In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicolas Carr analyzes the dramatic affects that technologies have been having on our brains. The short summary, the Net is making us all mindless zombies in Carr’s mind, but he is not the only who feels that way. His long dragged out article is abundantly full of meaning examples, personal opinions, and hard facts on the drastic changes the Net has done to our brains. Carr starts his articles with the death of super computer, HAL, from the movie A Space Odyssey.
In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr clearly states his thesis and the idea that not only is google changing the way we as humans think, read, and write, but all of technology is affecting us in our everyday lives. The internet sources such as Google are created to find information fast and easy for users. Google does all the searching and hard work of having to read through huge articles. We are humans have it easy now, we no longer have to do all the reading and digging around of endless articles and papers.
Within Is Google Making Us Stupid? By Nicholas Carr, the rhetorical devices that Carr uses allows for deep meaning to develop in the text. It also evokes emotions within the reader which makes him or her question if the internet is actually making him or her stupid. Carr also uses the different devices to persuade the audiences that the internet is actually more harm than beneficial. By using the devices he is able to make the reader rethink what he or she has thought before and question his or her thoughts.
All of these components add up to greatly increase the pathos present in Carr's essay. He ties this reference to the current state of the human population by claiming that we, too, are losing our minds. This puts the reader in the shoes of the computer, and it is a jarring realization. Furthermore, Carr uses a testimony from Bruce Friedman, a blogger who focuses on the use of computers in medicine. Friedman admits that "[he] can't read 'War and Peace' anymore...
Nicholas Carr makes claims about his own ideas supported by evidence from experts before providing his own rhetorical interpretation for his readers to consider. The question "Is Google Making Us Stupid" is posed by Nicholas Carr to determine whether our use of the internet has an impact on how our brains process written material. In order to connect with his audience, Carr employs ethos as a rhetorical strategy. He argues through the concept of ethos that the internet has produced a society where people are more concerned with getting quick information than setting aside time to read and relize an article.
Nicholas Carr wrote a short essay entitled “Is google making us stupid?”. The essay explains on how Carr believes how the web and search engines are effecting him and people every day. Carr explains that the web is making people lose focus a lot quicker because they are used to convince and can not handle more than a couple pages of an essay. Also, Google is starting to work as an artificial intelligence for the average human brain,and how the owners were hoping for an artificial brain to do all their thinking for them. The world wide web and various search engines are doing more damage than good for the people using it .The
Later, Carr mentions Scott Karp and Bruce Friedman, Friedrich Nietzsche, who underwent the same problem as his, which seems to be an approach using ethos to gain credibility. However, he denies that by writing “Anecdotes don’t prove much.” (Carr 316). Then, switching for ethos to logos, he cites a study from University College London, explaining how internet users have the tendency to skim over articles, and to save web pages, but never return to them, but Carr doesn’t explain how it relates to his loss of focus or how it is making us “stupid”, which takes away the credibility he is trying to
Nicholas Carr’s article titled Is Google Making us Stupid was written to deliver an urgent message to the reader. Carr’s purpose for writing this article was to inform the masses of the potential dangers in how new technologies change the ways our minds work. He is trying to warn us how writing has reduced our capability to remember details in our heads, just like the internet has been able to change the way our brains store, acquire, and handle information. The author makes the argument that Carr makes a reference to the movie 2001 A Space Odyssey. In his reference he tells the reader about the HAL computer who uncannily perfectly expresses human emotion, as it shares its concern that its data banks and artificial brain is being shut down
Is Google Making Us Stupid? The article "Is Google Making Us Stupid"? By Nicholas Carr depicts that the internet has become the most approved sources for modern research and studies as it contains all the information which might be needed. Carr uses ethos, logos and pathos to show his audience how the internet has changed our lives.
Every day the world is being introduced to new technology to make life easier for people. In the article, “Is google making us stupid”, author Nicholas Carr tells us about how he believes that the internet is making us stupid by changing the way our brain processes information. Carr begins to tell us how the web is causing these issues such as how he can no longer be occupied in a book for a long period of time. He then starts to talk about how his whole life is surrounded by the internet and that is to blame for the problem he has with being able to stay focused while reading; but he also talks about how at the same time the internet benefited him so much because he is a writer. When reading this article, you can see that Carr uses a lot of
A Response to Is Google Making Us Stupid? By Carmen Semaan In the article entitled Is Google Making Us Stupid? the author talks about how using the internet affects our ability to think and focus. The author shows this using his studies and own personal experiences as a writer.
The internet influences the human mind and Nicholas Carr delves into the reasons in Is Google Making Us Stupid? In this article Carr examines the internet’s influential possibilities. The internet is changing people psychologically but it is not negatively impacting, it is merely an evolution for society. Carr provides well-thought input, spanning from humanity’s psychological alterations to comparisons of historical inventions. SUMMARY
I’m not thinking the way I used I think. I can feel it most strongly when I’m reading.” (Carr 557). This is an effective use of pathos because it draws the reader to question whether or not their way of thinking is changing as well. Carr is trying to create this connection, so the audience feels exactly what he is feeling and is successful at doing so.
Brainless.com: Rhetorical Strategies in Carr’s “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Do we depend on the Internet to answer all of our questions? Nicholas Carr, an American author, wrote “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” published in 2008 in The Atlantic, and he argues about the effects of the Internet on literacy, cognition, and culture. Carr begins his argument with the ending scene of Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey.
The Influence of Technology In the essay, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr argues that utilization of the internet has an adverse effect on our way of thinking and functioning in everyday life. Whether it be reading a newspaper, or scrolling through Facebook, internet media has forever stamped its name in our existence. Carr explains to us that the internet is a tool used every single day in today’s society, but also makes most of us complacent with the ease of having the world at our fingertips.
