Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero Or A Villain
During the late 1800s, there were some very bad, powerful people. One of them was Andrew Carnegie, captain of the steel industry. Andrew Carnegie was a Scottish immigrant who came to America to seek a better life. He made his money in the steel industry after figuring out a way to manufacture it faster. Andrew Carnegie was a villain because he didn’t care about his workers, preached about world peace and then turned around and gave the U.S. Navy steel, and because his club tampered with a dam, killing thousands.
Carnegie didn’t get his money honestly sometimes, and didn’t care if the people didn’t like how he did things, because how he was doing things made him money. Carnegie didn’t treat his workers well, and docked their pay constantly, so he could turn around and donate libraries and money to paint himself as a philanthropist. To prove this, “he didn’t always follow the rules or treat people kindly”, meaning he would dock his workers pay, and have really dangerous working conditions just so he could make more money. This proves that Carnegie cared about making money more than anything else, but that also meant making lives harder for his workers.
…show more content…
In the end, the workers were forced to go back to work and they were forced to take a pay cut.” Carnegie refused to give his workers a raise and improve their working conditions. This proves that Carnegie cared more about his reputation and keeping sales than his employees. He would kill some of them just so they would comply and go back to work. To prove this, there is a reason it was renamed the homestead massacre in replacement of the homestead
Andrew Carnegie's Impact On The Industrial Era
750 Words | 3 PagesCarnegie was a firm believer in Social Darwinism. He saw himself as the most fit, and his financial success was attributed to this fitness. This idea of Social Darwinism made him believe that he was better than everyone else, because he was the most successful and elevated of all mankind. “America needed steel,” (45) and Andrew Carnegie provided. Although Carnegie felt he had more worth than most other people, he still felt he should give back to help others.
Was Andrew Carnegie A Robber Baron
346 Words | 2 PagesThe context of Andrew Carnegie is the robber baron. Industrialisation the expansion of factories and the mass production of manufactured goods like steel. The Industrial Revolution of the early 1900s set the foundation for the rise of Carnegie steel. While some say Andrew Carnegie is a caption of industry because he wanted to help others who were poor evidence suggests he is a robber baron because he made the vertical monopoly which makes it harder to compete with him and he had very poor working conditions and even killed some people with those horrible conditions. Andrew Carnegie made it hard for anyone else to produce steel and other various items so he could eliminate his competition which he pretty much did.
Andrew Carnegie Dbq
780 Words | 4 PagesIn document B, we can see an article that Carnegie himself wrote, in June of 1889, where he states “(why should a man) wait until he is dead before he becomes of much good in the world?” He shows here not only his desire to help the world before he dies, but his aspiration that others do the same. He also expresses in the same article “The man who dies rich dies disgraced.” He again here exemplifies his want for the wealthy to do good for communities with their finances. These pieces of evidence show Carnegie not only wanted to make sure he was giving back, but that other affluent people were
Is Andrew Carnegie A Hero?
427 Words | 2 PagesAndrew Carnegie was a hero in some people 's eyes , not so much in others . That’s why everyone has their own opinion. In this essay you will read one reason someone might think he’s a hero , and two reasons why he is not a hero for the rest of the people. What that means is that this paper mostly leans on that Andrew Carnegie is not a hero and you will read why . Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man.
Andrew Carnegie Dbq
219 Words | 1 PagesJust like the treatment his workers endured Carnegie wasn't any nicer to his competitors. Andrew Carnegie was a phenomenal businessman. Much of his success is due to how he operated his business. He watched the costs of his business intently (Document C), always making sure that the steel was being produced at a lower price than what it was being sold for (Document D), and he watched his competitors even closer. In March 1889, when Allegheny Bessemer Steel built a mill directly across from Carnegie's mill it intimidated Carnegie.
Who Is Andrew Carnegie A Robber And A Baron
1099 Words | 5 PagesIn 1870 he founded the Carnegie steel company a step which cemented his name as one of the “ captains of industry.” By the 1890’s the company was the largest and most profitable industry enterprise in the world. In 1892 the homestead strike in Homestead Pennsylvania pitted in one of the most powerful new corporation. Carnegie steel company against the nation's strongest trade union. Henry Clay Frick stepped up production demands and when
To What Extent Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero
549 Words | 3 PagesOnce he was sixteen Andrew was famous for being able to decode dot-dot dash-dash messages (morse code) and was paid $4.00 a week. In 1872 Andrew met Henry Bessemer, the creator of the steel mill, Andrew decided to adopt Bessemer's idea and bring the steel mill to the United States. This would be Called the J. Edgar Thomson Works (Pre-DBQ). This evidence helps explain why Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he had the courage to work hard to get to where he was at the nearing end of his life.
Analysis Of The Gospel Of Wealth By Andrew Carnegie
804 Words | 4 PagesIt was very impossible to ignore the fact that the main problem that was surfacing was the difference between poor and rich. From time to time, all of Carnegie’s work has become into practice. Most people agreed and some disagreed, but the most important aspect of his philosophy was to get a positive message across to people in America through his article. As Carnegie stated “When these apprentices rose to be masters, there was little or no change in their mode of life, and they, in turn, educated in the same routine succeeding
Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero?
654 Words | 3 PagesOne piece of evidence that supports this reason is in document B. We can see that Carnegie said that he didn't want to leave his money with his family. But inside of leaving his money with his family, He would leave it to better uses. I believe in not leaving all of his money with his family because they didn't work for it and other people need it. A second piece of supporting evidence is in document B as well. He didn't leave his money with his family.
Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero?
1300 Words | 6 PagesAndrew Carnegie was a poor man growing up. He started with a house that cost 20 dollars to rent, and throughout his life, he had to work his way up the social ladder and eventually ended up living in mansions and castles. Carnegie used a business practice he invented called vertical integration, which lowered costs and effectively made better quality products. Carnegie was a well respected boss and provided equal pay for
What Was The Impact On Andrew Carnegie
539 Words | 3 PagesCarnegie was involved in a highly competitive business. Does this excuse him (and others) for their treatment of workers? As told Carnegie grew up poor and then was forced to work unbearable hours and six days a week for little pay. “In 1849, at the age of 14, Ohio Telegraph Company hired Andrew as a telegraph messenger for $2.50 per week. With roaring ambition and an unbelievable work ethic propelling him, Carnegie taught himself the language of the telegraph and within a year became the operator.
Was Andrew Carnegie A Robber Baron?
363 Words | 2 PagesAndrew Carnegie is a Robber Barron because he sold monopoly to JP Morgan the most famous business man. The monopoly prices raised and it was ruthless tactics. Andrew Carnegie also stole the idea of the bessemer process. He also payed Irish men $850 to take his place in the civil war.
Andrew Carnegie Is Not A Hero Essay
454 Words | 2 PagesCarnegie is not a hero because he took money, only gave to other wealthy recipients, and contributed largely to his own. Andrew Carnegie took money away from deserving people. Carnegie cut the wages of his workers to donate money elsewhere. In document D, there are two images of Carnegie, one is giving a wage cut notice to the workers and the other is giving a check to Scotland and donating a library to Pittsburg. Carnegie’s employees were working hard and trying to survive in a tough economy, their wages did not deserve a cut.
Who Was Andrew Carnegie A Captain Of Industry Essay
460 Words | 2 PagesCarnegie was considered a Robber Baron for many reasons. For example, he gained huge profits because of his workers low wages. In the excerpt, “Who was Andrew Carnegie,” the author said, “his steel workers were often pushed to long hours and low wages.” Workers worked in harsh conditions and received no benefits causing them to live in poverty with scarce food, clothing, and shelter. Workers were tired of the low wages and decided to go on strike.
What Is Andrew Carnegie Ethical Or Unethical
338 Words | 2 PagesAndrew Carnegie was one of the most famous and wealthiest American industrialist during the Industrial Age. He was a robber baron who made a fortune in the steel industry and applied vertical integration to his business. Carnegie contradicted his views as a robber baron because he supported, but destroyed many unions. This made many of his views unethical.
More about Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero Or A Villain
Andrew Carnegie's Impact On The Industrial Era
750 Words | 3 PagesWas Andrew Carnegie A Robber Baron
346 Words | 2 PagesAndrew Carnegie Dbq
780 Words | 4 PagesIs Andrew Carnegie A Hero?
427 Words | 2 PagesAndrew Carnegie Dbq
219 Words | 1 PagesWho Is Andrew Carnegie A Robber And A Baron
1099 Words | 5 PagesTo What Extent Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero
549 Words | 3 PagesAnalysis Of The Gospel Of Wealth By Andrew Carnegie
804 Words | 4 PagesWas Andrew Carnegie A Hero?
654 Words | 3 PagesWas Andrew Carnegie A Hero?
1300 Words | 6 PagesWhat Was The Impact On Andrew Carnegie
539 Words | 3 PagesWas Andrew Carnegie A Robber Baron?
363 Words | 2 PagesAndrew Carnegie Is Not A Hero Essay
454 Words | 2 PagesWho Was Andrew Carnegie A Captain Of Industry Essay
460 Words | 2 PagesWhat Is Andrew Carnegie Ethical Or Unethical
338 Words | 2 Pages