how much money did he make last month and he said he does not know, Carnegie said that he would get out of it if it happened to him. Also, when a new steel competitor called Allegheny Bessemer Steel. Carnegie was worried about his competitor’s production method which is the direct rolling process which would undercut his prices so he sent a notice warning railroads that their methods created defective rails that could cause fatal accidents to raise alarm and after he buried the company, he modified it to use the direct rolling process. According to “Homestead and Its Perilous Trades,” the workers worked 12 hours for $2.25 with cuts of 85 cents with pay ranging from $1.40 to $10 with ⅔ of the workers getting the pay and how the crude molten iron kills workers often. Carnegie wrote to Frick: “My idea….is always to shut down and suffer. Let them decide to go back to work.” Last but not least, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch said how Carnegie confessed he was a coward and lied and ran off to Scotland out of harm’s way to await the issue of the battle he was too weak to share and also did not say anything to stop the bloodshed but only said he had confidence in the managers of the

First of all, he was a major pioneer in the steel industry and created one of the most successful steel companies of all time. Carnegie also played a lead role in recognizing the workers’ right to strike, as long as peaceful action is conducted. In addition to this, Carnegie disapproved of pools made by companies solely in order to raise prices and make more money. Second of all, Carnegie impacted the lives of so many with his work in philanthropy. He funded numerous libraries all across the U.S. and even in Europe, meriting him the title “Patron Saint of Libraries”. Aside from libraries, he also funded many church organs, schools, colleges, organizations, and funds. By the time of his death, he had given away ninety percent of his fortune. Finally, Carnegie left a strong psychological impact. In his article titled “Wealth”, he spread about his ideas of the successful economic system and the proper administration of wealth. Carnegie believed that it was the duty of the man with surplus to use that extra for the benefit of the community. He shared many of his other beliefs in his articles also. Clearly Andrew Carnegie was a remarkable man. His actions in life have improved the way of life of many around the world, especially through his donations of free public libraries. This is a clear example of the fact that God uses all people, Christian or not, for the benefit of his Church, many times through the society around

Andrew Carnegie was a major capitalist of the 19th century. He became a major capitalist in the steel industry. He attained much of his wealth because he practically created the steel industry. Starting from the bottom and working is way to the top Andrew Carnegie became one of the richest men during his time. Starting at earning a dollar and twenty cents a week. Over time he will gain experience as a telegraph messenger and work at a Pennsylvania railroad this will help him to get a job in the railroad industry and three years later he is the superintendent. The next decade Andrew now owns his own steel business called Carnegie Steel Company. Andrew Carnegie revolutionized steel as we knew it using technology and procedures that made making steel much faster. For this he is a “Captain of the Industry”. Carnegie was a smart business man unlike most industry’s during his time instead of buying the other companies out he would make his prices lower than another producer which would send them out of business. He helped out many by making colleges for individuals to attend and he gave back to his community by donating 56 million dollars to build libraries.

Andrew Carnegie was an immagrint who immigrated to america due to the struggles that his family faced which involved his mother not being able to support the family no matter how hard she tried. Andrew was fearful to leave even having to be carried on board by a sailor. even though the conditions on the boat were harsh andrew adapted, he became familiar with the entire boat even being allowed to help the sailors with their jobs this shows his resoufulness at an early age. when he arrived in america he still struggled even almost becoming apart of the terrible dead end of child labor that was an epidemic at the time but by sheer luck his uncle while spending his free time in a tavern over heard that O' riley telegraph was looking for a messenger