As dictated by human nature, when surrounded by a restrictive and controlling environment, one may struggle to maintain their free will. Both Winston from 1984 and Andy from The Shawshank Redemption strive to take control of oppressive situations and retain the liberty of individuality. 1984 depicts a society in which totalitarian power reigns, limiting Winston's grasp of reality, whereas The Shawshank Redemption embraces the value of persistence, revealing an eternal reward for Andy's fight against the constraining atmosphere of Shawshank. Under the influence of authority and manipulating circumstances, protagonists attempt to preserve humanity by forming human relationships and connecting with tangible objects. However, the protagonists eventually …show more content…
Despite his efforts to defy pressure and overthrow the ruling party, Winston submits to a higher authority. Winston wishes to test the limits of power, but in convincing himself that he is doomed to succeed, Winston takes risks and gets carried away in rebellion. As Winston sits with an open diary, the text details, "It was no longer the same cramped, awkward handwriting as before. His pen had slid voluptuously over the smooth paper, printing in large, neat capitals, 'DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER'" (13). Winston exposes himself to the internal notion of failure from the start, as he indicates foresight of his future adversities. Winston sets a predestined failure for himself, ultimately leading to his demise. As Winston fails to resist the government's manipulation, his values are stripped away, and his ideals become molded by the Party. In sacrificing his human spirit to the government, Winston loses sight of reality, failing to generate any genuine emotion. Andy, on the contrary, does not submit to a higher authority, as he is praised for leading with a positive mindset and securing his confidence. Within the harsh confines of prison, Andy manages to retain a spirit of hope, which he eventually uses to break free of the prison grounds. From the start, Andy strives to persist, as he meticulously protects his "unconquerable soul" and optimistically influences others. Andy attempts to help and encourage others by supporting convicts in adopting constructive hobbies, expanding the prison library, and playing euphoric music over prison speakers. After Andy escapes prison, he writes Red a letter, asserting that "hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things, and no good thing ever dies" (Darabont). Andy is detained at Shawshank but manages to maintain an uplifting demeanor, not allowing prison to change
In 1984 winston is working for rewriting history and making the past disappear The two characters are the same they both realize hey this is wrong this shouldn't be happening . They both get
He fought inside himself for not compromising to the prisoner-life and tried to be a ‘normal and free’man. Another example that symboled his will to gain freedom is the library. The library in Shawshank had a fairly important position, for it endowed the prisoners change to learn. And Andy paid a lot efforts to get it bigger and better. Somehow, I felt the greatness of Andy was not only
’s escape. Furthermore, when Andy arrives at the prison he slowly develops a friendship with Red and by the end of the film they become best
Eventually, Red got out on parole, and it was the hope that Andy brought to Shawshank that kept him going on the outside. In this story, Andy was the most hopeful person in Shawshank, but he was also sensible towards the notion of risk and reward. Despite being a
When Winston views his deteriorating body in the mirror, he realizes his helplessness in the power of the Party. This feeling of defeat causes him to believe he is inferior to the Party, which in turn causes him to question his views
Winston continues to disappoint further as because of the lack of his usual paranoia and good instinct in identification of character, he is defeated by Mr. Charrington’s avuncular mask, trusting him even with the notion that the Thought Police and telescreen surveillance is everywhere in the Party’s jurisdiction. His fatalism proves fatal in this scene as he falls with little resistance, allowing Julia to be violently captured in the process, conflicting with what a lover and a hero would normally do. Although unrealistic, it is to my belief that a heroic character would not betray their loved ones as well as themselves, which Winston eventually did as he developed love for Big Brother, detaching the connection he shared with Julia in the final scenes of the
The Darkness of Human Nature Revealed in the "The Shawshank Redemption" Abstract: If the confrontation of human nature good and evil in other movies may be a facial confrontation, but in the movie "The Shawshank Redemption" is no longer simple right and wrong, but pulled back to the concrete real world. Through contrast, the author presents the darkness and ugliness of human nature on the one hand, and on the other hand, embodies the self-salvation of human nature through completely different characters. In the loss of human nature, without reservation, the protagonist Andy still insist on self-belief, with a strong resilience to the end of salvation. This article will briefly expound the plot of "The Shawshank Redemption" and reveals the
When Andy is consistently denied by the government for funding to build a new library in Shawshank prison, Andy remains persistent and continues to write letters in hopes the government would change its mind. Red comments: “Prison time is slow time. Sometimes. It feels like stop-time. So you do what you can to keep going …”
At the beginning of the novel, Winston made it prominent that he dissented Big Brother and his party’s idea. He wrote in his diary, in Book 1 Chapter 1, “DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER…” (Orwell 18). This shows that Winston dissented his country’s government and was willing to rebel for he knew deep inside that
Andy immediately dedicated himself to programs and activities within the prison upon entry and that is what kept him going in the corrupt prison. Once Andy witnessed that his dedication within the prison was so harshly suppressed, Andy knew it was time to dedicate his life in other areas for “Whatever mistakes [he] made, [he’d] paid for them and then some”.
Sitting under a tree shortly after his release from Shawshank, Red reads a letter from his dear friend Andy Dufrense. In a very ambitious way, Andy writes, “Hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things, and no good thing ever dies. I will be hoping that this letter finds you and finds you well your good friend Andy.” Violating his parole Red travels to Texas then Mexico, and is reunited with his friend Andy. Frank Darabont’s The Shawshank Redemption shows the hope and determination of a man to make his dreams a reality.
They feel hope and a taste of humanity from the outside world for maybe the first time in Shawshank. " Every man in Shawshank felt free". The prisoners were given hope that there are places in the world that are not made of stone. Andy gives the prisoners a gift of memory and says 'they can’t take that away from you '. - When Andy cracks jokes with the Red 's group he permanently integrates himself in the group.
Andy entered Shawshank as a fresh young man and came out old and hardened. In his unfortunate time in Shawshank, furthermore, Andy was raped and attacked by a gang known as “The Sisters” and will forever have to live with these horrid memories. For twenty years Andy was stripped of his freedom and rights, for nothing at his
The Shawshank Redemption is a 1994 American drama film, by Frank Darabont, that tells of Andy’s journey. Andy is an accomplished banker, who was incarcerated at Shawshank prison for a crime he states he didn’t commit; the murder of his wife and her secret lover. The film focuses on his dramatic transformation from the moment that he was incarcerated until he eventuates his own freedom from Shawshank, due to the corruption of the guards by abusing them physically and verbally and also killing the inmates for no apparent reason. Andy also received special privileges as he was helping the warden with laundering money. The privileges that Andy received were being able to work in the warden’s office and to build a library for the rest of the inmates.
This moment of weakness for Winston demonstrates his ego because he is satisfying his urge to rebel against the government in an efficient and appropriate way, as described by Marie Doorey in a reference about psychoanalysis (Doorey). Winston waited until he had acquired the diary to begin conspiring his thoughts against Big Brother. Winston mistakenly thought he was writing in secret, when in fact he was not. He was always being watched by Big Brother. Moreover, Winston attempts expressing his individuality by writing his thoughts and feelings in the diary.