The Philanthropy of Andrew Carnegie: Did it make him a hero?
A person is classified as a hero through his or her actions. The actions of Andrew Carnegie prove that he is a hero. Andrew Carnegie was a hero through his hard work, valued education, and showed concern for others.
Andrew Carnegie was a wealthy man but he was also humble. Andrew Carnegie progressively became wealthy which is shown in document A of his two houses. The first house was the house that Carnegie grew up in while the second house is Carnegie’s castle that he purchased when he got older. Next to the house he grew up in, the caption states, “Carnegie and his family of four lived in an attic room above his father’s shop”(125). Carnegie came from humble beginnings and worked
…show more content…
Joseph Frazier Wall created a chart of Carnegie’s philanthropy which showed him providing “$50,365,000 for the construction of 2811 free public libraries” along with other gifts (129). Wall showed how Carnegie valued education. Not all people liked receiving the gifts that Carnegie gave to the community. William Jewett Tucker stated, “It is better for any community to advance more slowly than to gain altogether by gifts rather than, in large part, by earnings...but if the method becomes the accepted method, to be accepted and relied upon, the decline of self-respect has begun” (133). Tucker thought that the more gifts Carnegie gave the more the poor would rely on him for things and Tucker felt that the poor should earn what they receive. Tucker wanted the wealthy to give those in need the ability to help themselves. He also believed that those with wealth should have tried to fix real issues regarding the society rather than giving gifts. Carnegie was dealing with the issue of education in his society by providing the funds necessary to help build libraries. Libraries provided his community the research and knowledge they needed to grow as a community together. Carnegie is a hero because he brought the value of knowledge to his
He was also one the wealthiest men of his time and helped transform the steel industry. Andrew Carnegie could be considered to be a hero in many ways. He helped create jobs, transformed the steel industry and also helped other industries, and was an influential philanthropist. Many of the people at the time were poor and living in poverty. There weren't many jobs; and the one that they did have didn't pay enough to sustain a family.
Andrew Carnegie was a hero in some people 's eyes , not so much in others . That’s why everyone has their own opinion. In this essay you will read one reason someone might think he’s a hero , and two reasons why he is not a hero for the rest of the people. What that means is that this paper mostly leans on that Andrew Carnegie is not a hero and you will read why . Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man.
“I began to stop accumulating and begin the infinitely more serious and difficult task of wise distribution,” as said by Andrew Carnegie. The industrialist and hard-working Andrew Carnegie was a very successful businessman and philanthropist. Andrew Carnegie provided the United States economy to rise due to his steel production in the 1800’s and 1900’s. Although some may think Carnegie was a brutal businessman, Andrew Carnegie enhanced the United States due to his business investments, his philanthropy, and his educational institutions. One way Andrew Carnegie enhanced The United States is his business investments.
In his early life, he didn’t have a lot of money. He was a story of rags to riches. Carnegie learned the value of hard work from his mother. He stopped going to school at the age of 13 because his mother made him and his brother move to America.
His companies allowed for the heating of millions of homes and the construction of thousands of skyscrapers in America. He gave immigrants and American citizens working opportunities in the booming cities. While being the head of great businesses, Andrew generously donated millions of dollars to the sciences, the building of libraries and even gave over $10 million worth of pension money to teachers throughout America. Was Andrew Carnegie a generous benefactor or, perhaps, a money hungry robber baron? Andrew donated millions from his fortune to help the lives of the growing American population.
Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero? Andrew Carnegie was seen as an influential leader, but was he a hero? Andrew Carnegie was born on November 1835 in Dunfermline, Scotland in the attic of his family's cottage.
The distribution of wealth has always been a conflict of interest between those in an industrial society. Many times, we find the all the poor being grouped as oppressed, and all the rich being grouped as oppressive. But this is not the most accurate way of thinking. We see Andrew Carnegie as part of the rich being grouped as oppressive, or a villain. Given the fact that he saw his success in the height of the American Era of Industrialization, Carnegie got a lot of backlash for the issues surrounding the poor that worked for him.
That made him one of the richest men. But what did he do with all the money he was making? The real question is, was Carnegie a hero? A hero is someone who does outstanding achievements. There were three reasons Andrew Carnegie was a hero he always gave back, he didn't just leave his money with his family, and brought beauty to a castle in Scotland.
Then, he left and moved to New York. In 1872 he took a trip to England and cooperated with Henry Bessemer to build a steel mill. He became famous Homestead steel. The philanthropy of Andrew Carnegie made him a hero which set the foundation for three reasons. This was done through Carnegie’s gifts because he gave money to help many causes like education, religion, and other charities, ”The Gospel of Wealth” he believed that rich people are superior to all classes so they should use their money to help lessen or poor people and Carnegie helped his hometown.
Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he proved that the rags to riches American Dream is possible, he was also a philanthropist and he mastered the skills of a successful business man. Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he proved the American Dream from rags to riches is a real thing . Growing up, Andrew lived in Scotland with his family." Carnegie and his family of four lived in a garret room above his father's embroiderer shop with another family. Annual rent $20" ( Document 1).
He then started his first job, having his career take off he earned more than $100,000 in the middle of his life. Was Carnegie a hero or a villain? Andrew was a hero in business and philanthropy, but not with labor in many eyes. Carnegie was an American hero in the eyes of people who did not face the challenges of his labor. Workers at Andrew’s industry earned no more than $1.90 while he received over one-hundred thousand dollars.(Doc 7)
A hero is somebody who does something remarkable that alters someone's perception of life. A hero, must have the following three attributes; they must be brave, they must have a desire to make a difference, and they must have perseverance. Many people have heard of Andrew Jackson’s contribution to the revolutionary war, but have they ever considered him a hero? Andrew Jackson is one of the most commendable American Heroes Because of his independent education in law, his authoritative presidency, and legacy of Military Advancements. Andrew Jackson personally pursued an education in law.
Despite Carnegie’s difficult beginning, he became a determined and intelligent person. From an early age, Carnegie saw his father lose his money and dignity as a result of not being able to keep up with the rapid changes
Carnegie is not a hero because he took money, only gave to other wealthy recipients, and contributed largely to his own. Andrew Carnegie took money away from deserving people. Carnegie cut the wages of his workers to donate money elsewhere. In document D, there are two images of Carnegie, one is giving a wage cut notice to the workers and the other is giving a check to Scotland and donating a library to Pittsburg. Carnegie’s employees were working hard and trying to survive in a tough economy, their wages did not deserve a cut.
Andrew Carnegie Once, there was a man to have the largest personal fortune in the world. He helped improve mankind by donating millions of his fortune to charity. This mastermind was named Andrew Carnegie, an industrial monopolizer who used steel to gain his massive fortune. Andrew Carnegie was born November 25, 1835 in Dunfermline, Scotland.