Yuille And Cutshall Essay
DISCUSSION: ALL IN FAVOR, SAY “I” After much research, it appears that there are not many studies that prove that eyewitness testimony is reliable. However, an experiment performed by John Yuille and Judith Cutshall suggests that Loftus and Palmer et al. are incorrect, as well as Clifford and Scott et al. The Yuille and Cutshall (1986) experiment revealed that the witnesses were very accurate in their reports, neither leading questions nor weapon focus affected their memories, and the anxiety they experienced actually helped them remember the details even better.
Analysis of The Yuille and Cutshall Experiment In their experimental research, Yuille and Cutshall et al. conducted an experiment with twenty-one people who watched as a person was shot to death and another seriously injured. Afterwards, the police interviewed all twenty-one of the witnesses. Yuille and Cutshall et al. asked if they could interview them about four months later once again, and thirteen of the witnesses agreed. The results state that “the median accuracy of the classifiable new details was 81.07%, which compared favorably to the 84.14% accuracy of their police accounts” which proves the
…show more content…
In each incident, some characteristics can be more obvious than others, the distance from the incident matters, and what our brain chooses to do with the information we process are all big factors that come into play when trying to answer this question. For some people, their accounts of what occurs in front of their eyes is extremely accurate, while for other people - it is not. What I do know is, eyewitness testimony is to be used as a guideline in courtrooms, and not as any kind of evidence/proof. Too many innocent people have been wrongfully convicted due to false identifications and too many studies have proven that it is not as reliable as we all
Case Study Of John's Wrongful Conviction: Flawed Pathology Evidence
1139 Words | 5 PagesEyewitness accounts play a huge role in general in trials and verdicts, but may be unreliable many times, with certain views placed on evidence provided by children. Unreliability may arise from not being able to recount the identity of the accused, the actions and speech occurring during that time, the relationship of individuals towards the person in question, and many
Analysis Of Elizabeth Loftus Memory In Canadian Courts Of Law
851 Words | 4 PagesFollowed by the lack of corroboration, which is an important aspect in courtrooms, “corroboration will add credibility to the memory and lack of it may raise doubts about the allegations.” Loftus considers that relying on memory is not a valid way of justice; the legal system needs to improve when eyewitness testimonials are used in the courts. Loftus confides as a psychologist that psychological science has taught them about human memory and that the research has revealed the limits of human memory. Adding on, these research findings need to be incorporated in procedures to improve the court system. She hopes readers will acknowledge the fact that the use of memories in a trial can be problematic since they are “dangerous” and can lead to false
Summary Of Picking Cotton
1188 Words | 5 PagesIn the book “Picking Cotton”, the former Burlington Police Chief Mike Gauldin, who was the lead detective on Jennifer’s case, was certainly sure that Ronald Cotton was the guy he was looking for after Jennifer picked him twice (Jennifer, Ronald, Erin 80); also, on the McCallum’s case, the polices also chose to trust eyewitnesses when they did not have enough physical evidences. Furthermore, judges can be wrong sometime. Wise and Safer, who are authors of the report “ what US judges know and believe about eyewitness testimony”, surveyed 160 U.S. judges to determine how much they know about eyewitness testimony on a small test( Wise, Safer, 427-432). However, the survey responds the average judges in the U.S. only 55% correct within 14 questions (Wise, Safer, 431-432). Moreover, most of the judges who were surveyed did not know key facts about eyewitness testimony.
Similarities Between Scottsboro Boys And To Kill A Mockingbird
651 Words | 3 Pages“The two women also provided inconsistent accounts 160 of various details of the incident” Ruby Bates and Victoria Price’s testimonies were highly repugnant, to the extent where there were over 160 contradictions. “No, I don’t recollect if he hit me. I mean yes I do, he hit me.” “Was your last sentence your answer?” “Huh?
Essay On Curtis Should Be Paid In Restitution
503 Words | 3 PagesThey were proven wrong by other witnesses and new information was found. This is a reason for Curtis to be paid in restitution because he was charged for something that had false evidence and he should have never been convicted because of the false information said in court.
How Does Loftus Study False Memories
423 Words | 2 PagesHer earliest studies of eyewitness testimony addressed several issues: when someone sees a crime or accident, how accurate is his or her memory? These studies led Loftus to ask what happens when witness are questioned by police officers, and what if those questions are suggestive (Loftus, 2003). For instance, when Loftus began showing people films of traffic accidents, she found that a question such as “How fast were the cars going when the smashed into each other?” led to higher estimates of speed than a more neutral question that used the verb “hit”. Moreover, the “smashed” question led more people to falsely remember seeing broken glass when there was none.
Essay On Police Body Cameras
844 Words | 4 PagesBridget M. Synan also wrote that because, without editing, the footage will not change. This statement is good evidence because sometimes the citizen is wrong, so the body cameras can prove what happened in the story. The accused could lie about the police officer being in the wrong or vice-versa. In reality, though, the accused could’ve been in the wrong, so the video evidence will show that. There are no lies if it is coming straight from solid video
Witness For The Defense Elizabeth Loftus
1447 Words | 6 PagesPart One is very informational and contains the bulk of the book’s research. The information was presented in a thesis format; Loftus stated a claim and then supported her ideas with research and quotations from experts in the field of law and memory. Part One is helpful for psychologists, attorneys, and interested law people. The major principles concerning the errors in eyewitness testimony are supported by research and are accepted by psychologists (Kassin, Ellsworth, & Smith, 1989). Part One will contribute to the future of psychology by showcasing how the memory works and the different ways it is manipulated and changed: this will allow jurors and lawyers to become more wary when dealing with a traumatized
Eyewitness Misidentification
1297 Words | 6 PagesAre You Sure? Why have more than two-thousand people exonerated for crimes they didn’t commit? Eyewitness misidentification is the leading cause of wrongful convictions in the U.S. Memory can be influenced by anxiety, stress, reconstructive memory and other factors possibly affecting the testimony of the eyewitness and in turn, misleading the jury. I think that when subjects witness a crime they will struggle to remember important details of the event, and their recollection could be easily altered. This is because the reconstructive memory can be influenced by factors such as stress, anxiety, and verbal cues.
Why Is Milgram's Research Important?
950 Words | 4 PagesWhile arguably one of the defining psychological studies of the 20th Century, the research was not without flaws. Almost immediately the study became a subject for debate amongst psychologists who argued that the research was both ethically flawed and its lack of diversity meant it could not be generalized. Ethically, a significant critique of the experiment is that the participants actually believed they were administering serious harm to a real person, completely unaware that the learner was in fact acting. Although Milgram argued that the illusion was a necessary part of the experiment to study the participants’ reaction, they were exposed to a highly stressful situation. Many were visibly distraught throughout the duration of the test
Eyewitnesses: 60-Minute Segment Of Ronald Cotton And Jennifer Thompson
702 Words | 3 PagesThis week’s topic was very interesting to learn about how important eyewitnesses can be when a crime and accidents do occur. In the case that was presented in the 60-minute segment of Ronald Cotton and Jennifer Thompson is exactly how legal system can fail us when it comes to the eyewitnesses’ identification testimony and how a person’s perception and memory can be altered. The aspect of psychology and law research from this week’s course material is most relevant to the topic of perception and memory. The memory has different stages the first is encoding the process of entering perception into memory.
Essay On Wrongful Convictions
1225 Words | 5 PagesFurthermore, there can be several factors at play when a wrongful conviction occurs and each case is unique. Three of the more common and detrimental factors that will be explored in this essay are eyewitness error, the use of jailhouse informants and professional and institutional misconduct. Firstly, eyewitness testimony can be a major contributor to a conviction and is an important factor in wrongful conviction (Campbell & Denov, 2016, p. 227). Witness recall and, frankly, the human emory are not as reliable as previously thought. In fact there has been much research showing the problems with eyewitness testimony such as suggestive police interviewing, unconscious transference, and malleability of confidence (Campbell & Denov, 2016, p.227).
Eyewitness Identification Essay
1228 Words | 5 PagesEyewitness identification is ineffective and unjust. Studies have shown that 40% of eyewitness identifications are wrong (Vrij, 1998). Eyewitness identification has great importance in the legal system. This requires the best eyewitness testimony procedure. This essay examines the three main types of eyewitness line-ups; the showup, the sequential and the simultaneous line-up.
The Credibility Of Eyewitnesses In Criminal Investigations
441 Words | 2 PagesThis clearly sows that the memory is an active process and is expected to alter an opinion based on understanding society (Simple Psychology, 2014) . Eyewitness testimony is unethical as the evidence that is supplied can be provided by someone with stress or anxiety issues this can assist by distraught the image of the suspect. Wrongfully sending an innocent individual to prison. Bloods worth’s case displays it is unethical as there was no psychical evidence nor appearance matched that supported Bloodsworth was responsible for the murder and rape of the victim. Three eyewitnesses were able to identify the perpetrator out of the five and this was based from evidence that he was spotted with the young girl hours earlier before the crime was
Essay On Post Event Information
1397 Words | 6 Pages, (2003) study. Gabbert investigated the effect of post event discussion on the accuracy of eye witness testimony; where participants
More about Yuille And Cutshall Essay
Case Study Of John's Wrongful Conviction: Flawed Pathology Evidence
1139 Words | 5 PagesAnalysis Of Elizabeth Loftus Memory In Canadian Courts Of Law
851 Words | 4 PagesSummary Of Picking Cotton
1188 Words | 5 PagesSimilarities Between Scottsboro Boys And To Kill A Mockingbird
651 Words | 3 PagesEssay On Curtis Should Be Paid In Restitution
503 Words | 3 PagesHow Does Loftus Study False Memories
423 Words | 2 PagesEssay On Police Body Cameras
844 Words | 4 PagesWitness For The Defense Elizabeth Loftus
1447 Words | 6 PagesEyewitness Misidentification
1297 Words | 6 PagesWhy Is Milgram's Research Important?
950 Words | 4 PagesEyewitnesses: 60-Minute Segment Of Ronald Cotton And Jennifer Thompson
702 Words | 3 PagesEssay On Wrongful Convictions
1225 Words | 5 PagesEyewitness Identification Essay
1228 Words | 5 PagesThe Credibility Of Eyewitnesses In Criminal Investigations
441 Words | 2 PagesEssay On Post Event Information
1397 Words | 6 Pages