ipl-logo

Comparing Dostoevsky's Crime And Punishment

2300 Words10 Pages

Subjectivism and Salvation

Due to the insurmountable nature of God’s law, governments should adhere to and enforce the morality of their subjects in order to save them from its consequences. Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment clearly demonstrates the detrimental results of an individual, Raskolnikov, taking morality into his own hands. His sense of morality was largely defined by the consequences of his actions, for which destruction and evil ensued. This idea of morality is flawed due to the source being defined by the self, and hence the objective purpose that God has set for each individual is ignored. This leads to the consequential punishment of human beings, determined by God, that takes place physically and spiritually. The government …show more content…

He argued that the first precept of this natural law was that “…good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided… [and] there is in man an inclination to good, according to the nature of his reason, which nature is proper to him”. Additionally, he stated that “...the natural law can be blotted out from the human heart, either by evil persuasions, just as in speculative matters errors occur in respect of necessary conclusions; or by vicious customs and corrupt habits”. C.S. Lewis’ concurs with this idea of reason and heart through his illustration in The Abolition of Man: “The head rules the belly through the chest”. In this illustration, each of the anatomical features represents aspects of the nature of man. The head is the reasoning factor, the belly is the animalistic desires or instincts, and the chest (or heart) is the passion. Relating this to Aquinas, corrupt ideas can infest the head, which hinders the reasoning of the individual, and thus results in acts of evil. Raskolnikov hardly gave in to any guttural desires, and his mind pieced together half-ideologies to create his own perverted ideals. This makes him an overwhelmingly appropriate case study of how an individual’s deviation from God’s moral law results in chaos and …show more content…

C.S. Lewis wrote in his paper, The Humanitarian Theory of Punishment that modern punishment has moved away from giving criminals what they deserve, and rather it is used as a deterrent against certain acts or a cure for a disease. The remedial view of punishment interprets crime as a disease and that the criminal must be detained until they are cured. This is a problem, as a government could ordain that certain ideologies are a pathological deformity or disability and ‘rightfully’ detain those who carry it. The deterrent view of punishment is instituted to cause terror. This is a problem, as an innocent man could be treated as guilty and have the same result, given that the mass believe that he is guilty. Although, this act could only be seen as wicked if people take on the idea that punishment is deserved. It is better to “…be punished, however severely, because we have deserved it, because we ‘ought to have known better’ [because it] is to be treated as a human person made in God’s image”. Did Raskolnikov receive the punishment he deserved? The nature of his sentencing was more in line with the remedial punishment as it was ruled that “…the crime could only have been committed through temporary mental derangement… This fell in with the most recent fashionable theory of temporary insanity, so often applied in our days in

Show More
Related

Raskolnikov Pride Quotes

426 Words | 2 Pages

Raskolnikov is a very intelligent, prideful man, So much so that the very thought of leaving his house in tattered clothes made him anxious. Raskolnikov also refuses to go to his tutoring job because of this. despite these facts, Raskolnikov has little care for the people and the world around him believing himself to be above them because of his intelligence.

Read More

Dostoevsky's The Grand Inquisitor

216 Words | 1 Pages

1. The two sides of the debates in Dostoevsky’s “The Grand Inquisitor” are who can handle freedom the most. Christ gave human beings the freedom to choose weather or not to follow him, but almost no one is strong enough to be faithful and those who are not will be cursed forever. The Grand Inquisitor says that Christ should have given people no choice, and instead taken power and given people no choice, and instead taken power and given people redemption instead of freedom. So that the same people who were to scared to succeed Christ to begin with would still be stuck, but at least they could have joy and security on earth, rather than the impossible burden of moral freedom.

Read More

Tolstoy Death Of Ivan Ilych Analysis

695 Words | 3 Pages

Sansom writes, “He faces his mortality and realizes the failure of constructing a life on preferences and abstract relationships” (421). Shallow relationships and a focus on outward appearance lead to a neglect of Ivan’s actual purpose. In this time of Ivan grappling with death, Tolstoy proposes the idea that before we die “the choice is not how to act in ways so that we can control our death and question the meaning of life, but whether there is a reality to which we can find real value as individuals that is not nullified by the existential syllogism” (Sansom 424). The control that he sought as a way to defend himself against chaos does not lead him to peace; instead, it disappoints him and helps move Ivan to a place of deeper understanding. At the very end during an interaction with his son, Ivan finally “empties himself of meaningless false images of human purpose, [and] he then sees how to respond honestly with integrity to his destiny” (Sansom 427).

Read More

Crime And Punishment By Ron Rash Analysis

845 Words | 4 Pages

Ron Rash, born September 25, 1953, is an internationally acclaimed short story writer, novelist, and poet. Rash was born in a small mill town in South Carolina, and was raised in the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains in western North Carolina. Rash spent most of his youth on a farm near Boone, where he grew up listening to Appalachian folktales and reading voraciously; his time there later gave him inspiration for the setting of many of his stories. Rash’s family greatly influenced him as a reader and a writer. His father, a professor, and mother, a schoolteacher, encouraged him to read as much as possible, and his illiterate paternal grandfather inspired him to always be imaginative.

Read More

Corruption In The Great Gatsby

1237 Words | 5 Pages

One notable quote on moral corruption in the novel is when Raskolnikov says "I did not kill a human being, but a principle!" It highlights his moral justification for the murder and how it led to his downfall. Another quote is "By nothing but a fantastic theory that you've made up, you've taken away the life of a poor, decrepit creature, the drunken brute," it shows how the moral justification led to a terrible crime. Another quote that highlights the moral corruption is "The more I think of it, the more plainly I see that I have been a fool, that I have been duped, that I have been utterly in the dark about myself. "

Read More

Black Plague Research Paper

1014 Words | 5 Pages

know of the Black Plague and the rats that are associated with it. What they don’t know is that the plague originated in a different part of the world than they may expect. It actually began in parts of Asia where uncleanliness was as common as drinking water. A bacteria known as Y. Pestis took hold of rats. " Yersinia pestis (Y.Pestis) is a gram-negative, rod-shaped coccobacillus, a facultative anaerobic bacterium.

Read More

Evaluating Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics

1495 Words | 6 Pages

He describes the objection as, “all men desire the apparent good, but have no control over the appearance, but the end appears to each man in a form answering to his character” (1114b).   This view argues that all people pursue that which seems good, but some people cannot see the true good, which is out of their control.   The immediate implication of this objection, if it is indeed true, suggests that “no one is responsible for his own evildoing” (1114b).

Read More

Motives For Raskolnikov's Crimes

1478 Words | 6 Pages

Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s Crime and Punishment is a deep dive into the psyche of a young man named Raskolnikov, who is...well, who really is Raskolnikov? Through the method of unreliable narration Dostoyevsky employs, it is difficult to pinpoint just who Raskolnikov is, why he does what he does, and what the reader misses when he lapses into what is considered to be bits of fever and madness. In this paper I will attempt to unravel the ‘why’ of the murders Raskolnikov commits. I endeavour to prove that it is clear Raskolnikov kills Lizaveta and Alyona because of his need and desire for suffering in repentance for his perceived sins against his family and himself. This is not to say, however, that he may have thought of this as his motive;

Read More

Dostoevsky: The Problem Of Evil

463 Words | 2 Pages

“I want to forgive. I want to embrace. I don’t want more suffering.” said Ivan to his brother Alyosha after reflecting on the unjust evil innocents face because of humanity’s sinful actions. Ivan’s words shed light to the idea of idealism versus reality. Realizing that cruelty is present in the lives of the most innocent, lead me to assert that evil is a real problem as it intervenes between the harmonic and idealistic view that the world consists of genuine, good people.

Read More

Invitation To Beheading Essay

1455 Words | 6 Pages

In Nabokov’s “Invitation to Beheading” and Shalamov’s “An Individual Assignment,” totalitarian society represents a metaphorical prison that deprives the characters of their freedom and only through the renewal of their individual freedoms can the character’s break from their oppressors. In “Invitation to Beheading” Cincinnatus is imprisoned and sentenced to death for not fitting in with society and the opaqueness of his soul. Cincinnatus was always different throughout his life, but he managed to hide his strangeness. Eventually the masking of his unnatural behaviors subsides with his wife’s disloyalty and he is arrested and sentenced to death.

Read More

Comparing Dostoevsky's Crime And Punishment

441 Words | 2 Pages

The fact that all of these significant events take place in and around taverns suggests that taverns are a place where the truth can come to light because there are no inhibitors. Perhaps Dostoevsky simply holds the opinion that the loud noises and free, yet contained, atmosphere, combined with the liberating effects of alcohol can make one feel as though they are able to say and do whatever they please. They can have casual conversations about private information, or on a much more extreme end, beat a horse, and the consequences of those choices will never affect their real lives. As such, the most important conversations that perhaps would not otherwise occur, take place inside of a tavern. Rodya does, after all, refer to the tavern as “another world” (11), giving the impression that the tavern is, in his mind, separate from reality- an alternate dimension in which different rules apply.

Read More

Space In Crime And Punishment

951 Words | 4 Pages

Raskolnikov’s ability or inability to navigate through St. Petersburg directly correlates with his present mental stability. When he feels confident and clear-minded, he walks from location to location exactly as he intends and the rambling streets do not impede him. The opposite is true when he feels out of control. In another instance, Raskolnikov makes the semi-conscious decision to avoid going to the police station: “having reached his first turn, he stopped, thought, went down the side street, and made a detour through two more streets — perhaps without any purpose, or perhaps to delay for at least another minute and gain time.” Here, the turns and alleys of St.

Read More

Why Is Petrovich Not Likeable

293 Words | 2 Pages

Peter Petrovich, the fiancé of Raskolnikov’s sister, first meets Raskolnikov when Raskolnikov is ill in his apartment. Raskolnikov’s preconceived dislike towards Petrovich conveys the idea that Petrovich is not likeable. A reader could understand why Raskolnikov and Petrovich would not work well together; Petrovich carries himself well and is confident in himself while Raskolnikov has a lot of self-doubt and avoids socialization. Whether or not Petrovich is an enjoyable person, his thoughts about self-importance and self-love are easily extendable to outside the world of Crime and Punishment.

Read More

Crime And Punishment Quotes With Page Numbers

1588 Words | 7 Pages

Raskolnikov confronts reality and can never again legitimize his activities in light of political perspectives. The writer of Crime and Punishment, Fyodor Dostoyevsky composed this book uncovering some of his own perspectives on legislative issues and consolidating them all through the story. Like Raskolnikov, Dostoyevsky was captured by the administration and punished for his offense. He was rebuffed for his radical communist positions, just to later reject these thoughts. Through the story, the creator fuses a solid message of exactly how intense the legislature is and the solid impact of governmental issues.

Read More

St. Petersburg In Crime And Punishment

1052 Words | 5 Pages

Raskolnikov’s accumulating debt owed to his landlord prevents him from moving outside of Saint Petersburg and causes massive emotional damage. Each time he leaves his apartment, he fears seeing his landlady, The stress and anxiety arising from the debt he owes to his landlord causes him to become unruly and he had, “fallen into a state of nervous depression akin to hypochondria,” feeding into his detachment from society. Not only does Raskolnikov’s living situation seem grim, but his room itself furthers his emotional detachment from society. Raskolnikov’s room allows him to dehumanize himself.

Read More

More about Comparing Dostoevsky's Crime And Punishment

Related Topics

Open Document