Why Antony’s Eulogy Was Superior to Brutus’ Speech In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, Antony’s speech is more effective than Brutus’s because Antony utilizes emotions in order to stir up the people and start a riot and speaks in a way that the people can understand, whereas Brutus talks above the people, using prose like the nobility used, and uses ethic and logic to reason with the people why killing Caesar was justified. Brutus’ use of ethos and logos makes the most sense to knowledgeable thinkers and well educated individuals, however to the uneducated people of Rome, using pathos as Antony did would prove more successful. Brutus failed to recognize the most important aspect of speech and presentation, the audience. When speaking the most important …show more content…
“Believe me for my honor and have respect for mine honor that you may believe (III, ii, 15-16).” Brutus states that he is honorable and to remember this in order to believe him. However this will prove to be a terrible thing to say as Antony uses parallelism and repetition of words by saying “For Brutus is an honorable man… (III, ii, 81)” repeatedly. Antony uses this to get the audience to believe that all Brutus said about his honor was wrong. Antony uses this against Brutus and using fallacious arguments he convinces the people that Brutus was not in fact honorable, but a murderer and a …show more content…
“Our Caesar’s vesture wounded? Look you here, Here is himself, marred, as you see, with traitors (III, ii, 191-192).” Antony picks up Caesar’s body to show off the stab wounds and by putting names to scars it gives the people more hatred towards the conspirators who caused great damage to him. Antony also gets the people riled up and emotionally more involved by reading the will, but more than that, the taunting of the will got the people very mad especially when he said “I fear I wrong the honorable men Whose daggers have stabbed Caesar. I do fear it. (III, ii, 150-151).” This caused the people to be infuriated who responded with “They were traitors! “Honorable men (III, ii, 152).” The plebeians were angered by this statement because they truly don’t believe Brutus and the conspirators had any reason to kill Caesar. Overall Antony’s smart thinking allowed him to use his resources to the best of his ability and decimate Brutus and the conspirators'
Antony knew this would have an impact on the plebeians and it certainly did. Finally Antony destroys Brutus’ argument. First off he reminds the plebeians that Caesar truly did care about all the people of Rome. “When that the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept” (III.2.90). He also brings up how he offered Caesar the crown three times and three times he refused it.
This immediantly catches the ear’s of the audience as they hear about how much Mark Antony loved Ceasar. Antony repeats to the people that Brutus was an honorable man. He is being almost sarcastic when he says this though. Antony doesn’t actually think that Brutus is an honorable man. He is mocking Brutus.
Brutus did not only betray his friends, he betrayed his country also. Brutus intentions were to be the ruler of Rome himself, but he did not let the people know that’s all he wanted. Antony Tells the Romans that what Brutus did is wrong, although Brutus thought it would be the right thing to do. Antony had the advantage to make the Romans change their mind after Brutus’s speech, whenever brutus said “ I depart- that as I slew my best lover for the good of Rome, I have the same dagger for myself, when it shall please my country to need my death”. Antony critiques what Brutus says in his speech to help appeal to the audience emotions and end with the majority of the people on his
Brutus was a friend of Caesar as well. Brutus turned on his so-called friend and killed him for, what he thought, the safety of Rome. The crowd was on Brutus’s side but after hearing Antony’s speech, they didn’t know if Caesar’s death was necessary. Antony’s speech was the most effective because ethos, pathos, and logos were used to support his claims. First, Antony used ethos to effectively share his speech.
The text says, “Kind souls, when you weep but behold our Caesar’s vesture wounded? Look you here! [He removes the mantle] Here is himself, marred as you can see with traitors” (Act 3.2.192-194). In effect, this creates an emotional appeal within the crowd as they look on at Caesar’s deceased corpse because it gives the people yet another reason to trust Antony after seeing what the conspirators did to Caesar.
In the third paragraph of Brutus’ speech, he uses parallelism with the sentence structure I (verb) about Caesar's death. He said “I weep… I rejoice… I honor” (Shakepeare 26-28). By using these I statements, Brutus created a sense of togetherness, which boosted his credibility. But since Marc Antony thwarted Brutus’ honor in his speech, Brutus’ I statements didn’t serve him well. However, Marc Antony used anaphora when he repeated the words ambitious and honorable.
This shows that Caesar wasn't ambitious and trustworthy. Antony uses his emotions to also win the people's trust. Antony is talking about the emotional story of how Caesar was murdered. He brings the people to a sad state and the Romans start to respect Antony more. Brutus thought that his reasoning behind the assassination of Caesar would be enough to persuade that the killing of Caesar was the right thing to do.
And, sure, he is an honorable man.” Here, Antony is inquiring the civil men with questions leading to obvious answers whether or not the actions that Caesar has performed was him being selfish or just him being considerate. This quote highlights that the civilians start to realize that Brutus deceived them when he declared that the reason they killed Caesar was because he was doing it in honor of his country, but when Antony announces well known facts about the consideration he took with the Romans, it shows that he cared very deeply about them. The Romans comprehend the lies that had been told to them, so they started to riot by killing the Congressmen involved in the conspiracy. Accordingly, Antony shows the Romans the obvious truth that had been in front of them this whole time, so they’re able to understand that Caesar has been there for them this entire
To prevent Caesar from making Rome a dictatorship, envious conspirators, with the help of Brutus, plan to kill Caesar. Caesar’s death leaves Antony scarred and he intends to avenge his friend. Antony goes to war with Octavian and is defeated. As a result, he kills himself. Although Antony doesn’t include evidence of how Brutus wasn’t honorable, Antony’s speech is effective at convincing the Roman Citizens that Caesar's murder was not justified.
Mark Antony’s Speech Shakespere is considered by many to be one of the greatest playwrights of the renaissance period entertaining playgoers of all social classes with his comedies and tragedies. Julius Caesar, one such tragedy written by Shakespeare, has within it many speeches; however, Mark Antony’s funeral speech that he gives after Julius Caesar is assassinated contains a myriad of examples of rhetorical argument techniques. In Act three, scene two of Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, Mark Antony uses ethos, pathos, and logos to turn a despairing and disoriented crowd of mourners into a volatile and rebellious crowd of rioters turned against Brutus and his co-conspirators.
Antony was basically doubting Brutus’s words, yes Brutus is trustworthy and honorable, but were these acts of ambition? The people believed Antony more than Brutus since they saw Caesar refuse the crown thrice. Antony during his speech also kept repeating “honorable men” which by the end of his speech the people yell at saying “They were traitors. “Honorable men!””(II,ii,150-152) Antony said he didn’t want to turn the people against the conspirators but he knew exactly what he was doing.
When he ascends the pulpit to speak at Caesar’s funeral, Antony repeatedly says that Brutus is an “honorable man”, (Act III, Scene II) but continues to disprove his own claim with multiple pieces of evidence. By disproving his claim while seeming compassionate, Antony makes his audience believe that he is caring yet naive. This allows the audience to let their guard down and think that their later ideas are their own. Antony uses the crowds’ emotions to convince them that Brutus and the Conspirators aren’t honorable. Antony says that he won’t do the Conspirators wrong by stirring up a mutiny.
In his emotional speech to the crowd of mourners attending Caesar’s funeral, Antony utilizes ethos, logos, and pathos to argue that Brutus and the conspirators are traitorous, lying murderers, and they deserved to be killed for what they had done to Caesar. Doing so forces his audience to realize they are being
While Brutus spoke well, but had no real factual standpoint, Antony gave many examples of Caesar’s achievements. In his speech he uses Pathos, Logos, Ethos, and Situational Irony to sway his audience. He uses Brutus’ and Cassius’ precious honor and Caesar’s achievements against them, saying, “When that the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept./ Ambition should be made of sterner stuff./ Yet Brutus says he was ambitious,/ And Brutus is an honorable man” (3.2.90-93). In this statement and many other statements following the same pattern Antony degrades the honor and the arguments of Caesar’s ambition that were made by Brutus and the other conspirators.
Antony describes how much Caesar loved Brutus, and how upset he was when he was stabbed by his best friend — “Judge, O you gods, how dearly Caesar loved him! This was the most unkindest cut of all; for when the noble Caesar saw him stab, Ingratitude, more strong than traitors arms,” (3.1.181-184) He uses negative words like “traitor,” and “ingratitude,” to appeal to their emotions and convince the Romans that Caesar didn’t deserve to be stabbed. Having established Caesar's faithfulness, Antony was then able to build on the guilt that the crowd felt for having believed Brutus— “Whilst bloody treason flourish’d over us. O, now you weep; and, I perceive...