The Limits of Race
When asked to define oneself, powerful adjectives, or meaningful characteristics, are often described. The foundational identity that has been created in an individual, is explained through a deeply rooted word choice. Should ones race significantly assist in defining the essential make up of a person? Racial identity and its meaning is an on-going and crucial debate in modern American society. As the theory of race and its significance in the development of social equity continues to divide opinions, the racial prejudice that’s created from this damages individual and communal identities. In Zora Neale Hurston’s “How It Feels To Be Colored Me” she dives into her own personal racial identity issues. Similar themes of racial
…show more content…
From tough relationships, to difficult decisions, and significant lessons, Janie has a fair share of difficult experiences throughout the novel. In the novel Janie’s hair serves as an illusive metaphor. Hair is an important symbol in black identity and culture. For generations it has been used to express pride and resistance against racial beauty stereotypes formed against black women. Black women were told to straighten or chemically “tame” their hair to fit in with Euro-centric ideologies. With Janie being of mixed race she shares white features that aren’t commonly noticed in the black community. The novel …show more content…
(Hurston 45)
Janie’s being deemed attractive solely by her hair. With no regards of skin or personality, Janie is saved from judgement that many black women were subjected to. The black community also suffers from an inevidable diverge; skin tone. As slavery progressed, the promiscuity of white men became progressively notable. When the number of individuals with mixed-race became inescapable, there became yet another social divide:
By virtue of generally having lighter skin colour, the progeny of these sexual unions were visibly distinguishable from enslaved persons who were solely of African descent. The extent to which enslaved individuals of mixed ancestry received preferential treatment is debatable—though mulattoes benefited conspicuously from manumission, as enslavers sometimes granted freedom to their own children. (Wallenfeldt 1)
Although the impact of mixed skin continued to change over time, in the early 20th century it couldn’t be looked upon as anything less than a gift. The theory of colorism can not go unnoticed in the novel. Janie has a conversation with Mrs. Turner who shows readers a different sense of acceptance when it pertains to Janie:
But Mrs. Turner’s shape and features were
Nonetheless, one of the biggest obstacles that Janie faced in the novel was the belief associated with women: “inferior.” When I was a little girl, I quickly learned of this primitive idea. At the ripe old age of 6, I was playing in a sandbox and was suddenly struck with surprise when a little boy stole the toy that I was playing with. I approached him, and said, “Why did you take my toy? I was playing with it!”
After Janie leaves Killicks, Starks takes her to Florida to start a new life together and to establish the first colored town. At the beginning of their relationship Janie is convinced she has fallen in love with Starks for his charisma and confidence. However, Janie soon comes to realize that Starks’ true nature is pursuing his lifelong goal to become a “big voice” (Hurston 28). To achieve control and power, Starks soon becomes misogynistic and commanding of Janie and the townspeople. When Starks is elected mayor and the townspeople ask Janie for a speech, he interjects before Janie can answer and diminishes Janie to his conception of a woman’s place in society.
In her novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neal Hurston portrays the story of a black heroine named Janie who seeks to find confirmation of herself through vision and voice. Janie struggles with the visions not only Nanny have, but also by the three different men in whom she marries of how she should live her life. During the 1930’s, women were not able to have their own voice and had to submit to the restrictions of being a woman at the time. Even though she toils with having to find her own vision and voice, Janie finds herself through her mangled relationships and is, therefore, able to gain control over her own vision and voice.
The novel tells readers that she was teased for her clothes, hair and skin complexion in school. It says that Janie thought she was white until she
Mrs. Turner, like all other believers, had built an altar to the unattainable—Caucasian characteristics for all…”(153). Mrs. Turner believes in and enforces a system of power that is ultimately fruitless, as she is unable to assimilate to the whiteness that she so desperately desires. Even so, she chooses this ‘worship’ through the belief that this
As a black woman, she faced an extremely hard life. She knew it too, as seen in her conversation with Nanny: “So the white man throw down de land… He hand it to his womenfolks… de mule uh de world so fur as Ah can see” (page 14). Black women were mistreated by both white men and black men. Jody struck Janie on multiple occasions, forced her to tie her hair up, and submissed her into complete inferiority (page 71).
Thanks to this disparity between black and white people as well as the use of the African American Vernacular English, Hurston cherishes the black culture. Importantly, Benesch claims that: “if it were not for the abundant use of Black English, which in itself ties the text to a specific cultural background, Their Eyes Were Watching God night easily [...] refer to ubiquitous problems of human existence” (Benesch, 1988: 628). The problem of the relations between the black and the white in the novel is also discussed by Jürgen C. Wolter (2001). He argues that the progression visible in Janie`s character symbolizes the change in thinking about skin color.
Race, Gender, and Social Norms In the book Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston it focused on a woman named Janie who was on the quest of finding true love. Hurston made sure she included the realities of the era in which the book was written which is the 1900’s. Hurston made sure to include issues like race, gender, and social norms into Janie’s life and everything and everyone that was around her.
In Zora Neale Hurston’s short story “Sweat” and her essay “How It Feels to Be Colored Me” the African American social group is being represented in many ways. The texts have similar ways that African Americans are represented for the time period. The African Americans or “colored people” are represented in an aspect that comes from the author's point of view. The African Americans are represented as being unbothered, growing up in a closed community, playing the game with whites, and optimistic.
As a child, Janie did not even realize that she was actually black until she shown in a photograph among a group of white children. After growing up confused about her identity, Janie struggled with conflicting thoughts about love and marriage. Through a series of relationships, Janie found herself constantly struggling against
The minds of black people have been brainwashed into thinking that people with more European features are more beautiful. Janie’s appearance models power, reflects society’s hypocrisy, and shows the distinction between the inner
In Janie’s third marriage with Tea Cake, they encounter a white racist woman named Mrs. Turner. She is comfortable talking to Janie because she is part white and wants to bring her from the dark side to that of the light. One of her beliefs is that “it’s too may black folks already. We oughta lighten up the race” (Hurston 140).
Denial, Acceptance, and Resilience in Zora Neal Hurston’s Literature Since the 1930s, individuals have lived under a certain power or authority in which some defy or submit to it. Zora Neal Hurston writes two compelling stories, surrounding the protagonists, 2 black women. Janie from “Their Eyes Were Watching God” and Delia from “Sweat”, endure a myriad of adversity. Both are black women who spend their life in abuse and discrimination.
Being a woman of color in the 1920’s was no easy task. Gender and racial inequalities have made progress throughout history, however during the time of this novel, and even in our modern day world they are still present and causing conflict. This is an issue that should be focused on and taken more seriously. In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston, Janie does a fantastic job overcoming several of these inequalities in order to pursue her own happiness, overall depicting her as an extremely powerful role model for young
She had no desire to hide herself, but did for the hope of a happy marriage. It wasn’t until after Jody’s death that Janie let out her hair which Jody commander her to do. Janie’s hair was an important symbol of her true, individual self. The act of letting her hair down shows how Janie managed to break free from the bands of conformity and stand, on her own, as her true