ipl-logo

Response To Nicholas Carr's Is Google Making USupid?

981 Words4 Pages

In Nicholas Carr’s article “Is Google Making Us Stupid”, Carr argues that the Internet is causing our reading skills to deteriorate. Conversely in Trent Batson’s article “Response to Nicholas Carr’s ‘Is Google Making Us Stupid?’”, Trent argues against Carr saying that the changes in our reading habits are actually positive. Both writers have valid points within their essays but Batson’s article makes more sense logically. Carr sees only the negative aspects of the Internet on people’s reading and not the positive ones. Technology is not making society stupid. Technology is causing us to research more efficiently and to work together as a society in the combined forums.
One way in which technology influences society is in how individuals research …show more content…

Today’s media is abbreviated compared to the media of previous generations. This is a direct result of the media’s audiences’ shift in reading from analyzing to browsing (Carr 240). Carr discusses his own reading habits saying, “It’s changing… I can feel it most strongly when I’m reading. Immersing myself in a book or a lengthy article used to be easy” (Carr 236). He is talking about his mind shifting from deep analytical reflection to quick bursts of thought. The human mind is changing as a result of technology, and even Batson agrees with Carr on this saying, “There is no question our habits are changing… The Web is different in almost all aspects from a book” (Batson 259). This change from deep contemplative thought to reading thousands of quick snippets does not have to be seen only as negative. While they agree on the change, Carr and Batson have different views on the ways in which this change affects …show more content…

“Carr sees only one side of the change...the loss of book habits. But, for us over thousands of years of learning, the book is the anomaly, not the Web” (Batson 259). Batson makes an excellent point, and books have only be widely spread during the most recent era of human society. For thousands of years oral tradition was the only way in which people learned. Carr even discusses in his own article how reading is not natural for humans. “Reading...is not an instinctive skill for human beings. It’s not etched into our genes the way speech is” (Carr 238). In this Carr is discussing the ways in which humans learn. The book is an “anomaly” in the fact that it cannot be changed easily, and is not fluid like human society (Batson 259). Batson discusses how books are credited to one or two authors, but the authors themselves have been shaped by the people around them,
The book led us to think that one person could write a permanent compilation of truth… that one person ‘owned’ the ideas in a book as though the author had grown up in isolation from all other humans and all the ideas had sprung, fully-formed, from his or her brain. (Batson

Show More
Related

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

432 Words | 2 Pages

Every day new technology is advancing to makes its way into the world where it is used more efficiently. In the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?,”, Nicholas Carr claims that human are no longer able to focus on longer texts due to the rise of digital texts. Nicholas Carr includes strong evidences to support his statement; and through the usage of ethos and pathos, he is able to convince his readers that “the Net is becoming a universal medium” (Carr). Examples of Ethos are evident throughout the article making Carr’s argument deductively valid. Nicholas Carr is known for his reputation as someone who has written influential pieces and earning many awards for his accomplishments.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

240 Words | 1 Pages

In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” by Nicholas Carr, the author suggests that modern technology is changing the way him and other people think. He argues that, in the past, it was much easier to engage in long readings. Now, he claims, reading is more challenging and people are more likely to skim a passage rather than fully absorb the information due to excessive use of the internet (313-314). Carr uses Friedrich Nietzsche’s relationship with his typewriter as an example to express that with every new technology, he warns, the human mind is vulnerable to a change in structure (319). Carr observes and suggests that the more people use and rely on computers, the more the human mind essentially becomes a form of artificial intelligence

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

297 Words | 2 Pages

In Nicholas Carr's article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?,” the author argues that the Internet has become a new form of acquiring knowledge in people’s lives. Additionally, the author supports his own statement by demonstrating that within just a few clicks, one can instantly gain any information or article online without the need to visit and search a physical library. However, even though the Internet ameliorates the quality and quantity of resources to gain knowledge, he believes that as the source of knowledge is replaced by a convenient web page, society becomes easily distracted. In Clive Thompson's article, “Smarter Than You Think.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

330 Words | 2 Pages

In the essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, Nicholas Carr expresses his concern that the internet could be negatively affecting the way people think. He begins to argue his point by explaining his own issues of not being able to immerse himself in a book like he could before. Carr then reveals his suspicion that it’s the internet’s fault, and supports that by comparing his own experience to others. Reading is a common hobby for most of the people Carr compares experiences with. Like Carr, they found it difficult to read longer pieces of writing, and some blame the internet as well.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

256 Words | 2 Pages

Nicholas Carr is a writer who writes in these kind of field: technology, business, and culture. Carr wrote this essay called, “Is Google Making us Stupid”; Carr fully explains how internet changes people’s thinking, a way of reading, and knowledge with rhetoric strategies. For logos, Carr thoroughly supports his arguments with great supporting points from credit sources. He explains how the internet affects us in reading. For pathos, he points out that human’s brain would work differently since we are using the internet widely comparing to the generation, whom lives without the internet.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

1632 Words | 7 Pages

He attempts to show us in his essay how our minds have changed due to the use of the Internet. Summary Nicholas Carr examines in an essay how digital technology affects our intelligence. Nicholas was educated at Dartmouth and Harvard and is a member of Encyclopedia Britannica’s editorial board of advisors. He has written a book name “The Big Switch: Rewiring the World from

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

780 Words | 4 Pages

Despite, the changing, deploring effects alternating and hinder our cognitive reading habits, Carr suggest technology has proven our society reads more today than in past history (Carr 317). Of course in past history, television was a medium, however, their cognitive ability to read on deep levels appeared not to be altered. In addition, the internet is the largest, continuously streaming pool of knowledge ever built in the world which adequately supplies you with the ability to seek, research and surf more information than one brain can process. Inadvertently, causes reverse comprehensive engagement thus, leaving concentration of long pieces of writing the thing of the past (Carr 315). In agreement with Carr, Maryanne Wolf, a developmental psychologist with Tufts University, narrative of Proust and the Squid: The Story and Science of the Reading Brain also, suggests we are “mere decoders of information and our ability to interpret text … form mental connections from deeply reading is disengaged” (Carr 317).

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

866 Words | 4 Pages

Search engines such as Google make life much easier by accessing hundreds and even thousands of different sources of information. In the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” by Nicholas Carr he shows that the internet is negatively affecting people's ability to observe and concentrate. According to Carr, with so much information available to people on the internet, it makes them less patient and focused. While books require people to read thoroughly and search for information, on the internet people can just skim through quickly, go from article to article, and just read titles to figure out what information is needed. Carr writes, “When we read online, we tend to become ‘mere decoders of information.’

Read More

Analysis Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

521 Words | 3 Pages

Every day the world is being introduced to new technology to make life easier for people. In the article, “Is google making us stupid”, author Nicholas Carr tells us about how he believes that the internet is making us stupid by changing the way our brain processes information. Carr begins to tell us how the web is causing these issues such as how he can no longer be occupied in a book for a long period of time. He then starts to talk about how his whole life is surrounded by the internet and that is to blame for the problem he has with being able to stay focused while reading; but he also talks about how at the same time the internet benefited him so much because he is a writer. When reading this article, you can see that Carr uses a lot of

Read More

Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

1340 Words | 6 Pages

The rise of the technological age has brought to pass the downfall of mindful and comprehensive reading. At least this is what Nicholas Carr believes, as stated in his article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid”. He argues that because of the golden age of computers, in depth reading no longer occurs to the extent that it once did. According to Carr, people now simply skim and skip over articles instead of actually reading them in depth. Carr constructs his credibility by having a prestigious background, and citing academic sources.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

856 Words | 4 Pages

Shawntae Aikens Technology has a found a way into our lives where we use it everyday, and some have come to the point where they depend on it. People have become concerned that the Internet is becoming a distraction and has taken over our lives. The Internet, and social media has become very addicting our smartphones have given us the chance to have the internet and social media at our hands at all times. Nicholas Carr, a writer for the Atlantic Online, wrote the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Within his article he discusses his opinion on how the internet is something that is not helping us at all.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

1201 Words | 5 Pages

In Nicholas Carr’s Is Google Making Us Stupid? he expresses his position in what many people do not consider when reading online. Carr proves to the readers that our minds start shifting on how we read, from readers who want to take in every word of the information given to a reader who skims through and grasps bits and pieces. He presents his reasoning with actual college research from different sources and compiles them into a well proven point- the internet is changing us in a way we never thought of noticing. Within the title itself, he blames it first on the widely-known search engine, Google, to use a common tool most if not all readers go to in order to find their answers in a split second.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

648 Words | 3 Pages

In the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr argues that the internet is changing the way we think and work for the worst. Throughout the article, the author discusses how the use of the computer negatively affects our thought process. Carr touches on how his personal experiences of reading, surfing the web, scanning headlines and reading posts has affected his mind. The article explains how reading and spending time on the internet can affect reading ability.

Read More

Nicholas Carr's Essay 'Is Google Making USupid?'

492 Words | 2 Pages

The Influence of Technology In the essay, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr argues that utilization of the internet has an adverse effect on our way of thinking and functioning in everyday life. Whether it be reading a newspaper, or scrolling through Facebook, internet media has forever stamped its name in our existence. Carr explains to us that the internet is a tool used every single day in today’s society, but also makes most of us complacent with the ease of having the world at our fingertips.

Read More

Analysis Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

696 Words | 3 Pages

Nowadays, the internet is the biggest marketing and media tool that people can use today. It can have various effects on people’s daily life ranging from bad to beneficial. In the essay “Is Google making us stupid” by Nicholas Carr writes about how internet usage in the 21st century is changing people’s reading habit and a cognitive concentration. Particularly, he emphasizes on Google’s role in this matter and its consequences on making people machine like. Carr also stated that the online reading largely contributes to people’s way of reading a book.

Read More

More about Response To Nicholas Carr's Is Google Making USupid?

Related Topics

Open Document