NGRI Argumentative Essay: The Insanity Defense
The truth of the matter is that the insanity defense is rarely ever successful. As the public cries that this defense is a “get out of jail” free card it really isn’t. Statistics show that less than 1 percent of all felony cases are successful pleading insanity (Worrall, 2014). If a defendant is legally insane, it does not necessarily mean that he or she can plea insanity.
Crutchfield stated that sanity is a legal concept, not a psychological one (2009). Another public outcry is that, NGRI acquittees are quickly released from custody, the public has never been more wrong. Only 15 percent of NGRI acquittees have been released on restraints. An example of an NGRI that was never released is Daniel Mc’Naghten. Mr. Mc’Naghten died in the mental asylum where he spent 20 years, and he found guilty by reason of insanity. Also, another 35 percent of the NGRI acquittees are still in institutional custody to this date (Crutchfield, 2009).
…show more content…
A huge advantage is that this here defense when successful can save a life, in which it can avoid a defendant from being put on death row. When a defendant pleas insanity, in the courtroom it creates an insanity atmosphere of guilt. When a defendant pleas insanity, the attorney admits that the crimes happen, but the defendant is innocent because of his or her mind (Samaha, 2015).
By having a successful insanity defense, this can cause for the defendant to have a lenient charge when the jury reaches the verdict. The defendant would be declared either medically or criminally insane, he would not be trued under the same conditions of someone accused who is in the right state of
Exclusionary Rule Summary
625 Words | 3 PagesThen, the defendant has to formally plead guilty, not guilty, or insane at an arraignment. At this point, there may be a plea agreement, which avoids having to take the case to
FRE 704 V PA Rules Of Evidence
547 Words | 3 Pages. Under the Federal Rules of Evidence a mental health expert in a criminal trial can not offer an opinion on the ultimate legal issue of whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense. An opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue. (704(a)). However, in a criminal case, an expert witness must not state an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense.(704(b)).
Andrea Yates Murder Case Essay
1867 Words | 8 PagesIt lists that in order to declare a defendant not guilty by insanity, it must be proven that the person is significantly mentally ill and was not able to differentiate right from wrong in the instance of their crime (Levin). There was no dispute between prosecution or defense that Andrea was mentally ill, it was simply if her illness inhibited her judgement enough to meet the legal standards. Her family and defense attorney all believed that there was no questioning the severity of her condition, she simply could not function as a regular human being, and her judgement was clouded. Andrea’s mother-in-law, Dora Yates, who frequently watched over Andrea and witnessed her daily condition, stated, “I don't think she knew how to cope . . . how to function.
Insanity Defense Of Andrea Yates
935 Words | 4 PagesDr. Mark Nolan, Senior Lecturer at ANU College of Law, says that the NGRI plea “enables defendants to avoid criminal liability and standard criminal punishment” (Nolan 8). The main disagreement with America is the focus whether if the “guilty defendant” pursues to misuse the “Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity” as an alternative to imprisonment or if the criminally accused was at the time of committing the crime “clinically insane” and in need psychotherapy. Therefore, during this discussion of opposing viewpoints concerning the insanity defense being misused or ethical are going to be
After The Hammer Attack Jeff Weber
987 Words | 4 PagesLawyers could advise their clients not to plead NCR to avoid possibly lengthy and undetermined imprisonments. With a non-NCR plea, the corrections system must assign a fixed time length for a sentence. Unfortunately, such a tactic will swell the population of mentally ill intimates within the corrections system and further strain access to critical mental health resources. And it is probable that offenders who should have pled NCR but wound-up within the general population will be released in a worsened state then before they were sentenced.
Insanity Defense Reform Essay
2347 Words | 10 PagesI agree that the insanity defense is morally right. There are defects of the system. However, the criminal justice system’s foundation is made up of moral integrity. As a society we have decided to excuse those who lack the moral capabilities to know right from wrong. The murkiness of the system should not automatically equate to the abolishment of the defense.
The Importance Of The NGRI Defense
861 Words | 4 PagesAre they trying to beat the system? A number of us will turn on the TV or scroll through social media multiple times a day. We might just happen to run into a court case where the offender pleads not guilty by reason of insanity. Some may roll their eyes, some will shake their heads, and others may just skip onto the next topic.
Criminally Responsible Law
1035 Words | 5 Pages"The median amount of time taken to complete adult NCRMD cases was 132 days, which is 17% longer than the 113 days taken for non-NCRMD criminal court cases." (Miladinovic, Z., & Lukassen, J., 2015, February 25) This data demonstrates that those in charge of the case must know the case in order to set a just trial. "The verdict of not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder (NCRMD) is a final decision reached when a judge or jury finds that an accused was suffering from a mental disorder while committing the criminal act and as a result is exempt from criminal responsibility (Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, s.672.34). An individual found NCRMD is neither acquitted nor found guilty (Latimer and Lawrence 2006); the court or Review Board may make one of three dispositions: absolute discharge, conditional discharge, or detention in a hospital (Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, s.672.54)."
In Cold Blood Insanity Defense
621 Words | 3 PagesA case can be changed due to the call of the insanity plea. Nevertheless, This may cause a possible difference to the charge of the defence. In a court case dealing with murder such as the issue with the Clutter family, the Insanity plea was brought into thought to test if Perry and Dick were mentally stable during that time. By definition, the insanity plea is an argument stating the defense was not responsible for their actions due to a psychiatric disease at the time of the act, consequently, making him/her unaware of the occurring actions moreover the later consequences. In the book, In Cold Blood by Truman Capote, the main characters Perry and Dick killed the Clutter family committing the crime of the century.
Andrea Yates Case Essay
2011 Words | 9 PagesThe Andrea Yates Case: The Insanity Defense On June 20, 2001, in Houston, Texas, Andrea Pia Yates was charged with the murder of her five children, which she drowned in the bathtub one at a time, and was found not guilty by reason of insanity under the Texas Law Insanity Defense. The legislative history of the Texas Law Insanity Defense begins with the British test for right and wrong, known as the M’Naghten, being adopted in the majority of American states. The M’Naghten test for right and wrong required a mental disease that kept the defendant from controlling their actions and that cognitive impairment is the cause for the defective reasoning of what is right and what is wrong. Beginning in 1973, Texas adopted the American Law Institute’s
Lee Robin's Case Summary
593 Words | 3 PagesAn incident where pleading insanity worked in one’s favor is heard in the case of Lee Robin. Lee Robin was a 30-year-old doctor who was charged with murder of his wife and his two year old daughter. Robin admitted to killing his wife with an ax and drowning his infant daughter. After the murders, Robin called the police and reported that there was “a problem” at his home. Soon after, the police arrived.
Arguments Against Insanity Plea
312 Words | 2 PagesIf an insanity plea is successful, it can be implied that mental illnesses can be dangerous or harmful. Also, that the person with the mental illness is going to be treated and hopefully learn how to handle such an illness. Then perhaps that person can go free after a while. On the other hand, if an insanity plea is unsuccessful, then it can be implied that the person with the illness may not get treatment. Although, if the person is just using a mental illness as an excuse, then he or she is giving other people with a mental illness a bad name.
The Theme Of Death In Truman Capote's In Cold Blood
1445 Words | 6 PagesThe court dismisses the plea quickly because “the justice system ignores psychosocial complexities and histories in favor of black and white definitions of right and wrong” (Myers). The justice system in this time very rarely accepted pleas of insanity or mental illness. Capote wrote that “after an hour’s conversation with the defendants, the doctor rule[d] out that neither man
Arguments Against Insanity Defense
1042 Words | 5 PagesFor example, people try using insanity as a defense when being prosecuted in a criminal case. (Math, Kumar, and Moirangthem) It is based on the assumptions that at the time of the crime, the defendant was not suffering from severe mental illness. Therefore, they were well aware that they were committing a crime.
Argumentative Essay On A Mental Health Issue
947 Words | 4 PagesThere are more people incarcerated who have a mental illness that there are in psychiatric hospitals. (Psychology Today). Mental Health America reports that “there are more than 1.2 million people currently residing in prisons and/or jails with a mental health condition and lack of access to mental health care”. (MHA). 40% of adults with a serious mental illness will be arrested at some point in their lifetime, usually for disturbing the peace or for a petty crime which are caused by their mental illness.
More about NGRI Argumentative Essay: The Insanity Defense
Exclusionary Rule Summary
625 Words | 3 PagesFRE 704 V PA Rules Of Evidence
547 Words | 3 PagesAndrea Yates Murder Case Essay
1867 Words | 8 PagesInsanity Defense Of Andrea Yates
935 Words | 4 PagesAfter The Hammer Attack Jeff Weber
987 Words | 4 PagesInsanity Defense Reform Essay
2347 Words | 10 PagesThe Importance Of The NGRI Defense
861 Words | 4 PagesCriminally Responsible Law
1035 Words | 5 PagesIn Cold Blood Insanity Defense
621 Words | 3 PagesAndrea Yates Case Essay
2011 Words | 9 PagesLee Robin's Case Summary
593 Words | 3 PagesArguments Against Insanity Plea
312 Words | 2 PagesThe Theme Of Death In Truman Capote's In Cold Blood
1445 Words | 6 PagesArguments Against Insanity Defense
1042 Words | 5 PagesArgumentative Essay On A Mental Health Issue
947 Words | 4 Pages