Summary Of Death Of Horatio Alger By Paul Krugman
Many economists argue about the exact nature of the relationship of social mobility in the context of the modern economy. One such economist, Paul Krugman, negatively comments in his essay “The Death of Horatio Alger” on the decreasing social mobility among low-wage citizens in the United States. He claims that the American dream of advancement opportunities will diminish as the wealthy aim to prevent others from rising above them in the business world. Moreover, he labels America’s unequal society as a rigid “caste system” and opposes those who ignore the system’s lack of fairness to the lower class (134). Although Krugman strongly criticizes the inflexibility of economic mobility, his informal tone, biased perspective, and unjustifiable approach make his argument not only ineffective but also offensive. Initially, Krugman purposely uses an unprofessional tone to describe Business Week, a source referenced frequently throughout the essay. For example, he refers to Business Week as a “leftist rag” and as “commies” who repeatedly classify America as a minimal class advancement society (133). Despite Krugman agreeing with Business Week in most economic matters, he clearly aims to gain the reader’s attention by shock value through the use of a condescending tone, which not only is offensive to his …show more content…
For instance, he gives one distinct example of a conservative, Glenn Hubbard, who claims citizens with low-wages can easily gain upward mobility. After emphasizing the flaw in Hubbard’s argument, Krugman implies Hubbard’s article is typical of that of a conservative (134). By categorizing conservatives as a whole group, Krugman disrespects their individual opinions, which could differ regarding social mobility. Thus, Krugman’s broad generalization of conservatives presents his argument as biased, and consequently,
Summary Of Dude Where's My Policy Krugman
535 Words | 3 PagesIn his article, “Dude, Where’s My Policy?”, economist and columnist, Paul Krugman argues that the initial uproar and fear that many intellectual liberals felt immediately after Trump’s election should be abandoned on the basis of Trump’s lackluster domestic policy development. Krugman instead champions the idea that Trump will be an ineffective President. By minimizing the effect of Trump’s presidency on the long term political climate Krugman comforts an audience of his peers who fear the world that Trump’s presidency will create. Krugman begins his article with a comedic tone to express his frustration with Trump and establish camaraderie with his audience:“What Trump has done or tried to do over the past two years-wait it’s really only been two weeks?-is incredibly bad”(1). This statement also serves to introduce Krugman’s purpose.
Summary Of The Fractured Republic By Yuval Levin
717 Words | 3 PagesIn the book, “The Fractured Republic” the author, Yuval Levin tells of how he is a strong conservative, but he looks at both sides of our country's dysfunctional political polar division in this perceptive look at the country’s acute crisis of social fragmentation. The former White House staffer under President George W Bush sees both progressives and conservatives as wallowing in unhealthy nostalgia. The Fractured Republic argues eloquently that striving for a better future means resisting romanticising the past. Republicans, in Levin’s view, tend to hark back to 1981. In the first full year of his presidency, the conservative Ronald Reagan set about implementing free market reforms in earnest.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Confronting Inequality By Paul Krugman
290 Words | 2 PagesPaul Krugman author of the article “Confronting Inequality” stresses the inequality of our social classes in the United States, he uses statistics to demonstrate the staggering consequences of this inequality within our social classes. Krugman emphasizes the fact that a majority of our wealth is owned by about one percent of the population, which is leaving the middle and lower class at an extreme disadvantage. One example Krugman uses is education; children that have wealthy families, have a higher percentage of finishing college than those of lower income families, proving the statement that Krugman was accentuating, “Class-inherited class- usually trumps talent.” The parents within this middle to lower class have been exceed their financial
Of Nickel And Dimed: On Getting By In America By Barbara Ehrenreich
622 Words | 3 PagesEhrenreich learns and also hopes to teach her audience, which is anyone who has not experienced a low wage job or does not believe that low paying jobs are very difficult, that all the successors should credit the hardest workers at the bottom of the ladder. She calls “the 'working poor' [...] the major philanthropists of our society [because] they neglect their own children so that the children of others will be cared for; they live in substandard housing so that other homes will be shiny and perfect; they endure privation so that inflation will be low and stock prices high” (120). Ehrenreich simply aims for the privileged audience to understand why they are living such comfortable lives and where all of it comes from. Also, the author implies that the upper class is perfectly kept in balance by the lower class, and that it is owed to the single mothers, poor parents, and uneducated hard workers for others’
Jon D. Wiseman And The Great Depression
878 Words | 4 PagesThe Great Depression of 1929 is the one people know well, at least in the United States, but what cannot be agreed on is how it happened. Many historians turn to the Stock Market Crash that happened prior to explain it, which smoothly transitioned into the Great Depression, making it a viable option. Not all historians stopped there however, and dug further, fully analyzing and discovering less obvious factors that could have catalyzed the Great Depression. Such factors besides the Stock Market Crash that may have prompted the Great Depression were difficulties in wage adjustment, the overall failure of banks and monetary policies, and the Smoot-Hawley tariff controversy.
Michael Schaller's Friday Night Lights
139 Words | 1 PagesIn The Truth About the 1980’s Economy, Michael Schaller explains that “ put simply, the rich got richer and everyone else tread water.” In other words, Schaller suggests that the 1980’s age of Reaganomics wasn’t as renowned as some modern conservatives may suggest, and that under Reagan’s presidency majority of America did not financially benefit. Although Reagan was skilled in having corporate America succeed, the average American citizen did not gain the same prosperity. In Friday Night Lights, the small town of Odessa is a truly American town based in Texas that was widely traditional in values, and conservative in politics. Through Schaller’s perspective, the town is quite paradoxical because although they support and vote for conservative
Summary Of 35 Soul-Crushing Facts About Economic Inequality
775 Words | 4 PagesEconomic inequality is the uneven distribution of wealth and differences in economic security found in each individual in a specific country or region. Today, the topic is being discussed profusely by the American presidential candidates and by many writers around the world because of the beliefs of whether there should or should not be wealth redistribution policies put into action. Larry Schwartz, the author of “35 Soul-Crushing Facts about American Income Inequality”, makes a valid claim that economic inequality is the foundation of the problems that the entire American population face such as poverty and a hindrance of economic growth. To begin with, Schwartz has an exceptional argument that the high rate of economic inequality, like is
Paul Krugman Confronting Inequality Summary
1158 Words | 5 PagesThey all make decent points towards income inequality, and inequality as a whole. Becker and Murphy believe that if a higher education will give you a higher income, although education after high school is expensive, the returns are worth it. Even though statistics prove that Becker and Murphy's theory is correct, Krugman believes that the living standards are important and shouldne be jepordized, because of an education. Paul Krugman in “Confronting Inequality” attempts to explain how bad inequality is and the things that can bring inequality to high or low levels. He gives reasons of why he and Americans should care about the increase in inequality.
The New Gilded Age: A Comparative Analysis
1148 Words | 5 PagesWhen our species first came into existence, we began as a single, collective group of organisms, teamed up together with only one goal: to survive by finding food and water, and reproducing to facilitate our existence here on Earth. Though every organisms goal on this planet is to survive and reproduce, the means and skills they have of achieving these goals are different. Some may only be good at finding important items, thus making them gatherers. Others may only be good at fighting, thereby making them hunters, and then there are other organisms capable of both skills and roles. As a result, each organism groups into their respective roles, therefore creating a unity among the organisms with similar (if not identical) traits, while simultaneously
Class In America Gregory Mantsios Summary
977 Words | 4 PagesThere is lower, middle, and upper class, but there are also subcategories that fill the gaps in between, like the impoverished and the top one percenters. “Class in America”, written by Gregory Mantsios, addresses the myths and realities about socioeconomic class in America and how they affect American lives. His article highlights the unequal divide that has persisted over the course of history and will continue to manifest in the future. To introduce the existence of this issue, Mantsios states that this country’s citizens “don’t like to talk about class...or class privileges, or class oppression, or the class nature of society” (Mantsios 378). This is the case in America today because people are neglecting to acknowledge the existence of these elusive
William Domhoff's Who Rules America
1109 Words | 5 PagesWilliam Domhoff’s investigation into America’s ruling class is an eye-opening and poignant reading experience, even for individuals enlightened on the intricacies of the US social class system. His book, Who Rules America, explains the fundamental failures in America’s governing bodies to provide adequate resources for class mobility and shared power amongst classes. He identifies history, corporate and social hierarchies, money-driven politics, a two-party system, and a policy-making process orchestrated by American elites as several causes leading to an ultimate effect of class-domination theory pervading American society. In articulating his thesis and supporting assertions, Domhoff appeals rhetorically toward an audience with prior knowledge
Rhetorical Analysis Of Progressive Taxes By David Brooks
1052 Words | 5 PagesThis is where Brooks is wrong. He puts a negative tone on the progression of America because of the economic downturn. If you analyze the business and economic cycles, from when our country was founded to present, you can see that we have experienced awful depressions, but also really great periods of triumph. I believe Brooks is also biased on blaming the Democrats for the failure of economic prosperity. In order to bring a call to order, you must not blame one party, but offer a proposal to resolve the issue.
Rick Perlstein Before The Storm Analysis
268 Words | 2 PagesThis is a transformative book. It's the best book on American politics that I've read since Rick Perlstein's Before the Storm. Not all of it is original (the authors seek to synthesize others' work as well as present their own, but provide due credit where credit is due). Not all of its arguments are fully supported (the authors provide a strong circumstantial case to support their argument, but don't have smoking gun evidence on many of the relevant causal relations). But it should transform the ways in which we think about and debate the political economy of the US.
What Is Social Darwinism?
716 Words | 3 PagesConsider Congress. Members’ median net worth, in 2011, was $966,000. “They’re quite wealthy individuals,” Kraus says. “And because they’re wealthy they’re likely to engage in not only these essentialistic processes, but these people actually have power to enact laws to maintain inequality.” A top adviser to the U.K.’s education secretary just produced a report arguing that “discussions on issues such as social mobility entirely ignore genetics.”
Social Class And Social Inequality
1443 Words | 6 PagesTherefore, in a stratified society, the individual’s opportunities are always determined by his or her social class. In this essay, I will be arguing that even though mobility exists in the social class system, the opportunity to change status is relatively open for everyone but the distribution of opportunities among the members of a social class is not relatively equal to all. I will demonstrate this point by showing how participation of an individual in a specific social class will decide the opportunities in terms of attaining education and achieving a well-paid job. Education has a significant role in promoting social mobility; it enables people to acquire knowledge and certain skills in order to promote their social status. Nowadays, people believe that societies are based on meritocratic
More about Summary Of Death Of Horatio Alger By Paul Krugman
Summary Of Dude Where's My Policy Krugman
535 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of The Fractured Republic By Yuval Levin
717 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Confronting Inequality By Paul Krugman
290 Words | 2 PagesOf Nickel And Dimed: On Getting By In America By Barbara Ehrenreich
622 Words | 3 PagesJon D. Wiseman And The Great Depression
878 Words | 4 PagesMichael Schaller's Friday Night Lights
139 Words | 1 PagesSummary Of 35 Soul-Crushing Facts About Economic Inequality
775 Words | 4 PagesPaul Krugman Confronting Inequality Summary
1158 Words | 5 PagesThe New Gilded Age: A Comparative Analysis
1148 Words | 5 PagesClass In America Gregory Mantsios Summary
977 Words | 4 PagesWilliam Domhoff's Who Rules America
1109 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Progressive Taxes By David Brooks
1052 Words | 5 PagesRick Perlstein Before The Storm Analysis
268 Words | 2 PagesWhat Is Social Darwinism?
716 Words | 3 PagesSocial Class And Social Inequality
1443 Words | 6 Pages