In this essay, I am going to argue that although these stories are different in their structure and style as well as in the ultimate response of the main characters, the theme, tone, and general events are very similar. In both stories the main characters had a close encounter
“Nowadays you can go anywhere in the world in a few hours, and nothing is fabulous any more” . This quote is from a very famous author named Roald Dahl that has made an award winning book called “ The Landlady”. “All that we see or seem is but a dream within a dream.” This quote is also said by another award winning author and his name is Edgar Allen Poe and has made many books. One of his amazing books is called “The Tell Tale Heart”.
Comparative Essay Thesis- Throughout both of these stories, there are ideas and elements that are shared between the two, such as similar themes, and the same point of view. However, there are also disparities that are prevalent within the stories, like the setting and how much the reader knows. Both of these stories describe the similar narrative of a wife murdering her husband, due to him treating her bad. This sets up a theme of sympathy, or understanding for the killer in both stories, as they only kill them because they were treated so badly by their husbands.
The setting is now adding on to the dark madness of the character. This in the delivers a more powerful concentrated emotional impact. In conclusion, “The Black Cat” and “The Telltale Heart” both effectively use the same point of view to deliver different concentrated emotional impacts. For the contrast is the setting and their level of efficiency in the stories.
The theme in “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “The Black Cat” has one prominent similarity regarding the descent into insanity and the underlying mentality of the two main characters. “The Tell-Tale Heart” is a short story about a guy who kills an old man because of his “evil eye.” The narrator feels guilty about killing an old man, and he finally confesses his crime. In “The Black Cat,” an insane narrator tells the story about the murder of his cat and wife. As the narrator’s drinking gets out of control, he begins abusing his pets and wife, and kills them in the end.
The relationship between the black cat and The Tale-tell Heart, there is definitely similarities with these short stories because both narrators claim their sanity and then contradicts themselves by acting unusual and bizarre. The Tale-Tell Heart seems to focus more on his sanity and the “Evil eye”. Both the Tell-Tale Heart and The Black Cat have the theme of insanity, most of his stories are also told in first person The Tell Tale Heart is about a man being disturbed by an eye, the eye of the old man is harmless but drives the narrator mad and the eye seems to be a problem. Then the old man’s body is hidden within the house and hidden from police and eventually the narrator claims insanity with the heart beating faster and louder.
In "The Tell-Tale Heart,” the narrator planned his murder. Since he had been planning his murder I believe that something may have happened in the past and he was still holding a grudge or he was prejudiced. In “The Black Cat,” the narrator did not plan the murder. He committed his murder without any serious thought. I believe that when he finally saw the cat again, he got angry that the cat had ran away from him.
Some differences between the books The Black Cat and The Tell-Tale Heart is that there was a possibility that The Black Cat actually lived. Unlike horror books ones, they're all made up stories that seem to attract readers into reading them. One way that they do it is by making it exciting so it seems like they really lived. Another difference is that the Tell-Tale Heart story had some abnormal and thing that are hard to believe like when the narrator comes several times to the old man's house. However, The Black Cat narrator doesn't really have abnormal or not believable.
After an unsuccessful attempt to drown the child, the killer kills him with a sword and buries the body in the garden. He is now scared that the body will somehow come back to life and also confesses. The Plot in both stories are based on a murder, and in both, the murderer tries to conceal evidence of the murder but still they are discovered. The two short stories are both confessions, in Poe's the murderer could be telling his confession to a friend or a policeman.
Edgar Allan Poe has quite a few similarities in the short story “The Tell Tale Heart” and the poem “The Raven”. First off both are dark mysterious stories like the man himself. Both works of art use acute senses and are thrilling to grab your attention from the moment you start reading. To start off hearing is a key factor that Poe uses to create the sense of danger. “The Raven” had mentioned “faint tapping while sleeping” this indicates a slight suspicion and danger may be lurking.
One similarity in both of these stories is death that kills innocent people. In “The Tell-Tale Heart” the narrator kills the old man because of his eye. The old man never did anything to him to hurt him or to
Similarly, in “The Black Cat”, the narrator attempts to kill his second cat but slaughters his beloved wife when she tries to protect the animal. Madness is a common characteristic of both the narrators in these stories. Madness is signified in both “The Tell-Tale-Heart” and “The Black Cat” through the speakers’ lack of adequate reasoning for obligating murder. In “The Tell-Tale Heart”, the narrator becomes conscious that he lacks a distinct motive for killing the old man he dwells with. He admits he loves the man, even after committing the deed.
Edgar Allan Poe 's The Black Cat and The Tell-Tale Heart are very similar in the way that they portray insanity. In The Black Cat the narrator was an introvert that becomes an alcoholic and becomes “insane” when he starts to not feel any emotions when he does anything, cruel or not. In The Black Cat the narrator did things that many would consider insane, such as taking a cats’ eye out or hanging the cat because you love it. The narrator, despite being an alcoholic, did things that even if you were intoxicated would make you insane to be ok with. The narrator, in a drunken stupor, took the black cats’ eye out, then afterwards, after feeling some remorse at least, decided to hang the cat because he loved it.
The two stories which impressed me most were Tell Tale Heart and A Curtain of Green. Although they seem very different from each other, I see them as different representations of two pretty similar stories. Both Tell Tale Heart and A Curtain of Green take us into memories of two protagonists who have some mental issues and who are presumably very lonely people. Both of the stories include highly dramatic climaxes; however, the ways we took while we join the characters in their journey are certainly different.
“The Tell-Tale” is a short story by Edgar Allen Poe. “The Tell-Tale Heart” is a story about an insane man killing an old man because the man has cataracts, or what he calls “the devil eye.” The crazy man is friends with the old man and is actually very nice towards him. The crazy man watches the old man sleep day after day for a week strait. On the seventh day, the crazy man is watching the old man, and awakens him by shining a light on the cataract eye.
