During times of uncertainty and instability, highly appointed individuals in society can gain their status and people’s approval by arousing their audience members’ emotions and prejudices rather than through fair debate and argument. In politics, demagoguery is utilized by a speaker to persuade an audience with propaganda rather than the quality of his or her argument. Demagoguery refers to the political strategy that appeals to an audience’s emotions and prejudices with certain characteristics and elements. In junior Senator Joseph R. McCarthy’s speech to the American public, he manipulates demagoguery to appeal to the American audience on the wrongdoings and undermining communist actions of Edward R. Murrow, the Educational Director of …show more content…
Scapegoating is a scare tactic used by the speaker to demonize a particular group and persuade one’s audience that the out group is satanic and evil (“Characteristics of Demagoguery”). McCarthy chronicled the influence of communism in the past where, “ under their system, the individual was nothing; the family was nothing; God did not even exist. Their theory was that an all-powerful State should have the power of life or death over its citizens without even a trial; that everything and everybody belonged to the rulers of the states” (McCarthy). The audience undergoes a sense of displacement and anxiety, which brings about a sense of righteousness to the in group and their viewpoint. The audience is a group of individuals who wholeheartedly believe that Americans have individual rights, power, participation, and opinion on how the government should operate. This implication of the driving force behind communism generates a demonic and satanic image of communists to the audience. McCarthy’s generates and drills this satanic image of the communism supporting out group on his behalf, therefore his audience will side with the in group and support his argument. The outgroup, or the communists, are scapegoated because they had clever people such as Murrow to “sponsor invitations to students and teachers to attend indoctrinational schools in Moscow. They trained Communists in every country in the world. Their sole purpose was [to] infiltrate the government, and once Communists were in government, they in turn brought others in” (McCarthy). Their primary goal is to destroy what makes up the American government, thus riling up the anger from McCarthy’s supportive audience members. These communist individuals who aim to infiltrate the American government by any means are seen as demonic and satanic by the anti-communist audience
“The term ‘"McCarthyism’" has passed into general usage as a synonym for the anticommunist political repression of the early Cold War”. (Schrecker 3) The Crucible shows the similarities between the Salem witch trials and the Red Scare. The Crucible displays a relationship between the Salem Witch Trials and the fear of McCarthyism in the 1950s. Like The Crucible, with people terrified of witchcraft, people during the Red Scare feared communism and feared the punishment that came with an accusation.
Enemies from Within On February 20th, 1950, Senator Joseph McCarthy delivered a speech on his views of the communists 'invading' the American government. This famous speech started what's known as McCarthyism, which was the campaign that endorses unfair allegations and investigations. He believes the American democracy is being ruined by communist spies, so he uses his platform to scare the citizens into action. Paragraph 7 further details this with the quote, ''When a great democracy is destroyed, it will not be because of the enemies without, but rather enemies within.'' The quote in paragraph 7 reveals that McCarthy believes the American democracy is being undermined by communists within the government and is served to scare the
Throughout history, society has pushed down certain groups of people. One daunting example is the Salem Witch Trials, which was a series of hearings and trials wrongfully accusing people of witchcraft. Those accused of witchcraft were either thrown into jail, hanged, or forced to confess a sin that they did not commit. In The Crucible, author Arthur Miller warns of the detrimental persecution of groups by society in order to avoid history from repeating itself.
Not every anti-Communist person was caught in the fallacious McCarthyism, however, Harry Truman, himself a very open anti-Communist, opposed anti-Communist legislation and vetoed the Internal Security Act in 1950. In his veto message, he calls into question the required registration of ‘Communist front organizations’, writing, “This provision could easily be used to classify as a Communist-front organization any organization which is advocating a single policy or objective which is also being urged by the Communist Party” (181). In this message, Truman warns against the use of a hasty generalization fallacy, one which would indeed eventually be used. However, others did not see the threat of such fallacies and his veto was overridden by a large
In the 1940 's and 1950 's, an anti-Communist movement swept the United States of America. Fueled by the anti-Communist actions of Congress, particularly a Senator from Wisconsin by the name of Joseph McCarthy, the movement escalated and many people lost their jobs as a result of various blacklists. Congressional hearings, both in front of HUAC and McCarthy Senate committee were a study in organized persecution. The actions taken during the "Red Scare" were eventually given the general name McCarthyism. McCarthyism is the practice of making accusations of subversion or treason without proper regard for evidence.
The book lays out details of how regular Americans to politicians and celebrities were being accused of being communists, having connections to communists or advocating freely to be communist. The book also shows the effect of Joseph McCarthy to the public during the McCarthy era, as he was the direct cause of publicizing ordinary to well-known Americans to communist ties, as the effects of publicizing brought what is known as the “Red Scare” in the United States and Americans feared communism. I choose to read Nightmare In Red for
McCarthyism and Arthur Miller's “The Crucible” share many similar qualities regarding the actions of society when aroused with a certain fear. It was distinctly seen first in the 1600s during the Salem Witch Trials, which is portrayed through the play, “The Crucible”. It happened when talk of witchcraft scattered the town of Salem, making everyone hysterical and constantly accusing people of being witches without proof. Behavior similar to this came back in the mid 1900s when society was accusing people of being communist during a time of fearing Hitler. The claims of supposed communists were involved in the idea of McCarthyism.
“McCarthyism” now refers to a period of intense anti-Communism during which people such as McCarthy went on a witch hunt to expose supposed Soviet spies in the U.S. Government, media, and more. This was a period of political oppression that has not seen its equal in America before or since. The Salem Witch Trials consisted
McCarthyism was the fear of communism which spread across America in the 1950s. The hysteria of the American citizens was due to the threat that communism would spread across the globe. The government has accused many people of communism,
his skepticism towards McCarthy. He saw through McCarthy’s tactics and knew he was an opportunist using this petty form of bullying for his own social gains. Around 1950, McCarthy had formed accusations against policy makers and clerks, maintaining that there had to be traitors in the administration. Murrow responded to these accusations by saying that while it might have been a possibility that there were in fact Communists in Washington, those individuals were protected by the Bill of Rights. More importantly, he pointed out that McCarthy’s accusations were unfounded and held no signs of proof (Edwards 102).
This kind of hysteria caused the Red Scare, which was a period that Americans thought communists were working to destroy America. This mass fear of communism ruined people’s lives and made them turn against their own family and friends. Joseph McCarthy played an
With all of the accusations going around, people were forgetting that everyone can have their own opinion. Edward R Murrow, a television host of See It Now bashed McCarthy by saying “’We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty’” (Roberts, 2). Murrow was saying that just because a person disagrees with what the president or a government official says, does not mean they are a communist. The United States has freedom of speech, and citizens can say whatever they want about the government.
McCarthy manipulated the media, told outrageous stories about the communist conspiracy in the United States, and used his power and America’s fear to besmirch any opponents as “communist sympathizers” to make sure he remained at the top. Actually, most conservative members of Congress supported McCarthy because it helped them gain votes during elections. The majority of McCarthy 's movement attacked liberals and members of the Democratic Party and this aided anyone who was not part of those topics and organizations. Then McCarthy began to target the Army because they wouldn’t favor David Schine, one of his former investigators, who had been drafted in. “Senator Joseph McCarthy began hearings investigating the United States Army, which he charged with being ‘soft’ on communism.
It was derived from the fear and hatred they had deep inside them. Mccarthy used this plot to get rid of his opponents and secure him a prime spot for a next term as a senator. McCarthy’s trials were no different to The Salem witch trials by raising suspitions he was able to destroy lives with a written list. Although people tried to contradict his allegations the majority’s fear of communists clouded the court’s judgement. They had no remorse for the aftermath of their doings.
McCarthyism was a vociferous campaign against alleged communists in the US government. Many of the accused were blacklisted or lost their jobs, although most did not in fact belong to the Communist Party. In these two events, many similarities