“They traveled a short while toward the sun and left the vivid air signed with their honor,” is the concluding line of “The Truly Great” by Stephen Spender. This poem is about individuals who made a difference, after vying for it. An example of a "great" in the civil rights movement is Martin Luther King, Jr. He fought for the rights of African Americans through peaceful protest; however, in 1963, King was arrested and wrote A Letter From a Birmingham Jail to explain his motives for the movement. An example of an honorable character in fiction is Antigone from Antigone by Sophocles. In the story, she goes against the King Creon of Thebes, orders and buries her brother, Polyneices, who had been declared a traitor. She does this due to the love …show more content…
in "Letter from Birmingham Jail" and Antigone use metaphors to convey their beliefs and ideas. In King's letter, he uses the metaphor "rise from the bondage of myths and half-truths," where he is comparing the struggle for civil rights to the process of freeing oneself from ignorance and false beliefs. (Passage B) He suggests that just as Socrates believed in the importance of questioning myths and half-truths to gain knowledge and understanding, individuals must also question and challenge the oppressive beliefs and structures that keep them in bondage. On the other hand, Antigone uses the metaphor where she explains "unwritten” and “unshakable traditions," where she is referring to the unwritten laws that dictate proper burial rights for the dead. (Passage A) By describing these laws as "unwritten" and "unshakable," she is comparing them to a powerful force that cannot be ignored or disregarded. Antigone is illuminating how these unwritten laws are equally powerful and have a significant impact on society. Both Antigone and King suggest that persistence is necessary to overcome these powerful forces and achieve lasting change. Antigone is willing to face death to uphold these traditions, while King advocates for nonviolent direct action to create a crisis and establish tension that forces society to confront these issues. In both cases, the struggle for justice requires persistence and a willingness to fight against the status quo. One …show more content…
For instance, In King's letter, he uses the rhetorical question, “Why direct action?”...“Isn't negotiation a better path?" The effect of this quote is to establish rhetorical analysis in a dense society to motivate the audience to compromise with him on peaceful protests to get the civil rights movement started. Martin Luther King Jr. used rhetorical questions to persuade minorities and allies to ravish for change. However, there was opposition to these events because it was deemed uncomfortable to the non-affected. King justifies how it is necessary to have abnormal contact to develop a brotherhood; it is crucial to leave an impact on the spectator to receive support in the movement against racial inequality. To add on, Antigone states, “Who on earth, alive in the midst of so much grief as I, could fail to find his death a rich reward?” Moreover, Antigone further resists Creon's law because Antigone would rather be dead than face life without her brother Polyneices. This is meant to give the reader an understanding and better comprehension of the situation. This question shows she remains faithful to her truth and evokes emotions when she refuses to follow Creon’s blasphemous rule. Overall the difference between both rhetorical questions is that they show Antigone and King value society's values in different ways. Antigone and King
Click here to unlock this and over one million essaysShow More
King and Antigone both defy authority to further their causes but they demonstrate differences as Antigone views
The two stories of “Antigone” and of “The Letter from Birmingham Jail” both have the main theme of Civil Disobedience. This is the emphasis on God’s law over Mans law, and both stories show this in different ways. However, one story is clearly better than the other. In “Antigone”, Creon has ordered that Eteocles, Antigone’s brother be buried with all the formal rites, but that Polynices, the other brother, be left unburied on the streets. Antigone thinks that this is unfair and inhumane, so she secretly does all the rites and “buries him”.
King stated that he was “compelled to carry the gospel of freedom beyond my own home town” (King 21); likewise, Antigone was compelled to perform own duty to her family. The actions of Antigone and Martin Luther King, Jr. were aimed to spur tension within a community that would eventually cause the subjugators to confront the issue. Indeed, King’s work was able to catch the eye of political leaders at the state and local level, just as the city of Thebes ends up quietly supporting Antigone and enraging Creon. In both cases, neither figure sought to provoke anarchy, but instead aimed to bring light to corruption that was already boiling in a pot
Fortunately, those who followed King stayed true to his rhetoric, but thinking about our society now with just and unjust laws, will be skewed and taken advantage of. Furthermore, Antigone’s actions displayed a “maximalist” view, where she argues with Creon that the gods do not agree with his decree, emphasizing “the conviction that religion ought to permeate all aspects of social, indeed of human, existence.” This is a divergence from my definition of keeping the components of religion out of every aspect in
She believed that God’s laws were higher than man’s laws so she was ‘pleasing those [she] should please most’ (Blondell, 23). While arguing with her sister, Ismene, about breaking the law, Antigone demonstrated her determination to bury her brother because she knew that it was the moral thing to do, regardless of the deadly outcome. She was willing to perform the ‘crime of piety’ (Blondell, 23) – the crime that was ‘honored by the gods’ (Blondell, 23). To her, following God’s laws was the most justified even if it meant that she had to break man’s laws, because the God’s laws were ‘not for now or yesterday, but live forever’ (Blondell, 38).
Both Antigone and Martin Luther King Jr. engage in civil disobedience. Despite the similarities, they carry out civil disobedience in very different ways. Explain the differences between Antigone and King’s views on civil disobedience, the reasoning and purposes behind their disobedience, and different means they use to achieve their ends. Pick one version and argue it’s merits versus the other, using specific examples from both readings. Renowned for their defiance against the laws mandated within their society, both Martin Luther King Jr. and Antigone stood out as revolutionaries.
The struggle for justice has been the motivating factor for various movements across time. From fictional characters like Antigone to famous figures like Martin Luther King, it is possible to see various differences between their approaches to the law and how to change it. In Antigone's dialogue with Creon and Martin Luther King’s Letter from Birmingham Jail, the two characters share a variety of differences in their stances. Antigone’s dialogue with Creon focuses on religious law and how it is above mortal law while King’s letter focuses on changing mortal law without relying on religious law to dictate it.
King would not only agree with Antigone’s choice and methods for opposing the law, but commend her for it as well. Dr. King was a staunch believer in nonviolent, direct action when it came to protest. Antigone did exactly this by quietly and stealthily sprinkling dirt on Polyneice’s body as his “burial”. Dr. King would respect Antigone for taking a stand civilly instead of being just another bystander or worse, a violent rioter. Both Dr. King and Antigone were incarcerated for their opposition to the legal system, but both chose to accept it full-heartedly and without shame.
In hope of obtaining the Good Life, people often have to deal with balancing the ideas of doing what is best for society and doing what is best for the individual. Both Sophocles’ “Antigone” and Martin Luther King’s “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” support the concept that to obtain the Good Life, a person must act for the benefit of society more than for the benefit of himself or herself. In “Antigone”, through Antigone and Kreon’s actions and the repercussions of their actions, Sophocles argues for the preservation of values of society over self-preservation and putting the beliefs of society over the beliefs of the individual. In the “Letter from a Birmingham Jail”, King argues against the individual’s tendency for passivity and idleness
Both also understood that nonviolent resistance could bring attention to the issue and force those in power to address it. He argued that waiting for the legal system to bring about change is not enough and that direct action is necessary to force those in power to address issues of injustice. Furthermore, Antigone also believed that direct action was the only way for a higher authority to change their mind on certain issues. Their fight for justice and the right to challenge unjust laws is a similarity between the stances of Martin Luther King and
She has a heroic and courageous personality. Throughout her quest to bury Polyneices, Antigone encounters many hindrances along the way. The death of her father Oedipus led to her greatest disputant being given power, her Uncle Creon. He would show her no mercy for breaking his laws, until it is too late. Even when her sister Ismene states “Our own death would be if we should go against Creon And do what he has forbidden!
Laws have maintained the order and stability of society from old days of ancient civilization to today’s contemporary society. As law-abiding citizens, we allow the laws to be enforced through punishments and consequences; however, when these laws threaten ethical values and justice, they are challenged in a non-violent method known as “civil disobedience.” In Sophocles’ Antigone, Antigone challenged the political authority of Creon in a defiant act that related the struggles between her duty as a citizen of Thebes and her loyalty to her family. In “Letter from a Birmingham Jail,” written by Martin Luther King, Jr., King protests racial injustices and systemic racism throughout the South and laments the need for civil disobedience to be used
In the classic play by Sophocles, Antigone is a tragic story of the bold Antigone who defied her uncle, King Creonʻs, edict by burying her brother, Polyneices, who died attacking the city of Thebes, trying to take the power away from their brother, Eteocles, who refused to share the throne with Polyneices. Even though Antigone knew that going against Creon and burying her brother would not end well for her, she still choose to risk her life to do what is right. After being caught breaking the law, Antigone is appointed to be locked away, isolated in a cave until she dies, but she hangs herself at the end. At the same time, things for Creon are not looking good, as everyone around him seems to be against him in his decision for punishing Antigone. Everyone Creon cares about kills themselves from a curse that is put on Creon for not following the Godsʻ laws.
Both Antigone and Martin Luther King used nonviolent protests in their actions to express their opposition by doing what they believed was morally right. A prime example
The gripping play of Antigone written by Sophocles reveals a massive tragedy which is caused by the main character Antigone. This play reflects how Creon who is a prideful and arrogant man deals with Antigone who does not abide by his rules. The play of Antigone presents different ways selfishness and overconfidence along with extreme pride can cause unrepentable mistakes. “No woman, while I live, shall order me.” (Sophocles pg 29) articulates Creon as Antigone forces him to terminate her for her rebellious deed of burying her brother Polyneices although Creon voiced not to do so.