Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION………………………………………………………………...…1 2. OVERVIEW OF MINORITY LANGUAGES IN THE UNITED STATES AND GREAT BRITAIN…………………………………………………………………..…2 3. LANGUAGE POLICIES AND IDEOLOGY……………………………………….…3 4. MINORITY LANGUAGE POLICIES IN THE UNITED STATE…………………...4 5. AUTOCHTHONOUS LANGUAGE POLICIES IN GREAT BRITAIN……………..6 6. CONCLUSION………………………………………………………………………...8 Dean 1 INTRODUCTION The term minority language refers to a language spoken by a minority of the population on a certain territory (less than 50 percent of the population). Some minority languages are also national languages like for example Spanish or Irish. Societies undertake actions in order to promote or discourage the use of particular languages, …show more content…
In Louisiana, however, English and French are legally recognized languages, while in New Mexico, English and Spanish are legally recognized. Traditionally, the predominance of the English language in a country with so many ethnic minorities is a result of extreme patriotism and a systematic assimilation of immigrants and indigenous population. It began in the colonial period with the deculturation of Native Americans, lasted through World War I when German speakers were prosecuted and has been gaining more and more power since the 90s, when the English-Only Movement, also known as Official English Movement was started with the aim of establishing a “common language” and thus a “common culture”. In 1971, Massachusetts became the first American state to pass the law for obligatory bilingual educational program. The idea was that students would be taught English while learning other subjects in their native language. The law was abolished in 2002 with a legislation requiring that all subjects be taught exclusively in English, except under special circumstances. The same happened in Arizona and California. According to research, one out of five students in America is an immigrant or a child of …show more content…
Obvious violations of human rights can be seen in the case of the federal courts of Puerto Rico where English is mandatory, meaning that jury service is restricted to upper-class Puerto Ricans who have the required proficiency in English. (Piller and Takahashi, 2010: 584) “In most contemporary societies, literacy mediates access to health care, consumer rights, further education or employment. However, we live in a world where basic literacy is still denied to nearly a fifth of the world’s adult population. That means that some 771 million people aged 15 or above are excluded from access to education, health services, career opportunities and full citizenship that literacy affords.” (Piller and Takahashi, 2010: 585) But the segregation of minorities on the count of language is not typical only for the government, it is also common in social circles and at work. For example, Piller and Takahashi give an example of Spanish speaking kitchen workers in
Stepping outside, a person in the United States can instantly see how prevalent a role technology has in our lives. From the smart phones that connect people globally trough a few touches on the screen, to the airplanes roaring across the sky, the astounding capabilities and convenience that technology offers is unmatched. In “Why literature matters”, an article from the New York Times Corporation by Dana Gioia, Gioia explores how living in the high-tech 21st century has unfortunately deteriorated the percentage of Americans who read literature. Gioia is able to sway his audience to devote more time to the simple task of reading works of intellectual value through fearful diction and compelling consequences associated with being illiterate. Through his article, Gioia implements fearful diction to express his concern that America’s future is in the hands of those who are less informed and comprehending of situations; economic and social.
Los Angeles Times Writer Anna Gorman in her Article “Immigrants’ children grow fluent in English” argues “there is no way English is being threatened by immigrants. . . . The switch to English is taking place perhaps more rapidly than
Language is a part of one’s identity, and because the men do not speak the same language as the majority, they are not seen as a part of the culture or
These frustrations rose to the point of nationwide protests, where the Supreme Court upheld a New York statute that proclaimed all Italian laborers working on the New York subways would be discharged from their positions. The entrance of the Supreme Court on nativist actions meant that nativism was reaching a near hysteric position- corroding even the impartial Judiciary. The government’s leniency towards American nativism led to the institution of a literacy test, which proved to be useless in sieving out unwanted European immigrants due to rising literacy rates in European countries. This unsuccessful attempt at excluding Italian and Eastern European immigrants led to greater rising sentiment which included dehumanizing these immigrant groups, branding them “abnormally twisted” and “unassimilable.” Nativism grew so high to the point of comparing Italian immigrants with rats and other animals.
This shows us that the language barrier can not only have an effect on the immigrant themselves but also their children. Furthermore there are situations where the immigrants affect the country both positively and
In “Let them die” essay, Kenan Malik assert that endangered languages in the world should be left to dead. In other word, the minority languages should not be preserved, because it is not related to the achievement of “cultural diversity” (Malik, 3). Indeed, he expresses, dying languages should be removed in order to reach the “dynamic and responsive” (Malik, 6) culture. However, the claims that Malik uses in his essay does not tackle the counter argument correctly. In addition, the evidences in the essay is not clear.
For example, in the United States, a xenophobic group named U.S. English proposes that people should only speak English. Espada informs, “U.S. English devotes its energies to opposing bilingual
Language, though primarily used as a means of communication, can be used to form community-like bonds with additions to and evolutions of different regional, cultural, racial, etc., vernaculars. What is one community’s “how are you?” is another’s “what’s good?” or “‘sup?” Those terms are understood and accepted almost unilaterally in their respective communities, but beyond those borders, they may or may not be. The push to broaden mandating “proper English pronunciation” is a direct attack on those communities that do not fall in the narrow definition of those whose community is deemed “correct” by mainstream society. When this is enforced, its roots are usually found in racism/white supremacy.
Richard Rodriguez and Gloria Anzaldúa are two authors who both immigrated to America in the 1950s and received first hand experience of the assimilation process into American society. During this time, Rodriguez and Anzaldúa had struggled adjusting to the school system. Since understanding English was difficult, it made adjusting to the American school system increasingly difficult for Rodriguez. Whereas Anzaldúa, on the other hand, had trouble adjusting to America’s school system due to the fact that she didn’t wish to stop speaking Spanish even though she could speak English. Both Rodriguez and Anzaldúa had points in their growing educational lives where they had to remain silent since the people around them weren’t interested in hearing them speaking any other language than English.
In the essay “The Human Cost of an Illiterate Society”, written by Jonathan Kozol and published in the Reading for Writers, New York, 2013, the author is raising awareness of illiteracy and the effects it has on society to his audience, the literate who can read and can do something about the issue. Pointing out the illiteracy problem in the United States that is unknown to most, he explains the impact that such a vast amount of illiterate people can have on voting and the government. Being that such a large amount of individuals are uneducated on the voting candidates, he goes on to say that many often do not vote or vote for someone for the wrong reason. With the use of statistics from the 1980 presidential vote to argue his point, he said that Ronald Reagan likely would not have been the president.
In 1998, the growing resentment of the immigrants led to the approval of California Proposition 227, known as English Language in Public Schools Statue. Proposition 227 gave Californians the opportunities to choose whether students should or should not be taught primarily in English in public schools. When the Proposition 227 was approved, it was supported by the idea that it would be the “best way to integrate the state’s booming immigrant population
“If a person, Chicana or Latina, has a low estimation of my native tongue, she also has a low estimation of me. Often with mexicanas y Latinas we’ll speak English as a neutral language. Even among Chicanas we tend to speak English at parties or conferences. Yet, at the same time we’re afraid the other will think we’re agingadas because we don’t speak Chicano Spanish.” These sentences are mostly in English, but were oppressed by the three words “mexicanas y Latinas.”
Poverty exists all around us, whether people realize it or not. Those living in poverty encounter problems that one may not understand. Children are born into poverty and are more likely to develop learning disabilities, have less parent-child interactions, and have a lower academic performance compared to those children not living in poverty (Brooks-Gunn, J., & Duncan, G. J, 1997). A major problem that is related to those living in poverty is illiteracy. Adults living in poverty tend to have higher rates of illiteracy compare to those adults not living in poverty.
Along with people with disabilities, “inmates of political prisoners' camps are denied their basic rights, and routinely suffer from all forms of human rights violations including 12 hours of hard labor every day” (Dudley). Clearly human rights are being stepped on by this act of censoring out people with disabilities and criminals, which
Today, issues of social class are not straightforward as they once were; increased educational opportunity and economic prosperity means that more and more young people are exposed to standard English than ever before. Nevertheless, linguistic prejudice still exists, particularly amongst employers, some politicians and sections of the general public. as