The intention of upbringing is indisputable – you want your children to have a great life and a great future, but perchance certain ways of educating children can cause more damage than good. The article “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” was written in 2011 by Amy Chua, who is a professor at Yale Law School in the United States of America. The article follows significant themes such as the upbringing of children and perfectionism. In the article, the author, Amy Chua, explains the differences between the upbringing of children by respectively Chinese parents and Western parents. As for forms of appeal, the author has established a strong ethos.
It entails a strong respect and loyalty to one’s parents. According to the Classic of Filial Piety, the fundamental principles of filial practices are being respectful towards one’s parents, offering financial support, and performing ancestor worship after the death of parents. However, due to a weakening of parental power and the influence of China’s market economy, a younger generation less practices “traditional” filial piety. While the general younger generation shows the decline in filial practices, daughter tends to take the main filial responsibility. Shi argues that the change in preference does not mean that the society is feminized.
She suggests that Western parents are too concerned with the self-esteem of their children while Chinese parents hold a different feeling on the topic. Chinese parents believe that their children owe them everything and that the parents know what is best for their children whether or not it becomes more important than the children’s desires in life. At times, Jed does disagree with the harshness of Chua’s approach to parenting but he goes along with her because the methods have been shown to be successful and frequently Jed and Chua receive compliments about their children. Even Lulu when forced by her mother to master the violin eventually learns to appreciate her own
Parents in China put more expectation on their children and want them to be the best student in the class or whole school. All Chinese parents like to take a lot of after school classes for their students and never consider about their kids’ thoughts and feelings. In Chinese culture, however, academic success is believed to be strictly a product of effort and therefore completely within the control of the student. Because Chinese parents view grades as controllable, they see no reason as to why their children should be expected to achieve anything less than perfect grades. The only excuse for not achieving perfect scores would be laziness, which is considered unacceptable.
So in my opinion, some of the idea make some negative effect or lead to the wrong direction, fortunately many people realize that even if it is the great people, he is not right all the time. For example, there are three cardinal guides in Confucianism: ruler guides subjects, father guides son and husband guides wife. This strict sense of hierarchy to a certain extent works in the ancient China’s society but in today’s modern world we initiate that everyone is equal instead of having a strong idea of ranking. The second example is that in Confucianism, there is a value called ‘‘Male chauvinism” and Confucius had said: “Girls and inferior men are hard to get along with. If you get familiar with them, they lose their humility; if you are distant, they resent it.”(In Chinese子曰：“唯女子与小人难养也。近之则不逊，远之则怨。”)I think when this sentence is translated into English cannot completely express its meaning ,but it means that man are more honorable than woman and woman are looked down on.
At the end of this argument, Suyuan takes Waverly’s place and supports her opinion on Jing-Mei’s lack of style and poor writing skills; Suyuan agrees that her daughter is not sophisticated enough as Waverly who is a very successful tax attorney (Tan 197-207). As it can be seen, Amy Tan felt that she was not sophisticated enough because she did not become a neurosurgeon like her mother wanted. In the story, all Chinese mothers wanted their Chinese-American daughters to become doctors or businessmen and to be better than others. When Jing-Mei and Waverly were little, Suyuan wanted her daughter to be like Waverly, and there always was competition between them. Even though they are both grown women now, the
In the Chinese culture, education is valued because of its association with future success and career, as well as parents wanting the best for their child. So, due to the high standards in education, my parents are exceedingly strict with my grades that sometimes a grade of a B is unacceptable, whereas other people will view a B as remarkably good. Thus, I always push myself to try harder, despite being stressed out, because of how much my culture has influenced my values and beliefs towards education. Going to college is not a choice, but rather that I have to in order to obtain a successful career and abide by my culture. Therefore, my culture’s values and norms have a significant role in influencing my decisions and my
Based on the results, there is a positive relationship between identification to filial piety and willingness to give birth in the future, which is consistent with the hypothesis based to exchange theory. It indicates that participants who are more identified to filial piety have higher willingness to give birth in the future. Possible explanation for this relationship is that people who are identified with filial piety, they treat childbearing as a mission to be accomplished in their life, so they are willing to give birth in the future. In traditional Chinese culture, there is a saying that “There are three forms of unfilial conducts. Among them, the worst is not to have your offspring to continue your family.” In traditional Chinese society, both men and women treated childbearing as their mission of life that if they failed to give birth, they would bring shame to their family.
Regardless of the ease she benefited from her status, Ms. Xie still had to experience difficulties just as other single mothers living in China. As a single mom, she had to receive inconvenient perspectives from others when she applied the residency permit for her son—even though she was protected and had the right to apply for it. Furthermore, she also had to lie to her acquaintance about the existence of her husband, insisting that the father of her
In the foreign environment, they will not worry about gutter oil and melamine .Mainland students will suffer from these. They enjoy the foreign environment. In some families, Chinese parents invest heavily in their children’s international education. Parents want to fulfil their own life ambitions through sending their children to study abroad. It is said that the parents’ decision is the main reason which is main motivation of the students who are choosing to study abroad.