ipl-logo

Why Is Merit Pay Wrong

798 Words4 Pages

Imagine this: you 're a teacher at a very prestigious school, with an exceptional group of students. Your students try their hardest, but some subjects of the curriculum are more difficult than others. Most kids do well on the tests, with few slipping through the crack, and the only thought you have is, “how will this affect my paycheck?”Merit pay, according to google, is the raise in pay based on a set of criteria set by the employer.Merit pay is nothing but pernicious to not only the teacher, but the student and school as well. Pay for performance leads to no improvement in teaching by stripping teachers of their motivation to teach, and also leads to a narrower curriculum and ultimately more test prep and money. Additionally, it ultimately leads to corrupt incidences, like the situations in Atlanta, North Carolina and New York. One reason merit pay is ineffective is it does not increase teacher performance.When asked how to raise their effectiveness, teachers replied with a smaller class size, not merit pay.(Tying Teachers Salaries)This shows merit pay is, according to teachers, ineffective or even detrimental because it would not increase teachers aspirations …show more content…

Lastly, merit pay eventually ends in negative circumstances. School employees may try to tamper with test scores to obtain a higher salary. This shows merit pay leads to negative effects because it can lead to lying and cheating. One example of merit pay gone wrong is Atlanta Public School in Atlanta, Georgia. Authorities at the school were accused of lying and misgrading tests to increase the amount of dollars on their paycheck. This shows merit pay leads to negative effects because it shows one possible outcome of merit pay, cheating to gain more money. More than 8 teachers were sentenced to jail time, with a ending fine of $1000 and 1000 hours of arduous community service. ("Prison Time") This shows merit pay leads to negative effects because it lead to a detrimental outcome for these school

Show More
Related

  • The Pros And Cons Of Saskatchewan Government's Budget Cuts

    1111 Words  | 5 Pages

    This brings up plenty of problems, especially when there is only one opinion going into making crucial decisions. One of the decisions the government decided to make is to not pay outrageous salaries anymore (O’Connor). The problem with this is that teachers make nothing near outrageous salaries. By cutting salaries of teachers and people above them, there will be less incentive to work. Not only do they not get paid nearly enough for what they do, but they have to buy their own classroom supplies as well.

    Read More

  • Review Of The Article 'How Higher Salaries Could Save The Teaching Profession'

    705 Words  | 3 Pages

    “If the state is serious about helping its students, it would make sure its teachers are taken care of. Higher pay attracts the best, most qualified teachers” (qtd. in Long). If teachers are not getting paid enough by the district they will end up getting second or third jobs to make ends meet. This causes teachers to be not fully committed to their students since they now have other things to worry

    Read More

  • Economics In Steven D. Levitt's Freakonomics

    996 Words  | 4 Pages

    After the fine is introduced, the number of late pick-ups rises. Researchers concluded that the $3 fine was a poor incentive for parents to pick their children up on time because the fine was too low. They then turn to discuss cheating and how some incentives can encourage dishonesty, comparing school teachers to sumo wrestlers. Using the Chicago Public School System they discuss the connection between incentives and cheating. In 1996, the school system began to give small bonuses to the teachers whose students had a rise in standardized test scores.

    Read More

  • Adversity In Dubner And Levitt's Freakonomics

    495 Words  | 2 Pages

    Thesis: Although some may argue that adversity is essential for uncovering innate talent, it is impossible for adversity alone to accomplish this; solely relying on adversity to bring out a certain character is a detrimental move that can ultimately lead to immoral decisions and negative impacts on both mental and physical states. In Freakonomics, Stephen Dubner and Steven Levitt delve into schools from a teacher’s point of view, in which teachers are constantly under the pressure to secure both their jobs and reputations through corrupt methods. “If the entire school does poorly, federal funding can be withheld; if the school is put on probation, the teacher stands to be fired.” (p. 23)

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Documentary 'Waiting For Superman'

    221 Words  | 1 Pages

    Teachers unions refuse to reward good teachers who actually aid our nation 's students so they are able to succeed. The tenure system legislated by the American Association of University Professors in 1900, keeps teachers who hinder the education and performance of students from being fired. Which leaves students to fail and these teachers with no repercussions. Such as in New York, between 2006 and 2011 only 32 out of 132,000 teachers were fired for any reason.

    Read More

  • Social Incentives In Steven D. Levitt's Freakonomics

    790 Words  | 4 Pages

    The main argument in chapter one of Freakonomics written by Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner is that incentives have a large influence on human behavior. As the author explains, an incentive is “ a means of urging people to do more of a good thing or less of a bad thing” (17). The book further explains that there are three types of incentives- social incentives by which people’s actions are related to shame and glory; economic incentives which causes people to react toward their financial interest; and moral incentives in which one acts based upon what the right thing to do is. As you continue to read, you learn about three different case studies that all involve the effects of incentives. The first case is about public school teachers in Chicago and the algorithm that proved teachers guilty of cheating on standardized tests by substituting the answers on the student’s answer keys.

    Read More

  • Paying Students For Good Grades Essay

    763 Words  | 4 Pages

    Can schools pay kids for good grade? Many people will believe that students should not get paid for good grades, because it sends the wrong message, paying students for good grade is basically, a job and this can lead to countless practical problems. First of all, students should not be paid for good grades, for it sends them the wrong message. For example, in a video Ms Herbert shows

    Read More

  • Hrm/531 Week 7

    696 Words  | 3 Pages

    Reading Assignment #6 1. In order to keep top performers satisfied and productive, Steve Bates argues, there should be a substantial difference in the variable pay or merit- based salary increases that top performers and poor performers receive. Based on available research the increase needed to catch “anybody’s attention” should be a seven percent or eight percent increase in compensation. It also states that anything below that might be welcomed, but will not lead to substantially greater effort on the part of employees to increase business results.

    Read More

  • Incentive Summary

    449 Words  | 2 Pages

    The article, “Cheating report confirms teacher 's suspicions,” examines the Atlanta Public School system’s Georgia state Criterion Reference Competency Test scandal. CNN author, Paul Frysh, discusses former East Lake Elementary school teacher, Julie Rogers-Martin, account of events involving her fellow colleague’s involvement in the artificial inflation of their students’ standardized test scores in attempts to fulfill the requirements necessary for continued federal funding, job security, as well as bonuses. The economic idea that figures prominently in the article is Incentive, particularly the positive aspect of financial rewards and the negative aspect of fraud and depriving the most vulnerable groups of children their right to an education. In an ethical sense, I believe that the economic foundation of Opportunity Cost applies as well

    Read More

  • Good Grades

    972 Words  | 4 Pages

    According to some teachers, paying students for good grades can cause conflicts in the classroom, which could possibly lead to difficulty at home with parents. Paying students are also shown to be good for only a short period of time, can cause conflicts with parents, teachers, and fellow peers, and money does not leave kids with a true desire to learn. At the outset, students should not be paid, because students who receive money show lower academic performances than those that do not. As stated in the article “Parents paying their children money

    Read More

  • Should College Students Get Paid

    284 Words  | 2 Pages

    There has been no studies on paying for good grades can badly affect us. That 's why parents should pay us for good grades and like I said before if we get paid we will get better grades and have a better attitude towards school and think of it as an actual job. So that 's why I believe that we should pay students for good

    Read More

  • African American Education Analysis

    2200 Words  | 9 Pages

    African American education is important because it is by having education that African Americans can become well prepared for college, attend college, earn the same salaries as Caucasians and become successful in life. For many years, schools in America were segregated. In African American schools, most African American students did not have all of the laboratories, facilities, and quality of teaching that Caucasian students had. Five reasons why education is important to African Americans include money, equality, turning dreams into reality, economy and society (Levine). 1.

    Read More

  • Why Do Students Get Paid For Good Grades

    805 Words  | 4 Pages

    Did you know that paying students for having good grades resulted in a decrease in dropout rates, gangs, alcohol, and drug use? Students should get paid for having excellent grades. The reason why this is important is because it could lead to a brighter future for society. Three reasons why students should get paid for having awesome grades is because cash for good grades provide students with career-like rewards, it decreases dropout rates, and with the right incentive,could lead to success. All of those three reasons could and will result in success.

    Read More

  • Students Should Not Be Paid For Good Grades Essay

    706 Words  | 3 Pages

    When considering the choice of paying students for good grades and not paying students for good grades, the choice should definitely be, students should not be paid for good grades. Paying students for good grades may start off their youth incorrectly. Instead of focusing on getting an education, the reward of money is likely to block their priorities. Students will be angry when not given the money, and not being able to raise test scores or grades. In order for a bright and successful future, students should not be paid for good

    Read More

  • Should Students Get Paid For Good Grades Essay

    554 Words  | 3 Pages

    Some parents and teachers prefer intrinsic rewards over extrinsic rewards. Others believe that these kinds of rewards are bribes and that they take away the value of education. This argumentative essay will focus on three key reasons why children should be paid for grades: achievement, motivation, and real world application. Students need to be paid for good grades in school according to how much they have achieved. In Document C, it states that “For students who were closest to the achievement standard, the financial incentives appear to have improved their performance by an average 30-40%.”

    Read More

More about Why Is Merit Pay Wrong

Open Document