Why did Lévi-Strauss compare women to gifts?
“All French anthropologists are the children of Lévi-Strauss” Le Monde stated in its obituary for the deceased anthropologist in 2009 (Meany, 2011). As the main founder of structuralism, the impact he had on modern anthropology and also the humanities in general, is significant. Some might even say that Lévi-Strauss replaced Sartre’s existentialism with structuralism in world of French thinkers (Meany, 2011).
One of his earliest works was Les Structures Élémentaires de la Parenté (The Elementary Structures of Kinship), which examines kinship not in terms of lineage but through alliances. He explores how societies are based on the principles of the incest-taboo and the exchange of women. In his alliance
…show more content…
An anthropologist, whose ideas obviously influenced large part of his work, especially concerning the exchange of women, is Marcel Mauss. While he neglected Mauss’ seminars on gift exchange at the Collège de France in his early student years (Meany, 2011), Lévi-Strauss grew to become an ardent admirer, referring to him regularly in his writings.
In his work ‘The Gift’ Marcel Mauss stresses the significance of gift exchange in social interactions. He divides gift exchange into three actions: the giving of a gift, the acceptance of the gift and its reciprocation, which is all obligatory. Gift exchange serves to strengthen social bonds and if a part of the exchange is not fulfilled it affects the social standing of the persons involved. Therefor there is no such thing as a free or selfless gift.
Lévi-Strauss transfers this theory onto women, describing them as the most valuable gift, as the bonds created through their exchange are the strongest, namely marriage alliances. Here the reciprocation of the gift is also obligatory, which in its most basic form would be two men exchanging
…show more content…
In 1949 when he published ‘The Elementary Structures’, kinship was a widely discussed anthropological subject of the time. And as Lévi-Strauss himself, other famous researchers of kinship of the 1950s neglected to examine developed gender roles too: “When reading the classic studies of Boas, Kroeber, Malinowski, Radcliffe-Brown, Evans-Pritchard and Fortes today, the absence of analyses of gender and the social and cultural production of gender differences is striking. In studies of kinship, a male perspective is often taken for granted. Certainly, women have a place in these studies; they sometimes appear as wives, mothers and sisters, but rarely as independently acting persons.” (Eriksen, 1995, p.
Lineage was in reference to women, not men. Children did not know their father’s house. In Deerfield, children knew their fathers and they were active in their lives, but in Kahnawake, the father’s, to me, were more absent. Women worked in the fields. They were strong and strength, as well as courage, in the face of pain, was greatly
Summary The article “Returning the Gift” that written by Robin Kimmerer has discussed the importance of having our appreciations for nature. The Earth is providing many valuable gifts for us, including fresh air, water, lands and many more natural resources to keep us alive. The author has pointed out that human beings are being greedy, and taking everything for granted. From the author’s perspective, human beings should feel grateful of what we have.
The main point of the article is that in many cultures, there are alternatives to “man” or “woman” and that not all countries agree with the Western culture’s strict classification of male and female. Supporting Evidence The author, Walter L. Williams, first provides evidence of his main argument at the onset of the article. Before even introducing the berdache, Williams explains that Western tradition is often viewed to be normal, and anything outside of those norms may be considered abnormal. Williams then explains that to an invididual raised under Western ideals, gender is often viewed simply as male or as female.
This old notion of love and marriage contrasts sharply with what is expected and normalized in America. Other siblings take less customary and more controversial paths: Chai’s sixteen-year-old brother dates and has a child with a Christian girl, and one of her brothers divorces his first
Relying on Others People have utilized other people to help them to get what they desire the most. Whether that is the means of survival, or for luxury, people have relied on each other for as long as two people have set foot on earth. In the book Night by Elie Wiesel and Maus by Art Spiegelman both books demonstrate characters using one another’s resources and connections to survive. Both books show it is easier to overcome trials when one relies on one another, rather than oneself. Safety, it is a necessity for everyone and everyone desires it.
Brook’s target audience is the average American family member. As he had stated in the text many Americans have now fallen away from the typical nuclear family social unit. So with that being said the chances that the reader is an outsider to the nuclear family are very high. This reader may also feel very strongly about how they would have been treated in the 1950s due to their marital status. Although society no longer treats unmarried parents this way it may still be upsetting to know that older generations do not support your lifestyle.
“It 's not how much we give, but how much love we put into giving.” Those wise words come from the one and only, Mother Teresa. Her quote comes to mind when I think of the career Certified Nursing Assistant. Another is “It takes a special person to do what you do, I don 't know if I could handle it”.
It is heavily demonstrated that women are reliant on men when O'Connor describes how the Grandmother lives, “Bailey was the son she lived with, her only boy” (O’Connor). This suggests that because the Grandmother seems to
As expressed by Young (2002), male dominance was not present in the Lakota society, both genders had complimentary roles within their community and both were considered equally important. While woman were the caretakers, they did not think of themselves less than their husband’s counterpart who had to hunt to support his family and protect them against other
Scott Russell Sanders’ essay, “Looking at Women”, contains his views about women that originate from his experience living among a given group of people. In fact, it is apparent that his opinion results from his childhood memories. The quotes he chooses as well as language depict his opinion about how men view women and illustrate that his thoughts were acquired during his early years of life. As stated, his thoughts originate from the personal views of other people about women. Thus, this paper seeks to examine his perspectives about women.
MICHEL FOUCAULT ON SEXUALITY Michel Foucault was a French philosopher, philologist and social theorist. He made discourses on the relationship between power and knowledge and about how they are utilized as a form of social control through social establishments. This essay talks about Michel Foucault’s discourse on sexuality. He put forward his theory of the history of sexuality.
The autobiography, The Confessions of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, provides a vivid insight into the complicated, yet exhilarating, life of Rousseau. The beginning of his life was filled with misfortunes, such as the death of his mother which was quickly followed by a distraught and self-sabotaging attitude which his father adopted. This led to his father’s involvement in illegal behaviors and the subsequent abandonment of Rousseau. His mother’s death was the catalyst for his journey to meet multiple women who would later affect his life greatly. The Influence of Miss Lamberciers, Madame Basile, Countess de Vercellis, and Madam de Warens on the impressionable adolescent mind of Rousseau led to the positive cultivation of self-discovery and the creation of new experiences, as well as the development of inappropriate sexual desires and attachments towards women.
Individuals or groups of people have always had one thing in mind and that is surviving. Surviving means able to expand themselves without losing their traditional social structure and trying to fit in a larger network. Keeping track of who you are and come from holds the cultural meaningful by holding the group together. The Neolithic Revolution has been able to evolve and become a crucial part of being human by lineage exogamy, patrilineal, and matrilineal descent, and kinship and new reproductive technologies. Lineage exogamy means that lineage members must look for their marriages partners in other lineages.
Furthermore, it is possible that in mixed-gender families, the higher chances of comparisons between the two parents’ behaviours would reinforce specific ideas about gender roles than it would in families where parents are of the same gender (Endendijk et al., 2013). For example, it is often assumed in mixed-gender households that males are breadwinners of the family while females are caretakers, whereas in same-gender households, parents tend to be more open-minded about gender roles and do not necessarily subscribe to existing stereotypes (Sutfin, Fulcher, Bowles, & Patterson, 2008). Division of roles in terms of gender
Originating in France, ‘The Necklace’ is a short story written by French writer Guy de Maupassant in the late nineteenth century, the period where literary movements realism and naturalism dominated French fiction. Maupassant played an important role in both the realist movement and the naturalist movement through his depiction of the setting as well as the character’s decision. The short story reflects upon the rigid patriarchal society during the late nineteenth century, demonstrating how the wealth of a person can lead to their generosity and greed; thus affecting their lifestyles. Through ‘The Necklace’, Maupassant aims to depict the conflicts between the upper-class and the lower class, how their inner desires vary. This essay will analyze ‘The Necklace’ and how Maupassant uses the social context, characters and literary devices in the short story to illustrate his misogynistic viewpoints towards women.