ipl-logo

Does Magellan Deserve Credit

1239 Words5 Pages

To judge whether Magellan deserves all the credit writer gives him, it should be clarified what kind of people should deserve such credits. The name of book, a world lit only by fire, and its subtitle, the medieval mind and the renaissance, indicate that this book is about the thought revolution and change at that time. In this unstable era, the hero should be the person who stirred up the revolution and destroyed the unreasonable rule. I don’t think Magellan deserves this credit and, moreover, I don’t think everyone at that time deserves that, because the change is due to cumulative effect of various events. Magellan, according to the writer, is considered as the only man alone and the hero at his time, which I disagree with. In the opinion …show more content…

First, it was unimaginable for others to circle the globe at his time. Then, his ships are unseaworthy and his crews are hodgepodge and could not communicate in the same tongue. In this difficult situation Magellan finished his trip and in the long list of history it is difficult to find another figure whose heroism matches Magellan’s. I think this proposal is quibbling and ridiculous. This proposal implies that the difficulties Magellan went through are the reason why he should be considered as a hero. On the other word, if Magellan had had good ship and well-trained sailor, he would not be considered as a hero, or if he had not finished the voyage, he also would be considered as a hero. How ridiculous is it! If there is thing that makes Magellan become a hero, it should the result of this voyage but not his stubbornness and skill. Although Magellan’s characteristic plays a critical role in his voyage, it is one of the many factors that led to the success of this globe-trip. Moreover, there are many people in the world who are much more tenacious and skillful than him, so all of them should be hero of their time and should be credited a whole book? The characteristic and difficulties they went through are why heroes become more “hero” but why people become

Show More
Related

  • Is Andrew Carnegie A Hero?

    427 Words  | 2 Pages

    Andrew Carnegie was a hero in some people 's eyes , not so much in others . That’s why everyone has their own opinion. In this essay you will read one reason someone might think he’s a hero , and two reasons why he is not a hero for the rest of the people. What that means is that this paper mostly leans on that Andrew Carnegie is not a hero and you will read why . Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Columbus And Charles Lindbergh

    660 Words  | 3 Pages

    When faced with challenges, it is a sink or swim kind of deal. You either adapt your skills to fit the situation at hand, or you fail. This is the case for both Charles Lindbergh and Christopher Columbus, no pun intended. While on opposite ends of a four-hundred year gap, both of these men crossed the Atlantic ocean; one nautically and one aeronautically. Columbus and Lindbergh faced challenges, adapted, and in turn they both accomplished great feats.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Journal Of Christopher Columbus

    881 Words  | 4 Pages

    What is found to contradict Columbus being a hero is him telling of taking away people against their will to Spain. Just as human souvenirs. His obsessed greed to find wealth within the new world (that he thought to be India) as in spices and silks. On account of Las Casa’s thoughts he expressed great distaste for Columbus in the first place because of his greed blinding him against human rights. He brought sickness, and pain to the people he visited by also rape, theft, disease, and degrading the people he conquered.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Lies My Teacher Told Me Loewen

    711 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sugar coating, lies, and creating false heroism could lead to careless consequences. Loewen starts right off the bat with how Columbus was “portrayed as America’s first great hero”, when he was in fact an immoral and crooked person. He states that textbooks often leave out the crucial details about Christopher Columbus, but the books don't just lie about Columbus. American textbooks are no doubt biased to the whites. White people are often categorized as the “important” ones, while the rest are

    Read More

  • Chris Mccandless Characteristics

    554 Words  | 3 Pages

    There are many characteristics that make up a hero. For instance, many hero’s are known to be very brave, courageous and motivated people. Many people have different ideas of what they think a hero is, but no who idea’s are ever alike. Some people when they get asked “What is a hero?” they

    Read More

  • Miguel Hidalgo: An Epic Hero

    1195 Words  | 5 Pages

    events”(The Definition). Miguel Hidalgo can be seen as an epic hero in modern society because he has courage, has affected many people from his actions, and rose to a high position. Miguel Hidalgo showed a great deal of courage during his existence. Without his courage, he would of never been able

    Read More

  • James Loewen Herofication Chapter Summaries

    783 Words  | 4 Pages

    And Loewen further states how textbooks minimize other expeditions and how those explores are no where near praised as much as Columbus. Rather textbooks, seem to act as if expeditions began in the 1400’s in Europe but they didn’t. As Loewen states, “Most textbooks make no use of primary sources. A few incorporate brief extracts that have been carefully selected or edited to reveal nothing unseemly of the Great Navigator.” (p.63).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Chris Mccandless: The Hero's Journey

    594 Words  | 3 Pages

    Chris McCandless’s journey has inspired many people around the world. However, some people view him as a hero and others as a fool. The Hero’s Journey describes the typical adventure of the archetype known as the hero, the person who goes out and achieves great deeds on behalf of the group, tribe, or civilization. Some would argue Chris’s story does not paint the picture of a hero because everything he did was based on himself. On the other hand, some people believe he was a hero and broke down many barriers for people across the world through his actions.

    Read More

  • Black Conquistadors Analysis

    993 Words  | 4 Pages

    The role of historical explorers is often exaggerated, and many times, they are presented as mythical figures who have overcame great feats. Men such as Christopher Columbus and Hernan Cortes are recognized as such important figures due to external factors such as the symbolism of their name or their connections to the Spanish crown, respectively. In the novel, Estebanico states that often times, the Spaniards were not entirely truthful in their reports back to the Spanish crown. He indicates that though he fully wants to include the details of his relation with his Native American wife, Oyomasot, the other Castilians refused to include details that were contradictory to the rulings of the crown. (Lalami 234).

    Read More

  • Christopher Columbus And Lindbergh: A Journey Across The Atlantic

    787 Words  | 4 Pages

    Columbus and Lindbergh: A Journey Across The Atlantic “For the execution of the voyage to the Indies, I did not make use of intelligence, mathematics or maps”(“Christopher Columbus Quote.”). This is a quote from Christopher Columbus, one of the most prominent and well known explorers in history. As I typed this quote, I considered the differences between Christopher Columbus and Charles Lindbergh. Columbus and Lindbergh both travelled the Atlantic.

    Read More

  • The Heroic Traits Of Odysseus In Homer's The Odyssey

    836 Words  | 4 Pages

    These traits are shown by Genghis Khan, Choi Yuna, my brother, and Odysseus. The fact that Odysseus and heroes in the modern age share the same traits proves how important they are for being a hero. In addition, every hero should be able to protect others out of kindness and for a cause they believe in. Without heroes, society would continue to make the same mistakes. As role models, they push society in the right direction and assist people in decision

    Read More

  • The Heroic Qualities Of The Wright Brothers

    679 Words  | 3 Pages

    One example of why he is influential because of his heroic acts is because on the website http://www.businessinsider.com/10-items-not-invented-by-who-you-think-2011-8 it says, “Orville and Wilbur Wright were two brothers who fulfill a definition of a hero with their amazing accomplishment of inventing the first successful plane.” This quote shows me that people think he has heroic acts because it says they fulfill a definition of a hero. Another example why he is influential is because the same website says, ”Now treated as heroes, Wilbur and Orville Wright continued to set new records in distance and duration in front of amazed crowds.” This piece of evidence shows me that people around the world see him as a hero to the world because it says they were treated as heroes. Last piece of evidence is according to the same website it says, “A hero like Wilbur Wright is someone who follows their dreams.”

    Read More

  • Why Is Christopher Columbus Considered A Hero

    498 Words  | 2 Pages

    Almost everybody has heard of Christopher Columbus, but do you know that he tried to sail for 15 years. Christopher Columbus found new land, was a good navigator, and never gave up. Here are some reasons why Columbus should be considered a hero. The first reason that Christopher Columbus was a hero is because he found new land.

    Read More

  • What Stops People From Being Heroes Essay

    762 Words  | 4 Pages

    The first thing which I believe makes a hero and at the same time destroys potential heroes is the simple fact that heroes consistently choose to be good, and through their goodness they inspire others to become better. But here's the problem which limits most people, choice. We have the ability to choose if we want to be good or evil, but in reality, the majority of us choose neither, we choose to be mediocre, not evil, but not good. As well, because being moral requires effort it’s much easier

    Read More

  • Christopher Columbus Research Papers

    1382 Words  | 6 Pages

    Christopher Columbus, a Spanish captain who sailed to find new found land for the King and Queen of Spain. Columbus was a unique person in the middle Ages. Columbus was not born into the richest family but he was able to teach himself on how to sail and navigate the sea just by working on boats at a very young age. He was a man that worked very hard to earn the rank of captain of the seas, with this rank he became famous in European and American history and change the meaning of sailing. Christopher was born in the republic of Genoa, Italy on May 20, 1451.

    Read More

More about Does Magellan Deserve Credit

Open Document