The Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
To Gerrymander something is to manipulate the boundaries of a district to favor one party or class. The information used to choose how to manipulate districts is by census data which means district lines are usually redrawn every 10 years. Is gerrymandering a fair practice? Political parties that are currently in power would say that it is fair because gerrymandering the district lines that are drawn are reviewed by a judge and then made into districts that way. So that means it follows the proper system to do so. But, if you were in the same district and opposed the current political party, you might say that gerrymandering is unfair because they give the current party in power an advantage. It gives them an advantage because they are the ones that author the redrawing of districts. …show more content…
The party that is in office might say no, gerrymandering is not cheating because it isn’t always a safe bet that the party majority in that district will win. On the opposing side, they say that it would seem to take advantage and abuse the use of voter’s census information to manipulate districts. Are voters being manipulated into voting for one party over another to change districts? “The conditions under which election ballots are cast and counted—from registration to voting equipment, ballot design, polling locations, voter ID requirements, absentee ballots and early voting—are set in a very decentralized fashion and prey to political manipulation to advantage one party over the other.”
Parties that are winning elections by gerrymandering think It isn’t feasible to draw district lines perfectly, they are sometimes misshaped because of varying populations. The other side would argue that the districts aren’t representing the people if they are carefully constructed by the majority leader. They aren’t going to really represent the people they are going to represent the
Gil Vs Whitford Case Summary
490 Words | 2 PagesRedirecting, according to Loyola Law School states that the redirecting plan “is the way in which we adjust the districts that determine who represent us.” Ultimately, referring to the thought of the state being either Republican or Democrat due to those in assembly and senate; in this case Republican. The argument here is to determine whether or not ‘extreme partisan gerrymandering’ is constitutional or unconstitutional. The ruling is still uncertain but the chances are that it is unconstitutional because it is making the vote of democrats less significant.
Summary Of Lincoln And Douglas Debates
853 Words | 4 PagesLargely due to the government system of apportionment present which was largely based on partisanship. Proving to favor Douglas, “combined with the failure to win over the Whig districts, the apportionment doomed Lincoln’s chances of
Gerrymandering Issue Essay
756 Words | 4 PagesGiven the legal nature of the gerrymandering issue, there is an extensive legal background on the issue since the ninetieth century. This literature review gives the more relevant legal background regarding Pennsylvania’s current situation, as well as background information on the novel ways that policy-makers and researchers measure political gerrymandering. Keeping the legal background and measurement procedures in context, there are also legislative reforms and commission procedures that states have taken in order to ameliorate the problems that arise from gerrymandering. A. Constitutionality & Legal Background The Pennsylvania State Constitution contains relevant clauses that must be applied to any redistricting plan.
Comparison Between Race And Gerrymandering
106 Words | 1 PagesHello Erik, I really like how you explain gerrymandering. I also agree with you that racial gerrymandering is worse than partisan gerrymandering. Gerrymandering altogether is bad and create a lot of problem and it mess with the result of the election. I really like it when you said “Racial gerrymandering is aimed towards a specific racial group and leads to the unfair and unequal treatment based upon race while partisan gerrymandering is not based upon race.” That pretty much sum it up
Assignment 2: Congressional District Analysis
351 Words | 2 PagesPrevious representatives include Ben Chandler, who was a Democrat and served from February 17th, 2004 to January 3rd, 2013, and Ernie Fletcher, who was a Republican and served from January 3rd 1999 to December 8th, 2013 after resigning when elected Governor of Kentucky. In very recent years, from 1979 to present, Representatives have had a “tug-of-war” game with elected Representatives’ party affiliations switching from Republican to Democrat between every election. However, from 1979 to 1866, Kentucky’s 6th district was represented solely by Democrats with only one Republican representative being elected within 113 years. During this time, in 1931, Kentucky 6th congressional district was changed to an at-large district and continues to use the at-large voting system to this
The Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
712 Words | 3 PagesWhat is “Gerrymandering”? which until now was something that never crossed my mind until I attended my Political Science class. Interestingly, Gerrymandering is a tradition vested for a political advantage by a political party to manipulate the district boundaries. Gerrymandering can also be used to utilize from a race, ethnicity, class groups or religion point of prospect, simply to benefit a political party. “The word “gerrymander” was coined at a Boston dinner party hosted by a prominent Federalist in March 1812, according to an 1892 article by historian John Ward Dean.
Reapportionment And Redistricting Work
394 Words | 2 PagesWhat is a constituency, and why do constituencies differ for representatives and senators? A constituency is a group of individual voters in a specific area who elect a representative to a legislative body. Constituencies differ for representatives and senators: • Representatives – represent a district or area of a state and sometimes a whole state • Senators – represent the whole state Explain briefly how reapportionment and redistricting work? Why is gerrymandering frowned upon?
The Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
1008 Words | 5 PagesState Legislature gerrymanders in 37 states and the elected state lawmakers are responsible for drawing their own legislative districts and the boundaries for the congressional districts in their states. The governors in most of those states have the authority to veto the plans(Murse, ThoughtCo). In Independent Commissions, panels are used in six states to redraw legislative districts. They keep politics and the potential for gerrymandering out of the process because they are apolitical(Murse, ThoughtCo). State lawmakers and public officials are prohibited from serving on the commissions.
Congress Representatives Influence
360 Words | 2 PagesRepresentatives are elected from the United States citizenry to represent the people in Congress. Congressmen have to balance three things, national affairs, constituency matters, and party interests. Congress is influenced by money for campaigning, however normally this money comes from organizations and PAC's, for example the AARP. However the money does not come in the form of a bribe, with the AARP, instead they send out a questionnaire to candidates, and if they feel the candidate represents their interests, they will give them money for their campaign. PAC's are formed to combat individual donors and big businesses; they are essentially a pool of money, which represents certain interests.
The Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
442 Words | 2 PagesGerrymandering restrictions is likely to be a key topic of debate for the Supreme Court as partisan lines have tested the constitutionality of the act. While this process of redrawing boundary lines has been around for a long time, it is not the same that it once was. The act of gerrymandering and redrawing boundaries has become more of a drastic partisan act in the modern election world than ever before because of technology. The 1986 Supreme Court ruling in Davis v. Bandemer declared partisan gerrymandering for electoral advantage justiciable under the United States Constitution. The asymmetry standard in testing for gerrymandering states that the act needs to exhibit intentions that partisan gerrymandering would be recognized for its given distribution of popular votes, if parties switch who holds the popular vote and if the number of seats in a district would change unequally based on Supreme Court cases Vieth v. Jubelirer and LULAC v. Perry.
Why Is It Better To Vote Better Than Direct Vote
571 Words | 3 Pages" It can easily be done just like this, and it is a win for most majority of the population. Hopefully, direct votes won't take away this
The Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
1370 Words | 6 PagesIn newly captured districts created by cracking, serious officials that want to challenge this require extra fundraising just to meet balance with their gerrymandered incumbents, money that is less likely to come from citizen constituents since they constitute such a marked minority in the district (Schumate). Even in party strongholds that are created by packing, the effect of campaign finance is felt through candidate to candidate giving. Candidates with excess cash are permitted to donate it to any candidate they choose, creating a strong incentive for incumbents, even in “packed” districts, to fundraise like there’s no tomorrow, in order to build up political chits(Schumate). If gerrymandering produces a diminution of citizen faith in the democratic process, it would plausibly discourage constituents from donating to their congressional campaign or any other, further diminishing the incentive for Congresspersons to act in accordance with voter preferences (Schumate). Finally, the fact that our redistricting system affords redistricting power to state legislatures in the first place adds a new dimension to the campaign finance wars.
Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
982 Words | 4 PagesBut recently gerrymandering has become more controversial because people feel that it has taken away their rights as a voter and it swings the votes to one side by a big percentage. Current cases are before the courts to decide if gerrymandering is legal. Some states have been discussing whether it should still be allowed during elections. “Many efforts are underway to remedy this political
Pros And Cons Of The Articles Of Confederation
1304 Words | 6 PagesRepresentation refers to gerrymandering (“Functions of the Legislature,” 2014). Gerrymandering is the manipulation of the boundaries of (an electoral constituency) in order to favor one party or class. Despite the “one person, one vote” guidelines, gerrymandering still takes place after the census (“Functions of the Legislature,” 2014). On the state and federal level, the policymaking aspect means that legislatures try to remove conflicts. The President and the legislatures often collide in their policymaking roles.
The Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
614 Words | 3 PagesThe Federal judge John Hannah stated “The dominant political party treated all member of the opposing party as if they were “enemies of the state” instead of the respected state leaders, many with a great wealth of government knowledge and ability that has and would inure to be benefit of Texas” (133). The issue is that voting in Texas is so racially divided; discriminating against Democrats is equivalent to discriminating against minorities. Democrats fought to keep their place in legislature by concentrating on individual officeholders during the redistricting process. Republicans, instead of undertaking the chore of encouraging minority voters, would rather overpower their ability to choose their own representation.
More about The Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
Gil Vs Whitford Case Summary
490 Words | 2 PagesSummary Of Lincoln And Douglas Debates
853 Words | 4 PagesGerrymandering Issue Essay
756 Words | 4 PagesComparison Between Race And Gerrymandering
106 Words | 1 PagesAssignment 2: Congressional District Analysis
351 Words | 2 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
712 Words | 3 PagesReapportionment And Redistricting Work
394 Words | 2 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
1008 Words | 5 PagesCongress Representatives Influence
360 Words | 2 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
442 Words | 2 PagesWhy Is It Better To Vote Better Than Direct Vote
571 Words | 3 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
1370 Words | 6 PagesPros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
982 Words | 4 PagesPros And Cons Of The Articles Of Confederation
1304 Words | 6 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Gerrymandering
614 Words | 3 Pages