The last few years have been filled with many major news stories, ranging from terrorist attacks to mass shootings across the country. However, one of the most concerning and reoccurring themes of the past few years has been police misconduct. All across the country there have been incidents of police brutality, and sadly a lot of these incidents have led to the death of those involved. One of the most infamous cases of police brutality is the incident involving Eric Garner. Eric Garner, a forty-three-year-old African American male, was choked to death by the police in Staten Island, New York on July 17, 2014. Garner was confronted by the police on the suspicion of selling loose cigarettes. After denying these allegations and resisting arrest, …show more content…
Neil Cavuto, anchorman for fox news, reported on this story on December 3, 2014. In his report, he interviews Rod Wheeler, former homicide detective, and they discuss the decision of the grand jury. This report is drastically different from the other three news sources, and was not filled with as much information. The incident of Garner was only briefly touched on and then the focus was shifted completely. Most of their discussion was about the potential rioting of citizens in New York. This was the main focus for most of the interview, and this was because Cavuto’s questions were about this issue. Wheeler also mentions how the main issue at hand is not whether or not officer Pantaleo was indicted or not, but instead the biggest issue is the system. He mentions how there are flaws in the grand jury proceedings, and that is what people should be focused on. Cavuto’s tone in this clip was very unsympathetic towards the Garner family, and he didn’t seem to actually be concerned with Garner’s death. He was more focused on whether or not citizens would riot, and also whether or not they would light the tree in New York. He spent more time talking about the lighting of the tree than he did actually talking about Garner. Cavuto also asked several pointed questions that forced his guest to answer in a way that backed his ideas. On top of that, Cavuto interrupted wheeler several times while he was talking and didn’t really seem to appreciate the time that wheeler was giving him. It was clear from this clip that Wheeler was on the side of Garner, but it did not appear this way for Cavuto. He never once showed any sign of sympathy or support for the Garner family, and never made it clear that he did not support the grand jury’s decision. Media clips are used in this report, but they are not very effective. The report starts off by showing part of the video of Garner being choked, which
Police Officer Pantaleo arrested Garner “for allegedly selling loose cigarettes” (www.npr.org). During the arrest, Officer Pantaleo had put Garner in a chokehold position which caused Garner to suffocate. There was a video posted on YouTube of Garner saying he was not able to breathe while he was being held in a headlock. The man died because of the chokehold, but the grand jury, back in December of 2014, did not charge Officer Pantaleo. People protested in reaction to the officer not being charged for the death of Eric Garner and that led to the launch of the civil rights investigation for this case by the Justice Department (www.npr.org).
It really only made it worse. The videos were released, but without audio. Many believe that the videos may have been edited or altered in some kind of way. When watching the first version of the video that was released cars seemed to appear and disappear mid screen. A tow truck operator’s image also jumps from outside to inside the vehicle.
Garner was clearly not a very healthy man, said to weigh at least 350 lbs, he also had asthma. That being said, it would not have been easy for him to run or even get away. He also was not being aggressive or violent to anyone, including the officers. He was simply telling the officers (a bit annoyedly, but who wouldn’t have?) to leave him alone. Side note, if everyone were always complicit with authorities, this country would not be the “Land of the Free, and the Home of the
On July 17, 2014, 23 old, Ramsey Orta recorded the public killing of Eric Garner. The recording displays a six foot three inch, three hundred sixty pound unarmed black male being boxed in between a convenience store, located on a busy New York street and uniform as well as plain clothed officers. You can hear multiple offices persistently questioning Garner before the tattooed officer on his far right wearing a black fitted baseball cap takes charge of the situation. All though out the recording Garners body language shows him to be deeply vexed by the officers, however, not aggressive. The next scene depicts the officers on Garners far left attempt to put Garner in handcuffs without verbally warning Garner what he was doing before making the physical contact.
The author of ‘USA Today’ speaks about the controversial story of what really happened regarding the Michael Brown shooting. The author explains how in the first story, it was said that officer Darren Wilson was harassing Michael Brown for walking in the middle of the street, leading up to him hitting Michael Brown with the car door and proceeding to shoot him several times. Meanwhile, in the second story the author tells how Michael Brown reaches into the squad car while officer Darren Wilson was in it, hitting him in the face and reaching for the gun; causing the officer to release fire as defense. The author also stated that even with evidence from eyewitnesses, the grand jury determined that the shooting was a lawful tragedy, and not
Today bring forth the case of Michael Brown vs. Darren Wilson firstly state the argument in the case as being unjust, unfair ruling for justice of his family and the community. From the New York Times ( Michael Brown 's family attorney says grand jury proceeding is unfair). By Paul Cassel, In his opposition, the Grand Jury took too long to make its decision while the family was waiting for the verdict without reason. That is not a proper use of the grand jury decision, which made it harder to take the objections seriously. Which also criticized the parallel federal investigation for taking too long.
A combination of a chokehold by an officer, the chest compression, and poor health at the same, Garner has unfortunately died just an hour after being taken to hospital. The first thing worth mentioning is the police said they did not use chokehold on Garner. Later, the medical examiner concluded that Garner's death was caused by chokehold during physical restraint by police. After the Staten Island grand jury did not indict Pantaleo, people in New York City gathered to protest and made many speeches. Surprisingly, the number of protesters increase to more than 300 people.
" Cleveland case shows how body cameras can help police." Christian Science Monitor, October 13, 2015. , N.PAG, Academic Search Elite, EBSCOhost (accessed April 16, 2016).PARA
It was July 5, 2016 in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. A man named Alton Sterling was selling CD’s outside of the Triple S Food Market. A homeless man approached him and asked Alton for money. Alton showed the man his gun, and told the man to leave him alone. The men called 911, the police officers showed up, and soon after gunshots fired.
Michael Brown, an unarmed black teenager, was shot and killed on August 9, 2014 by Darren Wilson, a white police officer, in Ferguson, Missouri. The shooting prompted protests. When it was announced that Officer Wilson would not be indicted, the announcement set off another wave of protests. Not all police officers are dishonest and abuse their power but It 's obvious that today 's community of people has a suspicion of officers true intentions. The idea of cops and cameras has been around for a while but ever since the fatal shooting of Michael Brown the debate on whether police officers should be required to wear body cameras has been the center of attention.
They didn’t just focus on the police or the citizen side, the audience got to hear from both thus painting a bigger picture. Another good aspect of this interview was allowing Calvin Williams ample time to express his views in answering the interview questions. This allows the audience to get a better feel for the points he is trying to make, rather than cutting him off mid-answer with another question, as some interviews often are known to do. One thing bad I found was that, during the segment, it mainly focused on the wrong doings by the officers.
The officer in the death of Eric Garner denies any use of headlocks or chokeholds, but according to multiple eye witnesses and video evidence some may say otherwise. The true sad thing of this is that the man was only selling cigarettes. New York Police Officers had been watching Eric very closely and went they got close, Eric told the Officers that he was doing nothing wrong and did not deserve to be harassed. Eric had been selling single cigarettes from packs. The officers then went towards Eric to arrest, but things went south very
Images and video of Eric Garner’s murder by police generated outrage and protests across the nation. Many wept for the loss of this innocent, but for Black America, it was just another offense in a long series of transgressions against the black body. To them, the pain was familiar—they had known it by many names: slavery, Jim Crow, mass incarceration. Police brutality was nothing new. This situation was different, however.
Annotated Bibliography Books Dudley, William, et al., editors. Police Brutality. D.L. Bender, 1991. • Police Brutality gives information on how police brutality is a widespread issue in the United States and explains different controversies and cases that relate to police brutality. • The editors of this book include activists and nonfiction authors who provide reliable information on what happened during different incidences of police brutality and the viewpoints and controversies that come with it.
Police Brutality is an ongoing problem and existent concern in the United States and should be resolved immediately. Law enforcement must function as an element that consists of organized and civilized officers. The presence of police brutality is becoming more of an issue as society grows. The problem posed by the illegal exercise of police power is an ongoing reality for individuals of a disfavored race, class, or sexual orientation. Police brutality must be stopped so that police do not forget who they are serving – not themselves, but the public.