In his article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?,” Nicholas Carr expresses his view on technology. He touches on ideas about how technology has evolved and how it changes how humans view the world. He makes the points that technology is widely accessible and frequently used. Carr shows how technology changed the style of earlier writers’ pieces. Carr believes that how the earlier writers wrote contributed to the style of their works. His most important point, in my opinion, is his claim that technology alters the way our brains function. Technology is a fantastic tool but if used incorrectly, could lead to health problems, reliance, or alterations to brain functions. The first point Carr presents is that technology can provide health …show more content…
He provides his own personal experience in his article when he says, “Now my concentration often starts to drift after two or three pages. I get fidgety, lose the thread, begin looking for something else to do” (Carr 572). Carr claims that his wrongful usage of technology has rendered him incapable of focusing on one certain task. This deficit is very common due to the ongoing use of technology in society. I agree with this claim because as a constant user of technology, I sometimes have a hard time keeping still. However, focus is not the only health aspect that is affected by technology. In an article published in the New York Times titled, "Do You Have Any Bad Health Habits?; Student Opinion," it mentions headphones causing a loss of hearing. In the article, it says, “...half of 30 sets of …show more content…
For an expert opinion on this topic, Carr quotes Maryanne Wolf, a developmental psychologist at Tufts University. While analyzing her points, Carr explains, “Wolf worries that the style of reading promoted by the Net, a style that puts ‘efficiency’ and ‘immediacy’ above all else, may be weakening our capacity for the kind of deep reading…” (Carr 575). Carr points out that technology changes people’s minds to which they seek out finite answers to questions rather than reading between the lines and developing their own opinions. Carr also compares the human brain to a computer by the fact that both systems strive to be quick with as few errors as possible. Many people in the world function this way because “efficiency” is highly valued by the majority of the population. I find this point very believable because when I seek out an answer on the web, I don’t usually read into it because technology has changed my brain to think that the first answer is the most reliable. This way of thinking has become more apparent as the use of technology increases so the process of deep reading and deep thinking must be reacquired by many. When technology is misused and relied upon too heavily, it has the power to change how the human brain functions to imitate that of a computer
Every day new technology is advancing to makes its way into the world where it is used more efficiently. In the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?,”, Nicholas Carr claims that human are no longer able to focus on longer texts due to the rise of digital texts. Nicholas Carr includes strong evidences to support his statement; and through the usage of ethos and pathos, he is able to convince his readers that “the Net is becoming a universal medium” (Carr). Examples of Ethos are evident throughout the article making Carr’s argument deductively valid. Nicholas Carr is known for his reputation as someone who has written influential pieces and earning many awards for his accomplishments.
In “Is Google Making Us Stupid”, the author, Nicholas Carr, is arguing against the effect of our increased access to information. He is unsettled by the common idea that we’d all “be better off” if our brains were supplemented, or even replaced, by an artificial intelligence. Carr describes how am immediate access to a rich store of information from the Net has shaped his process of thought by reducing his capacity for concentration and contemplation. He is worried that placing efficiency and immediacy above all else is weakening our capacity to make rich mental connections that form when we read deeply without distraction. Carr uses an anecdote of the printing press to demonstrate how equipment takes part in the forming of our thoughts.
In Nicholas Carr’s writing, “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” mentions multiple examples of why the internet and the simplicity of looking up and getting exactly what we were looking for are causing a drop in the way we think and the intelligence of our minds. Carr explains that he was once a huge reader and could comprehend ten to fifteen-page articles easily, but the directness of the internet had dulled his brain that he could not read a few paragraphs before he gave up and his mind started drifting off into the emptiness of his brain. Carr mentions that the Net is being the universal medium causing information that is read and learned go in one ear and out the other. Carr defends his positions by adding multiple examples showing that the Net
The concentration that he once had while reading had nearly diminished. He was once able to read lengthy articles with no problem, but now the deep reading had become a serious struggle. Carr felt that he knew what was causing this problem. He states in the article that over the past several years, he has been doing much reading online. With reading
Nicholas Carr claims his opinion on how computer and internet changed people’s way of thinking and going to turn people into machines in the essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid”. He states current situation that we are in a Internet era and his mind is not going like before when we focused on deep reading. First of all, the new universal medium Net reshape our process of thought, from concentrating on one reading to skimming readings. Although we read more, we did not completely understand it and made a rich mental connection with it. He talks about how Google’s value contradict people’s healthy growth.
Being that Carr titled his work, "Is Google Making Us Stupid?", why does he think that it is only Googles fault? Technology is growing every single day and we are the ones creating it and changing the way we do things. Carr claims that his "concentration often starts to drift after two or three pages... deep reading that used to come naturally has become a struggle"(735). I agree that this happens to a lot of people, it even happened to me reading his article.
Michael Pacheco 11.22.2014 English 1101 Dianne Layden A Dire Consequence In his essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” Nicholas Carr professes his opinion on the impression that we, as a population, are becoming shallower and strewn in our thinking. As Carr states his concerns, “I'm not thinking the way I used to think. I can feel it most strongly when I'm reading…
Nicholas Carr is a writer that has expanded his writing to books, periodical and even has a blog at roughttype.com; his writing focus is about technology and culture. He addressed the issue of how technology can be a great and awful thing to use at the same time in his essay, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Carr made an ongoing debate where technology is making people stupid because they are spending a lot of time researching and this is causing people considerate less while using the reading skill but at the same time technology saves times, can expand more on the topic, find any information etc. With regards “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”
In the essay “Is Google Making Us Stupid? What the Internet is Doing to our Brains,” Nicholas Carr argues that the internet has altered, possibly not in a good way, how we use our cognitive mind. Today, most everyone is getting on to a computer and using the Net. It could be to do research, read an article, or just to scan the news in all its forms. What we don’t realize is that how we now read and research has weakened our minds cognitively.
1. Nicholas Carr’s argument in his article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” challenges Thompson’s argument which was that the internet is making people smarter by helping people improve their writing skills when they read other people’s work online. However, Carr believes with so much information available, the internet had changed our “mental habits” in a negative way. The internet has people using “ a form of skimming activity” which decreases how much people read to “no more than one or two pages of an article or book” (Carr 2) before they change to different site. Carr complicates Boyd’s view on how algorithms are filtering what people see on their screen and those who are not digitally literate would be clueless of this.
Is Google Making Us Stupid? In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” Nicholas Carr observes that people are beginning to have trouble reading for long periods of time. Carr explains that he is beginning to wonder what the internet is doing to our brains and he states that even he does not think the way that he used to. The author explains that he is also having trouble reading because he has begun to lose his concentration while reading long books or articles.
Technology is everywhere in today’s world and it is rapidly evolving. As technology evolves, so does the society using it. Technology is negatively affecting the way we read, write, and live. In the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” Nicholas Carr focuses on how the introduction of newer ease of access technologies has changed the way we read, write, and even think. “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” by Nicholas Carr discusses the remapping of people’s brains upon the release of new technologies.
Reading is harder, focusing is difficult, books are a thing of the past. In an intriguing article “Is Google Making Us Stupid” Nicolas Carr explains how the internet is affecting people’s cognitive ability to function. Since the creation of the internet, information has become more readily available, but at the cost of the human brains cognitive ability. Carr states that artificial technologies have an effect on the brains cognitive ability because its causing us to change our habits for the artificial technology. He writes about Friedrich Nietzsche a writer “[who’s] vision was failing, [who couldn’t keep] his eyes focused on a page [without it] becom[ing] exhausting and painful” (Carr 3).
Rhetorical Analysis of Nicholas Carr’s “Is Google Making Us Stupid? We are at a time where technology is widespread; it has become a part of our everyday life leading to advantages and disadvantages. Technology nowadays has become the most important topic to discuss and everyone has developed their own unique opinion. In Nicholas Carr’s article published in 2008, “Is Google Making Us Stupid” he argues that as technology progresses people’s mentality changes.
In Nicholas Carr’s article called “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, Carr talks about the many issues he believes are stemming from using online search engines and Google in general. This article was written back in 2016 and published into The Norton Field Guide to Writing with Readings. Carr discusses his view on the whole idea of online readings and most of the information available to the world being viewed online through a search engine like Google. He also goes into thorough detail explaining how he believes that technology is becoming more advanced and smarter than its creators. In Carr’s article, he will explain all that he believes is wrong with technology in today’s society and how dumbed down it has made us.