Zimbardo Vs. Milgram's Experiments
Ultimately, the behaviours executed by the group of policemen is suggested to be replicable, as some aspects of the consequences of the behaviours of the policemen and the results of both Zimbardo’s and Milgram's experiments paralleled. The Stanford prison experiment conducted by Philip Zimbardo yielded similarly chilling results: a nucleus of increasingly enthusiastic killers who volunteered for the firing squads and "Jew hunts"; a larger group of policemen who performed as shooters and ghetto clearers when assigned but who did not seek opportunities to kill (and in some cases refrained from killing, contrary to standing orders, when no one was monitoring their actions); and a small group (less than 20 percent) of refusers and evaders. (Browning 168)
Likewise, just like some of the subjects from Stanley Milgram’s experiment on the topic of obedience to authority, the policemen “mitigated their behaviour when they could do so without personal risk but were unable to refuse participation in the battalion's killing operations openly” (Browning 176). Although neither experiment can concisely explain the reason behind Reserve Police Battalion 101’s conversion, they each share elements suggesting that any group of sensible men can be moulded into obedient executioners. Just as human nature prompts individuals to reconcile with
…show more content…
Of those men and women incarcerated for murder, how many have been converted from “ordinary men” into killers? What circumstances did it take from carrying out tasks similar to those of Reserve Police Battalion 101? However disturbing this issue is, another part of human nature allows for us to exist in the world, and to experience joy and kindness. Perhaps accepting the possibility that maybe we all carry a little monstrosity inside could even be the first step to avoiding more
In Cold Blood And The Milgram Experiment
1043 Words | 5 PagesThis Milgram research on respect to authority figures was a series of cultural science experiments conducted by Yale University scientist Stanley Milgram in 1961. They assessed the willingness of survey participants, men from a different variety of jobs with varying degrees of training, to obey the authority figure who taught them to do acts conflicting with their personal conscience. Participants were led to think that they were helping an unrelated research, in which they had to distribute electrical shocks to the individual. These fake electrical shocks gradually increased to grades that could have been deadly had they been true. McLeod's article about the Milgram experiment exposed the fact that a high percentage of ordinary people will
Christopher Browning's Ordinary Men
1409 Words | 6 PagesHow does an ordinary group of people turn into bloodless killers? The author of Ordinary Men, Christopher Browning offers the most captivating argument towards how it is possible for ordinary men to commit extraordinary atrocities. This paper will analyze the different viewpoints of what caused ordinary men to commit murder. To better understand this issue one must understand the sides of argument.
The Milgram Experiments
992 Words | 4 PagesMany of the accused got sentenced to life in prison or death. Stanley Milgram conducted an experiment to explain the correlation of the environmental aspects that make people do terrible things and how far people will go to harm others. Social pressures also play a big role in how people think. Minorities can have their ideas of what is right and what is wrong swept over by majorities which was displayed in Solomon Asch’s experiments. The most important thing to learn from the Nuremburg trials, Milgram’s experiment, and Asch’s experiment is that sometimes it is better to resist authority if it means following moral
Philip Zimbardo: The Lucifer Effect
1254 Words | 6 PagesSituational effects and personality come into conflict when discussing behavior. Personality is someone’s “usual pattern of behavior, feelings, and thoughts” (Twenge, 2017, p.20). It remains constant throughout different situations, but some situations can be stressful enough to make a person act out of character. The transition between a person’s normal personality and behavior to a more evil, sinister behavior fascinates a man named Philip Zimbardo, who conducted the infamous Zimbardo Prison Experiment, or Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE). Zimbardo is an American psychologist at Stanford University and the mastermind behind the 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment (The Story).
Stereotypes Of Domestic Homicide
1068 Words | 5 PagesHomicide, as a criminality, has a vast array of methods. Domestic homicide is a sub-class, yet it is one of the most customary categories of homicide throughout the world. This essay intends to find connections in relationships and homicidal tendencies in regards to both genders through specific traits adopted by biological backgrounds. Drawing from research entailing queries into why domestic homicide is the leading cause of manslaughter on a global scale. The characteristics of the basic psyche behind how these events occur can date back to the natural biological progression of the male and female predispositions.
Why Is Milgram's Research Important?
950 Words | 4 PagesMilgram himself concluded how easily ordinary people ‘can become agents in a terrible destructive process. Moreover, even when the destructive effects of their work become patently clear, and they are asked to carry out actions incompatible with fundamental standards of morality, relatively few people have the resources needed to resist authority". (Milgram 1974) As this report has highlighted the research is not without controversy with many questioning to what extent Milgram’s experiment is true to real life and has been criticized for not highlighting further situational variables in determining obedience to authority. Regardless of this, there is no doubt Milgram highlighted a rather troubling phenomenon.
Examples Of The Milgram Obedience Experiment
320 Words | 2 Pages1) One real life example of the Milgram Obedience Experiment can be seen during Hitler's and the Nazi's reign in Germany from 1933 to 1945. Each Nazi was presumably paid, and if they defied Hitler's demands or higher ranking Nazi's orders they would be executed. As a result, as a fear tactic to ensure their lives. In the decades since the Milgram Experiment, the results have been held up as proof of the depths of ordinary people’s depravity in service to an authority figure. At the time, this had deep and resonant connections to the Holocaust and Nazi Germany.
Gender Differences In Prison
700 Words | 3 PagesCriminals are placed on a wide spectrum, ranging from small details like an IQ or how one was raised at a young age as to why one might commit a crime. Prisoners experience different experiments to understand their behavior and actions. Alongside the experiments, criminals often have different mental illnesses which could be diagnosed while there. One thing that is important to realize is how different gender roles are in a jail or prison. Prisoners often experience punishments, but there are other ways to deal with it.
Compare And Contrast The Milgram Experiment And The Stanford Prison Experiment
810 Words | 4 PagesDuring the 1960’s Stanley Milgram conducted a series of experiments to test how a person reacts to authority. He started these tests in response to World War Two and the reports of the German soldiers who claimed they were “just following orders’ when asked about
Los Angeles Men Central Jail Essay
2191 Words | 9 PagesOne of the most recent scandal that happened in Law Enforcement community is the Los Angeles jail scandal. Los Angeles County Sheriff are involved in the incident that took place in Men’s Central Jail in Los Angeles, CA. Based on the reports, the sheriffs were abusing the inmates and also in one occasion has been reported illegally detaining the visitors of the prison from Australia. The beatings were unjustified and causes a stir in the Law Enforcement community. This is just another case of police brutality that as been put into light and its giving our police officers a bad name.
Milgram's Study Of Obedience Essay
488 Words | 2 PagesMilgrams study of obedience is about the tendency to conform to authority Milgram uses a doctor in a lab coat to represent authority and used volunteer subjects to shock another subject if they do not repeat three word correctly it can be compared to the villagers in Barrnetts article because Milgrams study showed that over 50% of the test subjects are willing to do what the authority the doctor in this case instructions or commands. It was proven on how far they went in shocking the other subject with the highest setting on the shocking device. The same can be linked on what the Nazi’s did to the villagers in Muanchaussen with the swift and decisive ways they took care of protesters made the Nazi’s the authority and must be adhered too in any case. And that even if people know it is wrong they still listen to the authority this is the case with the employees like the doctors and nurses also including the maintenance man working in the euthanasia camp they continue to do what they are told to do even when they know what is happening is
What Makes Good People Do Bad Things Critical Analysis
865 Words | 4 PagesThe Monitor on Psychology article “What makes good people do bad things?” by Melissa Dittmann analyzes the results of the Stanford Prison Experiment conducted by Stanford psychology professor Phillip Zimbardo in 1971 and discusses what the experiment can tell us about human nature and what causes humans to be evil. In the novel “Lord of the Flies” the author William Golding discusses the effects of the theories mentioned in the article by creating his own fictional experiment with children stranded on an island during a nuclear war. Throughout his novel Golding explores the focus of Dittmann’s article; that environments and situations can bring out the evil that is inside all of us. People can act good or bad depending on their environment, and these actions are not entirely their fault because when people are not held accountable for their actions their more violent natures are revealed.
Analysis Of Miguel Piñero's 'Short Eyes'
1424 Words | 6 PagesThe “rule kill or be killed” is not only applicable in the wild nature but among prisoners whose primitive nature comes on surface once thrown among the criminals. The instinct to protect yourself and preserve your peace is often the very cause of violence in the prisons. Just like in Miguel Piñero’s Short Eyes, the “peace” of inmates is disrupted once an intruder from outside comes among them. Since there are many already established clashes in the prison, such as the ethnic clash between the different ethnic groups, clash between the victims and sexual offenders everything seems to perish once an intruder of human race comes in the picture. Seems like all the differences disappear when among criminals comes a man who committed the ultimate despicable
Zimbardo Stanford Prison Study
608 Words | 3 Pages11. The findings of the Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison Study is that the guards began to harass prisoners. It was concluded that people will readily conform to the social roles they are expected to play. 12. The findings of the Milgram study is that people are likely to follow orders given by an authority figure, even to the extent of killing an innocent human being; this because people with high authority is ingrained in us because of the way we are brought up.
What Is The Order In Stanley Milgram's Obedienc Obedience
334 Words | 2 PagesEveryday people will follow orders given by the authority, whether they want to or not and even if they think it is wrong. Stanley Milgram did countless studies on this to find the truth behind the startling idea. He was curious to know if people would follow orders given by the authority to the point of hurting another human being. The test included a teach, learner and experimenter.
More about Zimbardo Vs. Milgram's Experiments
In Cold Blood And The Milgram Experiment
1043 Words | 5 PagesChristopher Browning's Ordinary Men
1409 Words | 6 PagesThe Milgram Experiments
992 Words | 4 PagesPhilip Zimbardo: The Lucifer Effect
1254 Words | 6 PagesStereotypes Of Domestic Homicide
1068 Words | 5 PagesWhy Is Milgram's Research Important?
950 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of The Milgram Obedience Experiment
320 Words | 2 PagesGender Differences In Prison
700 Words | 3 PagesCompare And Contrast The Milgram Experiment And The Stanford Prison Experiment
810 Words | 4 PagesLos Angeles Men Central Jail Essay
2191 Words | 9 PagesMilgram's Study Of Obedience Essay
488 Words | 2 PagesWhat Makes Good People Do Bad Things Critical Analysis
865 Words | 4 PagesAnalysis Of Miguel Piñero's 'Short Eyes'
1424 Words | 6 PagesZimbardo Stanford Prison Study
608 Words | 3 PagesWhat Is The Order In Stanley Milgram's Obedienc Obedience
334 Words | 2 Pages