Why Do You Think Weber's Argument?
1) Why do you think Weber makes this argument?
I think that Weber makes this argument that Protestants are more economically rational and truer capitalists because of the overwhelming evidence he has received in compliance with this claim. Also, at the time Weber published this book, the United States was right in the middle of the second industrial revolution. The effects of the revolution on wealth and capitalism, were relevant, current, interesting, and obvious changes worth discussing.
2) What are the implications, if he is correct?
If Weber was correct, he implied that Protestants are more economically rational, solely due to their religion. Weber argued that, although, for many reasons, it would make sense that Catholics were more capitalistic, Protestants were. Weber also claims that due to this finding, capitalism has intimate ties to religion.
3)
…show more content…
To back up his argument, Weber discusses his observations, which have lead him to make this claim. For example, Weber says that in his experience, richer districts converted to Protestantism. Weber goes one step farther to say that Protestants turn more towards capitalism due to their inherited wealth. Weber also claims that Catholics are more otherworldly and ascetic than Protestants, which therefore makes them indifferent to material gain. In order to discuss capitalism’s intimate ties to religion, Weber quotes Benjamin Franklin because according to Franklin, it is an ethic for an individual to have the “duty” to prosper. This idea is similar to a religious
Andrew Carnegie's The Gospel Of Wealth
1193 Words | 5 Pages“The Gospel of Wealth” was written by Andrew Carnegie discusses the expansion era of industries post civil war, a time that produced extremely large wealth for many business at the time. Andrew Carnegie, was one of the top guys in the industry, he created an industry that made Carnegie very successful at the time. Carnegie thought that it was important for wealthy people to distribute their wealth throughout the society so communities in need will receive help. In the Gospel of Wealth he believes that the conditions of society have radically changed over the years, and it was certain that some people would become quite important and wealthy. He believes that the change that is occurring should be looked at a positive perspective and not in
Analysis Of 'The Gospel Of Wealth' By Andrew Carnegie
149 Words | 1 Pages“The Gospel of Wealth” is an article written by Andrew Carnegie. Carnegie was well known for his role in transforming the American Steel industry in the late nineteenth century. Carnegie was born in 1835 to Scottish immigrants. He was able to control the steel industry by not only owning the factories, but also owned the land with iron deposits, he also owned the boats and the trains which the raw materials were transported on, which is known as vertical integration. After creating a large fortune in the steel industry, Carnegie, sold his company and decided to focus on philanthropy.
How Did Andrew Carnegie Write The Gospel Of Wealth
462 Words | 2 PagesAndrew Carnegie was the one who wrote the Gospel of Wealth and it was a positive idea for the people who are not wealthy. Carnegie says that the upper class has a responsibility to address the issues of the wealth inequality. In the Gospel of Wealth, Carnegie stated that the wealthy class can be a better state than the government or state. Carnegie also states that the wealthy should dispense wealth and it should be a way that does not promote drunkenness. Carnegie argues that there are two types of wealthy people.
Benjamin Rush's Argument Analysis
1729 Words | 7 PagesIn his argument for the establishment of a public school system, Benjamin Rush does not waste any time addressing the obvious issue of taxpayer burden. While acknowledging this would warrant an initial investment, he insists that by establishing a system of public education in America would overtime cut taxes, and taxpayers would see a return on their initial investment [JEH1] [Rush, pg.678]. Rush maintains a position that as we acknowledge the benefits of learning spoken languages of the world, our youth would benefit as much learning the languages of finance and markets. To properly defend our liberties against the throes of tyranny, we must be aware of defending ourselves from economic tyranny. He establishes the potential merits of educating the youth in the matters of economics, arguing it provides “the best security
Summary Of William T Cavanaugh's Being Consumed
1404 Words | 6 PagesWilliam T Cavanaugh (2008), wrote Being Consumed: Economics and Christian Desire which is a philosophical book, which focus on four (4) economic life matters that addresses the consumer culture within society. These four economic life matters are free market, consumerism, globalization and economic scarcity. In order for this topic to be discussed on a theological point of view, the author draws the reader’s attention to human life, the ends of life in God. The key question in every process is whether or not the transaction contributes to the flourishing of each person involved. In order to address these questions the author points to concrete examples of alternative economic practices in which Christians participate-: business, co-operatives, credit union, practices of consumption which marks the vision for Christian economic life.
Allusions In Otherwise There's Nothing New
937 Words | 4 PagesAleichem indirectly proposes the idea that Capitalism is easily abused and inherently bad for the Jewish
The Bus Bee Rhetorical Analysis
900 Words | 4 PagesProtestants turned to God to learn how to live a pure life and have proper values and habits. Jane always looked for the good in people and learned how to better herself, by learning from the people she
Surfing For Thinness: Pro-Ana Community Analysis
689 Words | 3 PagesIn doing this, I hope to show the relationship between the pro-ana community and the protestant ethic and take the pro-ana community further and suggest that the existence and formation of the group provide an argument against secularization. Using Weber’s idea of the protestant ethic and his theory of religion and society, and focusing on, the certainty of salvation, inner-worldly asceticism, and religious virtuosi I will examine the pro-ana community by, suggesting a “pro-ana ethic” based on Weber’s ideas, and explaining the formation of the group. Using this pro-ana ethic, I will discuss how the pro-ana community shows a deviation from the thesis of
Created Equal Friedman Summary
751 Words | 4 PagesIt is false advertisement that capitalism is a system of the rich taking advantage of the poor is not true. The Friedmans believe that the free market has allowed the common man to achieve marvelous levels of prosperity. Whereas, when the market is controlled, the gap between the rich and poor becomes more extensive, like in Communist Russia or China. The achievements of capitalism have greatly benefited the common man. The Friedmans end their article by expressing that the society that puts equality before liberty will end up without one or the other, the society that puts liberty before equality will end up with both.
Strengths And Weaknesses Of Noll's Book
641 Words | 3 PagesThe final chapter expresses that Protestantism cannot be described in general terms, since; there are a vast array of churches that fall into the category of Protestantism. These groups differ in various ways but still belong to the same body of Protestantism. Therefore, is Protestantism recognizable to its early founding? If not, is that a good or bad thing? The question that develops
Carnegie Conwell And Alger Advocates Of Wealth For All
1696 Words | 7 PagesThis theory, Social Darwinism, was applied to the monopolistic efforts of businessmen as John D. Rockefeller, Jr. so eloquently stated: “The growth of a large business is merely the survival of the fittest” (Nash p. 417). The Gospel of Wealth based on Social Darwinism is the notion that the massive wealth held by prosperous businessmen was for the social benefit of everyone. The advocates of the Gospel of Wealth such as Andrew Carnegie, Russell Conwell, and Horatio Alger linked wealth with a sense of heightened responsibility as those with more wealth had an equally great obligation to society. Each of the advocates of the Gospel of Wealth came from diverse backgrounds, but preached the same ideals.
The Piety Myth Analysis
1324 Words | 6 PagesAfter reading Jesus’ words that “the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil” they determine that capitalism, which seems to be founded on just such a love, must
Would God Work By Capitalism Or Marxist Socialism?
809 Words | 4 PagesAlthough Marxism, especially in its Communist form, has been negatively perceived throughout history, liberation theologians, Gustavo Gutierrez and Leonardo Boff, have imagined God’s kingdom offers a preferential option for the poor by way of Neo-Marxist ideals. The corruption of Capitalism has provided lavish wealth for the middle and upper classes within the United States while enslaving the lower classes, and also the Latin and South American countries from which the U.S. obtains its imports. Gutierrez, witnessing this systemic abuse, cried out against Capitalism, calling for equality for all and a utopia where the lowest classes are the priority. Ultimately, Gutierrez and other liberation theologians acknowledge the Reformed understanding of God’s kingdom that is both present, but also still to come.
What Is Self-Interest In Bernard Mandeville's Fable Of The Bees
787 Words | 4 PagesAlthough, at the time the belief in the Catholic church was that self interest was both shameful and a sin, Bernard Mandeville and Adam Smith shared the belief that private vices are what became public benefits. They believed that self interest is what made society flourish. Mandeville believed that whatever an individual did, whether it was a “virtuous” action or greed, self interest was at the core of the action. An individuals act of self interest are what kept industry and the economy thriving. Mandeville believed that “a desire to create a purely virtuous society is based on a vain Utopia seated in the brain” this view can be seen in his writing “Fable of the Bees”.
Religious Symbolism Research Paper
1134 Words | 5 PagesNarmin Hasanli Section I 10.16.2015 Writing and Information Literacy 1 Argumentative essay- Final Draft Limitation of Religious Symbols When you destroy people’s religious expression, they will establish secularized religions like Marxism (Carrol Quigley). Religion is considered one way of expression of psychological requirements. Religion distributes allocated sacrament, stories, guiding, tales through various scriptures, worships and ways of public supporting.
More about Why Do You Think Weber's Argument?
Andrew Carnegie's The Gospel Of Wealth
1193 Words | 5 PagesAnalysis Of 'The Gospel Of Wealth' By Andrew Carnegie
149 Words | 1 PagesHow Did Andrew Carnegie Write The Gospel Of Wealth
462 Words | 2 PagesBenjamin Rush's Argument Analysis
1729 Words | 7 PagesSummary Of William T Cavanaugh's Being Consumed
1404 Words | 6 PagesAllusions In Otherwise There's Nothing New
937 Words | 4 PagesThe Bus Bee Rhetorical Analysis
900 Words | 4 PagesSurfing For Thinness: Pro-Ana Community Analysis
689 Words | 3 PagesCreated Equal Friedman Summary
751 Words | 4 PagesStrengths And Weaknesses Of Noll's Book
641 Words | 3 PagesCarnegie Conwell And Alger Advocates Of Wealth For All
1696 Words | 7 PagesThe Piety Myth Analysis
1324 Words | 6 PagesWould God Work By Capitalism Or Marxist Socialism?
809 Words | 4 PagesWhat Is Self-Interest In Bernard Mandeville's Fable Of The Bees
787 Words | 4 PagesReligious Symbolism Research Paper
1134 Words | 5 Pages