Zinn Vs Schweikart Analysis
Eric Harris
Rough Draft
Friday Paper
10/29/2015
Zinn vs Schweikart and Allen
In A People’s History of the United States (1980) by Howard Zinn, he makes the argument that the US Constitution was written to protect the selfish economic interests of the wealthy. Zinn has plenty of logical information to back his statement up, but in A Patriot’s History of the United States (2004) by Schweikart and Allen opposes the idea. They argue that the constitution was written to promote selfless ideas of unity and political truth like it should have. Schweikart and Allen feel that true patriots are ignored due to too much emphasis on political correctness. Their “true patriot” and only valid argument is that George Washington declined power for the country’s own good by opting out of his 3rd term as president. Sure, George Washington may have been a great leader and person, but to say that Washington’s selfless actions represents the motives of all of those in power, is preposterous.
…show more content…
To gain support, they gave the allusion to the less powerful that the power was equally distributed. Right after the constitution, voting was basically exclusive to Protestant, land-owning white men. It wasn’t until 1856 when North Carolina was the last state to lift its property requirements for voting. Even then it wasn't until the 15th Amendment in 1869 and the 19th Amendment in 1919 than let all men and then all women vote. How voting rights were set up exemplify the the “elite” trying to maintain their high
Dbq On The Progressive Era
699 Words | 3 PagesPeople that were for women vote said that they do so much work and deal with so many bad things in work, so why can't they vote. (artifact 3) They used many different strategies to gain the right to vote like moral persuasion. The Women's Christian Temperance Movement fought for the ban on production and sale of alcohol. The 19th amendment was passed in 1920 the women had the right to vote. (artifact
Jim Crow Law System DBQ
159 Words | 1 PagesThe whites thought that sooner or later if we let them vote that they’re going to take over. The Jim Crow Laws system stopped the blacks from voting. That caught the Civil Right leaders and that brought attention to Mississippi. That made it acceptable for that 7% of black people to vote. In Document B which was a “Freedom Summer Pamphlet.”
Similarities Between 1776 And The Constitution
1396 Words | 6 PagesFor example, the extension of property and voting rights to women in the United states was largely driven by political reasons rather than any desire to make women equal to men before the law. In many cases this reason was the need to promote settlement on the frontier. Evidence of this comes from the geographic distribution of the granting of women’s suffrage on the state level before women’s suffrage was granted federally. Nearly all of the states who granted women the right to vote early were western states that needed respectable women to move there in order to create a sustainable population with families. Sometimes, women’s suffrage was granted in order to bolster constituencies.
Differences Between 1776 And 1870
281 Words | 2 PagesMeaning that African American men could vote, but during 1776 only people who own land can vote Just a little after 1870 Susan B. Anthony was arrested because she tried to vote and she was a woman, major differences spark between then and now, 2016 anyone over 18 can vote. Whether you are a man or a woman. In 1776 size population changed drastically the population was around 2.3 million, but only a couple years later the population of the U.S. was over 3 million. As you can see time changes many things.
Zinn Critique
524 Words | 3 PagesJamie Isaacson Mr. Zontek History 136 Participation #0 Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States states how Zinn’s biases influenced his relationship with American history. He references his youth as a dock worker, and his military service, to explain how he couldn’t remain objective regarding his choices of what parts of history to teach, thereby displaying bias. He states that because the US was founded and is ran by self-interested white men with a desire to create a strong central government that could wage war on the whims of an individual, American history is a study of classism and arrogance. Zinn also claims that American history is “a white man’s history” because there is no mention of Black people or Native Americans beyond
Zinn Compare Contrast Analysis
730 Words | 3 PagesCompare the perspectives of both Zinn and Pageant on the government 's attempt to curb big businesses’ corruption. In comparing, evaluate the commitment government had on curbing big businesses’ corruption. After the Civil War, the United State of America underwent an industrial revolution. More and more machines were used in factories; steel production rose significantly and helped build railroads and infrastructure; oil started to light streets and homes; and various other innovations increased efficiency and impacted everyone’s lives.
Rousseau's Critique Of Economic Inequality
1079 Words | 5 PagesElected officials generally come from the more advantaged social class, therefore, they are the ones who write, adjudicate and execute the laws. Ergo, in a well-ordered society the less advantaged are able to vote and use their voice to keep the elites in or out of office, however our society doesn’t work this way. The high incumbency rate tells us that elected officials stay in office regardless of the quality of their representation. In addition, our extremely low voter turnout emphasizes the disconnect the American people feel to their elected leaders and the faith they have in the political system. Political parties design gerrymandering to keep the less advantaged from gaining power and a voice in
Constitutional Amendment Dbq
528 Words | 3 PagesAfter the Civil War in 1865, Republicans in Congress introduced a series of Constitutional Amendments to secure civil and political rights for African Americans. The right that gave black men the privilege to vote provoked the greatest controversy, especially in the North. In 1867, Congress passed the law and African American men began voting in the South, but in the North, they kept denying them this basic right (“African Americans,” 2016). Republicans feared that they would eventually lose control of Congress on the Democrats and thought that their only solution was to include the black men votes. Republicans assumed that all African American votes would go to all the Republicans in the North, as they did in the South and by increasing the
What Is Andrew Jackson's Presidency?
512 Words | 3 PagesMarch 4, of 1829 was the day Andrew Jackson was inaugurated as president of the United States. People had high expectations for Jackson to meet throughout his presidency. Did Jackson do a good job of changing the type of people who participated in the country 's economy and politics? His presidency certainly increased equality throughout social classes. Jackson gained himself and his years as president the title of "the era of the common man" due to his efforts at making politics and the economy more accessible to white men with fewer opportunities.
Persuasive Essay On Democracy In America
959 Words | 4 PagesToday I’d like to discuss something we all share - something so pervasive that it’s easy to forget that a few hundred years ago it hardly existed at all: Democracy. At least in America, democracy seems to be the only constant that our intensely partisan government can agree on. Nothing else is free from scrutiny: We’ve questioned the definition of marriage, the rights of embryos to live, and even the ethics behind our genetic code. Amidst all this turmoil, democracy has managed to remain the most unassailable concept in our nation. However, the time has come for us to take democracy, the most sacred of our institutions, off of its dusty pedestal.
William Domhoff's Who Rules America
1109 Words | 5 PagesOne important component in which the upper class rule America is the electoral process. Loose campaign finance regulation, including controversial Supreme Court decisions such as Citizens United v. US and Buckley v. Valeo is a primary cause of the wealthy ruling politics. These two decisions asserted that corporations are not limited in their spending on political candidates. Essentially, the US Supreme Court enabled corporate leaders to buy influence - SuperPAC heads and wealthy businessmen were welcomed to join forces and pour as much money as possible into candidates’ campaigns. The net effect: America’s wealthiest individuals could exert an unmatchable influence on candidates and the electorate while pressing an agenda favoring the upper class.
The African American Voting And Jury Rights Of African Americans
1147 Words | 5 PagesDuring that time, African Americans were not entirely free with all of their desired rights, as they still did not have complete political, economic, and social rights. Back then, African Americans did not have wholesome political rights. According to document A which shows the voting and jury rights of blacks in the north of 1860, only a few states, the New England states, had rights to suffrage. And this was only the male population of the New England region. And of that region, only one state, Massachusetts had jury rights, and that was only gained in 1860.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Susan B. Anthony's Speech
991 Words | 4 PagesFor a very long time, the voting rights of the citizens have been a problem in the US. It started out with only men with land being able to vote, and then expanded to white men, and then to all men. However, women were never in the situation, they were disregarded and believed to not be worthy enough to have the same rights as men. They were essentially being treated as property, therefore having no rights. But, in Susan B. Anthony’s speech, she hits upon the point that women are just as righteous as men.
Examples Of Selfish Founding Fathers
574 Words | 3 PagesFounding Fathers: Selfish or Selfless Founding Fathers, men that had risked their lives for our nation, so we could have our own independence. Their act was a great deed to the united states to make our nation come together, so we could improve our country. Our founding fathers were some of the greatest men to serve our country.
Susan B Anthony Figurative Language
974 Words | 4 Pages“It shall be my work this evening to prove to you that in thus voting, I not only committed no crime, but, instead, simply exercised my rights, guaranteed to me and all United States citizens by the National Constitution, beyond the power of any state to deny. ”(Anthony, 1) is a quote from Susan B. Anthony’s famous “Women’s Rights to the Suffrage” speech that inspired change in our great country. This speech was the most compelling of texts because she used solid evidence to support her claim and she uses many different types of figurative language. The third, fourth, and fifth paragraphs were the most important in her speech. This emphasis on ‘We the people’ and not ‘We the white male citizens’ in her third paragraph leads me to my first point.
More about Zinn Vs Schweikart Analysis
Dbq On The Progressive Era
699 Words | 3 PagesJim Crow Law System DBQ
159 Words | 1 PagesSimilarities Between 1776 And The Constitution
1396 Words | 6 PagesDifferences Between 1776 And 1870
281 Words | 2 PagesZinn Critique
524 Words | 3 PagesZinn Compare Contrast Analysis
730 Words | 3 PagesRousseau's Critique Of Economic Inequality
1079 Words | 5 PagesConstitutional Amendment Dbq
528 Words | 3 PagesWhat Is Andrew Jackson's Presidency?
512 Words | 3 PagesPersuasive Essay On Democracy In America
959 Words | 4 PagesWilliam Domhoff's Who Rules America
1109 Words | 5 PagesThe African American Voting And Jury Rights Of African Americans
1147 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Susan B. Anthony's Speech
991 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of Selfish Founding Fathers
574 Words | 3 PagesSusan B Anthony Figurative Language
974 Words | 4 Pages