Life in a concentration camp is unimaginably difficult and leaves many with great uncertainty. People must fight hard, have unspeakable grit, and go through life-changing events just to have a chance at the freedom they were unsure would ever come. In the memoir Night by Elie Wiesel, we learn Elie was only 15 when he was taken from his home, left only with his father, and forced into multiple concentration camps throughout Hitler's reign. We’re let in on the unbearable experiences and effects concentration camps had on many of the innocent people forced to try to live life as normal there. Elie overcomes the tragedy and struggles brought on by the situation by changing the way he approaches and experiences life's battles. In Night, it could …show more content…
He demonstrated the newfound trait when Idek became angry and decided to take his anger out on Elie for no apparent reason. “He threw himself on me like a wild beast … As I bit my lips in order not to howl with pain, he must have mistaken my silence for defiance and so he continued to hit me harder and harder … abruptly, he calmed down and sent me back to work as if nothing had happened” (Wiesel 53). This evidence goes to show that had Elie talked back things could’ve gone much worse for him. Idek proved signs of having very unpredictable behavior that he was able to control when he realized Elie was not saying anything. As Elie's silence did not stop Idek's actions right away, it certainly did lessen the wrath of Idek because had Elie made more noise it also would’ve been taken as defiance but dealt with much more harshly and without compassion. Even though Elie was not very fond of listening and obeying the SS officers, in times of life and death he had to get over his stubbornness to survive. If he continued thinking he would get what he wanted by complaining and not accepting the truth, this reality would be much harder to face. Once again Elie pushes through his stubbornness after accidentally being in the wrong place at the wrong time and seeing the wrong things, getting punished by …show more content…
This brings him to start bending the rules, lying, and overall coping unaided. This piece of text occurs just after the arrival at Birkenau concentration camp when Elie is approached by a random man telling him to lie about his credentials to SS officers to protect his safety. “‘Hey, kid, how old are you? … ‘Fifteen.’ ‘No. You’re eighteen.’ ‘But I’m not,’ I said. ‘I’m fifteen.’ ‘Fool. Listen to what I say’ … In no time, I stood before him [An ss officer]. ‘Your age?’ he asked, perhaps trying to sound paternal. ‘I’m eighteen’. My voice was trembling. ‘In good health?’ ‘Yes.’ ‘Your profession?’ Tell him that I was a student? ‘Farmer,’ I heard myself saying (Wiesel 30-32). Elie once again lies in this situation to protect his future. Had he been completely honest like he originally wanted to be, he would’ve ended up with the children marked as “useless” and eventually put to death. His last-minute adaptation to ensure his survival showed already so early in the book his signs of change. The situation was a very tough one to be put in as you have to decide to be morally correct or think about your future. This shows Elie had to lie and bend the rules to have a more successful chance at life after the camps. Once again Elie is seen bending the rules to protect himself when he lies about his “sickness” to a dentist trying to take the one thing he
Although Elie did not want to hurt Stein’s feelings even more than they were already he should have not lied to him. Many people believe that lying is okay. Lying is never okay. It hurts the ones a person's loved one and can actually hurt the person’s health in ways too. The truth will eventually always come out; therefore, why lie about anything?
What he saw caused him to laugh which then caused Idek to hear him then threaten him. Later on in the day, Elie was
lie Wiesel’s experiences of dehumanization in the Nazi concentration camps extraordinarily influence his behavior and identity. During his time in the camps, Elie demonstrated extreme behavioral adaptations to survive the treatment; these were made possible by the erasing of his identity. Elie’s identity is established in the opening pages of the book. Elie is characterized as a deeply religious and intelligent person.
What if he chose the other way? Lying is sometimes mandatory to stay alive. In this quote, Elie has to lie about his age, and his father’s age because another prisoner told them to say that to survive. “Fifteen.” “No.
Later, Elie begins to explain how his personality and outlook on life changed during his time at the camp. He stated, “The instincts of self-preservation, self-defense,
1 Benjamin Marks Honors English II Night Essay Prompt Choice 3 Throughout the memoir Night, Elie Wiesel explains how he went from a devout Jew, who was proud of his religion, and in the matter of months became unexpressive, and beaten down to the point where he was questioning God himself. Through culture, physical, and geographic surroundings, Elie’s character drastically changed. In the beginning of this hell, his main goal was to stick with his father for as long as possible, always staying with him in order to protect each other. But as time went, Elie’s innocent mind was beginning to see things differently, he became emotionless and numb towards the violence around him, and without care to what happened to his father
What had happened to me? My father had just been struck, in front of me, and I had not even blinked. I had watched and kept silent” (Wiesel 39). Elie is shocked by his reaction because normally he would stand up for his father, but what he has experienced has taught him to stay silent in order to not be punished himself and enhance the
For example, when his dad gets beaten by Idek, instead of feeling sorry for him Elie is angry. Elie states, "if I felt anger at that moment, it was not directed at the Kapo but at my father. Why couldn't he have avoided Idek's wrath? That was what life in a concentration camp had made of me..." (54). This quote shows how concentration camps change a person's identity tremendously.
Even in the wretched situation that the Jews were going through, Elie prays that he himself did not think like the son that he would stay by his father. Elie, who still had his innocence and was not yet aware of the changes in his life, had a major shift of opinion later on in the book when he wrote “if I felt anger at that moment, it was not directed at the Kapo but at my father. Why couldn't he have avoided Idek's wrath?” (Wiesel 54) Elie had lost his identity and himself but that was what living in a concentration camp had made Elie turn into and eventually his survival began to mean
Eliezer was so afraid that he used silence to corrupt him and keep him from speaking up. His fear overcame him which caused him to obey and listen. When obeying the officer, Wiesel implies this compliance by “[nodding] once, ten times, endlessly. As if my head had decided to say yes for all eternity.” Elie felt like nodding for eternity just to follow orders, showing the power and mastery the SS officers had over him.
One of those situations is when his father is getting yelled at and disciplined. Elie felt guilty as he did nothing to stop the officer and realized how much he had changed. He depicts this moment in his book when he says,“I had not even blinked… Only yesterday I would have dug my nails into the criminals flesh”(pg39 Wiesel). This is showing how Elie's time in the concentration camp has already taken a toll on his identity and how that change in identity can be found through his guilt in his hesitation to protect his father.
On pages 40 and 41 of chapter 2, Elie shares with us the questions the Nazi soldier asked him once he arrived at the concentration camp, which were "How old are you?" and "What's your occupation" to which Elie lied and responded anxiously with "Eighteen," and "Farmer." His lie gives us an insight into his thought process. Elie lied and proclaimed that he was 18 and a farmer, knowing he was just a student and 16 years old. This lie conveys to us that Elie’s number one goal was survival.
Imagine being a young 15 year old boy barely fed, dehydrated and at a camp that was created for the purpose of killing thousands of people and immediately once you arrive losing your mother and sister. Elie shows extreme mental strength during this event, rather than trying to stop it from happening
This piece of evidence shows that Elie rebelled against the SS to be with his father, which takes tremendous courage. Furthermore, in the earlier chapters of Wiesel’s novel he was beaten by a Kapo named Idek because he was in a bad mood. A French woman showed courage by giving Elie a mini speech in perfect German, a language no one knew she spoke, in order to pass off as an Aryan. Years later they meet
During the holocaust Elie had to overcome a whole lot of things and mature quickly to survive. Then he had to think of things to keep him going; “For the dead and the living, we must bear witness.” Thoughts to keep his head still staying up and to not to be quiver, but to be strong, independent, emotionless. He was trying to stay strong to stay alive and keep going on.