ipl-logo

Why Legislatures Pass Law

1883 Words8 Pages

Assess how different legislatures pass law? Whilst the system of how the UK and US passes laws is different, their purpose is the same which is to uphold democracy. Arguably the methods the UK and US use have significant flaws but they both also have their benefits. The system in the UK is considerably different due to its unbalance bicameral system compare to America. However some may argue the American system of passing laws is more effective than the UK. The first stage of passing a law in the US is the first reading, this stage is a mere formality as there is no debate and no vote. Typically thousands of bills are introduced which is a significant advantage of the system as any member of Congress can introduce a bill which in turn ensures the function of representation is carried out …show more content…

This places a significant disadvantage as both of the houses effectively go through a different process to get the laws through, the concurrent passage arguably means there will be differences. However in the UK this is a advantage of the system as the House of Lords and Commons are more connected, this is because laws can “ping pong” between the two houses until both effectively agree. Unlike America it ensures that those who have more knowledge in either house can amend the laws and have more of a contribution whilst in America if a congressmen has more information or knowledge on the potential law the Senate will have less knowledge about this, this effectively makes the US system of making law less connected. Arguably the US system can be seen as an advantage because each house effectively examines proposals, thus there is more scrutiny and check and balances compared with the

Show More
Related

  • Compare And Contrast How The Virginia Plan And New Jersey Plan

    759 Words  | 4 Pages

    The most obvious thing about the legislative branch is that, it is indeed a bicameral legislature which was proposed by Virginia, but with in this bicameral legislative branch there is one branch that is called the House of Representative which says that the more populated a state is the more votes it gets, while in the senate each state is given two votes regardless of their size. So in the constitutional both the Virginia plan and the New Jersey plan got put in and help solved the issue of representation by a compromise of combining both of the plans and making one branch of the legislative be based off of a state's population and the other off of

    Read More

  • Philadelphia Convention

    1067 Words  | 5 Pages

    The legislative branch consists of the two houses of Congress that have been decided upon by the Great Compromise (the House of Representatives and the Senate). Joint together as one system, Congress has the powers to create laws, declare war, override veto, and impeach the president. Secondly, the executive branch—consisting of the president, vice president, and the Cabinet—has the power to carry out laws (approve), negotiate foreign treaties—such as alliances—, and can grant pardons for federal offers. Finally, the judicial branch, or the Supreme Court Justices can interpret laws, declare laws unconstitutional, and declare the president unconstitutional. Having three branches of government helps keep the government in check, and it prevents one branch becoming more powerful than the other branches.

    Read More

  • Continental Congress Research Paper

    494 Words  | 2 Pages

    This procedure was later imitated in the drafting and ratification of the federal Constitution. In the British, a constitution was not a written document, but rather an accumulation of laws, customs, and precedents. Americans invented something different. The documents they drafted were contracts that defined the powers of government, as did the old colonial charters, but they drew their authority from the people, not from the royal seal of a distant king. As written documents the state constitutions were intended to represent a fundamental law, superior to the transient whims of ordinary legislation.

    Read More

  • Explain Why Every Bill That Shall Have Passed The House Of Representatives

    456 Words  | 2 Pages

    Per the United States Constitution Article One Section Seven, “Every Bill which shall have passed the House of Representatives and the Senate, shall, before it become a Law, be presented to the President of the United States.” (archives.gov) When a law idea is proposed, it MUST go to Congress, which is comprised of two chambers, House of Representatives and the Senate. The House of Representative consists of 435 members, the Senate has 100 members, and they both have committees and subcommittees that works with specific matters, for example the Education and the Workforce Committee and the Higher Education and Workforce Training subcommittee. ("The Legislative Branch"; edworkforce.house.gov) Currently, the Senate has 20 committees, with 68 subcommittees, and the House has 23 committees, with 104 subcommittees; there are four joint committees.

    Read More

  • How Did The Rise And Fall Of The Articles Of Confederation

    975 Words  | 4 Pages

    The structure of Congress was decided so that “Nine of thirteen states had to agree before a law could pass. If anyone wanted to amend the Articles to make the government more efficient, that took unanimous support. Many tried but weren’t able to secure all thirteen votes.” (iCivics packet). These harsh laws made it hard to pass any laws or make amendments to the Articles because it was near impossible to grasp the vast majority of votes.

    Read More

  • Unicameral Legislative Branch

    380 Words  | 2 Pages

    Legislative Branch in my government is unicameral legislative which only consists of a House of Representatives. The House of Representative elected thirty-five members that are divided among the states that have to be elected every two years but you had to follow by guidelines which are: Have to be at least twenty-five years old Is a U.S. Citizen for at least seven years Has to be a resident of that represents that state The House of Representatives forms a Congress which the constitution allows the Congress to pass legislation and to declare war. The One thing that makes my legislation different is not having a senate which goes in depth of determination of the bills. The determination of the bills allows them to look very deep into what they think the bills should be like which makes the senate slows down the process of the bills.

    Read More

  • How Does Paine Create A New American Government

    562 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both houses are elected by the people and create laws based on what the people want. In the following paragraph the author explains that each government needs a

    Read More

  • Texas Legislative Process Essay

    556 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Texas legislative process is governed by the Texas constitution as well as the House of Representative and the Senate. Its primary function is to enact laws to provide for the health, welfare, education, environment, and economic and general well-being of the citizens of Texas. It also establishes public policy through the passage of bills and resolutions and proposes amendments to the state constitution, which are then submitted to the voters for approval or disapproval. When a bill is proposed, it must go through the legislative process before it becomes a law. The legislative process is very long and has many steps.

    Read More

  • Polarization Of Congress

    1611 Words  | 7 Pages

    With leadership capability decreasing through the legislative branch policies become inefficient or biased. Decision to benefit the country as a whole is replaced with the appeasement of the public and sympathy of the republic. The functionality of the country as a whole prevents stable decision making for the United States and creates distractions and conflicts within the political system which may deter from efficient argumental decisions. In effect it creates distractive moments towards the political agenda and weakens the power that congress should have which

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay: We Should Keep The Senate In Canada

    875 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Senate is responsible for protecting the rights and interests of Canadians in all of its regions, especially minority groups or people who do not often get a chance to present their opinions to Parliament. Before a bill can become law, it goes through three stages, called "readings," in both Houses. The bill is debated, adjusted and then voted on by each House. Once approved, the bill is presented to the Governor General for royal assent and is made law. Another role of the Senate, not plainly provided for in the Constitution, “is to act as a non-ideological, routine revising chamber that picks up flaws in legislation that have avoided notice during a bill’s passage through the House of Commons.”

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Ohio Constitution And Us Constitution

    451 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are many different examples of how the structures between both levels of government are similar and how they differ. The US Constitution

    Read More

  • Hammurabi's Influence On The American Legal System

    1258 Words  | 6 Pages

    The American Legal System The American legal system has been influenced by many historical rulers and laws. Three that have influenced the American legal system the most are Roman laws, moral laws and Hammurabi’s code in my opinion. One legal system that influenced the American legal system are Roman laws. I picked Roman law because it said that law has been defined as the “Art of social control”; a system of rules regulating the conduct of man.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Senate And House Of Representatives

    545 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Senate and House of Representatives comprise the two chambers of the United States Congress. While both houses are representative bodies and jointly oversee the executive branch, both must approve all bills before the president, but both chambers have different roles according to the Constitution. The House of Representatives has 435 members apportioned to the house from across the United States. States with larger populations receive more seats within the house.

    Read More

  • The Controversy Of Choosing A Parliamentary System For Westphalia

    1420 Words  | 6 Pages

    Both the United States and Canada use this system and we can argue that in support of it. It prevents a single chamber from essentially “rushing” through legislation that could be unpopular. However, in order to stick to our goal, we could make it to where one chamber has little to no power in respect to legislation while the other chamber creates and votes on the actual legislation. An example of this would be the Senate of Canada; it rarely rejects legislation from the House of Commons and cannot purpose legislation that appropriates funds or centers around taxes, leaving most of the legislative power the House of Commons. By focusing most legislative powers in one chamber, the New Socialists would satisfied because they’d get their ten legislative seats, only in the chamber will little to no power, but they’ll receive their seats

    Read More

  • The Advantages And Disadvantages Of A Parliamentary Government

    944 Words  | 4 Pages

    Bagehot once described this feature “as the close union…of the executive and legislative powers.” Unlike the presidential system, which is in operation in the USA, the parliamentary

    Read More

More about Why Legislatures Pass Law

Open Document