Red Platoon by Clinton Romesha gives the reader a first person view of a solider during the events leading battle of Kamdesh. The book starts off by covering Clinton’s tours in Iraq and his training back at Fort Carson in Colorado springs. As the book progresses it explains what the day to day life at COP (Combat Outpost) Keating and all the concerns of the soldiers at the outpost. Next the book explains what each soldier was doing during the battle and it explains all the people it took to liberate the base. The book concludes by explaining what each soldier's life was after the battle and explains how Clinton Romesha received his medal of honor.
I believe that the author wrote this book to show what real war is like and to honor the lives
…show more content…
I had never heard of the battle of Kamdesh until reading this book. One thing that really surprised me was how the bureaucratic system of the military failed the soldiers. It appeared that the system was more concerned about saving money that the safety of the soldiers. An example of this was whenever the soldiers would request for supplies to reinforce the base they were always given the same response of the military isn’t going to invest more money into a base that were are going to disassemble in a few months. Another thing that surprised me was how many problems were created by the desertion of Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl. In order to make an attempt to find Sergeant Bergdahl the army and to dedicate air resources to search for him. This meant that resupply missions were more and more scarce and the airborne resupply network was being strained. The most surprising side effect of the desertion was how it pushed back the evacuation of COP Keatings. In fact, Keatings was originally planned to evacuated before October. This meant that if Sergeant Bergdahl had never deserted it was a possiblity that the battle of Kamdesh may have never occurred. In conclusion Red Platoon is an inspiring and eye opening book that shows what it was like to be a soldier before, during, and after the battle of
Perry for example was already uncertain of his future and his knee injury already had him on edge. towards the end of the book after burning the corpses of his past comrades he lost all faith, and innocence. So the theme of the book is that war is devastating to person both mentally and
Goodbye Darkness is a memoir written by William Manchester. Manchester was a U.S. Marine in the Pacific during World War II. What truly made this book stand out for me was how deep it goes in philosophically. For instance, it talks about the concepts of survivor’s guilt. When on the patrol on the Guadalcanal, Manchester’s entire group that he fought with was struck by a Japanese mortar leaving him the only survivor.
Christopher Browning’s book, Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 explains the story of the most infamous mass killing in modern history and the ordinary men who participated in this genocide. In this book Browning provides insight into who these ordinary men really are and their horrendous acts. The Police Battalion 101 became a mass-execution squad in Poland in 1942-43. Surprisingly every single one of these men were able to make the decision to avoid partaking in the killings with no repercussions, some left, while some stated that they were given no such choice and that they didn’t hear that part. When given the orders to take out these innocent Jews, some of the men pleaded that the reason they were hesitant to kill was the fact that they were simply just too weak.
The story gives me a newfound respect for the Army and the soldiers who were deployed in Iraq around that time because of the constant harassment the insurgents gave the unit. Not because of the war crimes that were committed. It was a magnificent book about the implications and psychological effects war can have on people and what it can lead them do, It has a lot of examples of good and bad leadership that I can take away from it and apply it to my own leadership style. And I can be more prepared in dealing with peers and subordinates in times of
So many soldiers are shoot and blown apart from artillery and 51,000 people died during this war, everybody knew that they were most likely not going to make it out alive and they all learned to deal with it. Another major theme is division among the nation because it was a fight between the north and the south of the United States. Both sides had to make themselves think that the other side was filled of people that were less than human like if they were fighting a different country or something because if not they probably wouldn’t be able to handle this war. So I would say that this book has a new and original
In the middle of a pause in the fighting of a civil war battle, Lieutenant John Dunbar realizes that his leg needs to be amputated to save his life. Dunbar has seen what happens to soldiers that go through amputation and he decides to take his own life in stead by ridiing a horse along the enemies front lines. However he doesnt get shot and unexpectedly rallys his comrades, who find new courage to storm the conferderate positions. After the battle is over, Dunbar’s superiors name him a hero and he is given acsess to the generals sugeon who is able to save his leg. He is given in reward his choice of his next posting, and also the horse named ‘Cisco’, the one that he used in his attempted suicide.
In The Red Badge of Courage by American novelist Stephen Crane, Henry Flemming, a private in the Union army, faces greater trials than he could have ever imagined. Henry grows from an untested boy to a noble soldier over four battles in less than two days. Henry joins a brand new regiment as a brand new soldier. These men all differ
The Unbeatable Souls The Lost Battalion is based totally on a real story of an American battalion that was sent out to battle during the World War I. Major Charles Whittlesey, a New York lawyer, who ends up in the trenches of France having under his command mostly young, unexperienced men. When Whittlesey and his battalion of five hundred men are ordered to advance into the Argonne Forest they find themselves surrounded by Germans troops when the other battalions instantly withdrew, leaving Whittlesey’s battalion on his own. Confined behind enemy lines, Whittlesey’s battalion turned into the only force in the German army’s plans to move forward. Trapped and with no other way to rescue, Whittlesey is given an opportunity to surrender, but chose to continue fighting and keep his men together.
“If I Die in a Combat Zone, Box Me Up and Ship Me Home” is a novel written by Tim O’Brien, featuring himself as the lead character. In this book, the reader is walked through his time serving as a foot solider in the Army during the Vietnam War. O’Brien uses a style of storytelling that includes multiple flashbacks to build a strong sense of character throughout the novel. The main theme throughout this novel is courage, and how everyone views it slightly different. Our main character is faced with the harsh realities of war and must decide for himself what he thinks courage truly is throughout his time serving.
What I have discovered about the book is that the author give very descriptive perspective about the horrors and experiences of the american soldiers faced during World War 2. The book has a violent nature and is not advice for those who have a weak stomach. In all of the chapters, people will die and it will not be suger-coat. This book is mainly from the perspective of the american soldiers and not of their allies perspective so it does not give as much credit toward Britain or its soldiers.
Although he learned that he had to learn to cope with every single physical, emotional and mental stress factor that came his way. He learned with every guy in his platoon, they all stuck together. This novel was a very well written book. Each story was different, and gave a different aspect on war every time. The emotions were real, and very descriptive.
This chapter “The Ghost Soldiers”, showed us how Tim O’Brien and the other soldiers were dealing with the war both physically and psychologically. It also shows us how the Tim O'Brien behaved and felt when he was shot, wounded and had a bacteria infection on his butt and how the war changed the way he thought, and viewed the other soldiers around him. This chapter also contain a lot of psychological lens. From the way Tim O’Brien felt when he was shot and separated from his unit to a new unit to when he wanted revenge on Bobby Jorgenson for almost “killing” him.
His embarrassment causes him to enlist in the military and he ends up serving time in Vietnam. The novel touches on his experiences and bonds with his platoon while serving his time in Vietnam. Throughout the book, Myers shows a realistic depiction of war such as the graphic violence, the inner thoughts of a soldier, and how the platoon struggles to survive. Throughout the novel, Myers utilizes many different ways to portray the realistic depiction of war.
Sebastian Junger, the author, did a fine job presenting the information he gathered, but also lacked the story structure and plot that a novel has. The book, The Perfect Storm, would have been much better if stuck to one storyline. Regardless of the written text, we still have to respect and appreciate these courageous men, who lost their lives in a true battle of men against
Present throughout the book is the theme of disillusionment. In the school, they’ve been told by their schoolmasters and parents that unless they join the war, they would remain cowards. They see propaganda after propaganda, all alluding towards the glory of battle and warfare. Out on the front, they realize that nothing was further from the truth. Their dreams of being heroes shattered, like when they compare themselves to the soldier on a poster in chapter 7.