In Ray Bradbury’s “Fahrenheit 451”, censorship vs. free speech are central ideas explored through the foil characters of Clarisse McClellan and Faber in relation to Montag’s emotional detachment. Clarisse's independent spirit and inquisitiveness about the worlds she encounters show the dangers of a society that discourages intellectual inquiry and encourages mindless compliance. Faber's persona, on the other hand, stands in for the negative effects of censorship, including the loss of knowledge and individualism. Through their interactions with Montag, the novel provides insight into the value of free speech and the consequences of a society that suppresses it, while also emphasizing the importance of emotional connection and humanity.
The
…show more content…
Faber is a retired professor who withdraws from society out of fear of government censorship. He is aware of the value of books and speech, but he lacks the courage to put his ideals into practice. When Montag seeks Faber’s help, Faber hesitates to assist him, saying, “I've had this little item for months. But I almost let you go, I'm that afraid!” (Bradbury 87). Montag is daring and willing to question the status quo, in contrast to Faber's fear and inaction. Through Faber, Bradbury portrays the dangers of censorship and the importance of free speech. “I’m one of the innocents who could have spoken up and out when no one would listen to the ‘guilty,’ but I did not speak and thus became guilty myself. And when finally they set the structure to burn the books, using the firemen, I grunted a few times and subsided, for there were no others grunting or yelling with me, by then. Now, it’s too late.” (Bradbury 78). When Montag visits Faber, the professor explains how he didn’t take action when books were first banned. Faber sees himself as being guilty of a crime, instead of the people who fought for literature. As Faber did not speak out, he never learned who else was on his side, and doesn’t know how to speak out now. His lack of knowing who his allies were is another example of how unconnected people in this world are. “So now do you see why books are hated and feared? They show the pores in the face of life. The comfortable people want only wax moon faces, poreless, hairless, expressionless. We are living in a time when flowers are trying to live on flowers, instead of growing on good rain and black loam.” (Bradbury 79). The underlying conflict between censorship and free speech is highlighted in this quote. Faber agrees that people have the freedom to select what they read, watch, and believe, but censorship aims to restrict access to specific ideas or information in
Montag believes the answer to his misery is in the books he has been burning for years, this leads to unexpected courage and impulsive behavior. In this section, Montag also develops a desire to change and rebel against society and the norm. Seaking Faber and coordinating a plan to save books from burning serve as an example of Montag’s courage and curiosity. Speaking to Faber
Faber talking to Montag about books “It’s not books you need, it’s some of the things that once were in books” (82). It’s the message and knowledge that the books possess. It is that which the government burns, because they are afraid of the truth that might come out of it. But Montag wants to search for the truth, that’s why he follows Faber and asks him for advice. This is a stage where Montag is turning into a rebel, the next event that happens turns him into a total rebel.
The protagonist of the story, Guy Montag, was never one to doubt the exact reason why he carried out his society’s prohibition of literature. However,
They show the pores in the face of life. The comfortable people want only wax moon faces, poreless, hairless, expressionless" (79). This shows us that in the society of Fahrenheit 451, books are burned because they tell readers real events, but since the government does not like this, they are using their power to burn
After killing Beatty, Montag rushes to Faber’s house where he learns from the rebel about the importance of books. In addition, Faber assists Montag with his cause, providing information and tools. “‘My cowardice is of such a passion, complementing the revolutionary spirit that lives in its shadow, I was forced to design this(86).”’Faber is essential to Montag’s journey even though he can only provide advice. With his “revolutionary spirit”, Faber creates a tool, which allows him to change the world and stay safe which is essential in his ideal life. His actions allow the reader to envision his ideal life where there is creativity and most importantly safety for all.
His language and tone not only stress the need to act alike but the dangers of not doing so. His words cause readers and intend to cause Montag to believe that books are as dangerous as a “loaded gun”. Although Beatty doesn’t say it, the true reason they are as dangerous as a “loaded gun” is that they force people to think and no longer allow the government to control that. Later after this interaction readers meet a character named Faber. Faber is an intelligent mind who represents freedom.
This results in a society that does not have any meaningful culture or history. This is evident when Faber emphasizes, “You can’t make people listen. They have to come round in their own time, wondering what happened and why the world blew up under them” (Bradbury 83). This highlights how the lack of access to books leads to a society that is uninformed and unable to learn from history. Censorship can even eventually lead to a society where individualism is discouraged, and
Bradbury uses ‘books’ to explain how free people feel within society. Even under the equilibrium, some are in fear of having ‘books’ taken away because of their freedom of speech and how they feel as an individual, an equal, in society. Montag, in Bradbury’s novel, goes through a whole series of events as he proceeds through learning the true need for equality. Montag gets chased, almost dies, and experiences all because of his choice to read a book. Granger, who appears later on, simply brings Montag into a place for his safety, because all people who felt or did the same things because they could not get their place in an ‘equal’ society.
Montag meets Faber at the green park in the city. Montag then overhears Faber reading a piece of writing, which we then find out that it was a poem. As we learned earlier, any form of writing or text is prohibited in this dystopian society. This is important since we now know that Montag is not the only one who believes in reading. “Then the old man grew even more courageous and said something else and that was a poem” (Bradbury 71).
Faber said that he “did not speak and thus became guilty [himself]” when faced with the people’s issues (Bradbury 78). Because Faber, unlike most people, had the option of free will, his decision to remain inactive in the face of a moral issue made him more ‘guilty’ than those who did not have the option to choose. Faber’s literary knowledge gave him this option to choose, which in turn made him more human and less like the almost robotic, thoughtless remainder of society. When Montag tells Faber through the green bullet that there is no reason in changing himself if he is just “told what to do,” Faber praises him for being “wise already” (Bradbury 88, 89). As Montag starts to follow in Faber’s steps and question the world around him, he too comes to realize that the main reason for changing himself was in gaining the option of free will taken from him by society.
Undoubtedly, the stance that is often taken against books or other types of artwork with particularly controversial topics is to ban the art. Similarly, Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 demonstrates the theme of censorship with the illegitimacy of books. Although literature contains knowledge and personal thoughts with the purpose to be shared, close-minded individuals refuse to understand the different perspectives books show. One of the major reasons the government bans literature in the fictional setting of Fahrenheit 451 is the offense taken by minorities targeted by particular books.
“The woman on the porch reached out with contempt to them all and struck the kitchen house against the railing” (Bradbury, 40). This peaks Montag’s interest in books, and even prompts him to steal one from the burning house to add to his hidden collection. Nevertheless the harms of censorship are eventually recognized, people become curious and want to know what 's being hidden from
“When freedom of speech is restricted, people will be afraid of speaking out about evil practices in society. In the name of blocking harmful information, censorship restricts real information that empowers local communities. The lack of access to truths often leads to ignorance.” (Naveen Reddy. “The disadvantages of censorship”)
Here, Faber is in his house telling Montag about how books bring life into the world. Faber is letting Montag know that books are important not because they are books, but because of their meaning. As difficult as they can be to deal with, the pores are the perfect imperfections needed to make the world great. Bradbury shows that books and knowledge are vital and that censoring books robs the world of individuality and freedom. “Give a man a few lines of verse and he thinks he’s the lord of all creation.
(Bradbury 55). He explains to Montag that censorship is the trick to a happy and ordered society. The advancement of entertainment technology aided in the censorship by distracting the population with entertainment. Montag’s view towards books is opposite to the views of Beatty, which makes Montag rethink whether or not his comrades are a positive effect on society. Additionally, Montag’s horrific experience of watching a woman die for her books, makes him wonder what books truly contain.