Was Andrew Carnegie a Hero?
Andrew Carnegie was a successful businessman. He was born in Scotland. In 1848, His family moved to the United States. When he was 24, he became a supervisor of the railroad company. He began his business in 1872. 30 years later, he became a world’s richest ex-businessman. He died after the end of World War I. Andrew Carnegie was not a hero in three areas of his life: Living, Business, and Charity. The first area in which Andrew Carnegie was not a hero was about Living. According to document 1, compare his houses that he was raised in cottage but died in castle. This evidence shows that he was very rich from nothing. According to his book “Wealth”(document 2) which is related to document 1, this document showed about his thought that he believed in the survival of the
…show more content…
According to document 3, He told Frank Doubleday to quit his business instead of encourage him. From the Production Costs and Selling Prices for One Ton of Steel Rails(document 4), showed that Carnegie’s Edgar Thomson Steel Works always get a profit because of location. According to Map of Selected Carnegie Properties(document 5), showed about his industries location that make him got a lot of profit. According to document 6, he got a lot of profit, have many industries but his workers were unhappy. Because, the workers were overwork and got a very low wages. According to the Average Daily Hours and Average Daily Wages in US Manufacturing 1892(document 7) showed that the average working hours per day of Carnegie workers were around 10 hours and the wages per day was about 1.5$ which is very cheap. According to document 8, showed about his thought about rich people. He told that the man who was rich will die with honor. He concern about rich people but did not care about the labourers. This Business thought and management could be the important evidences to proof that he was not a
He was also one the wealthiest men of his time and helped transform the steel industry. Andrew Carnegie could be considered to be a hero in many ways. He helped create jobs, transformed the steel industry and also helped other industries, and was an influential philanthropist. Many of the people at the time were poor and living in poverty. There weren't many jobs; and the one that they did have didn't pay enough to sustain a family.
Andrew Carnegie once said, “No man can become rich without himself enriching others” (Crazy Billionaires Speak: Motivational Quotes by Billionaires on Success, Business and Life 9). Many people associate Andrew Carnegie with his contributions to the economic world during his lifetime and future generations. However, he was also an inspiration to all, because he proved that a person living in tough times could ultimately strive and attain his/her utmost success. Additionally, Carnegie is the embodiment of the American Dream, because he is known as one of the greatest industrialists of his time who grew economically from rags to riches. He strived to achieve world peace and inspired others to follow his footsteps.
Andrew Carnegie was a hero in some people 's eyes , not so much in others . That’s why everyone has their own opinion. In this essay you will read one reason someone might think he’s a hero , and two reasons why he is not a hero for the rest of the people. What that means is that this paper mostly leans on that Andrew Carnegie is not a hero and you will read why . Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man.
When you hear the word “hero,” what names come to mind? What exactly makes a hero? One thing I’m certain of is that Andrew Carnegie was definitely NOT one of them. A hero is someone with integrity, concern for others, and protects. Carnegie, a selfish but self-made, made poor and unethical actions and decisions, not owning the traits of a hero.
He used his fortune to donate to charities and became the greatest philanthropist of all time. Despite his humble beginnings, Andrew Carnegie built the largest steel company and became a well known philanthropist. Andrew Carnegie was an American immigrant. Andrew was born on November 25, 1835 in the small town of Donfermline Scotland. (McGill 1).
The distribution of wealth has always been a conflict of interest between those in an industrial society. Many times, we find the all the poor being grouped as oppressed, and all the rich being grouped as oppressive. But this is not the most accurate way of thinking. We see Andrew Carnegie as part of the rich being grouped as oppressive, or a villain. Given the fact that he saw his success in the height of the American Era of Industrialization, Carnegie got a lot of backlash for the issues surrounding the poor that worked for him.
That made him one of the richest men. But what did he do with all the money he was making? The real question is, was Carnegie a hero? A hero is someone who does outstanding achievements. There were three reasons Andrew Carnegie was a hero he always gave back, he didn't just leave his money with his family, and brought beauty to a castle in Scotland.
Andrew Carnegie had opened his own ways to wind up distinctly a prosperous representative. From a youthful age, Carnegie conveyed the weight of supporting himself and his family, while working massively hard. Carnegie was conceived in Dunfermline, Scotland and lived in a little bungalow for the vast majority of his childhood (Document 1). From 1835 to 1848 Carnegie and his group of four, lived in the storage room of the cabin, which was over his dad's weaver's shop (Document 1). In 1897, Carnegie updated his living home office by obtaining the Skibo Castle in Dornoch Firth, Scotland.
Andrew Carnegie was a steel businessman and the richest man in the United State in half of 19 century. He was born in Dunfermline, Scotland in 1835. He lived in a poor place. So he decided to move to U.S in the late 1800s to have a better life. First, he worked in the railroad industry in seven years.
There have been many debates of whether he had the traits of a hero or that he wasn’t a hero. A hero is defined as a person who is idealized for courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities. People believed that Andrew Carnegie was a hero, but once they began to take a closer look to the characteristics they would come
After Andrew Carnegie sold his company, he decided to spend the rest of his life helping others (Biography.com Editors, 2014). Carnegie had begun his philanthropic work years before by building libraries and making donations, but he decided to expand his efforts in the early twentieth century (Biography.com Editors, 2014). Carnegie made many donations and other contributions to society and those in need. Andrew Carnegie changed his life in order to help those in
Kevin ruiz Mr. Plata US History: Period 3 22 October 2017 The philanthropy of andrew carnegie; did it make him a hero “The a who dies rich des disgraced”these were the wise words of a humble man andrew carnegie. Carnegie was born in 1835 in dunfermline, scotland. At age of twelve carnegie and his family set of to seek a better life in the united states; here he changed the course of history.
A hero is someone who does a meaningful deed, worthy of remembrance and selflessly. Andrew Carnegie was a wealthy man. After he sold his steel company in 1900, he devoted the rest of his life giving money to charity. Did Andrew Carnegie’s generosity make him a hero? Andrew Carnegie was not a hero.
Andrew Carnegie was a hero in numerous ways one of the first reasons why Andrew Carnegie was a hero was because he helped create a better environment for the poor
Andrew Carnegie was one of the most famous and wealthiest American industrialist during the Industrial Age. He was a robber baron who made a fortune in the steel industry and applied vertical integration to his business. Carnegie contradicted his views as a robber baron because he supported, but destroyed many unions. This made many of his views unethical.