ipl-logo

These Shining Lives Analysis

892 Words4 Pages

“What happens when you are not taken care of properly, at work?” This is a question, Catherine Donohue and her friends/co-workers had to face, in Melanie Marnich’s These Shining Lives. I was amazed by the fact that the play is based on a true story about The Radium Dial Girls and their contributions to history. For director Sally J. Robertson to present it to the public is a constant reminder on how important the role of women has changed in society. After watching the play, it was incredible being both entertained and educated at the same time. The plot of the play is set in Chicago & Ottawa, Illinois during the 1920s & 1930s. It was a time when America experienced prosperity and turmoil, along with liberal freedom for women. That means having the right to vote, and working outside the home. For protagonist Catherine Donohue, it was the start of a tumultuous relationship of her job at Radium Dial Company where she creates watches for $8.00 a day. During her time there, she meets three women with distinct personalities: Moral-Minded Frances, Talkative Pearl and Headstrong Charlotte. Together, the four of them create a strong bond, becoming more like sisters. However, a drastic change occurs at the company, when many workers (and sadly, Charlotte) suffer an illness that is …show more content…

It touches on a true story that has been overlooked throughout history, and needs to be shown in the spotlight more. For Melanie Marnich & Sally J. Robertson to present a topic of how a group of women stood up for their rights without being silent, is something that should remind women of all ages no matter who you are and where you come from, you have a voice to be heard. These Shining Lives is another excellent play that I have been able to watch from beginning to end. I definitely recommend this play for women ages 13 and over, if you love theatre or just interested in history, in

Show More
Related
371 Words | 2 Pages

The roles of these women, whether viewed in a positive or negative light, bring together the plot and the influence that they posses. These female characters There is a message that these women bring beyond the surface of their

Read More
838 Words | 4 Pages

It also shows them their capacity of achievement. There was inequality that made situations unfair and difficult, but that didn’t hold back Sarah, Hetty and Nina’s courage. They were focused on change, and gaining rights for women and slaves. They got a point across for people to notice that something was wrong. The characters never gave up.

Read More
865 Words | 4 Pages

In comparison to the movie, the play undermines male dominance by focusing on women’s efforts to solve their own problems. First of all, there aren’t even men in the cast of the play,

Read More
1680 Words | 7 Pages

These women worked in deplorable working conditions, for a ludicrous number of hours each week, and earned meager compensation. Although to modern readers, the women’s working conditions alone seem horrific, at this time, these conditions were far from uncommon across factories in

Read More
369 Words | 2 Pages

Claire Standish is labeled “The Princess” of the group as she is rich, beautiful, and possibly the most popular female at her school. Many people assume her life is perfect and a dream when in reality her parents are on the verge of a divorce. They use, pamper, and indulge her in order to spite each other and Claire is painfully aware of this. The group initially see Claire as a “snobby stuck up bitch” assuming she is solely shallow and materialistic.

Read More
866 Words | 4 Pages

The women of the neighborhood analyzed the couple’s every move. Theresa remained unaffected and unaware of the gossip around here. On the other hand, Lorraine was self-conscious as she was previously fired from a job because of her relationship with Theresa. Lorraine relied on Theresa’s tenacity and self-confidence. Theresa had many friends of her own, while Lorraine depended on the support of the women in the community.

Read More
409 Words | 2 Pages

The prostitutes are not consistent with my view of women in the 1960’s. Since, they were not fighting for self respect and empowerment. Mcmurphy passed around the girls knowing they would not mind it. Nurse Ratched however, is a role which is consistent with my view of women in the 1960’s. Since, she was powerful,and did not let the men belittle her.

Read More
1492 Words | 6 Pages

Franny talk about their life 's and what they have both been up to. They spend it by critique each other on how they should act and what they should not do. Franny tries to play the role of a good girlfriend listening and paying attention to what her boyfriend Lane has to say, but there bickering at one other cause Franny to argue with Lane on how she hates people that are phoniness and just wants to fade into the background and be a nobody. Throughout the story Franny 's comments on how a person has to act a certain way because of the social standards that are set. She spends her time in the story abiding by the standers and commenting on them causing her to have an emotional breakdown.

Read More
765 Words | 4 Pages

The film shows the struggle that these miserable women are going through after losing sons, brothers, and husbands to the Trojan War. The amount of times that these women discuss their mourning is unavoidable. It is nearly impossible to watch the film without feeling empathy for the women. This is very relatable for the many women who lost their husbands and boys to the war.

Read More
599 Words | 3 Pages

The conflict was between the narrator and herself. She knew the girl was not good for her but she did not care and wanted her anyways. She could deal with all of her annoying qualities because she loved the way she always looked. The other conflict I saw was Charlotte cheated on both the narrator and the boyfriend, Maurice.

Read More
850 Words | 4 Pages

Main character sammy is a witty, rude, immature boy who is driven by sexual characteristics of women. His masculinity is hindered when the three girls are kicked out and must feel like “their unsuspected hero” to them by quitting his job. Unfortunately, the girls don't stop. “Queenie” (5), is characterized as striking and confident. She's bold and the herring snacks implies she is rich.

Read More
1245 Words | 5 Pages

The play takes place in the 1950s in New Orleans containing a diverse population. However, is race discriminated against, those who go against classifed gender roles are often discriminated and have trouble finding their way in society. Although gender equality has

Read More
816 Words | 4 Pages

The famous play shows the audience the life it was like to live as a black female, and shows the struggles that the Young family faced being the first African American family to move into a white neighborhood. This play is considered a

Read More
1737 Words | 7 Pages

Although being written centuries apart, the limited expectations of women presented in ‘Othello’ and ‘A Streetcar Named Desire’ differ little from each other. The female characters are confined by society’s expectations of male dominance, female purity and virginity, and the many passive roles of women. Despite the differing legalities surrounding the position of women between the centuries in which the plays were written, both plays explore the impact of how societal conventions confine women and the ways they must comply to be safe in a patriarchal society. The behaviours and treatments of Desdemona, Blanche and Stella illustrate the attitudes enforced on and the behaviours of women throughout both periods in time and it is these attitudes and behaviours that impact the plays to the greatest extent. When characters in either plays defy their norms, or demonstrate a lack of compliance they induce negative consequences, such as the murder of Desdemona and the institutionalisation of Blanche.

Read More
3436 Words | 14 Pages

The movie clearly exposes the many ways that the human dignity of African- American maids was ignored. They had suffered daily embarrassment but were able to claim their own way dignity. The film described about empowerment of individuals as well as about social justice for a group. It is a moving story depicting dehumanization in a racist culture but also the ability to move beyond the unjust structures of society and to declare the value of every human being.

Read More

More about These Shining Lives Analysis

Open Document