The Tell Tale Heart And The Black Cat Comparative Essay

1083 Words5 Pages
"The Tell-Tale Heart" and "The Black Cat" are two short stories composed by Edgar Allan Poe. Both stories share components of murder and craziness; both have creepy and unnerving evening time scenes. At first look, however, the heroes of both stories appear to have next to no in like manner. Their conjugal status, living conditions, and individual obligations are altogether different. On the off chance that the peruser looks all the more carefully, in any case, the two men show up progressively indistinguishable: both share their criminal history in flashback, in this manner unveiling their thought processes and admitting to their violations. All the more essentially, as both characters relate their stories, they eagerly safeguard their rational…show more content…
The storyteller of "The Tell-Tale Heart" is unmarried; not so in "The Black Cat." The storyteller in "The Tell-Tale Heart" covers an old man with whom he lives and disguises the body underneath the floorboards of his room chamber. The storyteller in "The Black Cat" kills his better half with a hatchet and dividers up the body in the basement of the condo in which they live. The storyteller in "The Tell-Tale Heart" painstakingly arranged the murder of the old man; in "The Black Cat," the murder is spontaneous, a wrongdoing of enthusiasm. These are minor contrasts, in any case. In truth, the storytellers of both stories are strikingly comparable. As prove in the outlines above, both storytellers are blameworthy of murder and experience a powerful inclination to admit to their violations. While each clarifies the conditions of his revolting activities, he likewise endeavors to protect his rational soundness. Each gives a sound clarification of his mental obsessions and depicts his criminal action as reasonable inside the rationale of his admissions. These two storytellers utilize the type of the admission to clarify away the substance of their activities, yet Poe utilizes this cozy association amongst frame and substance to undermine their unwavering quality as
Open Document