In Romeo and Juliet, Romeo does kill Tybalt but who is really to blame? Mercutio is minding his own business while Tybalt insults him and starts a fight. Romeo may have done the deed of killing him but Tybalt brought Romeo to that point. Since he killed Mercutio, It drove Romeo to such anger. And then ended with the death of Tybalt. Tybalt is to blame for his own death, since he was looking for a fight with Romeo, he insulted Mercutio, and Tybalt instigated the conversation.
Tybalt is responsible for his own death because he caused Mercutio to fight him. Tybalt did this by first insulting Romeo when he says, “Romeo, the love I bear thee can afford no better term than this: thou art a villain” (3.1.56-57). He calls Romeo a villain and challenges him to a duel. When Romeo keeps turning him down and walks away Tybalt gets even angrier. He insults him again and doesn’t really pay attention to what Romeo says. Mercutio decides at that
…show more content…
Gentlemen, good den; a word with one of you”(34-35). Tybalt is calling to Mercutio and his friends. This is an example of him speaking to Mercutio in order to start the conversation that results in a fight. Also in Act 3 Scene 1 Tybalt says, “You shall find me apt enough to that, sir, an you will give occasion”(38-9). Tybalt is speaking to Mercutio reassuring the fact that that he will fight on the chance that Mercutio were to give him a reason to. Tybalt is expressing a certain quality of animosity towards Mercutio. This is another of the many bad actions that Tybalt carries out. Another thing that Tybalt the Capulet says in Act 3 Scene 1, Tybalt says, “Mercutio, thou consortest with Romeo”(41). Tybalt is asking them if they associate with Romeo. This clearly infuriates Mercutio and while Mercutio seems always to be drunk Tybalt should realize this and not try to anger him. The death of Tybalt is due to his own lack of foresight, since he began the
Romeo and Juliet was a tragic play about two star crossed lovers who are indirectly murdered by Juliet’s cousin Tybalt. It was not the stars who killed Romeo and Juliet, it was Tybalt. There are three main reasons Tybalt is accused of killing Romeo and Juliet: he was a violent person, he killed Mercutio, and Tybalt wanted to keep the feud going. Tybalt was a violent person who kept the Capulet, Montague feud going separating Romeo and Juliet.
If he had not died then Tybalt would not have been a part of the fight that had Romeo
The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, Tybalt is responsible for his own death because he starts the fight, he’d still be killed by the prince for starting another fight and killing Mercutio, and his angry personality makes him continue to get into fights. The first reason that Tybalt’s death is his own fault is the fact that he starts this fight just like the many others that he had
As those lines were delivered, Tybalt had no idea what Romeo was talking about. Leaving him frustrated and even more angry than before. Had Romeo simply acknowledged that Tybalt was a danger, and indeed not family, he would have been able to fight his own battle and leave Mercutio out of
But, Tybalt's is also to blame in the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. Romeo kills Tybalt right after marrying Juliet and this story starts to have a downfall. As Tybalt in Act 1, Scene 1 states, “ What, art thou drawn among these heartless hinds? " Tybalt makes fun of Benvolio for trying to stop the fight. Almost immediately you see that he is a arrogant and impulsive character.
Tybalt is at fault for his own death because he started the fight. After the Capulet party, Benvolio says, “Tybalt, the kinsman of old Capulet, Hath sent a letter to his father's house. ”(2.4.6-7) followed by Mercutio, “A challenge, on my life. ”(2.4.8) While looking for Romeo, Mercutio and Benvolio stumbleupon a letter while looking for Romeo.
In the tragic play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare, Mercutio and Tybalt have an argument which leads up to a fight to the death but they both end up dying. Even though some may believe it’s Mercutio’s fault for the deaths, I believe that it’s Tybalt’s fault for both of the deaths. I believe that Tybalt is responsible for both his own and Mercutio’s death because he is hot-headed and opinionated when it comes to listening to other people One of the Reasons Tybalt is to blame for both of the deaths is because of his careless action choice. After talking to Mercutio, Tybalt was furious and wanted to fight him “(Draws his sword)”
My first reason as to why the blame for Mercutio's death falls on Romeo is that in the text he is directly responsible for making Mercutio let his guard down, giving Tybalt a window of opportunity to strike. This is demonstrated in the old movie version of Romeo and Juliet, where it looks as though Tybalt and Mercutio aren’t seriously fighting. But as they are engaging in these theatrics, Romeo decides he should
Mercutio then decided to step in to protect Romeo of his vulnerability and fight Tybalt. In the text Mercutio states, “Will you pluck your sword out of his pitcher/by the ears? make haste, lest mine be about your/ears ere it be out” (3.1.108-110). Mercutio felt that it was his responsibility to take down Tybalt since he was intimidating Romeo. So, Mercutio decided to brawl with Tybalt.
Romeo is to blame for Mercutio’s death in Act III of Romeo and Juliet. First of all, Romeo did not fight back when Tybalt insulted him. Tybalt calls Romeo a villain and other various names, but Romeo responds by saying (paraphrase), “I love you more than you believe for we are family, even if you are oblivious to this fact. I love the name Capulet as much as I love my own name”(3.1.72-75). When Romeo says this, Tybalt becomes confused and enraged.
Romeo acts as an arbitrator between Tybalt and Mercutio because he understands the repercussions of the impending clash. He tries his best to reason with Tybalt by saying “I do protest, I never injured thee, But love thee better than thou canst devise.” Meaning that he won 't fight because he is related to him through marriage. Tybalt, not knowing of their secret wedding ignores Romeo’s comment, continuing his goading of Mercutio.
Some may argue that it was not his fault that he was killed, for the prolonged feud between the two households, Montague and Capulet, could be considered the reason for the fight and death. In being rivals for so long, the households grew to violently despise the other. This led to Tybalt's desire to duel with Romeo, for he hated him for no reason except his last name. If the households were not enemies, neither would Tybalt and Romeo. Mercutio, right before his death, said, “A plague o’ both your houses!
Lastly, Tybalt is the most to blame for the events that occur in Romeo and Juliet because of the the first events he caused leading to the suicides of Romeo and Juliet. The confirmation that Tybalt is the cause of the terrible events in Romeo and Juliet is shown in the play “Romeo and Juliet” when Romeo says, “Is it even so? then I defy you, stars! Thou know ' st my lodging: get me ink and paper, and hire post-horses; I will hence tonight.”
Tybalt is the most to blame for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet. Tybalt is furious with Romeo showing up at the Capulet’s party. In the Quote, “It fits when such a villain is a guest, I’ll not endure him”(1.5.82-83).Since, Tybalt saw Romeo at the party he sends a note to Romeo challenging him to fight. Rome ignores the letter which cause Tybalt to go up to Romeo and challenge to fight face-to-face. That then leads to them fighting and people dieing.
Preciado 1 Lizeth Preciado Deborah Sidler Pre AP English 9: 2A February 18th, 2018 From the moment children are born, their actions begin to have an exponential effect on the lives of those around them. No action is free of consequences, and the decisions made throughout an individuals life can make or break the following course of events.