ipl-logo

Is George Killing Lennie Justifiable Homicide?

873 Words4 Pages

Is George’s murder of Lennie a justifiable homicide? Does great power come with great responsibility? Lennie was a very strong guy inside of a 4 year old brain.George was his companion who was in a normal man’s body with an average brain, who was ordered to take care of Lennie by Lennie’s Aunt Clara. But Lennie keeps getting them in trouble everywhere the go to work. Lennie’s pure strength and actions led his best friend George to kill him, so that he doesn’t get in any more trouble. George killing Lennie was a justified murder because Lennie was too dangerous, Lennie would have been killed anyways, and he only would slow George down and drag him into trouble. Lennie was way too dangerous to be kept alive, because he has no comprehension of his true strength. He was just too mentally challenged to even understand his sheer power. For example, Lennie explains to Curley’s Wife how he unintentionally killed the puppy, “I made it like I was gonna smack him… an I done it. An then he was dead.” (Steinbeck 87). Also Lennie was told to fight back against Curley and simply caught one of Curley’s fists and crushed it with one hand like it was …show more content…

They could say that George could have rescued Lennie and ran away from the ranch like he did in weed. This is wrong because George couldn’t live a life of running and saving Lennie from all his mistakes. George wanted to settle down on his own ranch, but he couldn’t do that with Lennie messing up all the time. The opposing viewpoint could also say that Lennie was too good of a worker to be killed. But this is also incorrect because it doesn’t matter how good of a worker he is, if he keeps getting them kicked out of wherever they are. Finally, the opposing side could argue that Aunt Clara told George to take care of Lennie not kill him. This claim is false because Aunt Clara also would not want Lennie to keep on killing people and putting George through a lot of

Show More
Related

  • Should George Have Killed Lennie

    346 Words  | 2 Pages

    The side that I am choosing is that George should have killed Lennie because Lennie can’t live by himself, he is mentally challenged, and Curley would have killed him anyway if George didn 't. Lennie is mentally challenged and he likes to talk to dead animals and other different things. He gets in trouble a lot and can 't really do anything by himself because he will always be getting in trouble if he is by himself. “Jus wanted to feel that girl’s dress-jus wanted to pet it like it was mouse(Steinbeck 11). The quote proves my reason because Lennie got both George and Lennie in trouble because he wanted to feel a girls dress. George should have killed Lennie because Lennie can 't live by himself and I believe if George didn 't kill Lennie

    Read More

  • How Did George Kill Lennie Justified

    272 Words  | 2 Pages

    George killing his best friend is both justifiable and condemning. At the end of the novella, George makes a difficult decision to kill Lennie by gun. His action can be justified because Lennie was going to die either way, and it was better to be killed while he was at peace. Before Lennie died, George retold the story of their future together. This was a nice thing to do because it made Lennie happy and at peace for his last moments alive.

    Read More

  • How Is George Justified In Of Mice And Men

    483 Words  | 2 Pages

    He didn’t want to do that to Lennie but he did to make some things better. One reason George should be justified is because he never killed George out of hate, just after this time Lennie now killing Curleys wife although it was accident

    Read More

  • Why Is Lennie Be Considered Murder

    549 Words  | 3 Pages

    he only had george after his aunt clara died. Killing Lennie is not what his aunt clara told George to do. So in the end George ended up betraying Lennie's aunt clara for killing Lennie and not taking care of him. That is one reason why George should be charged for murder.

    Read More

  • George Should Kill Lennie

    361 Words  | 2 Pages

    The topic im talking about is from Mice and Men written by John Steinbeck. My argument is George should have killed Lennie because Curley would have killed him anyway. My second reason is if George didn’t Kill Lennie he would have died a more slow and painful death. The other side of the argument is that they were very close friends and Lennie never did anything to get killed. My first reason George should have shot Lennie is that Lennie would have suffered because Curley would have only shot him in the gut and let him die slowly.

    Read More

  • George Should Not Have Killed Lennie's Death

    424 Words  | 2 Pages

    Another reason Lennie should not have been killed for what he did was because Lennie doesn't know his own strength. George should not have killed Lennie because he should of taught him that he is stronger, when the first accident happened in Weed. George should have taught Lennie how to control himself when he was little.

    Read More

  • How Does George's Decision To Kill Lennie In Of Mice And Men

    737 Words  | 3 Pages

    Lennie with his simple mind, always gets into trouble. This time, Lennie gets himself in a bind once again, that George can’t save him from. George decision to kill Lennie in the story, was due to his responsibility, sympathy, and love for Lennie. George’s decision to kill Lennie was out of sympathy for him.

    Read More

  • Who Is George Guilty In Of Mice And Men

    689 Words  | 3 Pages

    Because George essentially executed Lennie, his shooting of him was a murder. Lennie was mercilessly and harshly put to death by George without any provocation. Lennie was defenseless and with no choice but to meet George's predetermined end, which is death. Murdering someone is not something you do out of love; if he had loved him, he would have tried to find a better method to assist him in getting through it. Although George believes that killing Lennie is the

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Of Mice And Men

    751 Words  | 4 Pages

    George was a good worker, but Lennie was an amazing worker with a tenacious work ethic and stamina. Lennie had incredible strength, but sometimes he did not understand just how massive he was. Many times throughout the book Lennie is caught hurting people or killing animals on accident. The biggest reason Lennie should not have been killed was because he was a major asset in the working force. That means he could have helped continue to bring in money towards the farm they dreamed about operating someday.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay Of Mice And Men

    507 Words  | 3 Pages

    Some people might think in the opposite side that George should not killed Lennie because Lennie did not mean to anything. He has done it without knowing how strong of himself. Lennie made many troubles this might be because of his disability, but this is the reason that he deserves to live. He has done many thing that make George get into trouble and It is better if Lennie has to die because of George shoot him not the other. "All the time he coulda had such a good time if it was not for you” (Steinbeck).

    Read More

  • George's Decision To Kill Lennie In Of Mice And Men Analysis

    839 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, George’s decision to kill Lennie at the end of the novel was justified. George and Lennie were best friends, and have been since they were little. They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. He was just scared from her screaming and kicking. He didn’t mean to harm, or scare her.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Persuasive Essay Of Mice And Men

    532 Words  | 3 Pages

    The main reason George killed Lennie is because Lennie would have killed somebody again. And the evidence is clearly there, the pet mice that he killed, the poor puppy that he accidently hit to hard, and especially Curley’s wife. He almost killed the girl in weed if he had gone any further. The sad thing is is that he doesn't know how strong he really is, nor does he know what he’s done wrong in the first place.

    Read More

  • How Did George Kill Lennie Justified In Of Mice And Men

    667 Words  | 3 Pages

    Another reason is the ranchers would’ve killed him no matter what so this way George ensured it was fast and painless. On the other hand, this was condemned because George had been saying how his life would be so much better without Lennie and this allowed him to be able to live that life. George's decision to kill Lennie was justified because Lennie was going to be killed no matter what. After all of the ranchers find out that Lennie killed Curley’s wife, Curley states that he is going to kill Lennie, "I'm gonna get him.

    Read More

  • George Do The Right Thing

    652 Words  | 3 Pages

    On the other hand you can analyze the actions that George did and you can say that they were not very human decisions. George killed his best friend because Lennie killed a person and was going to get into more problems but nevertheless can not say that this is justified. George always told Lennie all the plans they had together, like buying a ranch, he was always keeping it with the expectation that they were going to stay together forever. This quote is an example of how Lennie and George looked happy in the future. "O.K. Someday- we 're gonna get the jack together and we 're gonna have a little house and a couple of acres an ' a cow and some pigs..." (Steinbeck 7).

    Read More

  • Dreams Vs. Reality In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men

    942 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the novella Of Mice and Men, Steinbeck incorporates many thematic ideas into his text. He includes the ideas of dreams and reality, the nature of home, and he difference of right and wrong. He develops these ideas throughout the story. The first theme incorporated is the idea if dreams versus reality. Lennie and George have a plan.

    Read More

More about Is George Killing Lennie Justifiable Homicide?

Open Document