ipl-logo

Essay On Moral Luck

665 Words3 Pages

Actions delivers consequences
Luck is a phenomenon present in our lives in very different ways, so much so that it is not easy to imagine a world without it. But, even so, it seems that when it comes to making moral judgments about the actions or beliefs of other people we want to find ways to neutralize it. Our main guide is the purpose of being fair to those we judge and, therefore, we want to set aside what does not strictly depend on them, aspiring to eliminate any possible distortion of this goal. However, the nature of luck is such that it makes it difficult to neutralize it in any sphere of human life. In order to grasp the philosophy of luck in our existence we must analyze the philosophy of Thomas Nagle’s article, “Moral Luck”. Nagle dispute the Kantianism ideology in which states that we must submit our actions to certain universal moral laws, such as "do not kill". At the same time is important to analyze the concept that they are other factors to take in consideration. This philosophy can be applied in a specific case such as the judicial system or as an opportunity to analyze our behaviors. At the end it can be concluded that the major issue with the analysis of Moral Luck is the ethical aspect.
Moral luck is what you have …show more content…

Holding on to this principle, they try to show that the supposed phenomenon of moral luck, after due reflection, turns out to be an illusion. A fundamental weapon to reach this conclusion is the epistemic argument, according to which the supposed cases of moral luck do not show that luck can really affect the moral judgment that a person deserves, his moral status, but only affect our knowledge of what she deserves, because not in vain we are not all-knowing beings and our knowledge is linked to the evidence to which we have

Show More
Related

  • Compare And Contrast The Lottery And The Rocking Horse Winner

    782 Words  | 4 Pages

    (Lawrence, 1933, p. 310). When you are lucky, this does not mean that people are fortunate economically. The chance of luck is to let things flow without imposing control over them and the situation. In The Rocking-Horse Winner, Paul 's mother gives the impression that to believe in luck is to have money in abundance, and when you do not have money, it is because you do not have

    Read More

  • Alice Sebold

    673 Words  | 3 Pages

    (Sebold 4) “Lucky” is written in a way that transmits the tumult an attack can cause to the community as much as it affects the victim. One other important lesson that Alice teaches us with this memoir is that everybody is responsible of their actions and decisions. Every choice people make will lead to a set of consequences; Alice gives the message by stating that no once will be held responsible for other people’s actions “No one can pull anyone back from anywhere. You save yourself or you remain unsaved.” (Sebold

    Read More

  • Summary Of Julie Beck This Article Won T Change Your Mind Analysis

    618 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Julie Beck’s informative article, “This Article Won 't Change Your Mind,” she explores and challenges the phenomenon that belief and choices are often influenced by a person’s moral characteristics and their environment. Beck first uses a short anecdote explaining how people often chooses to only believe the things that they want to believe. If a subject matter is too uncomfortable to discuss, people often become dismissive and choose not to acknowledge the unbearable truth. Beck then continues to pursue her argument by applying reliable studies in order to strengthen the ethicality of her beliefs. She uses sources such as T Leon Festinger’s study and Stanley Schachter’s book, When Prophecy Fails, in order to imbed undeniable facts into

    Read More

  • Karma In The Most Dangerous Game

    546 Words  | 3 Pages

    Yannick Noah, a professional tennis player and co-founder of a charity organization, once said, “I believe in Karma. If the good is sown, the good is collected. When positive things are made, that returns well.” (brainyquote.com). Karma is shown in countless ways every day to most people on a daily basis.

    Read More

  • Morality In Socrates 'The Ring Of Gyges'

    661 Words  | 3 Pages

    If the opportunity arose, where no consequences were given for someone’s actions, do you think that individual will still commit an unfavorable action such as killing for his own personal need? In “The Ring of Gyges” the disposition of justice is called into question. As humans continue to live we must contemplate the true driving force for our morality. A discussion between Socrates and Glaucon is one main focal point into explaining the differences in how humans truly established their morality. Glaucon believes humans are restrained by consequences and human’s happiness comes from being an unjust person rather than Socrates’ belief of being just truly leads to happiness.

    Read More

  • Karma In Beauty And The Beast

    219 Words  | 1 Pages

    Beauty and the Beast shows many great examples of karma playing out. In the beginning, the Beast turned the frail old woman away because of her looks, however she turned out to be a beautiful enchantress. If the Beast would have prioritized getting to know who she was personally instead of looking at her appearances, he would not have wound up in the curse that became because of this behavior. It is greater to seek knowledge about a person’s knowings within. What they are educated and skilled in truly exposes who they are as an individual.

    Read More

  • Nage Nagel On Moral Luck

    1154 Words  | 5 Pages

    Moral luck is a term used by Nagel to describe the external factors beyond our control, which determine our actions upon certain moral decisions we make. Nagel's opinion is that people make moral decisions that may have good or bad intentions, but because of moral luck the outcome may be contrary to what he/she intended. Moral luck can be constitutive, the kind of person that someone is. Some people are born with certain characteristics, which enable them to be more virtuous then others. Others are born with a nasty streak of envy or jealousy, which makes it that much harder for them to make the best moral decisions.

    Read More

  • Now The Serpent Elie Wiesel Analysis

    555 Words  | 3 Pages

    Human nature is naturally good but influence compels us to commit deeds we never would have considered. For example, Eve picking the forbidden fruit . Now as I’m sure many know this story. It could be argued that Eve knowingly opened Pandora's box and exiled humans to be less than perfect. But in truth Eve shows humanity was innocent from the very beginning.

    Read More

  • Essay On Moral Panic

    949 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Media and The Manufacture of Deviance 800 words, Assessment Weighting 30% Briefly define the concept of ‘moral panic’ Cohen argues the concept of moral panic is a person or group that becomes defined as a threat to society to a person’s social value and their interests. Moral panic is fear that comes from a group or issue that causes panic within society, but it’s believed this fear and reaction is exaggerated and this is felt and reacted to by the public forms of media such as newspapers, articles and live news etc; knife crime and islamophobia. “Implicit in the use of two words moral panic is the suggestion that the threat is to something held sacred by or fundamental to the society” (Thompson, Kenneth 1998) Cohens definition of moral panic is an over exaggerated reaction by groups

    Read More

  • Thomas Nagel Moral Luck Summary

    420 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Thomas Nagel’s response to Bernard William’s, Moral Luck, Nagel questions whether our “moral goodness” or “moral badness” is simply a matter of sheer luck. Judging if someone is in fact “good” or “bad” or in other words, the way we are, the circumstances we face and, the way things turn out are indeed caused by luck. In this paper, I will confirm Nagel’s assertions in that the way things turn out, how we respond to given situations, and how one was raised are all a matter of luck in deciding ones moral goodness or badness. Being morally good or bad is just about how we are, and our temperaments. One’s background or upbringing can affect the outcome of one’s judgment, and that judgment is essentially what determines morality.

    Read More

  • Impossibility Of Moral Responsibility By Galen Strawson

    878 Words  | 4 Pages

    Lucy Bichakhchyan Introduction to Philosophy Second Short Written Assignment GALEN STRAWSON THE IMPOSSIBILITY OF MORAL RESPONSIBILITY Galen Strawson is a British philosopher, who is famous for his philosophical works on free will, panpsychism, causality, determinism etc. This paper is about his article “The Impossibility of Moral Responsibility”. The title of the article already gives away the stand that Strawson has considering Moral Responsibility..

    Read More

  • Moral Code Essay Examples

    800 Words  | 4 Pages

    “The most finite resource for all humans is time.” My father says this to me all the time, and I’m beginning to understand why he says it. So my personal philosophy, at this point in time, is that since time on Earth is limited, one must make that short time meaningful and make the most of that time. This can be done by living life by a moral code, chasing one’s goals, as well as being aware of one’s own deficiencies. Living by a moral code requires that one defines that code.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Philippa Foot On Abortion And The Doctrine Of Double Effect

    196 Words  | 1 Pages

    In every day life, we face many situations that require a moral decision. We have to decide what is right and what is wrong? Not always is this an easy task thus, it seems important to analyze how we make our moral decisions. I will start with an analysis of how we make decisions in general

    Read More

  • Arguments Against Retributivism

    1926 Words  | 8 Pages

    We will first look into the idea of how we treat people as they deserve. According to Rachels, “Moral judgments about what to do frequently depend on considerations about what will happen as a result of our actions.” (Rachels, 1997). People deserve to be treated the same way they treat others. Rachels has also mentioned that people can control their fates by the way they treat others.

    Read More

  • Kant's Formula Of Universal Law

    1969 Words  | 8 Pages

    Kant and the Lying Promise In “Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals”, Kant explores the subject of duty and the binding force of morality. Kant explores the morality of among many cases, this paper being focused particularly on the case of the lying promise. To determine the morality of such action, Kant provides the Formula of Universal Law, which relies on a maxim passing four steps in order to be considered moral.

    Read More

More about Essay On Moral Luck

Open Document