ipl-logo

Ignorance And Prejudice In The Scottsboro Case

565 Words3 Pages

Scottsboro argumentative response Ignorance and prejudice seems to plague the Southerners and this idea of ignorance and prejudice is exemplified in this case. In 1931, Haywood Patterson and eight other African American teenagers were falsely charged for rape and all the boys also received the death sentence after accommodating a train with the victims Ruby Bates and Victoria Price. Haywood Patterson is innocent due to three reasons, no evidence of rape from the doctor’s notes, Victoria Price and Ruby Bates were prostitutes, and Ruby Bates claimed that Victoria and her were lying the whole time. Admittedly, Haywood Patterson is guilty. However he is not guilty of rape, since he is only guilty of assault on the white boys. Two important discoveries that support this is that the doctor’s notes reveal no evidence of rape. Dr. R. R. Bridges, the Scottsboro doctor who examined the girls, tested that the rape victims only had dead semen and there were no traces of semen that were alive, which should of been an indicator of rape. Dr. R. R. Bridges also found that the girl’s heart rates seemed to not be elevated after the supposed rape. This is another indicator of rape which the girls …show more content…

The “Fact Sheet” states that the victims were prostitutes and they wanted money, which suggests that accusing the boys of rape during the Great Depression would bring in a lot of money for winning the case due to pity and weak knowledge to the case. According to the “Fact Sheet” These women were also sleeping with their boyfriends, Lester Carter and Jack Tiller, in a hobo jungle prior to the supposed rape. This exemplifies that the women were desperate for money during the Great Depression and they wanted to get money from winning the case. The intercourse between the girls’ boyfriends is not valid evidence for rape, however it is evidence of intercourse which is stated in Dr. R. R. Bridges

Show More
Related

  • Goldschmidt's Modern Day Muckraking?

    1065 Words  | 5 Pages

    Modern Day Muckraking “In 1979, Goldschmidt, who as mayor had won national renown for the development of the downtown bus mall and the city 's then-revolutionary light rail, was tapped by President Jimmy Carter to be Secretary of Transportation” (Jaquiss). Neil Goldschmidt was a very successful politician, but he was hiding a very dark secret that the people of Oregon deserved to know. Should the type of person, who raped a 14 year old girl for three years, be considered someone that the people of Oregon look up to? This is just one of the questions Nigel Jaquiss addressed in his article about the affair between Neil Goldschmidt and a 14 year old girl that occurred from 1975-1978 (Jaquiss).

    Read More

  • Salem 1692 Dbq Essay

    332 Words  | 2 Pages

    Not many people believe in witchcraft. Once you live in Salem, where people are accusing others of being witches, you’ll start to believe. So, why did people go crazy in Salem 1692? It was caused by poor young girls who acted possessed because they were jealous of the rich. Young girls that did not want to be told what to do, afflicted girls acting as if they were possessed, and poor people that were jealous of the rich cause the death of 24 people in Salem 1692.

    Read More

  • What Was The Fault In The Case Of West Memphis Three

    1584 Words  | 7 Pages

    One of the main pieces of evidence that prosecutors used against the West Memphis Three relied on the confession given by Jessie Misskelley. This so-called “confession” consisted of a story that placed both Echols and Baldwin at the scene of the crime, included information directly fed to Misskelley, and above all, contained major discrepancies within the story Misskelley provided versus the events that actually took place. During the first recorded confession, Misskelley incorrectly identified the time of the murder more than once, claiming that the “events took place about 9:00 a.m. on May 5” and later “chang[ing] that time to 12:00 noon,” which was still incorrect(). He also mentioned that “[the three boys] had skipped school that day,” when, in fact, they had attended class and were accounted for, along with misidentifying the item used to tie up the boys, claiming the item was rope when it was actually shoelaces that were used(). Misskelley also implied that the victims were raped, though no evidence supported his indication.

    Read More

  • Eugene Williams Case

    507 Words  | 3 Pages

    Thirteen year old, Eugene Williams, was traveling from Chattanooga to Memphis looking for work when he was accused of rape (PBS, “Williams”). Eight other blacks were accused of rape along with Eugene by Ruby Bates and Victoria Price on March 25, 1931. However, there was an overall discrimination and hatred of blacks during the time period, Bates and Price were unable to identify their attackers and answer questions, and there was a lack of physical evidence. Eugene Williams was not guilty of rape. Undoubtedly, Eugene Williams was guilty, although he was guilty of hoboing, not rape.

    Read More

  • The Trial Of Brian Banks

    466 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the summer of 2002, Brian Banks, a 16-year-old outstanding high school football linebacker from Long Beach Polytechnic High in Southern California had a promising future ahead of him. He had a verbal agreement to play for USC once he finished high school, but he had a lot of recruitment letters coming to him. Unfortunately, his future was cut short. Wanetta Gibson, a 15-year-old who also attended Long Beach Polytechnic, had accused Brian Banks of rape. That summer morning, Wanette and Brian were making out in the stairwell of the school, that night, Brian was being arrested for rape.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Scottsboro Trials And The Salem Witch Trials

    884 Words  | 4 Pages

    Racism and Vengeance Humans judge others on how they look, where they come from, or just plainly who they are; it is human nature. Everyone judges someone at some point in their lives, but how far are people willing to take their judgement. In the 1930’s, at a time when racism was at its peak, nine black boys got in a freight train fight with a couple white vagrants. The boys’ consequences were fatal.

    Read More

  • To Kill A Mockingbird Historical Influences

    1019 Words  | 5 Pages

    The executions were later suspended and the trial was moved up to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court ordered a new trial because the representatives were not considered to be in their right mind (Johnson). Ruby Bates, one of the women involved, later stated that they were never raped. On April 9, 1933 the first of the defendants was again found guilty and his punishment was execution, which was later delayed. After that, yet another trial took place.

    Read More

  • The Salem Witch Trials In 1692

    741 Words  | 3 Pages

    Doc. B. The young girls who were accusing the older women were jealous of the older women, because they wanted rich husbands. Doc. A. There was 14 women killed, they all were married, some girls wanted their husbands so they cried witch.

    Read More

  • How Did The Trial Of Brian Banks Vs California

    985 Words  | 4 Pages

    The state of California vs Brian Banks In early 2002 a 16 year old football prodigy, Brian Banks was excused from class with a hall pass to use the restroom, where he met up with 15 year old female, Wannetta Gibson. The two went into the elevator with intent to go to the infamous “ make out “ spot, when Wannetta was allegedly raped by her fellow classmate. When Wannetta went back to class she wrote a note to her stating that, “ she use to be a virgin but she ain’t one anymore because Brian had raped her.” After school that evening she informed her sister that she had been assaulted, and then her sister urged her to report it to the school administration.

    Read More

  • James Richardson's Innocence

    927 Words  | 4 Pages

    Innocence is is a lack of guilt, with respect to any kind of crime, or wrongdoing. In a legal context, innocence refers to the lack of legal guilt of an individual, with respect to a crime. Being convicted of a crime and found not guilty later on can frustrate the convict and the convict’s family as the time spent behind bars, is time they will never get back. James Richardson was convicted and charged for murder and rape in Cross Lanes, West Virginia on May 18, 1989. First, Richardson noticed the neighbor’s house burning.

    Read More

  • Racial Stereotypes In To Kill A Mockingbird

    1225 Words  | 5 Pages

    In this Lynching, six black men were accused of raping a white woman. A physician who examined Irene, the ‘rape’ victim, determined that there were no signs of assault. However, six men were confined to to the jail and three were lynched (Minnesota Historical Society n. pag.). Just as with Robinson, the men in The Duluth Lynchings were assumed guilty, despite a lack of evidence. The citizens of Duluth were too quick to act in this case rather than hear the accused side of the story.

    Read More

  • How Did Tom Robinson Get A Fair Trial

    1634 Words  | 7 Pages

    This trial was extremely unfair because the only people that were actually called to the stand were the two girls. When the two girls were on the stand they were incoherent most of the time and their statements did not match. Yet, the all-white jury gave each of the boys a death sentence, except for the twelve-year-old, Roy Wright. Roy was given a mistrial because of his age. Six of the boys denied raping or ever seeing the two girls.

    Read More

  • Injustice: The Scottsboro Case

    1657 Words  | 7 Pages

    Injustice The Scottsboro Case shed light on the racial practices expressed in law that made a great impact on the legal system today. The actual victims of the Case did not receive a fair trial due to the color of their skin. The ones who played the victims planned the crime, and their stories made no sense. But like many of the trials during the time it wasn’t based on the actual evidence that was found,or even the defendants ' stories.

    Read More

  • Domestic Violence In The Oj Simpson Case

    448 Words  | 2 Pages

    On June 13, 1994 Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman were found murdered outside of Browns condo. The police suspected OJ Simpson to have committed the crime seeing Mr. Simpson had attacked Ms. Brown previously. It was clear that Mr. Simpson committed the crime jet a jury of 10 women and 2 men found him not guilty (9 of the jurors were black, 2 white and 1 Hispanic). This trial dealt with class, race and gender all at once. Make no mistake if OJ Simpson was not a wealthy man and could not afforded the defense her received the outcome of this trial would have been much different.

    Read More

  • The Story Of Victoria Price And Ruby Bates

    1447 Words  | 6 Pages

     Doctors examined both young women and had determined that no rape had occurred, but the jury did not care. The nine men were given two volunteer lawyers for the trial.   The youngest boy, who was twelve, was sentenced to life in prison.   By 1937, all the attorneys agreed that  the four youngest men would be freed then the rest would be on parole for a

    Read More

More about Ignorance And Prejudice In The Scottsboro Case

Open Document