ipl-logo

Comparing Descartes Views On The Difference Between Dreams And Reality

632 Words3 Pages

Another marker might be that waking life has continuity which is not present in a dream. When one is dreaming one can defy the natural rules and anything can become true. However, in reality this does not occur. Therefore, we can know a difference between the dream world and reality. At first glance, this opposing argument might appear to be valid and sound. Nevertheless, is not sound. This is because the first premise that of the continuity present in waking life and not in dream is not truth. I know from my own experience and many others may know too that not all dreams are scenes put together with nothing that matches it to the previous ones. Seeing that some dreams have continuity, then the argument fails and cannot prove a difference between the dream world and waking life.
Further criticism on Descartes argument of dreaming and its reflection on the external world might not be about the premises of this argument and proving that dreaming and waking life can be differentiated. An opposition might be born …show more content…

For example, how we know that tomorrow the sun will rise. We base our knowledge from past experiences, nonetheless, there is no test to show that the sun will come up other than waiting till the next morning to see if it occurs as expected. Yet, this opposition does not provide certainty that the event will happen according to the past experiences, there could be an extraneous variable which has never been part of our experiences that occurs and prevents the expected outcome of occurring. So, this counter argument would have to be explained in more detail because the skeptics can also say that in the end someone might have thought he was awake, and experienced things with certainty, when in reality they might have just dreamt it. Which in return would make premise two follow premise one

Show More
Related

  • Descartes 'Argument From Past Failure'

    1301 Words  | 6 Pages

    This is evident through arguments such as “The Argument from Past Failures”, “The Argument from Madness” and “The Dreaming Argument”. In Descartes’ famous “Dreaming Argument” Descartes argues that “there are never any sure signs by means of which being awake can be distinguished from being asleep.”, giving an example where he thought he was sitting next to a fireplace, unaware he was actually in bed dreaming (13). This argument challenges the idea of the senses again as it presents the idea that we can never know if what we are currently experiencing is real as we may be in a dream. Proving that there is no way to differentiate between reality and a dream, resulting in the idea that our whole life may have just been a dream, Descartes provided a counter argument to elaborate on the “Dreaming Argument” known as the “The Painting Analogy”. This analogy explains how like a painting and painter, dreams derive their material based on experiences we have while awake (13).

    Read More

  • Dreaming Argument: Skepticism Of The External World

    513 Words  | 3 Pages

    Even though we know there is no water, how can we trust our own perception if our eyes have deceived us in the past. They use these types of arguments to display their argument that we can not

    Read More

  • Justice In The Odyssey

    411 Words  | 2 Pages

    How can one believe they are anything but when they have no logical reasoning behind them? These stories have been thoroughly thought out and are very descriptive, such as the Odyssey and the Iliad. Even today, in the twenty-first century, there is no way to prove one’s dreams are anything other than that- a dream. You cannot display the images and sounds onto a big screen.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Documentary 'Nova What Are Dreams'

    393 Words  | 2 Pages

    PBS’s, Nova What Are Dreams, is a forty-five-minute documentary about how different stages of sleep effect our dreams. Throughout the documentary, we also witness how dreaming is essential for making sense of the world around us. For nearly a century, many thought when one is asleep the brain is asleep as well. Yet not until technology advanced, did scientists begin examining sleeping patients to notice every ninety minutes their patients brain showed activity as if they were awake but were still unconscious.

    Read More

  • How Did Descartes Make One Doubt Their Beliefs About Reality?

    837 Words  | 4 Pages

    However, Descartes could not without a doubt solely discard his perceptions based on his senses, just because his senses did or did not fail him on other occasions or under less than ideal circumstances. This argument does not allow Descartes to doubt all that could be doubted. The dream argument is a skeptical argument. It means is that it is possible, at any given moment, one could be sleeping and having only dreams, but the dreams are so realistic that they are undistinguishable from sleep or waking experiences.

    Read More

  • What Are The Similarities Between The Great Gatsby And The American Dream

    1109 Words  | 5 Pages

    How dreams can all have different construals. Others verbalize the Dream still lives because there are people these days who are living the Dream. That is erroneous, though, because who already have the Dream are currently raised those living it in the

    Read More

  • Did Romeo And Juliet Do In Bed Asleep While They Do Dream Things True

    472 Words  | 2 Pages

    This ultimately keeps the reader on their toes regarding dreams, because they know that some part of it, may in fact be true, and another may be false. It is just a matter of which part and

    Read More

  • Dreams In Chester Himes's The Meanest Cop In The World

    1111 Words  | 5 Pages

    How Dreams Affect Reality In the works of Chester Himes there is an underlying theme of dreaming. Throughout his various stories Himes uses dreams to function as a retreat for his characters. In his short story “The Meanest Cop in the World”, Himes is able to concoct an entire story that is descriptive and lifelike, which the readers just assume is real. However, when the curtain is pulled back at the end and Himes tells the readers that the entire thing is just a dream the readers are shocked.

    Read More

  • Descartes First Meditation Analysis

    997 Words  | 4 Pages

    The idea that if one can comprehend something in a dream, it therefore must exist in real life. The fact of this is that we know no positive transition between our dream state and the state of reality, and since dreams are so similar to reality, one can never tell when they are truly dreaming. Descartes demonstrates this idea with his own experiences, “How often, asleep at night, am I convinced of just such familiar events-that I am here in my dressing-gown, sitting by the fire – when in fact I am lying undressed in bed! Yet at the moment my eyes are certainly awake” (Descartes 145). By using simple experiences like these Descartes is able to emphasize that when a person is dreaming, they do not usually know they are dreaming, and the sensations they experience are as real as if they were awake.

    Read More

  • Lucid Dreaming Research Paper

    1849 Words  | 8 Pages

    Although in most dreams we are not aware of the fact that we are dreaming, a remarkable exception occurs in "lucid dreams" in which the dreamer “attains a clear cognition that he or she is dreaming while dreaming” (LaBerge 2000). This state can be viewed as being awake while

    Read More

  • Informative Speech Outline On Dreams

    1252 Words  | 6 Pages

    Credibility: In preparation of this speech, I did read numerous articles on the subject and I also did confer with friends and family. IV. Preview of Points: In my presentation today, I am going to highlight some interesting findings that I have found when I was researching the very interesting topic of dreams. (Transition: Let us take a peek into the mystical world of dreaming.)

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud's Dream Analysis

    901 Words  | 4 Pages

    Dreams are based on the dreamer’s attitude towards life. He believed dreams were deceptive. He believed dreams provided a secure environment to overcome one’s limitations without disturbing the dreamers waking life. Also a dream could depict some important aspects about the dreamer, such as how factors like power; acceptance, etc affect the relation between the dreamer and his reality/world.

    Read More

  • What Is Rene Descartes Dream Argument

    685 Words  | 3 Pages

    The first thing he does is doubted what the senses give us. However, Descartes pushes his doubting one step further by doubting whether we are actually awake. In the dream argument Descartes is saying that he often experiences the sensations of dreaming while he is awake. From reflecting on this he comes to the conclusion that if he can falsely perceive himself to be awake while he is dreaming then he can falsely believe he is dreaming while he is awake. So, he can never actually know when he is awake or dreaming (Windt).

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay About Dreams

    806 Words  | 4 Pages

    The “why we dream argument see dreams as only nonsense that the brain creates from fragments of images and memory” (Obringer). On this side of the argument dreams are viewed as tricks of the mind that just seem to happen. Other people believe differently. Some people believe dreams have meaning even if we don’t recognize it at first. “Many think dreams are full of symbolic messages that may not be clear to us on the surface” (Obringer).

    Read More

  • Definition Essay About Dreams

    1086 Words  | 5 Pages

    Today I first discussed when dream occurs. Second, I discussed theories of dream. Finally, I discussed the dream interpreter. Understanding when dream occurs, theories of dream and what they mean help us grasp what dreams actually

    Read More

More about Comparing Descartes Views On The Difference Between Dreams And Reality

Open Document