The Axe Grinding Mystery of the Borden Murders
“Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks and when she saw what she had done she gave her father forty one.” These famous words are dedicated to the suspected murderess, Lizzie Borden. Plenty of people feel as if Lizzie was not guilty of the murders, but many think she was. There is evidence for both sides of this daunting mystery, but no one really knows the truth: did Lizzie really commit this crime? Many questions are raised due to the Borden murders, and much evidence connects to the two theories, whether Lizzie murdered her parents or not.
Despite the mysterious murder Lizzie’s life remained fairly normal, even right before the assassination. Born July 19, 1860 in Fall River Massachusetts was Lizzie Andrew Borden, daughter of Andrew Borden (“Lizzie Borden”). Lizzie’s mother died when she was young and her father eventually married Abby Gray (“August 04”). Lizzie’s had a casual
…show more content…
First of all shown in the article “August 04, 1891 Borden Parents Found Dead” Lizzie says she was in the barn at the time of the murders, and eventually found her father's dead body (“August 04”). Many people were skeptical about this theory because there wasn't much to back it up. On the contrary there was no evidence showing she murdered her parents, there was no blood or weapon found (“Lizzie Borden On”). Also, other studies show that the illegitimate son of Andrew Borden or Townspeople might have been guilty (“Lizzie Borden”); then again not much evidence is shown to back that up as it is not a very well known theory. Another claim Lizzie made was that she was looking for lead weights at the time of the murder (“Lizzie Borden”) and that “According to her story, Lizzie remained in the barn for 15 minutes and then returned to the house” (“Lizzie Borden On”). As a result of all this evidence Lizzie may have been
Lizzie Borden is guilty of homicide of Andrew and Abby Borden because Lizzie’s investigations were never done correctly, Lizzie was doing peculiar things days before the murders, and Lizzie and her stepmother had bad blood. Lizzie Bordens investigation was never done correctly. Lizzie's room was never searched for any evidence. According to Bio.com, back then during
The judges who presided over the case dismissed a bloody pail and cloths that was brought as evidence against Lizzie. The police discovered the pail filled with blood, water, and cloths in the Borden’s cellar during their investigation on August 4th, 1892. The authorities claimed the bloody bucket proved the killer used the cellar to clean up after the two homicides, further incriminating Lizzie. Despite the hefty evidence, the court dismissed the provided evidence. The three judges concluded that this could have been the blood from menstruation.
“August 4, 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden are murdered in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts.” Chery Eddy Lizzie Borden is arrested for the murder of her father and stepmother. ... Lizzie Borden was found not guilty But I think that she was. The first reason, I think lizzie borden was the murderer because of the suspicious behavior before and after the murder. A clean, handle-free hatchet blade was found in the basement, which was the only reason it was suggested murder weapon.
It seems unusual that a woman would choose to wait alone in a house if she thought a murderer still might be in the neighborhood on the loose. Furthermore, On the night before the murders, Lizzie went to visit Alice Russell ( a neighbor), and told her that she was worried that some unknown enemy of her father's might try to kill him soon. As a result, this convinced me to believe that Lizzie Borden was the only possible culprit for the murders of her
The most plausible theory is Lizzie Borden the daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Borden who allegedly murdered them. To start with, Samantha M. Gavin, a full-time lecturer in Administration of Justice, describes her past relationship with both her father and stepmother,¨Lizzie's relationship with her father and stepmother was unstable¨(Borden, Lizzie 1860-1927). The morose and unstable relationship between Lizzie Borden, her Father, and her Stepmother possibly was the motive for the killings. After the police came, the bodies were found. In an interview with Lizzie Borden, they noticed it had been strange that she showed no signs of grief, and remarked a snarky comment when speaking about her stepmother (Mooney).
“Lizzie Borden took an ax, and gave her mother forty whacks when she saw what she had done, She gave her father forty-one” the infamous song of Lizzie Borden allegedly accused of both the murders of her father and stepmother. But now come to think could she really have been innocent? There are many suspicious details leading to her being guilty but Lizzie was declared innocent. So now the suspicion begins. Despite the many information on the Lizzie Borden case, I believe Lizzie Borden should have been proven guilty.
And lastly, Lizzie Borden didn’t kill her father and stepmother. In 1891, Mr. and Mrs. Borden were killed in their home. And the killer was unknown. I believe that Lizzie Andrew Borden, did NOT murder her parents. But then, who killed them?
He had also said there was blood leading up to the front door, and had gotten on the door. In addition to the evidence found we start now with Adelaide B. Churchill testimony, and she has concern for Lizzie as she dimly says in her testimony. Adelaide Churchill is clearly suspecting Lizzie had killed her parents. We could give her the benefit of the doubt and say she probably liked Lizzie’s dress or something, but also Adelaide had not seen what Lizzie had on that morning. In Emma Borden's testimony, she had said “It was very dirty, very much soiled and badly faded.”
In August 1892, one of the most disastrous murderers occurred that is still yet to be solved. Andrew Jackson Borden and Abby Durfee Borden were a married couple in the 19th century. They were suddenly murdered with an ax and were given multiple whacks to the head. Lizzie Borden, daughter of the two victims, still remains as the only suspect that committed the murderers. For this reason, Lizzie Borden is guilty.
I read through all the witness testimonies and Lizzie Borden is guilty let me tell you why. All these testimonies mentioned something that made her look guilty. here’s why, she changed the story way too much, Lizzie Borden burned a really big piece of evidence, she also could have been jealous of her stepmother because her father bought her stepmother Abby Borden a house. Lizzie Borden seems to change her answers a lot in the very last document. Let me explain to you why she is guilty.
The only one in the house at the time was Lizzie Borden. Also, they found no evidence that someone came in and just murdered mr. and mrs. Borden. Another reason why I think she committed the murder was because she was having conflict with her mother All in all, Lizzie had to have been guilty because she had the most evidence out of everybody else that was considered a suspect.
Lizzie Borden is Guilty Many cases were named “Trials of the 19th Century”. Lizzie Borden’s trial was one of them. Lizzie was put on trial for the murder of her father and step mother.
Why She Is Guilty “My door was open part of the time, and part of the time I tried to get a nap and their voices annoyed me, and I closed it. I kept it open in summer more or less, and closed in winter.” Lizzie Borden stated after the murder.(BrainyQuotes.com) The people who seem innocent are the real guilty ones. Some of them try to hide behind their shyness or the motive.
In Lizzie Borden: Murderess or Media Sensation it states that “There was no physical evidence linking her to the murders” There was no evidence that she did the murders. They didn't question anybody but Lizzie. Anyone could have done it. This just proves that Lizzie did not do
Many events in history have gone unanswered and one of those events was the killing of the Bordens. The book has three separate parts to it and they are all very well detailed. The Borden family consisted of Andrew, the father, Abby the stepmother to Andrew 's daughters, Lizzie and Emma, Andrews two daughters and Bridget, the house maid. They all lived together in Fall River until on August 17, 1892 when Bridget was out cleaning windows, Emma was out of town, and Lizzie was in the back yard a gruesome killing happened. Arnold R. Brown wrote this book primarily to uncover the truth about who killed the couple while either proving or disclaiming theories that have surrounded the story.